Sterner & Anor v ACT Planning and Land Authority (Administrative Review)

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STERNER & ANOR v ACT PLANNING AND LAND AUTHORITY (Administrative Review) [2023] ACAT 60

AT 91/2022

Catchwords:               ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – planning and development control – merit track assessment – Planning and Development Act 2007 Part 5.2 contents of Territory Plan – zone objectives – relationship with codes – discretion to refuse approval where development proposal is code-compliant – occasion for exercise – exceptional case – unintended consequence of code drafting – mischaracterisation of ‘Standard ‘block’ – approval contrary to planning intention – Territory Plan RZ1 Suburban zone objectives – protection of character – single dwelling housing area – low density – proposal for four dwelling building – Statutory interpretation – ‘Standard block’ – “originally leased or used” – “original lease” – “explicitly” – purpose of Territory Plan provisions for residential housing areas – Multi Unit Housing Development Code – courtyard walls – setback and materials composition – basement ramp wall – setback and safety

Legislation cited:        ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 s 68

Districts Act 2002 s 6
Legislation Act 2000 ss 4, 6, 10, 13, 136, 139, 142, ch 14
Planning and Development Act 2007 ss 13, 46, 48, 50, 51, 53, 54, 55, 66, 73, 119, 120, 146, 191, 193, 235, 407, Sch 1

Subordinate

Legislation cited:        Australian Standard AS2890.1 – Off-Street Parking

Boundary Fences General Code

Multi Unit Housing Development Code rr 6, 10, 16, 17, 18, 23, 29, 30, 38, 39, 41, 42, 59, 61, cr 30, 40, 41, 42, Table A6
Planning and Development (Draft Variation Number 306) Consultation Notice 2011
Planning and Development (Plan Variation No 306) Notice 2013
Planning and Development (Plan Variation No 306) Commencement Notice 2013
Planning and Development (Plan Variation No 350) Approval 2019
Residential Zones Development Code
RZ1 Suburban Zone Objectives and Development Table
Territory Plan 2008 (NI2008-27, Planning and Development Act 2007), 1.1 Governance, 13.1 Definitions

Cases cited:4THD Planning & Design Pty Ltd v ACT Planning and Land Authority [2021] ACAT 59

Baptist Community Services v ACT Planning and Land Authority [2015] ACTCA 3
Glover v Minister for Planning [2003] ACTSC 42
Javelin Projects Pty Limited v ACTPLA [2017] ACAT 87
Re City Area Leases Ordinance 1936 and Axiom Pty Ltd (1986) 66 ACTR 1
Sladic & Anor v ACT Planning and Land Authority; Charter Hall Retail Reit & Ors v ACT Planning and Land Authority [2018] ACAT 38
Ward v Griffiths (1987) 9 NSWLR 458

List of

Texts/Papers cited:     Frank Brennan, Canberra in Crisis (Dalton Pub. Co, 1971)

Tribunal:Senior Member R Arthur

Senior Member G Tomlins

Date of Orders:  5 October 2023

Date of Reasons for Decision:      5 October 2023

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          AT 91/2022

BETWEEN:

KAREL STERNER
First Applicant

AND:

SAMUEL MCDONALD
Second Applicant

AND:

ACT PLANNING AND LAND AUTHORITY
Respondent

AND:

BRETT BIDDINGTON
Party Joined

AND:

DEAKIN RESIDENTS’ ASSOCIATION
Party Joined

TRIBUNAL:Senior Member R Arthur

Senior Member G Tomlins

DATE:5 October 2023

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sterner & Anor v ACT Planning and Land Authority (Administra... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACAT 60
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Sterner & Anor v ACT Planning and Land Authority (Administrative Review) case involved the applicants contesting the decision of the delegate of the respondent to refuse their development application for a property located in Deakin, Canberra. The applicants sought to develop a two-storey four-unit building on a block previously used as a single dwelling. The main legal issues before the court were whether the block in question was a'standard block' under the planning codes and, if it was, whether the development proposal complied with the relevant planning codes. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the proposal complied with the zone objectives, and if there was any justification to refuse the proposal despite its compliance with the codes.

The court first examined the definition of 'standard block' and concluded that Block 11 was indeed a standard block as it was originally used as a single dwelling. This conclusion was critical because if Block 11 was a standard block, the lease did not explicitly permit two dwellings. The court further considered whether the proposal was code compliant and found that it was, except for two specific matters: the setback of the courtyard walls and the basement side setback related to safety and privacy. The court also considered the interplay between sections 119 and 120 of the Planning and Development Act, noting that while a code-compliant proposal typically meets the zone objectives, there is a discretion to refuse such a proposal if necessary. However, the court concluded that it was not an exceptional case warranting the exercise of this discretion.

In its decision, the court confirmed the delegate's decision to refuse the development application. The reasoning was grounded in the interpretation of the planning codes and the finding that Block 11 was a standard block, which precluded the proposed two-dwelling development. The court's final orders confirmed the delegate's decision, thereby denying the applicants' appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1.

The decision of the delegate is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The parties joined maintained their opposition to the application.Evidence Expert evidence was given for the applicants by:(a)Mr Richard Nash – town planner;(b)Mr Ronan Moss – architect;(c)Mr Neil Hobbs – landscape architect; and(d)Mr Hamish McDonald – traffic engineer.[8][8] Witness statement of Hamish McDonald dated 11 January 2023 Expert evidence was given for the respondent by Mr Trent Varlow – town planner. Expert evidence was given for the second party joined by Mr Owen Pankhurst – town planner. Mr Peter Young also gave evidence for the applicants, relating to comparisons made by him of developments in the RZ1 zone in Deakin and elsewhere in Canberra, and of calculations made by him of site coverage and plot ratio of various properties.[9]Adequacy of public notification[9] Witness statement of Peter Young dated 8 March 2023 The parties joined contended that the combined effect of the changes, including those introduced after the commencement of the hearing, required amendment of the development application and re-notification to the public. During the hearing, we took time to consider whether the further notification was required. We informed the parties that, for reasons to be given later, we had decided that the combined effect of the changes were not such as to give rise to the requirement for re-notification of the application. Those reasons are now set out. Although many in number, the design changes do not alter the essential nature of the development – it still remains a two-storey four-unit development with associated landscape works, albeit less obtrusively so. As such, no-one other than the applicants will be adversely affected by the amendments and there will be no greater environmental impact caused by the approval of the amendments. In short, there is nothing in the amended proposal that could reasonably cause a person who had not objected to the original proposal to now do so. It is accordingly appropriate for the Tribunal to waive the requirement to publicly notify the amended application pursuant to section 146(3) of the PD Act. Deakin has three main components. The area east of Hopetoun Circuit, which extends to the Prime Minister’s Lodge and contains some streets following the alignment of Walter Burley Griffin’s plans, was mostly built much earlier than the other parts of Deakin. The mixed-use community, educational, commercial, and diplomatic area to the west of Kent Street forms a second main component of Deakin. The third component is the central area between Hopetoun Circuit and Kent Street. It is a neighbourhood development which, in many respects, is similar to other complete neighbourhoods in Canberra. It has a local neighbourhood centre surrounded by commercial and recreational areas. Vacant blocks, set aside for the purpose, along Adelaide Avenue and in the area adjacent to the local centre, have been infilled with higher density in low-rise profile housing after the majority of the residential area for separate detached housing was developed.The subject block

Decision

Reasons for decision

We have considered the letters in Exhibit R8, but do not regard them as of assistance for the reason that, as extrinsic material that may be considered under section 142 of the Legislation Act 2001, they would carry very little weight as neither refers to Block 11 and we do not know the circumstances of the blocks they are concerned with.Conclusion – Block 11 is a standard block The purpose of the Territory Plan in relation to Canberra’s suburban residential areas is to establish them according to an expressed template, allowing each to develop its own character, and then to manage change predictably so as to protect that character appropriately. That element of predictability requires the definition of ‘standard block’ to be given an operation which, in accordance with section 139 of the Legislation Act 2001, ensures that the codes are applied to like blocks in like manner, unaffected by random events which are not themselves the outcome of planning. Our conclusion is that Block 11 was ‘originally used’ as a single dwelling and is therefore a standard block. The corollary of that proposition is that the lease for Block 11 is not an ‘original lease’ and therefore does not come within the exception. Even if that is not the case, we also conclude that the lease for Block 11 does not explicitly permit two dwellings. Block 11 remains a standard block. We have considered the proposal on the basis that Block 11 is not a standard block, and concluded that it is code compliant, but that it is not consistent with RZ1 Zone Objective b). We have considered whether Block 11, on the proper construction of the codes and its lease, is a standard block, and concluded that it is. This conclusion is sufficient to decide the matter independently of other considerations. Nonetheless, we have also considered whether, if it were necessary, we should exercise the discretion to refuse the proposal in the light of our other conclusions. The Court of Appeal has said that a decision-maker has a discretion to reject a code-compliant proposal after consideration of the section 120 matters.[119] The Court made no express comment as to when it would be appropriate to exercise that discretion.[119] Baptist Community Services v ACT Planning and Land Authority [2015] ACTCA 3 at [59] That question was touched on in Javelin Projects Pty Limited v ACTPLA, where the tribunal considered the “[i]nterplay between Sections 119 and 120” and, after noting that the objectives had a role in providing guidance on the interpretation of the codes, observed “that if a development has been assessed as code compliance (sic) in this way there will be a strong presumption that the zone objectives have themselves been met”.[120] We agree with that observation as we do with the further statement that “it would be in an exceptional case that a single development would offend a zone objective and so bring section 120 into play”.[121][120] [2017] ACAT 87 at [142][121] Javelin Projects Pty Limited v ACTPLA [2017] ACAT 87 at [145]

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It is either common ground or otherwise very clear that the proposal, with Block 11 as a non-standard block, complies with the majority of code provisions. In respect of two matters, further consideration is necessary. Those matters are Courtyard walls and basement side setback and related structures concerning safety and privacy.Section 120 considerations Section 120 of the PD Act sets out a number of considerations a decision-maker must consider when deciding a development application for a development proposal in the merit track. Paragraph 120(a) – zone objectives – requires detailed consideration. Paragraphs (b), (d), and (h) – dealing with suitability of land, representations, and probable impact, respectively – have some relevance. Exercise of discretion Consideration of the proper exercise of the discretion to refuse approval to a proposal which is code compliant arises in this case. We will set out our consideration of the issues in the statutory order, and on the initial assumption that Block 11 is not, as the applicant and the respondent contend, a standard block. It will then be necessary to return to the interpretation of the definition of ‘standard block’, before considering the final disposition of this application. Relevantly, section 119 of the PD Act requires “development approval must not be given … unless the proposal is consistent with … the relevant code”. In considering the proposal against the codes, we have assumed that Block 11 is not a standard block. The relevant code is the MUHDC. We have reviewed the planning assessment and expert evidence. We are satisfied that:(a)The building is a maximum of two stories as required by rules 16-18.(b)The building height is less than 8.5m as required by rule 23.(c)The front boundary setbacks of 4m and 6m, as required by rule 29, are met.(d)The side and rear boundary setbacks, as required by rule 30 are met, with the exception of the driveway wall and basement at the driveway entry. This matter is discussed below.(e)The landscape, planting area, and site open space and principal private open space requirements of rules 38, 39, and 61, and criterion 40, are met.(f)The privacy requirements of rule 59 are met. The front fence rule and the courtyard walls requirements of rule 41 and of criteria 41 and 42 are discussed below. We are satisfied otherwise that the planning assessment shows that all other matters of parking and driveway requirements, waste, letter boxes and so on are now compliant. Two matters remain:(a)the setback of the courtyard walls; and(b)The basement side setback and related structures concerning safety and privacy. Both of these matters were the subject of extensive evidence and investigation during the hearing.Courtyard walls Concern was raised by the parties joined about the location and material composition of the courtyard walls. In the notice of decision on reconsideration dated 19 October 2022, it was said:The proposed courtyard wall along Norman Street is located at a minimum setback of approximately 0.5m rather than the required 2m which is not adequate to provide planting. They total length of this courtyard wall also exceeds the permissible 60% of the width of the block. It extends almost the full length of the frontage inconsistent with the existing/desired streetscape character including the courtyard walls to Norman St on the recent dual occupancy development across [Lawley St from] the subject block which has greater setbacks. In relation to the courtyard wall to Lawley Street, the applicant states “… has been significantly reduced in length and setback 2m. Where the wall has been removed, a hedge will be established, paying homage to the original inner South suburban design aesthetic”. But the same treatment is not afforded to Norman St, which is a longer frontage and has greater impact. Considering the front yards to Norman Street are not PPOSs, courtyard walls to majority of the width of the block frontage is not warranted.[32][32] Notice of Decision on Reconsideration dated 19 October 2023, page 4-5