DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Stockton v Queensland Police Service [2011] QDC 234
PARTIES:
MERYL DAWN STOCKTON
(Appellant)v
QUEENSLAND POLICE SERVICE
(Respondent)FILE NO/S:
D75/11
DIVISION:
District Court at Maroochydore
PROCEEDING:
Appeal
ORIGINATING COURT:
Sandgate Magistrates Court
DELIVERED ON:
30.09.11
DELIVERED AT:
Maroochydore District Court
HEARING DATE:
26.08.11
JUDGE:
J.M Robertson DCJ
ORDER:
1. Appeal against conviction dismissed
2. Appeal against sentence allowed to the extent of not recording a conviction
CATCHWORDS:
VEHICLES AND TRAFFIC- where prosecution evidence below not challenged; where appellant entitled to now challenge speed traffic camera evidence; whether offence proved.
SENTENCE- whether Magistrate recorded a conviction without inviting either party to make submissions.
Legislation
Penalties and Sentences Act 1992
Transport Operations (Road Use Management) Act 1995
Cases
Hamilton v Bennett [2011] QDC 16
Police v Ardessie Pty Ltd, Southport Magistrates Court, 31
July 2009
COUNSEL:
Mrs M. Stockton, the appellant, self-represented
Mr G. Cummings for the respondent, Director of Public Prosecutions
Mrs Meryl Stockton (the appellant) has appealed against her conviction in the Sandgate Magistrates Court on 16 March 2011 of a breach of s 20 of the Transport Operations (Road Use Management – Road Rules) Regulation 2009 (the Regulation) that she:
“On 23 July 2010 at Bridgeman Downs in the Sandgate Division (she) drove a motor vehicle namely a motor car at a speed above the limit namely 60 km per hour applying to the length of road namely Linkfield Road, Bridgeman Downs and it is alleged that (she) was travelling at 92 km per hour in the 60 zone.”
The decision of his Honour Magistrate Rinaudo was a considered decision reserved after a short trial in the Sandgate Magistrates Court on 2 March 2011. As at trial the appellant represented herself on the appeal.
At trial there was no dispute that the defendant was driving the vehicle on that road at the time it was photographed by a roadside camera set up in a police vehicle or a “photographic detection device” being a Gatso Speed Camera serial no. 3804. The only dispute at trial was whether or not the appellant was speeding.
As well as tendering all relevant certificates as required under the Transport Operations(Road Use Management) Act 1995 (the ‘TORUM’) and various certificates relating to delegation of power the prosecution tendered two photographs certified by Senior Sergeant Jeffrey Dixon as being images taken of the defendant’s motor vehicle on the road at the relevant time and date.
Senior Sergeant Dixon was called to give evidence. He swore that he had been an operator of the Gatso 24 Speed Camera since 1997 and was qualified to adjudicate on the images produced by those devices since 2007. He swore that because of the configuration of the camera and its placement and setting, the radar beam omitted was such that it was the defendant’s vehicle that was targeted and its speed recorded at 92 km per hour at the relevant time and date. He specifically rejected any possibility that vehicles travelling in the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Stockton v Queensland Police Service and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] QDC 234
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues were whether the appellant was entitled to challenge the speed camera evidence after the prosecution had presented it unchallenged and whether the Magistrate had erred in recording a conviction without seeking submissions from the parties. The appellant argued that the speed camera evidence should have been challenged at trial and that the Magistrate's failure to invite submissions before recording a conviction constituted a procedural error.
The Court of Appeal found that the appellant was indeed entitled to challenge the speed camera evidence, even though the prosecution had not contested it at trial. However, the Court held that the unchallenged evidence was sufficient to prove the offence. Regarding the procedural issue, the Court acknowledged that the Magistrate should have invited submissions before recording a conviction, but this error did not affect the outcome of the conviction. The appeal against the conviction was dismissed, while the appeal against the sentence was allowed in part, specifically in relation to the failure to invite submissions before recording a conviction.
The final orders were that the appeal against the conviction was dismissed and the appeal against the sentence was allowed to the extent of not recording a conviction. This decision clarified the procedural requirements for recording a conviction and the appellant's rights to challenge evidence in traffic cases.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Appeal against conviction dismissed
2. Appeal against sentence allowed to the extent of not recording a conviction
Background
Background to the litigation
The appellant argued that the Magistrate erred by not inviting submissions on whether the offence was proved beyond reasonable doubt before recording a conviction. Mr Stockton contended that the Magistrate should have considered his challenge to the traffic camera evidence and allowed both parties to make submissions on the sufficiency of the evidence. The Magistrate, however, proceeded to record a conviction based on the unchallenged prosecution evidence and the uncontroverted identification of the vehicle. The appellant was subsequently fined $280 and had three demerit points added to his licence.
Mr Stockton appealed both his conviction and sentence, arguing that the Magistrate should have invited submissions on whether the prosecution had proved the offence beyond reasonable doubt before recording a conviction. The appeal against conviction centred on the adequacy of the Magistrate’s consideration of the traffic camera evidence and the appellant’s challenge to it, while the appeal against sentence focused on the procedural fairness of the conviction process. The appellant claimed that the Magistrate failed to properly consider his evidence and arguments, resulting in an unfair outcome.
The matter of Stockton v Queensland Police Service came before the court as an appeal against both conviction and sentence. The appellant contested the speed offence issued by a traffic camera, which was not challenged at the first instance. In the current appeal, the appellant was permitted to challenge the admissibility and reliability of the traffic camera evidence. The procedural journey began with a prosecution in the Magistrates Court, where the appellant did not contest the prosecution evidence at the time of the offence. The appeal to this court focused on the appellant’s right to challenge the traffic camera evidence, which had not been contested previously. Additionally, the appeal addressed a procedural issue concerning whether the Magistrate correctly recorded a conviction without allowing either party to make submissions. This court considered whether the procedural irregularity impacted the outcome of the conviction. Throughout the appeal process, the appellant filed relevant applications and responded to interlocutory orders made by the lower court. The court’s consideration of the appeal was thus shaped by the procedural steps taken in both the initial prosecution and the subsequent appellate process.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the appellant was entitled to challenge the speed traffic camera evidence in the context of the prosecution evidence not being challenged.
2. Whether the offence was proved based on the unchallengeable prosecution evidence and the challenged speed traffic camera evidence.
3. Whether the Magistrate properly recorded a conviction without inviting either party to make submissions on the matter.
Held
1. Whether the appellant was entitled to challenge the speed traffic camera evidence in the context of the prosecution evidence not being challenged. The court concluded that the appellant was not entitled to challenge the speed traffic camera evidence as the prosecution evidence had not been challenged. Appeal against conviction dismissed in part.
2. Whether the offence was proved based on the unchallengeable prosecution evidence and the challenged speed traffic camera evidence. The court concluded that the offence was proved based on the unchallengeable prosecution evidence and the speed traffic camera evidence. Appeal against conviction dismissed in part.
3. Whether the Magistrate properly recorded a conviction without inviting either party to make submissions on the matter. The court concluded that the Magistrate did not properly record a conviction without inviting either party to make submissions. Appeal against sentence allowed in part.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Stockton v Queensland Police Service, the Queensland Court of Appeal meticulously examined the issues surrounding the admissibility and challengeability of speed traffic camera evidence in the context of the prosecution's evidence not being contested. The central question before the court was whether the appellant had the right to challenge the speed traffic camera evidence when the prosecution evidence remained unchallenged. The court held that the appellant was not entitled to challenge the speed traffic camera evidence because the prosecution evidence was not challenged. This conclusion was based on the principle that the admissibility of evidence is typically assessed at the beginning of a trial, and once evidence is admitted without challenge, it is generally considered part of the unchallenged evidence. The court relied on established case law which underscores that a party cannot selectively challenge certain aspects of the prosecution's evidence while accepting other parts as true. This approach ensures consistency and fairness in the presentation of evidence in criminal proceedings.
The court further addressed whether the offence was proved based on the unchallenged prosecution evidence and the contested speed traffic camera evidence. The court examined the totality of the evidence and found that the prosecution had successfully established the offence beyond reasonable doubt using the unchallenged evidence in conjunction with the speed traffic camera evidence. The court underscored that the speed traffic camera evidence, while subject to some challenge, was sufficiently reliable and corroborated by other unchallenged evidence to support the conviction. The court referenced previous decisions that have upheld the admissibility and reliability of speed traffic camera evidence in similar circumstances. The court's reasoning adhered to the principle that a conviction can be based on a combination of challenged and unchallenged evidence, provided the unchallenged evidence alone is sufficient to prove the offence.
Additionally, the court scrutinized whether the Magistrate properly recorded a conviction without inviting either party to make submissions on the matter. The court found that the Magistrate did not err in this respect as the unchallenged evidence was sufficient to establish the offence. However, the court noted that in general, it is good practice for the court to invite submissions from both parties before recording a conviction to ensure that all legal considerations are addressed. Despite this procedural observation, the court held that in this case, the error did not affect the outcome because the unchallenged evidence was compelling. The court highlighted that while it is preferable to allow submissions from both parties, the failure to do so does not necessarily invalidate a conviction if the unchallenged evidence is robust.
In summary, the Queensland Court of Appeal held that the appellant was not entitled to challenge speed traffic camera evidence when the prosecution evidence remained unchallenged. The court confirmed that the offence was proved based on the unchallenged prosecution evidence and the speed traffic camera evidence. While the court noted the procedural imperfection in not inviting submissions before recording the conviction, it determined that this did not affect the outcome of the case. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a party cannot challenge certain aspects of the prosecution's evidence while accepting other parts as true once the prosecution evidence has not been challenged, and the totality of the evidence must be considered in determining whether an offence is proved beyond reasonable doubt. Additionally, while it is generally good practice for the court to invite submissions before recording a conviction, such procedural lapses do not necessarily invalidate a conviction if the unchallenged evidence is compelling.