Steven Sandford and Linfox Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

[2014] AATA 375

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2013/4680

Re

Steven Sandford

APPLICANT

And

Linfox Australia Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President RP Handley

Date 16 June 2014 
Place Sydney

1.          The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes the following decision:

(a)        The Respondent continues to be liable to pay compensation to Mr Sandford for the effects of the injury to his back sustained on 17 December 2010.

(b)        Mr Sandford continues to be incapacitated for work as a result of the injury.

(c) The fusion of Mr Sandford’s lumbar spine at L4/5 recommended by his treating Spinal Surgeon, Associate Professor Peter Papantoniou should be considered ‘reasonable treatment’ for the purposes of s 16 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act) provided the reasonable concerns of the other expert witnesses in these proceedings are first addressed, namely that appropriate further investigations and assessments are undertaken with satisfactory outcomes.

2. The Respondent is to pay the costs of these proceedings incurred by the Applicant pursuant to s 67(8) of the SRC Act.

.........................[sgd]...............................................

Deputy President RP Handley

Catchwords

WORKERS COMPENSATION – back injury – whether continues to suffer the effects of the injury – whether frank injury or aggravation of a pre-existing degenerative condition

WORKERS COMPENSATION – treatment reasonable for an employee to obtain in the circumstances- spinal fusion – need for further investigations and assessments

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 5A, 14, 16, 19

Secondary Materials

Jens Ivar Brox et al, ‘Four-year follow-up of surgical versus non-surgical therapy for chronic back pain’ (2010) 69 Ann Rheum Dis 1643

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President RP Handley

  1. Mr Sandford (the Applicant) has applied to the Tribunal for the review of a decision made by a delegate of Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (‘Linfox’, the Respondent) that the Respondent is no longer liable to pay compensation to Mr Sandford because the effects of his compensable condition have now ceased.

    BACKGROUND

  2. Mr Sandford was born in 1962 and is aged 52. He has worked in the trucking industry since leaving school at the age of 16. He began work for Linfox in 1998 as a truck driver. He typically worked 6 days a week on normal duties up until 2011 when he was moved to light office duties. These light duties ceased on 31 July 2013 and he has not worked since. He currently lives with his wife and four grandchildren for whom he and his wife care. Having exhausted his accrued leave entitlements, Mr Sandford has been receiving Newstart Allowance since February 2014.

  3. During the period in which he was employed by Linfox, Mr Sandford first complained to his GP of back pain in 2004. Subsequently, on 19 May 2008, he suffered a ‘low back strain’ whilst pulling a pallet off the back of a truck. After undergoing physiotherapy, Mr Sandford was certified fit to return to his normal duties from 12 June 2008.

  4. On 17 December 2010, Mr Sandford…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Steven Sandford and Linfox Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 375
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Steven Sandford applied to the tribunal for a review of a decision made by a delegate of Linfox Australia Pty Ltd, asserting that the Respondent was no longer liable to pay compensation for the effects of his compensable back injury. The dispute involved whether Mr Sandford continues to suffer the effects of his compensable back injury and whether the injury was a frank injury or an aggravation of a pre-existing degenerative condition. The legal issues the tribunal needed to decide were whether Mr Sandford's injury has resolved and, if not, whether he has a continuing incapacity for work and if the fusion surgery recommended by Dr Papantoniou is reasonable treatment.

The tribunal examined the medical evidence and expert opinions presented by both parties. Professor Papantoniou, Mr Sandford's treating specialist, argued that the December 2010 incident caused structural damage to Mr Sandford's spine that would not have resolved, while Dr Wallace and Professor McGill held the view that the incident caused a temporary aggravation of pre-existing degenerative disc disease or an exacerbation of a pre-existing degenerative condition, which had now resolved. The tribunal found Professor Papantoniou's opinion more persuasive due to his specialisation and the fact that he had been treating Mr Sandford since 4 September 2012. The tribunal concluded that a spinal fusion is reasonable treatment for Mr Sandford's back condition following satisfactory results from further investigations, such as a new MRI of the lumbar spine, and once any further assessments, such as a new cardiac assessment, have been undertaken to minimise the risk of complications.

The tribunal set aside the decision under review and substituted the following decision: (d) the Respondent continues to be liable to pay compensation to Mr Sandford for the effects of the injury to his back sustained on 17 December 2010; (e) Mr Sandford continues to be incapacitated for work as a result of the injury; and (f) the fusion of Mr Sandford's lumbar spine at L4/5 recommended by his treating Spinal Surgeon, Professor Papantoniou should be considered 'reasonable treatment' for the purposes of s 16 of the SRC Act provided the reasonable concerns of the other expert witnesses in these proceedings are first addressed, namely that appropriate further investigations and assessments are undertaken with satisfactory outcomes. The tribunal ordered the Respondent to pay the costs of these proceedings incurred by the Applicant pursuant to s 67(8) of the SRC Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Sandford (the Applicant) has applied to the Tribunal for the review of a decision made by a delegate of Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (‘Linfox’, the Respondent) that the Respondent is no longer liable to pay compensation to Mr Sandford because the effects of his compensable condition have now ceased. BACKGROUND Mr Sandford was born in 1962 and is aged 52. He has worked in the trucking industry since leaving school at the age of 16. He began work for Linfox in 1998 as a truck driver. He typically worked 6 days a week on normal duties up until 2011 when he was moved to light office duties. These light duties ceased on 31 July 2013 and he has not worked since. He currently lives with his wife and four grandchildren for whom he and his wife care. Having exhausted his accrued leave entitlements, Mr Sandford has been receiving Newstart Allowance since February 2014. During the period in which he was employed by Linfox, Mr Sandford first complained to his GP of back pain in 2004. Subsequently, on 19 May 2008, he suffered a ‘low back strain’ whilst pulling a pallet off the back of a truck. After undergoing physiotherapy, Mr Sandford was certified fit to return to his normal duties from 12 June 2008. On 17 December 2010, Mr Sandford sustained an injury to his back. He stated that the injury occurred whilst bending over the chassis of his prime mover in order to disconnect the air hoses between the trailer and his prime mover. Mr Sandford described the injury in his WorkCover claim form as “sore lower back + hip + right shoulder”. The Respondent accepted liability for ‘mechanical back pain’ in a decision of 9 February 2011. A series of medical certificates provided by Mr Sandford’s treating doctors, Dr Danny Tang and Dr Tas G Fermanis, certified Mr Sandford as fit to work suitable duties from 3 February 2011 through to 6 February 2013. Dr Fermanis referred Mr Sandford to Associate Professor Peter J Papantoniou, Orthopaedic and Spinal Surgeon, who first saw Mr Sandford on 4 September 2012. Professor Papantoniou referred Mr Sandford for an MRI and CT scan. On the basis of those results, in a report dated 2 October 2012, Professor Papantoniou diagnosed Mr Sandford with a disc prolapse at L4/5 level and an annular tear. He also stated that Mr Sandford had “disc desiccation and facet degeneration at the L4/5 level”. Professor Papantoniou recommended a steroid injection and stated that, if the injection failed, he would recommend a fusion. In a report dated 19 November 2012, Professor Papantoniou noted that the steroid injection administered on 30 October 2012 only provided pain relief for approximately two days. As a result, he recommended that Mr Sandford undertake an L4/5 instrumented fusion. After an incident on 1 January 2013, when Mr Sandford experienced a significant increase in pain while leaning forward to brush his teeth, Professor Papantoniou provided a further report dated 29 January 2013 again recommending a fusion. CGU Insurance, acting for the Respondent, subsequently arranged for Mr Sandford to be reviewed by Associate Professor Paul Myers, General and Vascular Surgeon, and Dr Robin Chase, Occupational Physician. Dr Myers, in a report dated 5 February 2013, stated that the sequestrated disc fragment sustained in the 2010 incident appeared to have settled, and there was no justification for a surgical fusion. Dr Chase, in a report dated 8 February 2013, also expressed his reservations about surgical intervention, and emphasised that Mr Sandford should be made aware that it is unlikely that he would be completely pain free following surgery and of “a risk that he will be worse”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

If Mr Sandford’s 2010 injury has not resolved and he continues to suffer the effects of that injury, the Tribunal must determine whether he has a continuing incapacity for work and, in particular, whether the fusion surgery recommended by Dr Papantoniou is reasonable treatment for the purposes of s 16(1) of the SRC Act. MR SANDFORD’S EVIDENCE Mr Sandford agreed that prior to December 2010, he had other accidents. In 1983, when he was riding a motorcycle, he was hit by a semitrailer which ran over his legs. He recovered completely from this accident, being able to walk again without difficulty and resume work. In 1993, he had an accident while driving a truck and jarred his back. He was off work for a week and then returned to his normal work duties. He does not remember making a claim for compensation in respect of this accident. In February 1995, Dr Bodel told him that his back injury had completely resolved. Mr Sandford commenced work as a truck driver for Linfox in 1998, having previously been employed as a truck driver by TNT, Interlink and Toll. His usual duties with Linfox did not involve lifting, although about once a week or once a fortnight he would need to stack milk crates. Mr Sandford said he was physically active in the first 10 years of employment with Linfox: he would go fishing, water skiing, and motorbike riding. Mr Sandford said he cannot recall having any problems with his back until 19 May 2008 when he injured his back while bending down to lift a pallet. He could not recall complaining to his GP, Dr Fermanis of back pain in October 2004. After the incident in May 2008, Mr Sandford felt pain on the left side of his lower back for which he had physiotherapy for about three weeks before returning to normal duties. He did not experience any numbness or radiating pain. Mr Sandford also could not recall complaining to Dr Fermanis of lower back pain on 27 April 2009. On 11 November 2008, Mr Sandford suffered a myocardial infarction. He said that following an angiogram which showed blood vessels that were 75% blocked, he had a stent inserted. After recovering from this, he resumed his normal work. On 17 December 2010 at about 2.10 am, Mr Sandford was bending beneath a trailer to disconnect the air lines from the prime mover he was driving. This involved bending to 90 degrees, pushing himself off the ground over the refrigeration motor, and twisting and applying pressure to release the connection to the bayonet fitting. Mr Sandford said he felt a sharp pain across his lower back reaching to about eight centimetres either side of his spine. He had never experienced such a level of pain before. At the time, his mobile phone was in the cabin of the prime mover and, being early in the morning, there was nobody else around. He was stuck for about 10 minutes until he managed to wriggle back so that his feet were on the ground. He then walked painfully back to the office to notify his supervisor of the accident. The accident occurred on a Friday morning and, at that time, Mr Sandford thought he had probably just pulled a muscle. He took paracetamol and rested over the weekend hoping that he would recover.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In conclusion, I am satisfied that a spinal fusion is reasonable treatment for Mr Sandford’s back condition following satisfactory results from further investigations, such as a new MRI of the lumbar spine, and once any further assessments, such as a new cardiac assessment, have been undertaken to minimise the risk of complications. It would also seem sensible for Mr Sandford to undertake a fitness and weight loss program prior to surgery in line with Dr Bodel’s opinion, albeit that I have chosen not to make this a pre-condition to spinal surgery being considered reasonable treatment. DECISION The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes the following decision:(d)The Respondent continues to be liable to pay compensation to Mr Sandford for the effects of the injury to his back sustained on 17 December 2010.(e)Mr Sandford continues to be incapacitated for work as a result of the injury.(f)The fusion of Mr Sandford’s lumbar spine at L4/5 recommended by his treating Spinal Surgeon, Professor Papantoniou should be considered ‘reasonable treatment’ for the purposes of s 16 of the SRC Act provided the reasonable concerns of the other expert witnesses in these proceedings are first addressed, namely that appropriate further investigations and assessments are undertaken with satisfactory outcomes. The Respondent is to pay the costs of these proceedings incurred by the Applicant pursuant to s 67(8) of the SRC Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Kelly, for the Respondent, contended that there is no onus on the Respondent of the kind suggested by the Applicant. He noted, in particular, the specialist opinions of Dr Wallace and Professor McGill that Mr Sandford no longer suffers the effects of injury on 17 December 2010 and that his ongoing condition is the result of constitutional degeneration of the lumbar spine. Consideration In the course of the hearing, both parties referred to the MRI scan dated 3 February 2011, taken approximately six weeks after the accident on 17 December 2010. The report on the scan by Radiologist Dr Melvin Chew notes “Disc desiccation without significant loss of disc height present at L2/3m L4/5 and L5/S1 with relative spurring of L3/4”. Dr Chew identified:·a “mild posterior bulge” at L2/3, with no facet joint degenerative changes.·a “mild posterior annulus bulging” at L3/4 and early facet joint degenerative changes.·“a broad-based posterior disc bulging with a subtle right par central annulus tear characterised by a tiny hyper intense focus” at L4/5 together with a “sequestered disc fragment”, also “a right foramina disc bulge which is partially impinging the right L4 nerve root exiting the foramen”, and early facet joint degenerative changes.·at L5/S1, a “mild posterior disc bulge” and “facet joints demonstrate early degenerative changes”. Dr Chew concluded that the findings were primarily those at L4/5. The Tribunal was presented with a range of expert opinion about these findings. In his report dated 4 December 2013, Professor Papantoniou, Mr Sandford’s treating specialist and expert in the field of lumbar surgery, stated:Nowhere would an annular tear, a disc bulge or disc protrusion be described as constitutional. These are traumatic incidents and in a normal person would not be present. Professor Papantoniou referred to a report of an x-ray of the lumbar spine dated 12 October 2004 by Radiologist Dr A Dutt who found “mild spur formation at the anterior body margin of L3, L4 and L5 due to mild osteoarthritic type changes”. Professor Papantoniou said that in the case of a constitutional disposition to degenerative change, one would expect to see spurs all the way up the spine. He noted that there is no available MRI scan of Mr Sandford’s lumbar spine dating from before the accident on 17 December 2010. Professor Papantoniou is a spinal surgeon specialising in the lumbar spine. He said spinal surgery accounts for approximately 50 to 60% of his practise. In my view, I should, give particular attention to his opinion because of this specialisation and of the fact that he has been treating Mr Sandford since 4 September 2012. Dr Bodel expressed the opinion that the December 2010 incident had caused structural damage to Mr Sandford’s spine which would not have resolved, although the symptoms might have waxed and waned. Dr Wallace and Professor McGill expressed a contrary view. Dr Wallace considered that the December 2010 incident had caused a temporary aggravation of pre-existing degenerative disc disease. Professor McGill expressed the opinion that the incident had not caused any substantial structural damage but rather had caused an exacerbation of Mr Sandford’s pre-existing degenerative condition which had now resolved. He was, however, unable to satisfactorily explain Mr Sandford’s back pain and the burning sensation in his left thigh having remained largely unchanged since the incident, and how and when the cause of those symptoms ceased to be the incident on 17 December 2010 and became the constitutional degenerative condition. Professor McGill acknowledged that his opinion was based on probability.