| [2023] FWC 2730 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
| DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.365—General protections
Stewart Andrew Haven
v
CJH Group (WA) Pty Ltd
(C2023/4565)
Yupaporn Haven
v
CJH Group (WA) Pty Ltd
(C2023/4563)
| COMMISSIONER LIM | PERTH, 14 NOVEMBER 2023 |
Application to deal with contraventions involving dismissal – jurisdictional objection – applicants not dismissed – jurisdictional objection dismissed.
Introduction
Mr Stewart Haven and Ms Yupaporn Haven have both applied pursuant to s 365 of the Fair Work Act (Cth), alleging that CJH Group (WA) Pty Ltd (the Respondent or CJH Group) contravened Part 3-1 of the Act by dismissing them from their employment.
The Respondent has raised a jurisdictional objection alleging that Mr and Ms Haven were not dismissed as they resigned from their employment.
Mr and Ms Haven are husband and wife. They were employed by the Respondent and their applications arise from the same series of events. In the interests of efficiency, both matters were listed and heard together. However, each application must be determined on its own merits.
It is uncontroversial that for the matter to proceed, the Respondent must have dismissed Mr and Ms Haven. In Coles Supply Chain Pty Ltd v Milford,[1] the Full Court of the Federal Court held that where a respondent submits that the applicant to a section 365 application was not dismissed, as is the case here, the Commission must determine that issue before exercising its powers under s 368 of the Act.[2]
The matters were allocated to my Chambers and a mention was held on 22 August 2023 for Mr Haven and on 29 August 2023 for Ms Haven. At Ms Haven’s mention on 29 August 2023, I confirmed that the parties consented to have both matters jointly heard. I issued Directions to the parties for the filing of material in relation to the jurisdictional objection.
I conducted a hearing on 19 October 2023.
Having considered the evidence and submissions of the parties, I am satisfied that the Respondent terminated both Mr and Ms Haven’s employment.
My detailed reasons for my decision follow.
Observations on the evidence
The Applications and disputed events arise from three interactions over a period of just over 24 hours. The witnesses gave similar evidence as to what happened and what was said. There are some differences in evidence across the witnesses.
At the hearing, Mr and Ms Haven represented themselves and were witnesses for both their own and each other’s cases. During Ms Haven’s cross-examination, Mr Holland took issue with inconsistencies in Ms Haven’s evidence. I consider those inconsistencies to be minor and do not affect Ms Haven’s credibility. I note that Ms Haven is not a native English speaker and have taken that into account in assessing her evidence.
The Respondent was represented by Mr Chris Holland, who is owner and manager of the Respondent. In addition to Mr Holland, Ms Lita Bromwich and Ms Terri Hawera gave evidence for the Respondent. Ms Bromwich and Ms Hawera are both employees of CC West, one of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Stewart Andrew Haven v CJH Group (WA) Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] FWC 2730
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The key issue before the Commission was whether the applicants were dismissed by their employer, as required for the Commission to exercise its powers under section 365 of the Fair Work Act. The employer argued that the applicants resigned when their request for a pay rise was denied, whereas the applicants argued that they were dismissed when they were told to collect their belongings.
Commissioner Lim found that the applicants were dismissed when they were told to collect their belongings. The Commissioner accepted the applicants' evidence that they were told to collect their belongings and found the employer's submission that this constituted a resignation to be unreasonable. The Commissioner found that the employer had taken the action that resulted in the termination of the employment relationship and that the applicants would not have left voluntarily had the employer not taken that action.
The Commission dismissed the employer’s jurisdictional objection and found that the applications were within its jurisdiction. The matters will be listed for a conference pursuant to section 368 of the Act.