Stephen Mark Middleton and Valvoline (Australia) Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY  N0.  NI  908 of  1994

BETWEEN  Stephen Mark MIDDLETON

Applicant

AND              VALVOLINE (AUSTRALIA) PTY LIMITED

Respondent

MINUTES OF ORDER

31 March 1995  WALKER JR

THE COURT DECLARES:

  1. The termination of the employment of the applicant did contravene s170DE of the Industrial Relations Act 1988.

AND THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

  1. The respondent is to pay to the applicant the sum of $9,100.00.

NOTE:     Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Industrial Relations Court Rules.
INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY  N0.  NI  908 of  1994

BETWEEN  Stephen Mark MIDDLETON

Applicant

AND              VALVOLINE (AUSTRALIA) PTY LIMITED

Respondent

Reasons for Judgement

31 March 1995  WALKER JR

The applicant Stephen Mark Middleton commenced employment with the respondent on the 13 December 1989 as a sales representative.  He was subsequently transferred to Brisbane in March 1991 and on the 7 March 1994 was transferred to Newcastle.  On the 17 August 1994 he was promoted to acting branch manager, Newcastle with a probationary period of three months, on his existing salary.

The applicant gave evidence that he was very happy working for the respondent however he was concerned that his salary of $34,466.00 plus a fully maintained car was insufficient for the responsibility of his position.

On the 8 September 1994 the applicant was contacted by Mr Gavin Prendegast, the manager of Independent Fuel Suppliers in Queensland, a customer and friend of the applicants and was asked if he was happy.  The applicant said that he loved working for the respondent but they were not paying him the money that he was worth.  Although counsel for the respondent maintained that the applicant had indicated that he was not happy working at Valvoline the applicant was emphatic that it was only the salary that was the cause of any discontent.  During this conversation with Mr Prendagast it was suggested to the applicant that he should ring Mr Lowe as it could be to the advantage of the applicant.  It appears that Mr Prendagast’s position was to become available in the near future and the Independent Fuel Suppliers were looking for a replacement.

On the 22 September 1994 the applicant received a telephone call from Independent Fuel Suppliers inviting him to come to Queensland for an interview on Sunday 25 September.  He flew to Coolangatta at lunch time on the Friday 23 September and attended the interview at Mr Mark Lowe’s home, the Managing Director of Independent Fuel Suppliers on the Sunday.   The applicant denied the respondent’s assertion that the “job was in the bag” and maintained that he was unaware as to whether he had been successful.  He also insisted that he was not going to accept the position as he was disappointed with the salary package and that it was his intention to only test the water as to what his real worth would be on the market in any case.

On…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stephen Mark Middleton and Valvoline (Australia) Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1995] IRCA 118
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Stephen Mark Middleton, was employed by the respondent, Valvoline (Australia) Pty Limited, from December 1989 until his termination in September 1994. Middleton was initially a sales representative, later promoted to acting branch manager. His employment was terminated after he attended an interview for a position with Independent Fuel Suppliers. Middleton claimed that the termination was unlawful and in contravention of s170DE of the Industrial Relations Act 1988, which requires that dismissals must be for valid reasons connected with the employee's capacity, conduct, or operational requirements. Valvoline argued that Middleton resigned, but Middleton maintained that he was forced to resign under pressure. The Court had to decide whether Middleton's termination constituted a dismissal or a resignation and whether the termination was for a valid reason.

The Court found that Middleton's termination was a dismissal by the employer, as there was no written resignation, no notice was given, Middleton was taken home immediately after the meeting, and his belongings were not collected. The Court also found that the termination was not for a valid reason as it was based on Middleton attending an interview with another company, which does not constitute a valid reason under the Act. The Court concluded that the termination contravened s170DE of the Industrial Relations Act 1988. The Court ordered that Valvoline pay Middleton compensation of $9,100.00 for the unlawful termination.

The Court considered the manner in which Middleton's employment was terminated, the distress and humiliation it caused, and the financial losses incurred as a result of the termination. The Court awarded compensation up to the limit specified in the Act, rejecting Valvoline's argument that it had already compensated Middleton. The Court did not address the broader issue of whether compensation under the Act could include common law general damages. The Court ordered Valvoline to pay Middleton $9,100.00 in compensation for the unlawful termination.