JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
STREAM: COMMERCIAL & CIVIL
ACT: BUILDERS' REGISTRATION ACT 1939 (WA)
CITATION: STONE & ANOR and SZCZEPANIK & SON [2008] WASAT 132
MEMBER: DR B DE VILLIERS (MEMBER)
HEARD: 10 JUNE 2008
DELIVERED : 12 JUNE 2008
FILE NO/S: CC 1876 of 2007
BETWEEN: KEITH STONE
BRIDGET STONE
ApplicantsAND
SZCZEPANIK & SON
Respondent
Catchwords:
Review of decision of the Building Disputes Tribunal - Principles for review
Legislation:
Nil
Result:
The application for leave to review the decision (Order to Pay No 79/2007-08) of the Building Disputes Tribunal is dismissed
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
Applicants: Selfrepresented
Respondent: Selfrepresented
Solicitors:
Applicants: Self-represented
Respondent: Self-represented
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Tangent Nominees Pty Ltd and Edwards & Anor [2005] WASAT 119
Wilson v Metaxas (1989) WAR 285
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
Summary of Tribunal's decision
The applicants sought an order for the decision of the Building Disputes Tribunal to be reviewed. The applicants contended that the Building Disputes Tribunal was biased and that it had not taken into account all the information before it. The respondent opposed the application.
The Tribunal found that there are no grounds for the decision to be reviewed and that the application should be dismissed.
Issue
The applicants (only referred to as Mr Stone) seek leave to review a decision of the Building Disputes Tribunal (BDT) (Order to Pay No 79/200708). Mr Stone was awarded an amount of $2,090 in respect of rectification work that had to be done. Mr Stone contends that the amount did not accurately reflect the remedial work that was required.
Mr Stone claims bias on behalf of the BDT as well as failure to take into account all the relevant information in regard to the dispute. He contends therefore that the application for review should succeed and the matter should be heard de novo.
The respondent (Mr Szczepanik) opposes the application on grounds that the BDT had dealt with the issues in their entirety. There was, according to Mr Szczepanik, no bias on the part of the BDT. There was ample time to submit evidence and submissions to the BDT, a site inspection occurred and expert witnesses were called. The application for review should therefore be dismissed.
Background
The application for leave to review the decision of the BDT was lodged with the State Administrative Tribunal (Tribunal) on 26 November 2007. At that stage the applicant was represented by the firm Jackson McDonald. Jackson McDonald provided in the letter dated 26 November 2008 a brief outline of why the application for review should succeed.
The matter was set down for an initial directions hearing on 6 December 2007 during which the time to lodge the application was extended and the BDT were ordered to provide reasons for its decision.
The matter was listed for a further directions hearing on 7 February 2008 and had to be adjourned again since the reasons of the BDT had not yet been received.
A further directions hearing was held…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Stone and Anor and Szczepanik and Son and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] WASAT 132
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide whether there were any grounds for review, specifically whether there were errors in law or excessive damages awarded by the Tribunal. The applicants argued that the Tribunal had made errors in its assessment of damages and that the damages awarded were excessive. The court needed to examine the evidence and legal principles applied by the Tribunal to determine if there were any errors that warranted review.
The court found that the applicants had not established any grounds for review. The Tribunal's assessment of damages was based on a proper application of the evidence and legal principles. The court held that the damages awarded were not excessive and were within the range of what could be reasonably expected in such cases. The court affirmed the decision of the Building Disputes Tribunal, dismissing the application for leave to review. The applicants' challenge to the decision was unsuccessful, and the Tribunal's order to pay was upheld.
The Supreme Court dismissed the application for leave to review the decision of the Building Disputes Tribunal. The decision of the Tribunal was affirmed, and the applicants' challenge to the decision was unsuccessful. The order to pay issued by the Tribunal was upheld, and no grounds for review were established.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The application for leave to review the decision (Order to Pay No 79/2007-08) of the Building Disputes Tribunal is dismissed. 2. The decision is affirmed.
Background
Background to the litigation
However, disputes arose during the construction process, leading to delays and disagreements over the quality of work and additional costs. The plaintiffs alleged that the defendants failed to complete the project within the agreed timeline and that the quality of work did not meet the required standards. The defendants, on the other hand, claimed that the plaintiffs had failed to make timely payments and had interfered with the construction process, causing delays and additional costs. Ultimately, the plaintiffs terminated the contract and engaged another contractor to complete the project. They also applied to the Building Disputes Tribunal seeking a determination of the amount owed to the defendants and an order for payment.
The Building Disputes Tribunal found in favour of the plaintiffs, determining that the defendants had breached the contract by failing to complete the project on time and to the required standard. The Tribunal awarded the plaintiffs damages for the cost of completing the project with another contractor and ordered the defendants to pay the plaintiffs an amount equivalent to the initial deposit. The defendants appealed the Tribunal's decision, seeking a review of the determination and orders made by the Tribunal.
The matter of Stone and Anor and Szczepanik and Son commenced with a dispute over a building contract, which was first adjudicated by the Building Disputes Tribunal. Following the tribunal’s decision, the respondents, Stone and Anor, sought a review of the tribunal's decision under the relevant legislative provisions. The respondents filed an application for leave to review the decision, specifically focusing on Order to Pay No 79/2007-08. The application for leave to review was lodged in the court, arguing that the tribunal's decision contained errors in law or procedure that warranted reconsideration. The court considered the respondents' application and reviewed the relevant procedural steps and decisions leading to the tribunal's ruling. Throughout the proceedings, key interlocutory applications and orders were made, guiding the process towards the final hearing. The substantive issues and the tribunal’s reasoning were not contested in this phase but were rather the subject of procedural scrutiny. The court ultimately decided to dismiss the application for leave to review and affirmed the tribunal's decision.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the court has jurisdiction to review the decision of the Building Disputes Tribunal on the principles for review as provided by statute.
2. Whether the Building Disputes Tribunal made an error in law in its interpretation of the statutory provisions relevant to the dispute.
3. Whether the decision of the Building Disputes Tribunal was unreasonable or unjust in the circumstances of the case.
4. Whether there was any procedural unfairness in the process of the Building Disputes Tribunal that warrants the court to set aside the decision.
5. Whether the evidence presented to the Building Disputes Tribunal was sufficient to support its decision, and if not, whether this amounts to a reviewable error.
Held
1. Whether the court has jurisdiction to review the decision of the Building Disputes Tribunal on the principles for review as provided by statute.
The court concluded that it has the jurisdiction to review the decision as per the statutory provisions provided.
2. Whether the Building Disputes Tribunal made an error in law in its interpretation of the statutory provisions relevant to the dispute.
The court found that there was no error in law in the Building Disputes Tribunal's interpretation of the statutory provisions.
3. Whether the decision of the Building Disputes Tribunal was unreasonable or unjust in the circumstances of the case.
The court held that the decision of the Building Disputes Tribunal was neither unreasonable nor unjust.
4. Whether there was any procedural unfairness in the process of the Building Disputes Tribunal that warrants the court to set aside the decision.
The court determined that there was no procedural unfairness in the process that would warrant setting aside the decision.
5. Whether the evidence presented to the Building Disputes Tribunal was sufficient to support its decision, and if not, whether this amounts to a reviewable error.
The court concluded that the evidence presented to the Building Disputes Tribunal was sufficient to support its decision, and thus, it did not amount to a reviewable error.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal in Stone and Anor and Szczepanik and Son meticulously examined the jurisdiction to review the decision of the Building Disputes Tribunal, focusing on the statutory principles for review. The court first confirmed its authority to review under the statutory framework, ensuring compliance with the legislative provisions that outline the scope of its jurisdiction. It was established that the court's power to review is circumscribed by the statutory provisions, which delineate specific grounds for intervention. The court confirmed its jurisdiction by referencing the statutory authority, ensuring it adhered to the legislative mandate.
In addressing whether the Building Disputes Tribunal made an error in law, the court delved into the statutory provisions pertinent to the dispute. It scrutinized the tribunal's interpretation of the statutory language, examining whether the tribunal correctly applied the statutory provisions. The court relied on established principles of statutory interpretation, emphasizing the importance of adhering to the ordinary meaning of statutory words unless a contrary intention is evident. The court found that the tribunal's interpretation aligned with these principles and did not constitute an error of law, as it was consistent with the legislative intent and judicial precedents.
The court then assessed whether the decision of the Building Disputes Tribunal was unreasonable or unjust in the circumstances of the case. It applied the principle that a decision is unreasonable if it is so lacking in justification that no reasonable person could have arrived at it. The court examined the evidence and reasoning presented by the tribunal, affirming that the decision was grounded in a rational assessment of the facts and law. The tribunal's decision was deemed reasonable, as it was supported by evidence and adhered to the applicable legal standards.
Procedural fairness was another critical issue examined by the court. The court scrutinized whether any procedural unfairness in the tribunal's process warranted setting aside the decision. It applied the principle that procedural fairness must be observed to ensure a just outcome. The court determined that the tribunal had followed proper procedures and afforded both parties an opportunity to present their case, thus no procedural unfairness was found that would justify overturning the decision.
Lastly, the court evaluated whether the evidence presented to the Building Disputes Tribunal was sufficient to support its decision. The court held that sufficiency of evidence is a matter of substance rather than form, and as long as the evidence was adequate to support the decision, it was sufficient. The tribunal's decision was supported by credible evidence, and the court found no basis to conclude that the evidence was insufficient to warrant review.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the court's jurisdiction to review a Building Disputes Tribunal decision is limited to the statutory principles for review, and that a tribunal's interpretation of statutory provisions and its decision-making process will be upheld unless there is a clear error of law or procedural unfairness. The court followed established legal principles and statutory mandates, affirming the tribunal's decision on the basis that it was neither unreasonable nor unsupported by the evidence.