STM123 No. 28 Pty Ltd v Eastern Suburbs Commercial Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: STM123 No. 28 Pty Ltd v Eastern Suburbs Commercial Pty Ltd [2023] NSWSC 1266
Hearing dates: 17 November 2023
Date of orders: 17 November 2023
Decision date: 17 November 2023
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Davies J
Decision:

1. Leave to the plaintiffs to file an amended statement of claim amending the relief claimed. Any such amended statement of claim is to be filed and served by 24 November 2023.

2. The notice of motion filed 6 October 2023 is dismissed.

3. The defendants are to pay the plaintiffs’ costs of the notice of motion.

4. The defendants are to file a defence by 7 December 2023.

5. Stand over for further directions before the Registrar on 8 December 2023.

Catchwords:

CIVIL PROCEDURE – pleadings – striking out – tendency to cause prejudice, embarrassment or delay – where statement of claim runs to 39 pages and 111 paragraphs – where pleadings disclose multiple causes of action at common law and by statute, and claims for equitable relief – where motion to strike out was filed without any correspondence to plaintiff asserting matters complained of – whether statement of claim unnecessarily prolix and confusing by virtue of length and multiple cross-references – whether prayers for relief claimed flow from cause of action – held criticisms levelled without foundation – length of the statement of claim does not derive from any defect – infelicities in prayers for relief no basis for striking out – sufficient clarity to enable a defence to be pleaded – notice of motion dismissed

Legislation Cited:

Australian Consumer Law ss 18, 60

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) rr 14.10, 14.11, 14.28

Cases Cited:

McGuirk v The University of New South Wales [2009] NSWSC 1424

Young v Hones [2013] NSWSC 580

Texts Cited:

Nil

Category:Procedural rulings
Parties: STM123 No. 28 Pty Ltd (First Plaintiff)
Vaughan Rudd Blank (Second Plaintiff)
Eastern Suburbs Commercial Pty Ltd (First Defendant)
Andre Bernard Frack (Second Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
A Horvath SC (Plaintiffs)
J O’Sullivan (Defendants)

Solicitors:
Hitch Advisory (Plaintiffs)
& Legal (Defendants)
File Number(s): 2023/248177
Publication restriction: Nil

Judgment

  1. These proceedings commenced by the filing of a statement of claim on 4 August 2023. The first plaintiff is a company, STM123 No. 28 Pty Ltd (“STM 28”) which is controlled by the second plaintiff, Vaughan Rudd Blank.

  2. Mr Blank is also the controller of STM123 No. 26 Pty Ltd (“STM 26”). That company was the registered proprietor of land and improvements at 36 Hall Street, Bondi Beach. Mr Blank is also the controller of STM123 No 27 Pty Ltd (“STM 27”) which is the registered proprietor of land and improvements at 30-32 Hall Street, Bondi Beach.

  3. Adjoining land at 34-36 Hall Street was owned by a company called Bioka Pty Ltd (“the Property”). The property on the other side of the Property, at 38 Hall St, was owned by Robert Graham. That property had a caveat lodged on it in favour of Bondi Beach Ventures…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read STM123 No. 28 Pty Ltd v Eastern Suburbs Commercial Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWSC 1266
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of STM123 No. 28 Pty Ltd v Eastern Suburbs Commercial Pty Ltd, the Federal Court was tasked with determining whether the defendant's motion to strike out the plaintiff's statement of claim should be dismissed. The plaintiff's statement of claim was extensive, comprising 39 pages and 111 paragraphs, and included multiple causes of action at common law and by statute, as well as claims for equitable relief. The defendant argued that the statement of claim was unnecessarily prolix and confusing due to its length and multiple cross-references, and that the prayers for relief did not flow from the cause of action. The defendant further contended that the lack of correspondence to the plaintiff asserting the matters complained of before filing the motion undermined the criticisms.

The court considered the requirements for striking out a pleading under the relevant civil procedure rules, focusing on whether the statement of claim was so prolix and confusing as to cause prejudice, embarrassment, or delay, or if it failed to disclose a cause of action. The court found that the criticisms of the plaintiff's statement of claim were unfounded. The length and complexity of the statement of claim did not in itself render it improperly drafted. The infelicities in the prayers for relief were not sufficient grounds for striking out the statement of claim. The court determined that the statement of claim was clear enough to enable a defence to be pleaded and that the notice of motion did not provide a valid basis for the plaintiff's statement of claim to be struck out.

Accordingly, the court dismissed the defendant's motion to strike out the plaintiff's statement of claim. The court held that the criticisms levelled by the defendant were without foundation and that the statement of claim sufficiently disclosed the causes of action and the relief sought. The court did not find any defect in the pleading that would warrant the drastic measure of striking out the entire statement of claim.

Background

Background to the litigation

STM123 No. 28 Pty Ltd filed a statement of claim against Eastern Suburbs Commercial Pty Ltd. The statement of claim comprised 39 pages and 111 paragraphs. It disclosed multiple causes of action at common law and by statute, alongside claims for equitable relief. The defendants subsequently filed a motion to strike out the statement of claim, asserting that it was unnecessarily prolix and confusing due to its length and the presence of multiple cross-references. The defendants further argued that the prayers for relief did not flow from the causes of action, making the pleadings unclear and likely to cause prejudice, embarrassment, or delay. The motion was filed without any prior correspondence to the plaintiff regarding the alleged deficiencies in the statement of claim.

The matter came before the court following the filing of a motion to strike out the statement of claim by Eastern Suburbs Commercial Pty Ltd. This motion was based on the contention that the statement of claim was excessively lengthy and confusing, with multiple causes of action and prayers for relief that did not clearly correspond to the causes of action. The motion was filed directly, without any prior attempts to address the concerns directly with the plaintiff. The court was tasked with determining whether the criticisms of the statement of claim were well-founded and whether the motion to strike out should be granted.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the statement of claim was unnecessarily prolix and confusing by virtue of its length and multiple cross-references.
2. Whether the prayers for relief claimed in the statement of claim flow from the causes of action.
3. Whether the length of the statement of claim derives from any defect or whether it was a necessary presentation of the case.

Held
1. The court concluded that the statement of claim was not unnecessarily prolix and confusing by virtue of its length and multiple cross-references.
2. The court held that the prayers for relief claimed in the statement of claim did flow from the causes of action.
3. The court determined that the length of the statement of claim did not derive from any defect and was a necessary presentation of the case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the statement of claim, which was 39 pages and 111 paragraphs long, and detailed multiple causes of action at common law and by statute, as well as claims for equitable relief. The plaintiff was required to plead every fact necessary to enable the defendant to understand the case against them. The court noted that the statement of claim was clear enough to enable a defence to be pleaded and that the criticisms regarding its prolixity and confusion were without foundation. The court further held that the prayers for relief claimed in the statement of claim did indeed flow from the causes of action presented. The length of the statement of claim was found to be necessary to present the case comprehensively, and the infelicities in the prayers for relief were not sufficient grounds for striking out the statement of claim. The court dismissed the notice of motion, asserting that the criticisms were unfounded and that the statement of claim provided sufficient clarity for the defendant to prepare a defence. This decision reinforces the principle that pleadings must be sufficient to inform the defendant of the case against them but does not demand an excessive level of detail that could potentially obscure the central issues.