Stone Living Pty Ltd v 3 Property Group 9 Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Stone Living Pty Ltd v 3 Property Group 9 Pty Ltd (No 2)

Citation:

[2020] ACTSC 357

Hearing Date:

18 December 2020

DecisionDate:

18 December 2020

Before:

McWilliam AsJ

Decision:

See [26]

Catchwords:

COSTS – Where parties engaged in building dispute and caveats had been lodged over land owned by the defendants – whether issuing lapsing notices in respect of caveats prior to litigation was unreasonable conduct – whether costs ought follow the event in circumstances where the substantive issue is yet to be resolved between the parties – where parties resolved the interlocutory issue following judgment – whether each party should pay their own costs

Legislation Cited:

Land Titles Act 1925 (ACT) ss 105, 107

Cases Cited:

International Computer Network Pty Ltd v Lumos International Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 1793
Stone Living Pty Ltd v 3 Property Group 9 Pty Ltd [2020] ACTSC 149

Parties:

Stone Living Pty Ltd (Plaintiff)

3 Property Group 9 Pty Ltd (ACN 618 155 409) (First Defendant)

3 Property Group 10 Pty Ltd (ACN 618 426 190) (Second Defendant)

3 Property Group 11 Pty Ltd (ACN 618 671 560) (Third Defendant)

Representation:

Counsel

Dr A Greinke (Plaintiff)

Mr D Robens (Defendants)

Solicitors

Mills Oakley (Plaintiff)

Harrington Hall (Defendants)

File Number:

SC 143 of 2020

McWilliam AsJ:

  1. On 10 June 2020, judgment was delivered in proceedings SC 143 of 2020 which are now the subject of an application for costs made by the plaintiff: see [2020] ACTSC 149 (the primary judgment).

  1. The judgment resolved a controversy between the parties as to whether the Court should extend three caveats that were lodged over three parcels of land owned by the defendants which were identified in the primary judgment at [2] (the Land).

  1. It is sufficient for the purposes of the costs application to say that the plaintiff and the defendants have been engaged in a lengthy building dispute whereby the plaintiff says each of the defendants owes it money, either for work it has undertaken or in interest arising from delays in payment. The defendants issued lapsing notices in respect of the caveats in or around April 2020. They did so pursuant to s 107 of the Land Titles Act 1925 (ACT) (the Act). 

  1. This brought the parties to court on an urgent basis and following the grant of urgent interlocutory relief, I extended the operation of the caveats for a period of three months or until 10 September 2020 to give the plaintiff sufficient time to take appropriate action to commence substantive litigation in which to resolve the dispute about whether the plaintiff has any legal or equitable interest in the land.

The issue

  1. As part of the reasons for judgment, I indicated at [50] that I would hear the parties further as to the question of costs.  Separate proceedings involving the same parties have now been commenced, namely proceedings SC 268 of 2020.  The issue concerning the caveats…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stone Living Pty Ltd v 3 Property Group 9 Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] ACTSC 357
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Stone Living Pty Ltd v 3 Property Group 9 Pty Ltd (No 2), the court was asked to decide the issue of costs following a dispute between the parties regarding the operation of caveats lodged over land owned by the defendants. The primary judgment, handed down on 10 June 2020, resolved a controversy between the parties as to whether the Court should extend three caveats that were lodged over three parcels of land owned by the defendants. The plaintiff and the defendants had been engaged in a lengthy building dispute, and the defendants issued lapsing notices in respect of the caveats in or around April 2020. This brought the parties to court on an urgent basis and following the grant of urgent interlocutory relief, the court extended the operation of the caveats for a period of three months or until 10 September 2020 to give the plaintiff sufficient time to take appropriate action to commence substantive litigation in which to resolve the dispute about whether the plaintiff has any legal or equitable interest in the land.

The legal issues that the court was required to decide included whether the issuing of lapsing notices in respect of the caveats prior to litigation was unreasonable conduct, whether costs ought to follow the event in circumstances where the substantive issue is yet to be resolved between the parties, and whether each party should pay their own costs following the resolution of the interlocutory issue. The plaintiff sought a variety of costs orders dividing the proceedings into three phases, including the conduct leading up to the litigation with the service of three lapsing notices. The plaintiff argued that it should receive its costs on an indemnity basis in respect of the first phase because of a lack of notice that the defendants were about to take that course, which the plaintiff says was unreasonable. The plaintiff further submitted that taking such action deprived the parties of attempting to negotiate an outcome, as they ultimately did, albeit after judgment had been delivered. The plaintiff also argued that the Act also provides for an alternative means of removing a caveat in the form of s 105 of the Act which permits a party to approach the Supreme Court directly without issuing a lapsing notice. The plaintiff says this would have enabled the parties to negotiate and prepare the matter for court in a timely manner rather than seeking urgent relief.

The court found that the defendants were not unreasonable in issuing the lapsing notices, and that the plaintiff had not suffered any significant prejudice as a result of the defendants' actions. The court also found that the issue concerning the caveats had been resolved between the parties without the need for any further hearing, and that the only outstanding issue was the costs of the proceedings. The court held that each party should pay their own costs following the resolution of the interlocutory issue. The court made an order that each party bear their own costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [26]

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 10 June 2020, judgment was delivered in proceedings SC 143 of 2020 which are now the subject of an application for costs made by the plaintiff: see [2020] ACTSC 149 (the primary judgment). The judgment resolved a controversy between the parties as to whether the Court should extend three caveats that were lodged over three parcels of land owned by the defendants which were identified in the primary judgment at [2] (the Land). It is sufficient for the purposes of the costs application to say that the plaintiff and the defendants have been engaged in a lengthy building dispute whereby the plaintiff says each of the defendants owes it money, either for work it has undertaken or in interest arising from delays in payment. The defendants issued lapsing notices in respect of the caveats in or around April 2020. They did so pursuant to s 107 of the Land Titles Act 1925 (ACT) (the Act). This brought the parties to court on an urgent basis and following the grant of urgent interlocutory relief, I extended the operation of the caveats for a period of three months or until 10 September 2020 to give the plaintiff sufficient time to take appropriate action to commence substantive litigation in which to resolve the dispute about whether the plaintiff has any legal or equitable interest in the land. As part of the reasons for judgment, I indicated at [50] that I would hear the parties further as to the question of costs. Separate proceedings involving the same parties have now been commenced, namely proceedings SC 268 of 2020. The issue concerning the caveats has also been resolved between the parties without the need for any further hearing. Accordingly, the only outstanding issue is the costs of the proceedings. The plaintiff seeks a variety of costs orders dividing the proceedings into three phases. The first phase concerns the conduct leading up to the litigation with the service of three lapsing notices. The plaintiff argues that it should receive its costs on an indemnity basis in respect of the first phase. Such an order is said to be warranted because of a lack of notice that the defendants were about to take that course, which the plaintiff says was unreasonable. The plaintiff argues that taking such action deprived the parties of attempting to negotiate an outcome, as they ultimately did, albeit after judgment had been delivered. The plaintiff further submitted that the Act also provides for an alternative means of removing a caveat in the form of s 105 of the Act which permits a party to approach the Supreme Court directly without issuing a lapsing notice. The plaintiff says this would have enabled the parties to negotiate and prepare the matter for court in a timely manner rather than seeking urgent relief. The second phase, as described by the plaintiff, concerns the period from the commencement of this litigation – and by this litigation, I mean the present proceedings – to the delivery of judgment on 10 June 2020. In that regard, the plaintiff seeks its costs on a party-party basis, arguing that as it was successful in having the caveats extended, costs ought to follow the event.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established