Stirling v Police No. Scgrg-98-1502 Judgment No. S435

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

STIRLING  v  POLICE
[1999] SASC 435

Full Court: Duggan, Debelle and Bleby JJ

  1. DUGGAN J.      The appellant was convicted in the Clare Magistrates Court of driving a vehicle while there was present in his blood the prescribed concentration of alcohol, driving whilst disqualified from holding a driver’s licence, driving without due care and driving with inadequate lights. It was alleged by the prosecution that the offences arose out of the one incident which occurred on 5 September 1997.

  2. The prosecution called two police officers who were patrolling in a police vehicle in the town of Blyth on the evening of 5 September.  They gave evidence that at about 11.35 pm they saw a car travelling towards them along one of the streets in the town.  The vehicle then veered sharply to the right onto the wrong side of the road.  The lights of the vehicle went off, the vehicle returned to the correct side of the road and it was brought to a halt outside the Blyth Hotel.

  3. One of the officers, Constable Berry, said the vehicle was 90 to 130 metres away from the police vehicle when he first observed it.  He said the police vehicle was approximately 20 metres from the other vehicle while it was being parked.  The other police officer, Constable Hutchings, said the police vehicle was about 25 metres away from the other vehicle as it was parked.

  4. According to the evidence of the police officers the appellant got out of the vehicle after it was parked.  The vehicle was a red Sigma.  They said that the appellant denied he was driving the vehicle and said that he did not have a licence.  He was later required to submit to a breath analysis and the reading recorded was 0.169 grams in 100 millilitres of blood.

  5. The appellant gave evidence at the hearing before the learned magistrate who summarised that evidence in the following passage in his reasons for judgment:

    “In his answer to those four charges the defendant denied that he had driven the Sigma sedan on Guilford Street on the occasion in question.  He did admit that he was disqualified from holding or obtaining a licence at that time.  According to his version of events the Sigma sedan had been angle-parked on the northerly side of Guilford Street outside the Blyth Hotel since about 7.00 pm on that night.  He said that Richard Agnew, his girlfriend’s brother, had driven him to the hotel in that vehicle at about that time.  After a few drinks, Agnew had left to walk home. The defendant stayed at the hotel until it closed.  He said that when he eventually departed he walked over to the Sigma to retrieve a bottle of Cougar whisky which had been left there, and to look for a cigarette lighter.  He explained that, although he did not have a key to the vehicle, he was able to gain access through the driver’s door which was unlocked.  He also explained that, as the interior…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stirling v Police No. Scgrg-98-1502 Judgment No. S435 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] SASC 435
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Stirling v Police, the appellant was convicted in the Clare Magistrates Court of various driving offences, including driving under the influence of alcohol, driving while disqualified, driving without due care, and driving with inadequate lights. The conviction arose from an incident on 5 September 1997, where police officers observed a car veering sharply, losing its lights, and then being parked outside the Blyth Hotel. The officers testified that they saw the appellant exit the vehicle, which was identified as a red Sigma, and that he denied driving the car and admitted to being disqualified from holding a driver’s licence. The appellant claimed he was merely retrieving items from the car, which had been parked since 7.00 pm by his girlfriend’s brother, Richard Agnew. Agnew corroborated the appellant's account, stating that he had driven the appellant to the hotel and left the car keys with him.

The legal issues before the court were whether the learned magistrate correctly assessed the evidence to determine if the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant was driving the vehicle at the relevant time, and if the magistrate appropriately considered all evidence, including that of Agnew, in reaching the conclusion. The court held that the magistrate erred by concluding that the vehicle observed by the police was the same one from which the appellant emerged without fully considering Agnew’s evidence, which contradicted the police account. The court found that the magistrate’s failure to adequately consider Agnew’s evidence before reaching a final conclusion on the vehicle identification was a misstep in the assessment process.

The Full Court allowed the appeal, set aside the convictions and sentence, and ordered a retrial before another magistrate. The judges agreed with Duggan J’s reasoning and the proposed orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

DUGGAN J DEBELLE J BLEBY J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DUGGAN J, DEBELLE J, BLEBY J