Stern v City of Adelaide

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

Supreme Court of South Australia

(Magistrates Appeals: Criminal)

STERN v CITY OF ADELAIDE

[2020] SASC 220

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Bampton

13 November 2020

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT

TRAFFIC LAW - OFFENCES - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - BREACH OF STOPPING AND PARKING RESTRICTIONS - OTHER CASES

TRAFFIC LAW - DEFINITIONS

The appellant appeals the decision of a Magistrate that she stopped her vehicle within 1 metre of a fire hydrant contrary to r 194 of the Australian Road Rules (“the Rules”) – whether the Magistrate erred by finding that the “fire hydrant” was a fire hydrant pursuant to the Rules – whether the respondent failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the vehicle was stopped within one metre of a fire hydrant – whether the defence of act of a stranger was excluded beyond reasonable doubt – whether order for costs made by the Magistrate was manifestly excessive.

HELD: Appeal dismissed – the fire hydrant was a fire hydrant for the purpose of r 194(1) of the Rules – it was open to the Magistrate to accept the evidence of the parking officer and to draw inferences from the photographic evidence to find that the Mini was stopped within one metre of the fire hydrant – there is no evidence worthy of consideration that suggests the offending is attributable to the act of a stranger – there are no grounds for interfering with the Magistrate’s discretion regarding costs.

Australian Road Rules 2014 (SA) r 3, r 194, r 204, r 270, r 318, r 319; Road Traffic Act 1961 (SA) s 174, referred to.
Kelly v The Queen (2004) 218 CLR 216; Boucher v G J Coles & Co Ltd (1974) 9 SASR 495, applied.
Howie v Sutcliffe (1988) 49 SASR 225, discussed.

WORDS AND PHRASES CONSIDERED/DEFINED

"fire hydrant"

STERN v CITY OF ADELAIDE
[2020] SASC 220

Magistrates Appeal:  Criminal 

  1. BAMPTON J:      At 6.18 pm on 13 June 2019, a parking and information officer observed a white Mini Cooper (“the Mini”) parked “smack bang” in the middle of a no parking zone in front of a fire hydrant on a residential street in the southeast of the City of Adelaide.  The officer issued an infringement notice to Ms Stern being the owner of the Mini that was stopped within one metre of the fire hydrant and took the following photographs:

    (“Photo 1”)

    (“Photo 2”)

  2. Ms Stern elected to be prosecuted and was subsequently charged on a Magistrates Court Information and Summons dated 9 September 2019, which alleged that she was the owner of a vehicle that was stopped within one metre of a fire hydrant contrary to r 194(1) of the Australian Road Rules[1] and s 174(2) of the Road Traffic Act 1961 (SA).[2]

    [1] The Information and Summons refers to rule 194(1) of the Australian Road Rules 1999.  The Australian Road Rules 1999 were revoked and replaced by the Australian Road Rules (No 205 of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stern v City of Adelaide and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] SASC 220
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Stern v City of Adelaide involves an appeal against a decision by a Magistrate who found that the appellant, Ms Stern, had contravened r 194(1) of the Australian Road Rules by stopping her vehicle within 1 metre of a fire hydrant. The primary legal issues addressed by the court were whether the object in question was indeed a fire hydrant under the Rules, whether the council had proved beyond reasonable doubt that the vehicle was stopped within one metre of the fire hydrant, and whether the defence of an act of a stranger was excluded beyond reasonable doubt. Additionally, the court assessed whether the order for costs made by the Magistrate was manifestly excessive.

The court determined that it was open to the Magistrate to accept the evidence of the parking officer and to draw inferences from the photographic evidence to conclude that Ms Stern's Mini was indeed stopped within one metre of the fire hydrant. The court also found that there was no evidence suggesting the offending was attributable to the act of a stranger, thus dismissing the defence. Furthermore, the court held that there were no grounds for interfering with the Magistrate's discretion regarding costs, as the costs order was within the Magistrates Court Criminal Scale of costs.

The appeal was dismissed, and the order for costs made by the Magistrate was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The fire hydrant is located on the footpath adjoining the length of road where parking is not permitted as depicted in photo 1.The evidence before the Magistrate The parking officer gave evidence that on 13 June 2019 he was working night shift for the council. He stated that his usual practice was to look for a driver present or nearby a vehicle before issuing an expiation and that prior to issuing the expiation notice in respect of the Mini he waited for longer than he usually would as “it was just an odd, odd occurrence where the car was”. He referred to two visible yellow lines marking the location of the fire hydrant and parking signs either side of the hydrant indicating where cars could park. In cross‑examination, the officer clarified that it was particularly unusual because “… there was ample parking there and normally cars that are actually obstructing a fire hydrant’s either the front or the back. This was the whole car was smack bang in the middle …”. The officer gave evidence that the Mini was within one metre of the fire hydrant. In cross-examination by Ms Stern, the officer said that he did not measure the distance between the fire hydrant and the Mini with a tape measure. He said that he knew based on his years of experience as a parking officer that the distance was less than one metre. In response to Ms Stern’s question that he did not actually confirm that the Mini was within one metre of the fire hydrant, the officer said that the fire hydrant “was right up against the actual gutter and your – the actual vehicle was close to the gutter, yeah, it was a lot lot less than a metre, without having to measure it”. The officer agreed that the fire hydrant looked “tatty” but added that “the majority of fire hydrants in the city are probably a little bit like that”. The officer also said that he had a memory of reporting the Mini because of “the type of vehicle and also there was two signs that were actually indicating where the car could park” … “I do remember that it was just, it was just odd”. Ms Stern gave evidence that when she parked the Mini at approximately 4.30 pm on 13 June 2019, she believed that she parked with the one hour parking sign. She said that “at that time when I parked my car, I remember looking back at my back wheel to make sure I was within the yellow bit when I’m parking the car in, in front of my house”. She said that she had been in the habit for 20 years to park inside one of the one hour parking zones outside her home. Ms Stern said that when she returned to her car later that evening at about 6.45 pm she did not notice the position of the Mini nor the infringement notice attached to the Mini’s window. She drove off and “suddenly I realised I had a ticket”. Ms Stern also gave evidence that “some years ago [when she owned a Mazda sedan 69] someone did literally move that car down the street and I ended up with police arranging for RAA to do something to my ignition so that it couldn’t happen that they could open my car and drive it down the street”. Ms Stern said that more recently, in July 2018, one of the tyres of her Mini was slashed. She said:… it sounds outlandish just to be in that space where the, you know, all you had to do, my car was parked in front of my house and I contemplated that someone had moved my car. … It sounds outlandish, even I can’t take it seriously because I haven’t actually followed that argument seriously with the council although I did write about it to the council making that argument in my response to the expiation notice.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the present case, Ms Stern is only able to point to an event some years ago involving an old vehicle she owned that was moved and the slashing of one of the tyres of the Mini in 2018. There is no evidence before the Court that suggests that these events were in any way related to the Mini being stopped within one metre of a fire hydrant on 13 June 2019. Accordingly, Ms Stern merely puts forth a hypothesis that a stranger moved the Mini, which even she conceded “sounds outlandish” and is difficult to take seriously. Ultimately, as there is no evidence worthy of consideration that suggests that the Mini was stopped within one metre of a fire hydrant due to the act of a stranger, no onus on the prosecution to exclude such a possibility beyond reasonable doubt arises. Ground 3 is not made out.Conclusion I dismiss the appeal. There are no grounds for interfering with the Magistrate’s discretion regarding costs. The costs order is within the Magistrates Court Criminal Scale of costs and there is no reviewable error identified in exercise of the discretion as to costs. The order for costs stands.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established