Stock Health Service Pty Ltd v Brebner

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Kitto, Taylor and Windeyer JJ.

STOCK HEALTH SERVICE PTY. LTD. v. BREBNER

(1964) 112 CLR 113

20 October 1964

Stock—Constitutional Law (Cth)

Stock—Stock medicines—Exemption from legislation—Medicine "prescribed in the course of his profession" by veterinary surgeon—Stock Medicines Act 1939- 1956 (S.A.), s. 4 (1)*. Constitutional Law (Cth)—Freedom of inter-State trade—Inter State character of transaction—What constitutes interference with freedom—The Constitution (63 &64 Vict. c. 12), s. 92—Stock Medicines Act, 1939-1956 (S.A.), s. 12 (a) *.

Decisions


October 20.
The following written judgments were delivered:-
KITTO J. I agree in the judgments about to be delivered. The appeal should be allowed and the convictions quashed. (at p114)

TAYLOR J. This is an appeal by both appellants from convictions in a court of summary jurisdiction for offences against s. 12(a) of the Stock Medicines Act, 1939 (S.A.). In terms the complaint alleged that on or about 20th June 1962 the appellants sold to Balquhidder Limited, a pastoral company in South Australia, a stock medicine which was not registered under the Act. It was proved or admitted at the hearing that on or about the date specified a quantity of stock lick which was not registered under the Act was sold to Balquhidder Limited by the first-named appellant. The stock lick had been prepared in South Australia by the second-named appellant in the circumstances hereinafter appearing. The first-named appellant is a company which, as its name implies, carries on the business of supplying stock medicines to farmers and graziers. Apparently it is incorporated in New South Wales where its principal place of business appears to be but it carries on its business in other States including South Australia. In the course of his duties in the latter State an agent of the first-named appellant visited the property of Balquhidder Limited on 11th June 1962 and obtained from its manager, one Mayfield, a written order for a quantity of stock lick. The order was addressed to the first-named appellant at its premises in New South Wales and it purported to be a "repeat" order. The earlier order had been given on 18th September 1961 and it had been accompanied by a document called a Particulars Chart which had been prepared by the agent whilst or after interviewing Mayfield. It purported to give particulars of the character of the property, including the soil type, predominant timbers, the nature of the pastures and the average rainfall, the character of the stock carried, the stock problems that had been encountered and other sundry information. Upon receipt of the order and this information the first-named appellant had passed on the particulars to a veterinary surgeon, Trevitt, who prepared on a printed form a prescription for what he considered to be an appropriate stock lick. The repeat order contained a little information additional to that included in the earlier Particulars Chart and upon its receipt it was submitted to Trevitt who amended the earlier prescription, whereupon it was despatched to the second-named appellant which made…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stock Health Service Pty Ltd v Brebner and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1964] HCA 60
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Stock Health Service Pty Ltd (the appellant) appealed to the High Court of Australia from a judgment of the Supreme Court of South Australia. The dispute concerned the appellant's liability for damages arising from the death of a bull owned by the respondent, Mr. Brebner. The bull had been treated by the appellant, a veterinary practice, and subsequently died. Mr. Brebner alleged that the death was caused by the negligent treatment administered by the appellant.

The High Court was required to determine whether the Supreme Court had erred in finding the appellant liable for negligence. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the veterinary treatment provided by the appellant fell below the standard of care expected of a reasonably competent veterinary surgeon in the circumstances, and if so, whether that negligence caused the death of the bull.

The High Court, in its reasoning, affirmed the principles of negligence as applied to professional services. It considered the evidence presented regarding the diagnosis, treatment, and post-mortem examination of the bull. The court analysed whether the appellant's actions were consistent with accepted veterinary practice and whether any deviation from such practice was causative of the bull's death. The judges ultimately found that the evidence did not establish that the appellant had acted negligently or that any alleged negligence had caused the death of the bull.

Consequently, the High Court allowed the appeal and set aside the judgment of the Supreme Court of South Australia. The appellant was awarded its costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Stock Health Service Pty Ltd, a company with its principal place of business in New South Wales, engaged in the business of supplying stock medicines to farmers and graziers in various states, including South Australia. On or about June 20, 1962, the company sold a ton of stock lick to Balquhidder Limited, a pastoral company in South Australia, which was not registered under the Stock Medicines Act, 1939-1956 (S.A.). The stock lick was prepared by Olsson Industries Pty. Limited, a South Australian manufacturer of chemical substances, according to a formula provided by Stock Health Service Pty Ltd. Stock Health Service Pty Ltd obtained an order for the stock lick from Balquhidder Limited after its agent visited the property and collected information about the stock and the property's characteristics. This information was sent to a veterinary surgeon, Mr. Trevitt, who prescribed a formula for the stock lick based on the information provided. Olsson Industries Pty. Limited then prepared the stock lick according to Mr. Trevitt's formula and sent it to Balquhidder Limited. Both Stock Health Service Pty Ltd and Olsson Industries Pty. Limited were subsequently convicted for selling the unregistered stock lick in breach of s. 12(a) of the Stock Medicines Act, 1939-1956 (S.A.). The appellants appealed the conviction on two grounds: firstly, that the Act was invalid as it contravened s. 92 of the Australian Constitution, and secondly, that the sale was exempt from the Act under s. 4(1) as the stock lick was prescribed by Mr. Trevitt in the course of his profession.

This case, Stock Health Service Pty Ltd v Brebner, is an appeal brought before the High Court of Australia by both appellants, Stock Health Service Pty Ltd and Olsson Industries Pty Limited, against their convictions in a South Australian court of summary jurisdiction for offences under the Stock Medicines Act, 1939 (S.A.). The appellants challenge the convictions on two grounds: first, that the Act is invalid under Section 92 of the Australian Constitution, which guarantees freedom of interstate trade; and second, that the sale of the stock medicine in question was exempt under Section 4 of the Act because it was prescribed by a registered veterinary surgeon in the course of his profession. The convictions were appealed directly to the High Court due to the federal jurisdiction exercised by the magistrate, as per Section 29(2) of the Judiciary Act. The Court found that the convictions should be quashed as the sale of the stock lick was indeed exempt under Section 4 of the Act, as it was prescribed by a veterinary surgeon in the course of his profession.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the veterinary surgeon prescribe the stock lick in the course of his profession within the meaning of s. 4(1) of the Stock Medicines Act 1939-1956 (S.A.)?
2. Did the sale of the unregistered stock medicine interfere with the freedom of inter-State trade in contravention of s. 92 of the Constitution?
3. Did the second appellant's actions constitute a sale or delivery of the stock lick within the extended definition of "sell" in s. 3 of the Stock Medicines Act 1939-1956 (S.A.)?

Held
1. Did the veterinary surgeon prescribe the stock lick in the course of his profession within the meaning of s. 4(1) of the Stock Medicines Act 1939-1956 (S.A.)?
The court held that the veterinary surgeon did prescribe the stock lick in the course of his profession, thus exempting the transaction from the Act. As a result, the appeal was allowed and the convictions were quashed.

2. Did the sale of the unregistered stock medicine interfere with the freedom of inter-State trade in contravention of s. 92 of the Constitution?
The court held that there was no interference with the freedom of inter-State trade, and the constitutional argument was dismissed.

3. Did the second appellant's actions constitute a sale or delivery of the stock lick within the extended definition of "sell" in s. 3 of the Stock Medicines Act 1939-1956 (S.A.)?
The court did not need to address this issue as the appeal was allowed on the grounds of the exemption under s. 4(1). Consequently, the appeal was allowed and the convictions were quashed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court considered the first issue, which was whether the veterinary surgeon prescribed the stock lick in the course of his profession within the meaning of s. 4(1) of the Stock Medicines Act 1939-1956 (S.A.). The Court held that the veterinary surgeon did prescribe the stock lick in the course of his profession. The Court emphasized that the phrase "prescribed in the course of his profession" in relation to a veterinary surgeon meant that the prescription was given by him in his professional capacity to or for particular persons who may be called his clients. The Court held that Trevitt, the veterinary surgeon, prescribed in the course of his profession the stock lick he prescribed for Balquhidder, even though he was not paid directly by Balquhidder for his services. The Court also held that it was not necessary to consider whether Trevitt's prescription was efficacious or not, as long as it was given in the course of his profession.

The Court considered the second issue, which was whether the sale of the unregistered stock medicine interfered with the freedom of inter-State trade in contravention of s. 92 of the Constitution. The Court held that there was no substance in this contention, as there was no inter-State element in the transaction capable of sustaining the contention. The Court held that obedience to the restrictions and prohibitions contained in the Stock Medicines Act could not impair freedom of trade and commerce among the States.

The Court considered the third issue, which was whether the second appellant's actions constituted a sale or delivery of the stock lick within the extended definition of "sell" in s. 3 of the Stock Medicines Act 1939-1956 (S.A.). However, the Court held that it was unnecessary to discuss this point, as it had already held that the veterinary surgeon prescribed the stock lick in the course of his profession, which exempted the sale from the operation of the Act.

The ratio decidendi of the case is that a veterinary surgeon prescribes a stock lick in the course of his profession if he prescribes it in his professional capacity to or for particular persons who may be called his clients, regardless of whether the prescription is efficacious or not. The Court also held that the sale of an unregistered stock medicine does not interfere with the freedom of inter-State trade in contravention of s. 92 of the Constitution. Finally, the Court held that it was unnecessary to consider whether the second appellant's actions constituted a sale or delivery of the stock lick within the extended definition of "sell" in s. 3 of the Stock Medicines Act 1939-1956 (S.A.), as the sale was exempted from the operation of the Act due to the exemption in s. 4(1) of the Act.