Stephen Huckle and Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

[2014] AATA 362 

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2013/6125

Re

Stephen Huckle

APPLICANT

And

Commissioner of Taxation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Ms A F Cunningham (Senior Member)

Date 6 June 2014  
Place Perth

Decision under review is affirmed.

....(Sgd) A F Cunningham.................................

Ms A F Cunningham (Senior Member)

CATCHWORDS

TAXATION – taxation liability – application for release – whether payment of tax liability would cause serious financial hardship – substantial income and investment properties – no serious hardship found – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 s37

Tax Administration Act 1953 ss14ZZ, 14ZZK, 340-10(2), 340-5, 340-5(3) and

Division 340 part 4-50

CASES

Cinerari and Commissioner of Taxation [2006] AATA 171

Commissioner of Taxation v Milne [2006] FCA1005
Commissioner of Taxation v a Taxpayer [2006] FCA 888
Corlette v MacKenzie (1995) 62 FCR 584
Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) ALD 634
Powell v Evreniaves & Ors (1989) 21 FCR 252
Rasmussen v Commissioner of Taxation [2013] AATA 746
R v Trebilco; ex parte F.S. Falkiner and Sons Ltd (1936) 56 CLR20

Saw v Commissioner of Taxation AAT SS2004/11 and 2004/12

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms A F Cunningham (Senior Member)

6 June 2014

  1. The applicant, Stephen Huckle seeks the review of a decision of the respondent Commissioner to disallow an objection, which was made against the Commissioner’s decision to deny Mr Huckle’s application for release from his tax liabilities. Mr Huckle‘s taxation debt balance is $81,387.23 as at 21 February 14 and includes amounts for balance income tax payable, penalties and interest charges.

  2. The hearing was conducted by way of video link to the Perth Registry in Western Australia. Mr Huckle appeared on his own behalf and gave oral evidence. The respondent was represented by Mr Hill. The T documents were tendered pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. The applicant also tendered a number of documents which were received into evidence.

  3. Mr Huckle contends that his income tax debts have arisen as a result of his unauthorised early access of superannuation benefits in order to support his gambling addiction. Mr Huckle seeks release from his tax liability either in whole or in part on the basis that he would suffer serious hardship if he was required to pay the outstanding balance.

  4. It is contended by the respondent that Mr Huckle has not discharged his onus of establishing that he would suffer serious hardship if he was required to satisfy his tax liabilities. Further, if the Tribunal is satisfied that the applicant would suffer serious hardship it is contended that the circumstances do not justify the exercise of a discretion to release him in whole or in part from his taxation debt.

    LEGISLATION

  5. Mr Huckle’s application for review is made pursuant to section 14ZZ of the Tax Administration Act 1953 (TA Act). The provisions of section 14ZZK state that the applicant has the burden of proving in this case, that the taxation decision should not have been…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stephen Huckle and Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 362
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Stephen Huckle and the Commissioner of Taxation involves a dispute over the release of Mr Huckle's liability to pay taxes. Mr Huckle, who had illegally accessed his superannuation benefits, applied for the release of his tax liability. The application was contested by the Commissioner, leading to a hearing before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The primary issue before the AAT was whether Mr Huckle was entitled to a release from his tax liability on the grounds of serious hardship. The decision hinged on the application of the ATO Receivables Policy and the criteria set out in section 340-5 of the relevant legislation.

The legal issues that the AAT needed to resolve included the interpretation of "serious hardship" and whether it resulted from Mr Huckle being required to satisfy his tax liability. Additionally, the AAT considered Mr Huckle's financial situation, including his income, assets, and liabilities. The AAT had to evaluate whether Mr Huckle's choices and financial commitments justified the exercise of discretion by the Commissioner to grant a release. The tribunal also examined Mr Huckle's compliance with tax laws and whether his actions, such as unauthorised access to superannuation benefits and non-compliance with tax return obligations, impacted the discretion to grant a release.

In its decision, the AAT found that Mr Huckle's claims of serious hardship were not sufficient to warrant the release of his tax liability. The tribunal noted that Mr Huckle's financial situation, while challenging, did not meet the stringent criteria for serious hardship as required by the legislation. Mr Huckle's ability to reduce discretionary expenses and sell assets to meet his tax liability undermined his argument for serious hardship. The AAT emphasised the importance of taxpayers contributing to the community's infrastructure and services, and Mr Huckle's failure to do so by prioritising other financial commitments over his tax liability was a critical factor in the decision. Consequently, the AAT upheld the Commissioner's decision not to release Mr Huckle from his tax liability.

The final orders of the tribunal were that Mr Huckle's application for the release of his tax liability was dismissed. The tribunal confirmed that Mr Huckle remained liable to pay the outstanding tax debt, and no discretion to release the liability was exercised by the Commissioner. The decision underscored the importance of compliance with tax laws and the necessity for taxpayers to meet their obligations to the community.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Paragraph 24.6.21 provides the tests by which the Commissioner should evaluate the merits of individual cases and was summarised by Member Fice in Cinerari and Commissioner of Taxation [2006] AATA 171 as follows:Paragraph 24.6.21 provides the steps by which the Commissioner should evaluate the merits of individual cases; those being:Income/Outgoings TestsAssets/Liabilities TestsOther factorsThe relevant factors when applying the three tests are set out in detail in paragraphs 24.6.22 to 24.6.31. They can be summarised as follows:Income/Outgoings Tests(a) what is the person's capacity to pay measured by income and outgoings stated in the application or supporting documents;(b) the accuracy of the income/outgoings stated by the applicant;(c) by what margin does available income exceed reasonable outgoings; is that sufficient to allow liability to be met and the debt cleared within two or three years; and(d) other optional expenditures which could be reduced or deferred;Assets/Liabilities Tests(a) whether a person's equity in assets is indicative of capacity to pay the tax debt;(b) whether acquisition of assets has unreasonably been put ahead of meeting tax liabilities;(c) are the assets normal and reasonable possessions, which would not be expected to be surrendered or sold to meet revenue debts;(d) whether assets have been valued realistically and liabilities accurately recorded; and(e) whether a person's asset possession indicates untapped borrowing capacity.Other Factors(a) whether the Commissioner should exercise a discretion to grant a release if serious hardship is established;(b) has the person disposed of funds or assets without making proper provision to meet tax liabilities;(c) will the granting of release result in reduction of hardship;(d) has the person used available funds to discharge debts due to other private creditors in preference to debts due to the Commissioner;(e) has the person used available funds to discharge debts due to other business creditors where those payments are not considered reasonable to maintain the viability of the business and could be considered as an unfair preference payment to the detriment of the Commissioner; and(f) whether the person is able to demonstrate they have made provision for future debts.The ATO Receivables Policy has been applied by the Tribunal in a number of cases, including Re Ferguson and Commissioner of Taxation [2004] AATA 779, Re Filsell and Commissioner of Taxation [2004] AATA 1012, Re Spicer and Commissioner of Taxation [2004] AATA 960, Re Perrott and Commissioner of Taxation [2004] AATA 1372, and Re Lipthay and Commissioner of Taxation [2005] AATA 224).BACKGROUND FACTS There was little dispute about the following facts that gave rise to Mr Huckle’s application for release of liability as set out in the respondent’s Statement of Facts Issues and Contentions. Mr Huckle was a trustee of the Stephen Huckle Superannuation Fund (the Superannuation Fund) and during the income year ended 30 June 2011, illegally accessed his superannuation benefits by withdrawing amounts totalling $180,600 from the Superannuation Fund.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Hill claimed that Mr Huckle is in the fortunate position of being able to earn a high income and has made choices that have led to his current position. It was submitted that if the Tribunal nevertheless found that he suffered serious hardship, the discretion should not be exercised in these circumstances for the following reasons: Mr Huckle had preferred other creditors to his tax liability and had made only a very small contribution in reduction of his tax debt; despite his position as a former employee of the ATO, he had prepared tax returns for others when he was not authorised to do so; he had been non-compliant with the tax legislation by failing to lodge returns for his superannuation fund in a timely manner; he had made unauthorised access to his superannuation fund.CONSIDERATION AND FINDINGS The “serious hardship” referred to in section 340-5 must result as a consequence of an individual being required to satisfy their tax liability. In other words if the relief sought was to be granted and the individual still suffered serious hardship because of their other financial commitments, the discretion sought should not be exercised. In his release application Mr Huckle lists his total asset value at around $579,500 with total liabilities of $666,200 which does not include his tax liability of $81,387.23. His total after-tax income appears to exceed his listed household expenditure by the fortnightly amount of $429. These expenses in my view however, include discretionary spending that could be reduced for instance, entertainment of $250 per fortnight, other expenses of $264 per fortnight and most notably vehicle expenses including repairs and loan repayments of $926 per fortnight. Although a sale of the motor vehicle would not totally discharge Mr Huckle’s loan, it is likely to significantly reduce his overall fortnightly repayments. Further, on the figures provided, a sale of his investment property would result in equity almost sufficient to reduce his total tax liability. Mr Huckle’s advice that any proposed sale would force him to take up residence in the property was a clear indication that he did not acknowledge his legal responsibility to settle his tax liability. In this context Deputy President Forgie’s comments in paragraph 98 of Rasmussen are of relevance:Mr Rasmussen has made other choices that have led him, until very recently, to maintain the payments on the family’s two assets but not to maintain any payments towards the reduction of the tax liability since December 2011. When faced with choices of that sort, it may well be easy for a taxpayer to characterise an obligation to pay a tax liability in terms of an obligation to pay the Commissioner of the Australian Taxation office (ATO). Focusing on those whose task it is to administer the taxation legislation and to collect tax, is to take the focus away from the fact that it is collected under those laws for, ultimately, the benefit of the Australian community of which the taxpayer is a member. Within that community, an individual taxpayer may husband his or her own income and assets but, as a member of it, he or she must make a contribution to the infrastructure that is provided for the benefit of all. It is provided whether or not an individual taxpayer need to call on it all the time, some of the time or not at all. Hospitals and roads are obvious examples but so too are income maintenance payments. When seen in this light, when choosing to maintain payments on privately acquired assets but not to maintain any payments to meet a tax liability, a taxpayer is saying that the community should support him or her for his or her share of the costs of meeting the infrastructure and services that are met out of taxpayers meeting their tax liabilities.