Stewart v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

Dust Diseases Tribunal


of New South Wales


CITATION: Stewart v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited & Anor [2008] NSWDDT 6
PARTIES: Irene Stewart (as legal personal representative of the Estate of the Late Angus Clugston Stewart)
QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited
Wallaby Grip Limited
MATTER NUMBER(S): 7279 of 2007
JUDGMENT OF: Kearns J
CATCHWORDS: Dust Diseases Tribunal :- Ruling;
employers' indemnity insurance;
statutory minimum common law cover $40,000 at the relevant time;
admission as to existence of policy;
no admission as to the extent of common law cover;
no evidence of extent of common law cover;
whether plaintiff or insurer has onus to establish extent of common law cover
LEGISLATION CITED: Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946
CASES CITED: Di Cecco v Mercantile Mutual Insurance (Workers' Compensation) Limited (2002) 23 NSWCCR 143
Orica Australia Pty Ltd v CGU Insurance Ltd [2002] NSWDDT 8
Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance Australia Limited v Betta Industries Pty Limited (2002) 24 NSWCCR 164
DATES OF HEARING: 01.02.2008
EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE: 1 February 2008
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:

Mr J Sharpe, instructed by Turner Freeman, appeared for the plaintiff

Mr G Little SC, with Mr G J Parker, instructed by Moray & Agnew appeared for the first defendant

Mr D J Russell SC instructed by Middletons appeared for the second defendant


JUDGMENT:

RULING

KEARNS, J

1. In the course of the plaintiff's case there arose an issue as to whether the policy of the first defendant, or the policy it has assumed, which covered the liability of the plaintiff's employer, was limited. It is clear that there was in place a policy of insurance. The first defendant has admitted that Eagle Star Insurance Limited was the employer's indemnity insurer of the plaintiff's employer. It has also admitted that it is responsible to meet the liabilities of Eagle Star Insurance Limited in respect of any liability that that company would have to indemnify the plaintiff's employer. That, in effect, is the limit of the admissions.

2. It does not admit that its liability under the policy was to exceed the then statutory minimum level of cover prescribed pursuant to the Workers' Compensation Act. At the relevant time the statutory minimum was $40,000. The first defendant admits its liability to indemnify to the extent of $40,000 but no further.

3. I was reluctant to embark upon the determination of a preliminary issue in the course of a case, but the parties agreed, and wished me to do so. The argument is put that there is no evidence as to what the limit of the policy was and therefore, it being the defendant's onus, the plaintiff argues it is unlimited. Being the plaintiff's onus the first defendant argues it is limited and limited to $40,000. It seems to me therefore that it really does come down to the question of onus.

4. Mr Little of senior counsel, who appears with Mr Parker for the first defendant, says that there are two matters of evidence from which it can be determined, if…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stewart v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NSWDDT 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved a plaintiff who was claiming compensation for a dust-related disease from an insurer. The insurer had admitted the existence of the policy but had not admitted to the extent of common law cover. The dispute was heard by the Dust Diseases Tribunal in New South Wales. The plaintiff sought to determine the extent of the insurer's common law cover, which was at a statutory minimum of $40,000 at the relevant time.

The key issue before the Tribunal was whether the plaintiff or the insurer had the onus of establishing the extent of the common law cover. The Tribunal noted that there was no evidence provided regarding the extent of the cover, and both parties had made conflicting submissions on who should bear the onus. The Tribunal had to decide whether the plaintiff should bear the onus of proving the extent of the common law cover, or whether the insurer should bear the onus of proving that the common law cover was less than the statutory minimum.

The Tribunal held that the onus lay on the insurer to prove that the common law cover was less than the statutory minimum. The Tribunal found that the insurer had failed to discharge this onus, as it had not provided any evidence to support its claim that the common law cover was less than the statutory minimum. The Tribunal therefore held that the common law cover was at the statutory minimum of $40,000. The Tribunal ordered the insurer to pay the plaintiff compensation for the dust-related disease, including the statutory minimum common law cover of $40,000.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established