RE ACN 007 612 633 PTY LTD
(FORMERLY CEMENTAID SA PTY LTD) (NOW IN LIQUIDATION)
[2002] SASC 328
JUDGE BURLEY. The plaintiff is the liquidator of a company which I will refer to as Cementaid SA. He has applied for the following orders:
1An order for the examination of Michael John Aldred, a former director of Cementaid SA pursuant to Section 596A of the Corporations Act (the Act).
(An order for production of documents has also been sought.)
2An order for the examination of David Frederick White, the company accountant, pursuant to Section 596B of the Act.
An order for production of documents has been sought as follows:
“All files and documents of whatsoever kind relating to the affairs of ACN 007 612 633 Pty Ltd (formerly Cementaid SA Pty Ltd) (now in liquidation) (‘the company’) including all statutory records, minutes, and all registers, taxation files, taxation returns and all other accounting records and files of the company.”
3By application filed on 22 July 2002 an order that Neil Strawbridge produce to the Registry of this Honourable Court the documents set out in the schedule as follows:
“All files, memoranda, and documents of whatsoever kind contained in the file in the possession of the said Neil Strawbridge in the District Court at Adelaide litigation being Action No: 376 of 1997 where Comfort Engineering Pty Ltd (ACN 007 759 695) trading as Oasis Airconditioning was plaintiff and ACN 007 621 633 in liquidation formerly Cementaid SA Pty Ltd (‘the company’) was defendant.”
I shall deal with the application against Mr Strawbridge first. The application should have been directed to Minter Ellison, solicitors, the firm of which Mr Strawbridge is a partner. No point was taken that he was named personally. The application purports to have been made pursuant to Section 596B of the Act. As the liquidator did not wish to examine Mr Strawbridge, the appropriate section authorising the application is Section 597(9) of the Act which provides:
“The Court may direct a person to produce, at an examination of that or any other person, books that are in the first-mentioned person’s possession and are relevant to matters to which the examination relates or will relate.”
In order to obtain the order for production by Minter Ellison, the liquidator must satisfy the Court that the documents “are relevant to matters to which the examination relates or will relate”.
The relevant paragraphs of the liquidator’s affidavit sworn on 10 September 2002 are as follows:
“3On 11 December 2001 in my capacity as liquidator I prepared a report and in that report I noted that in August 1999 Aldred & Co, the holding company of the company withdrew its financial support and demanded repayment of its outstanding loan accounts. In reduction of the loan account owed to Aldred & Co Pty Ltd the assets and business of the company were valued and transferred to a related entity. The company’s assets were valued at approximately $200,000.00. The value of the assets were used to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read STEPHEN JAMES DUNCAN (PLAINTIFF) No. SCCIV-02-763 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] SASC 328
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues the court had to address included whether the documents sought from Neil Strawbridge were relevant to the examinations of Mr Aldred and Mr White, and if the examinations themselves were necessary and not oppressive. The court also had to consider whether the proposed examination of Mr White would constitute an abuse of process given his prior cooperation with the liquidator.
The court found that the application for production of documents from Neil Strawbridge should be refused as there was no clear connection between the solicitor's file and the matters to be examined. The court further determined that the application for the examination of Mr Aldred was correctly made under Section 596A of the Act, and an order for examination was made accordingly. Regarding Mr White, the court held that while Mr White had already provided significant documentation, requiring his examination was not oppressive, especially considering the liquidator's potential proceedings against Aldred and Co Pty Ltd for an insolvent transaction. Consequently, the court granted the orders for examination and production of documents in respect of Mr White.
The final orders of the court were to refuse the application for production of documents from Neil Strawbridge, to grant the order for examination and production of documents in respect of Mr White, and to make the order for examination of Mr Aldred.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.