Stephen James Anderson v Caffitaly System S.p.A

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Stephen James Anderson v Caffitaly System S.p.A. [2019] APO 16

Patent Application:                2013233969

Title:System for making beverages

Patent Applicant:                   Caffitaly System S.p.A.

Opponent:  Stephen James Anderson

Delegate:  Dr V. Z. Kolev

Decision Date:  29 March 2019

Hearing Date:  07 August 2018, in Melbourne, further submissions filed on 09 August 2018, 14 August 2018, and 15 March 2019

Catchwords:  PATENTS – section 59 opposition to grant of a patent – novelty – inventive step – usefulness (utility) – regulation 5.23 request – system for making beverages – sealing arrangement between the capsule and the capsule holder – sealed contact involving a lateral face – one document consulted under regulation 5.23 – opposition unsuccessful on all grounds – costs awarded

Representation:  Counsel for the applicant:  Mr Ben Fitzpatrick

Patent attorney for the applicant:  Mr Richard Ollerenshaw of Patent Attorney Services

Counsel for the opponent:  Ms Clare Cunliffe and Mr Wen H. Wu

Patent attorney for the opponent:  Anderson IP

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:                2013233969

Title:System for making beverages

Patent Applicant:                   Caffitaly System S.p.A.

Date of Decision:                   29 March 2019

DECISION

Under regulation 5.23, for the purposes of deciding the opposition, I will consult document WO 2007/137974 A2 (D6). 

For the purposes of deciding the opposition, I will not consult any of the following documents: Watson-2, D5, D7, D10, and Annexure H of the Opponent’s Summary.

The opposition is unsuccessful on all grounds.  Subject to appeal, I direct that the application proceeds to grant.

I award costs according to the amounts specified in Schedule 8 against Stephen James Anderson.

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Throughout this decision, unless explicitly stated otherwise, any reference to an Act or a section, subsection, etc. of an Act refers to the Patents Act 1990 (the Act), and any reference to Regulations or a specific regulation refers to the Patents Regulations 1991 (the Regulations).

    Background

  2. The matter relates to patent application 2013233969 (the Application) in the name of Caffitaly System S.p.A. (the Applicant).  The Application is the national phase entry of the International Application PCT/IB2013/051595, published as WO 2013/136209.  The Application was filed on 28 February 2013 and claims a priority date of 14 March 2012.

  3. The Application was advertised as accepted on 09 June 2016.  A notice of opposition to grant was filed on 09 September 2016 by Stephen James Anderson (the Opponent).    

  4. The statement of grounds and particulars (the SGP) was filed on 09 December 2016 together with the accompanying documents D1 to D22 (including D9A, D11A, and D16A).  The evidence in support was completed on 09 March 2017.  No evidence in answer was filed.

  5. On 04 April 2017, the Opponent filed a request to amend the SGP.  Document WO 2012/118367 A1 (already filed in evidence as exhibit SW-4) was also filed with this request as a corrected version of document D13 as mentioned in and filed together with the SGP.  The request was allowed on 02 May…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stephen James Anderson v Caffitaly System S.p.A and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] APO 16
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Stephen James Anderson filed an opposition to the grant of a patent in the name of Caffitaly System S.p.A. The opposition was based on the grounds of lack of novelty, lack of inventive step, and lack of utility. The parties submitted written arguments and the matter proceeded to a hearing. The Delegate, Dr V. Z. Kolev, considered the evidence and submissions and found that the opposition was unsuccessful on all grounds. The Delegate concluded that the claimed invention was novel, involved an inventive step, and was useful. The Delegate awarded costs against the opponent, Stephen James Anderson. The Delegate directed that the application proceeds to grant.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns a patent application 2013233969 (the Application) for a system for making beverages, filed by Caffitaly System S.p.A. (the Applicant). The Application was opposed by Stephen James Anderson (the Opponent) on various grounds, including lack of novelty, lack of inventive step, and lack of utility. The invention pertains to a system for making beverages using capsules containing a powdered food substance. The system includes a capsule holder and a capsule designed to create a watertight seal between the capsule and the capsule holder. The seal is formed by a lateral contact involving the lateral faces of the sealing elements, rather than relying on axial pressure. The invention aims to simplify the construction process and reduce production costs by avoiding the need for resilient sealing members or excessive precision in manufacturing.

The Application was advertised as accepted on 09 June 2016. A notice of opposition to grant was filed by the Opponent on 09 September 2016. The statement of grounds and particulars (SGP) was filed on 09 December 2016. The Applicant filed a request to amend the SGP, which was allowed on 02 May 2017. The Applicant also filed a request to amend the specification, which was allowed on 30 November 2017. The hearing took place on 07 August 2018, with further submissions filed on 09 August 2018, 14 August 2018, and 15 March 2019. The decision was made on 29 March 2019.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the invention defined in claim 1 is not novel in light of the prior art documents D1, D13, and the information made publicly available through doing the act evidenced by documents D16 to D22 (including D16A).
2. Whether the invention defined in claim 1 lacks an inventive step in light of the common general knowledge considered separately, and in light of the common general knowledge together with document D6, D5, and D10, and the information made publicly available through doing the act evidenced by documents D16 to D22 (including D16A).
3. Whether the invention defined in any one of the claims is not useful.

Held
1. The invention defined in claim 1 is not not novel in light of the prior art documents D1, D13, and the information made publicly available through doing the act evidenced by documents D16 to D22 (including D16A).
2. The invention defined in claim 1 lacks an inventive step in light of the common general knowledge considered separately, and in light of the common general knowledge together with document D6, D5, and D10, and the information made publicly available through doing the act evidenced by documents D16 to D22 (including D16A).
3. The invention defined in any one of the claims is not not useful.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case note focuses on the opposition to grant a patent on a system for making beverages, with the Applicant Caffitaly System S.p.A. and the Opponent Stephen James Anderson. The Delegate Dr V. Z. Kolev considered three grounds of opposition: lack of novelty, lack of inventive step, and lack of utility. The Delegate concluded that the opposition was unsuccessful on all grounds.

First, the Delegate examined the novelty of the invention. The Opponent relied on prior art documents D1 and D13, as well as the information made publicly available through doing the act evidenced by documents D16 to D22 (including D16A). The Delegate found that none of these documents disclosed all essential features of claim 1, and therefore the invention was considered novel.

Next, the Delegate considered the inventive step of the invention. The Opponent argued that the invention was obvious in light of the common general knowledge and the prior art documents D6, D5, and D10, as well as the information made publicly available through doing the act evidenced by documents D16 to D22 (including D16A). The Delegate found that the evidence on file was insufficient to establish that a person skilled in the art would be motivated to reach something within the scope of claim 1. Therefore, the invention was considered to involve an inventive step.

Finally, the Delegate examined the utility of the invention. The Opponent argued that the invention did not meet the promise of the specification, and that not everything within the scope of the claim would be useful. The Delegate found that the evidence on file did not allow the establishment that the invention did not fulfill its promise as properly identified, and therefore the invention was considered useful.

Based on the findings, the Delegate concluded that the opposition was unsuccessful on all grounds, and awarded costs against the Opponent.