Stevedoring Employees Retirement Fund Pty Ltd v Gilberg

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Stevedoring Employees Retirement Fund Pty Ltd v Gilberg [2006] FCA 1590

APPLICATION FOR PERMANENT DISABLEMENT BENEFIT – rejection of application by Trustee – application to Superannuation Complaints Tribunal – rejection of medical opinion by Tribunal– error of law – Tribunal and Trustee bound by rules of Fund.

Superannuation (Resolution of Complaints) Act 1993 (Cth) s 37

Cameron v Board of Trustees of the State Public Sector Superannuation Scheme (2003) 130 FCR 122
Hornsby v Military Superannuation and Benefits Board of Trustees No 1 (2003) 126 FCR 484
Retail Employees Superannuation Pty Ltd v Crocker (2001) 48 ATR 359
Seafarers’ Retirement Fund Pty Ltd v Oppenhuis (1999) 94 FCR 594

STEVEDORING EMPLOYEES RETIREMENT FUND PTY LTD v JOHN GILBERG
NSD 554 OF 2006

BUCHANAN J
23 NOVEMBER 2006
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 554 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

STEVEDORING EMPLOYEES RETIREMENT FUND PTY LTD
Applicant

AND:

JOHN GILBERG
Respondent

JUDGE:

BUCHANAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

23 NOVEMBER 2006

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Determination D05-06/132 of the Superannuation Complaints Tribunal is set aside.

2.The decision of the Trustee of the Stevedoring Employees Retirement Fund Pty Ltd upon the claim by Mr John Gilberg for a Total and Permanent Disablement Benefit is restored.

3.There be no order as to costs.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 554 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

STEVEDORING EMPLOYEES RETIREMENT FUND PTY LTD
Applicant

AND:

JOHN GILBERG
Respondent

JUDGE:

BUCHANAN J

DATE:

23 NOVEMBER 2006

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

BUCHANAN J:

  1. In May 2001 John Gilberg was 46 years old.  He was working as a waterside worker for Patrick Stevedores at Port Botany.  As a result of his employment he was a member of the Stevedoring Employees’ Retirement Fund (‘SERF’) and had been since 31 March 1982.

  2. On 12 May 2001 he fell at work.  He landed on his buttocks.  He sustained a back injury, described as an L5-S1 disc bulge.  He has not worked since.

  3. His injury has caused him considerable pain and restriction of movement.  His worker’s compensation claim, resulting from the accident, was settled for a lump sum payment of $500,000.  As part of the settlement he resigned his position on 2 December 2002.

  4. On 4 April 2003 he lodged a claim with the Trustee of SERF. He claimed a Total and Permanent Disablement benefit (‘TPD benefit’). Payment of the benefit arises under Rule 17 of the Rules of SERF which will be set out to in due course.

  5. It is common ground in this appeal that the relevant version of Rule 17 appears in Rules dated 7 April 2003, and that it applied from 29 August 2002. In accordance with Rule 17, medical reports were supplied by medical practitioners selected by Mr Gilberg and by medical practitioners appointed by SERF. Mr Gilberg’s medical practitioners certified that each of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stevedoring Employees Retirement Fund Pty Ltd v Gilberg and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 1590
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Stevedoring Employees Retirement Fund Pty Ltd v Gilberg, the parties were involved in a dispute regarding the eligibility of Mr Gilberg for a total and permanent disablement (TPD) benefit from the Stevedoring Employees Retirement Fund (SERF). The Superannuation Complaints Tribunal (SCT) had ruled against the Trustee of SERF in favour of Mr Gilberg, and this decision was appealed to the court. The central legal issues revolved around the interpretation of Rule 17 of the Trust Deed and the appropriate application of medical opinions in determining Mr Gilberg’s entitlement to the TPD benefit. The court needed to ascertain whether the SCT had correctly interpreted Rule 17, and whether the Trustee was justified in relying solely on the opinion of Dr Oates, one of the medical practitioners.

The court found that Rule 17 required the Trustee to base its determination solely on the medical opinion of an additional practitioner if there was a division in medical opinion. However, the Trustee was not obliged to weigh all medical opinions, but rather to follow the opinion of the appointed practitioner. The court held that Dr Oates’ opinion was consistent with the other medical opinions obtained by the Trustee, and therefore, the Trustee was correct in concluding that Mr Gilberg did not meet the conditions for a TPD benefit. The SCT's decision was based on an error of law in that it applied the wrong version of Rule 17, which did not impact the reasoning or outcome. However, the SCT had incorrectly concluded that the Trustee should not base its determination solely on Dr Oates’ opinion and that Dr Oates’ opinion should not be accepted.

The court set aside the SCT’s determination, restored the Trustee’s original decision, and made no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Determination D05-06/132 of the Superannuation Complaints Tribunal is set aside.

2. The decision of the Trustee of the Stevedoring Employees Retirement Fund Pty Ltd upon the claim by Mr John Gilberg for a Total and Permanent Disablement Benefit is restored.

3. There be no order as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a claim for a Total and Permanent Disablement (TPD) benefit by Mr John Gilberg against the Trustee of the Stevedoring Employees Retirement Fund Pty Ltd (SERF). Mr Gilberg's employment was terminated on 12 May 2001, and he applied for a TPD benefit under Rule 17 of the Fund's Rules. The Trustee assessed his claim and concluded that he was not entitled to a TPD benefit. Dr Oates, a medical practitioner appointed by the Trustee, provided a medical opinion that Mr Gilberg was not permanently incapable of performing his duties or a danger to others. This opinion was consistent with reports from three other medical practitioners but contrary to the opinions of medical practitioners relied upon by Mr Gilberg. The Trustee's decision was based solely on Dr Oates' medical opinion, as required by Rule 17.

Mr Gilberg's claim was initially assessed and denied by the Trustee. He appealed this decision to the Superannuation Complaints Tribunal (SCT), which determined that the Trustee should not have based its decision solely on Dr Oates' medical opinion and that his opinion should not have been accepted. The Tribunal also concluded that the claim should be determined by it, rather than remitted to the Trustee. The Trustee then appealed the Tribunal's decision to this Court under section 46 of the Act, which allows for an appeal on a question of law.

Decision

Reasons for decision

BUCHANAN J
Dr Oates’ opinion is clearly a ‘medical opinion’ about the relevant issues, in particular the issues raised by Rule 17(c)(ii)(B). His opinion on these matters is consistent with the opinions of the three medical practitioners whose reports were sought by the Trustee for the purposes of Rule 17(c), Drs Synnott, Hall and Walsh. It is contrary to the opinions expressed by the medical practitioners upon whom Mr Gilberg relied. Rule 17 required the Trustee to base its determination solely on Dr Oates’ medical opinion. No occasion arose for weighing the totality of medical opinion. The Trustee in my view was correct to conclude that Mr Gilberg had no entitlement to a TPD benefit because the conditions for such an entitlement stipulated by Rule 17 had not been satisfied.The Decision of the Tribunal The Tribunal determined that it should be guided by the provisions of the Trust Deed consolidated up to 28 March 2001, incorporating the old Rule 17. The reason for this approach appears to be that they were the rules in force at the time that Mr Gilberg last worked – i.e. 12 May 2001. Why the date of injury, or last working day, was chosen in lieu of the date of cessation of employment is not made clear. SERF advised the Tribunal on 15 February 2005 that, in its view, the relevant Trust Deed was that dated 7 April 2003. This contained the new Rule 17. The parties are agreed (and were never at issue) that these were the correct rules to use. The new Rule 17 clearly applies to Mr Gilberg’s circumstances because his employment was terminated after 29 August 2002. The Tribunal’s error in this respect is an error of law. It provides a foundation for the appeal. However the error did not, in my view, have any effect upon the approach which the Tribunal took, its reasoning or its ultimate decision. If this were the only error of law identified it would provide no basis to interfere with the Tribunal’s decision. As I read the Tribunal’s decision there were, for the purpose of my consideration of this appeal, three important aspects to its reasoning. First, it took the view that the Trustee was obliged not to base its determination solely on Dr Oates’ medical opinion. Secondly, it decided that, in any event, Dr Oates’ medical opinion should not be accepted. The Tribunal summarised its findings on these two issues in the following way:‘There are two reasons why the Tribunal has determined that the decision of the Trustee operates unfairly and unreasonably to the Complainant in the circumstances, viz:(a)the Trustee has misconstrued its powers in believing that it is bound to follow the decision of the additional medical practitioner, and(b)the additional medical practitioner has not considered, or not considered sufficiently, the effect of the multiple conditions from which the Complainant suffers in the report (including the supplementary report) and his opinion that the Complainant was not TPD should not have been accepted by the Trustee.’ Thirdly, the Tribunal decided that Mr Gilberg’s claim for a TPD benefit should be determined by it, assessing for itself all the medical evidence before the Trustee, rather than remitting the matter to the Trustee for any necessary further action.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BUCHANAN J

The appeal to this Court arises under s 46 of the Act. That section provides for an appeal on a question of law.Operation of Rule 17 Before discussing the progress of Mr Gilberg’s claim in greater detail it is necessary to spend a little time on the meaning and effect of Rule 17 itself. Rule 17 of the Rules dated 7 April 2003 (which was the rule used by the Trustee of SERF in assessing Mr Gilberg’s claim) provides as follows:‘As from 29 August 2002, a Contributing Member or a Non-Contributing Member is entitled to a total and permanent disablement benefit if:(a)the Member's employment as an Employee or a Permanent Employee is terminated solely on the grounds that the Member's physical or mental condition at that time is such that the Member is permanently incapable of performing the Member's duties satisfactorily or is a danger to others;(b)the Trustee has received a report from each of at least two medical practitioners which satisfies the guidelines established by the Trustee from time to time and which expressly states that in the medical practitioner's view, the Member is by virtue of the Member's physical or mental condition:(i)incapable of performing the Member's duties or may be a danger to others because of his or her physical or mental condition; and(ii)unable ever to work again in a job for which the Member is qualified by education, training or experience; and(c)the Trustee has received a report from each of at least two medical practitioners which have been appointed by the Trustee which satisfies the guidelines established by the Trustee from time to time and which expressly states that in the medical practitioner's view:(i)Member's employment as an Employee or a Permanent Employee was terminated solely on the grounds that the Member's physical or mental condition at that time is such that the Member is permanently incapable of performing the Member's duties satisfactorily or is a danger to others; and(ii)by virtue of the physical or mental condition referred to in paragraph (i), the Member remains:(A) permanently incapable of performing the Member’s duties or may be a danger to others because of his or her physical or mental condition; and(B)unable ever to work again in a job for which the Member is qualified by education, training or experience; and(d)after receiving the reports referred to in paragraph (b) and (c) of this Rule, the Trustee determines that the Member is entitled to a benefit under this Rule PROVIDED THAT in the event of a division of medical opinion expressed in the medical reports referred to in paragraph (b) and (c), the Trustee shall appoint (at the election of the Trustee) an additional medical practitioner and the Trustee shall base its determination solely on the medical opinion of the additional medical practitioner so appointed; and(e) the Member has not received or is not due to receive a benefit under Rules 13, 14, 15 or 16 and the Member has not received or is not due to receive a payment as part of a redundancy or early retirement scheme.A total and permanent disablement benefit payable under this Rule 17 shall be calculated as follows:(f) In the case of a Contributing Member the sum as applicable of:(i)the Member's Voluntary Contribution Benefit; plus(ii)the Member's Fund Service Benefit; plus(iii)the Member's Potential Benefit; plus(iv)the Member’s Past Service Benefit.(g) In the case of a Non-Contributing member the sum as applicable of:(i)the Member’s Voluntary Contribution Benefit; plus(ii)the Member’s Fund Service Benefit, plus(iii)the Member’s Past Service Benefit.’(I have emphasised some of the matters arising for consideration)