Stephanie's Management Services Pty Ltd ATF Shepherd Management Trust (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

Stephanie's Management Services Pty Ltd ATF Shepherd Management Trust (Migration) [2021] AATA 4270 (3 November 2021)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

APPLICANT:  Stephanie’s Management Services Pty Ltd ATF Shepherd Management Trust

CASE NUMBER:  1830703

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S):          BCC2018/471841

MEMBER:Terrence Baxter

DATE:3 November 2021

PLACE OF DECISION:  Brisbane

DECISION:The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes a decision approving the nomination.

Statement made on 03 November 2021 at 8:43am

CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – application for approval of nomination of position – temporary residence transition stream – financial capacity to employ nominee for two years – no financial statements or tax returns provided to department – documentary and oral evidence provided to tribunal – continuing trading during COVID-19 restrictions – continuing employment of nominee as integral part of team – group of companies or trusts related to applicant – joint hearing with review of refusal of visa application – decision under review set aside

LEGISLATION  
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s 140GB
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), r 5.19(3)(d)(i)
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 50AAA

CASE     
MIBP v Jayshree Enterprises Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 264

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs on 11 October 2018 to reject the applicant’s application for approval of the nomination of a position in Australia under reg 5.19 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the Regulations).

  2. The applicant, Stephanie’s Management Services Pty Ltd as trustee for the Shepherd Management Trust, applied for approval on 29 January 2018. The applicant nominated Mr Willington Rene Jimenez Garnica (the nominee) in the position of Client Services Manager. The requirements for the approval of the nomination of a position in Australia are found in reg 5.19 of the Regulations which contains two alternative streams: a Temporary Residence Transition nomination stream (reg 5.19(3)) and a Direct Entry nomination stream (reg 5.19(4)). If the application is made in accordance with reg 5.19(2) and meets the requirements of either stream, then the application must be approved. If any of the requirements are not met, then the application must be refused: reg 5.19(5).

  3. In this case, the applicant has applied for approval of a nomination, seeking to satisfy the criteria in the Temporary Residence Transition nomination stream.

  4. The delegate refused the application on the basis the applicant’s nomination did not satisfy reg 5.19(3)(d)(i) of the Regulations because the delegate found that the applicant did not demonstrate the financial capacity to employ the nominee on a full-time basis in the position for at least two years.

  5. The applicant lodged an application for review of the delegate’s decision with the Tribunal on 19 October 2018.

  6. The applicant’s Director of Finance and Inventory, Ms Natalie Dunstan, appeared before the Tribunal on 1 September 2021 by video conference to give evidence and present arguments. The hearing was a joint hearing with the application for review of a decision to refuse the visa application of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stephanie's Management Services Pty Ltd ATF Shepherd Managem... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 4270
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Stephanie's Management Services Pty Ltd ATF Shepherd Management Trust for approval of a nomination of a position under the Temporary Residence Transition stream. The applicant sought to have the decision of the delegate, which refused to approve the nomination, set aside. The case was heard by Terrence Baxter.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicant met the requirements for approval of the nomination as set out in regulation 5.19(3) of the Migration Regulations 1994. This involved determining whether the applicant had the financial capacity to employ the nominee for at least two years, whether there was a genuine need to employ the nominee, and whether the applicant had a satisfactory record of compliance with workplace relations laws. The Tribunal also considered whether there was any adverse information known to the Department concerning the nominator or associated persons.

The Tribunal found that the applicant had provided sufficient documentary and oral evidence to satisfy the requirements of regulation 5.19(3). This included financial reports, tax returns, activity statements, and evidence of ongoing employment and training expenditure, demonstrating the applicant's financial capacity and the genuine need for the nominee's role within the group of related entities. The Tribunal was satisfied that there was no adverse information known to the Department and that the applicant had a satisfactory record of compliance with workplace relations laws. The Tribunal also accepted that the nominee's role was integral to the operations of the various spas within the group, despite the applicant primarily providing payroll services.

Consequently, the Tribunal decided to set aside the delegate's decision and substitute a new decision approving the nomination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant produced to the Tribunal the following documents: a.A copy of the delegate’s decision. b.Submissions from the representative dated 22 July 2021. c.Details of the contact person for the business, Ms Dunstan. d.An updated current ABN Lookup form for The Trustee for Shepherd Management Trust, ABN 53 743 599 190. e.A further unsigned copy of the trust deed for the Shepherd Management Trust. f.Trust tax returns and financial reports of the Shepherd Management Trust for the 2018 to 2020 financial years. g.Activity statements for the period from July 2019 to June 2021. h.An updated organisational chart and position description. i.Updated extracts from the applicant’s website. j.A copy of the job advertisement for the position and the nominee’s covering letter previously produced to the Department. k.A copy of the employment contract of the nominee dated 7 July 2015 previously produced to the Department. l.A letter from the applicant confirming the availability of the nominee’s position dated 20 July 2021. m.Updated market salary research. n.PAYG payments summaries and notices of assessment of the nominee for the 2016 to 2020 financial years. o.Payslips of the nominee for the period from January 2019 to June 2021. p.Notification of the applicant’s approval as a standard business sponsor for the period from 31 July 2015 to 31 July 2020. q.An updated training expenditure summary prepared by the representative. r.Payroll activity summaries prepared by the applicant for the 2016 and 2020 financial years.s.A summary of in-house training hours and expenditure prepared by the applicant for the 2015 to 2020 financial years. t.Payslips of Stacey Leong from December 2017 and June to July 2021. u.An employment contract of Stacey Leong dated 23 January 2017 and a copy of the employment contract dated 31 March 2017. v.A copy of the letter from the applicant confirming Stacey Leong’s position and duties dated 18 April 2017. w.Copies of the internal training logbooks of the applicant. x.Training procedure manuals of the applicant. y.A submission from the applicant regarding adverse information dated 21 July 2021. Evidence presented at the hearing regarding the applicant’s operations Ms Dunstan gave evidence regarding the business operations of the applicant. She stated that the applicant provided a payroll employment service for six discrete entities operating spas under the umbrella of Stephanie’s Luxury Spas. She explained that the applicant trust had been established because employees worked for the various spas within the Group. She stated that the applicant employed all of the employees working at the various spas and received payment from the respective spa operators for the labour supplied. She said that the operators of the six spas were all related to the applicant. Ms Dunstan stated that the applicant operated from premises situated in Murarrie, Queensland, which she described as the head office of the Group. She said that the premises included an office, a reservations team, a commercial laundry facility and a training room.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has decided to set aside the decision under review and substitute a decision approving the nomination.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The issue in this case is whether the applicant meets the requirements for approval of the nomination under the Temporary Residence Transition nomination stream set out in reg 5.19(3), which is extracted in the attachment to this decision. For the nomination to be approved, all the requirements must be met.Evidence presented prior to the hearing The applicant produced to the Department of Immigration and Border Protection (now the Department of Home Affairs) (the Department) the following documents: a.An unsigned copy of the trust deed for the Shepherd Management Trust. b.A current ABN Lookup form for The Trustee for the Shepherd Management Trust, ABN 53 743 599 190. c.A job advertisement for the position. d.Market salary research. e.An employment contract of the nominee dated 7 July 2015. f.An application by the nominee for the position dated 24 June 2015. g.A letter from the applicant dated 14 November 2017 confirming the availability of the nominee’s position for a period of two years. h.Activity statements for the period from July 2016 to February 2018. i.Payroll activity summaries prepared by the applicant for the 2016 and 2017 financial years. j.An employment contract for the position Beauty Therapist/Spa Trainer addressed to Stacey Leong, dated 23 January 2014. k.A payslip of Stacey Leong from December 2017. l.A position description. m.Website extracts of the applicant. n.Payslips of the nominee for the period from October 2015 to August 2017. o.An organisational chart. p.A training expenditure summary prepared by the representative. q.A letter from the applicant confirming the nominee’s position and duties dated 14 November 2017. r.A document summarising in-house training expenditure of the applicant. s.Notification of the applicant’s nomination approval for the nominee’s subclass 457 visa dated 26 August 2015.t.Notices of tax assessment and PAYG payment summaries of the nominee for the 2016 and 2017 financial years.u.A letter from the applicant confirming Stacey Leong’s position and duties dated 18 April 2017. v.Various internal training logbooks of the applicant. w.An employment contract of Stacey Leong dated 31 March 2017.x.A submission from the applicant’s accountant dated 19 April 2018. The applicant produced to the Tribunal the following documents: a.A copy of the delegate’s decision. b.Submissions from the representative dated 22 July 2021. c.Details of the contact person for the business, Ms Dunstan. d.An updated current ABN Lookup form for The Trustee for Shepherd Management Trust, ABN 53 743 599 190. e.A further unsigned copy of the trust deed for the Shepherd Management Trust. f.Trust tax returns and financial reports of the Shepherd Management Trust for the 2018 to 2020 financial years. g.Activity statements for the period from July 2019 to June 2021. h.An updated organisational chart and position description. i.Updated extracts from the applicant’s website. j.A copy of the job advertisement for the position and the nominee’s covering letter previously produced to the Department. k.A copy of the employment contract of the nominee dated 7 July 2015 previously produced to the Department. l.A letter from the applicant confirming the availability of the nominee’s position dated 20 July 2021. m.Updated market salary research. n.PAYG payments summaries and notices of assessment of the nominee for the 2016 to 2020 financial years. o.Payslips of the nominee for the period from January 2019 to June 2021. p.Notification of the applicant’s approval as a standard business sponsor for the period from 31 July 2015 to 31 July 2020. q.An updated training expenditure summary prepared by the representative. r.Payroll activity summaries prepared by the applicant for the 2016 and 2020 financial years.s.A summary of in-house training hours and expenditure prepared by the applicant for the 2015 to 2020 financial years. t.Payslips of Stacey Leong from December 2017 and June to July 2021. u.An employment contract of Stacey Leong dated 23 January 2017 and a copy of the employment contract dated 31 March 2017. v.A copy of the letter from the applicant confirming Stacey Leong’s position and duties dated 18 April 2017. w.Copies of the internal training logbooks of the applicant. x.Training procedure manuals of the applicant. y.A submission from the applicant regarding adverse information dated 21 July 2021. Evidence presented at the hearing regarding the applicant’s operations

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Accordingly, the requirement in reg 5.19(3)(f) is met.No adverse information known to Immigration: reg 5.19(3)(g) Regulation 5.19(3)(g) requires that there is no adverse information known to Immigration about the nominator or person associated with the nominator; or it is reasonable to disregard any such information. For these purposes, ‘adverse information’ and ‘associated with’ have the meaning given in regs 1.13A and 1.13B of the Regulations. There is no evidence before the Tribunal that there is any adverse information of the type described in the relevant definitions known to the Department about the applicant or any associated person. Accordingly, the requirement in reg 5.19(3)(g) is met.Satisfactory compliance with workplace relations laws: reg 5.19(3)(h) Regulation 5.19(3)(h) requires the applicant to have a satisfactory record of compliance with the laws of the Commonwealth, and of each State or Territory in which the applicant operates a business and employs employees in the business, relating to workplace relations. There is no evidence before the Tribunal to suggest that the applicant has an unsatisfactory record of compliance with workplace relations laws of the Commonwealth or any State or Territory in which the applicant operates a business. The Tribunal is satisfied that the applicant does have a satisfactory record of compliance. Accordingly, the requirement in reg 5.19(3)(h) is met.Genuine need to employ nominee: reg 5.19(3)(i) Regulation 5.19(3)(i) requires that there is a genuine need for the nominator to employ the person, as a paid employee, to work in the position under the nominator’s direct control. The applicant provided to the Tribunal a job description which included a position overview. This document states that the primary responsibility of the position is to provide leadership, direction and supervision of staff in the daily operations of the Contact Centre whilst developing and maintaining customer service policies to maintain, promote and improve customer engagement and relations throughout the related spas and Contact Centre as well as monitoring after-sales performance and client satisfaction across the Group’s spas. At the hearing, Ms Dunstan gave evidence regarding the genuine need for the position. She stated that the nominee spent the majority of his time working in the head office/Contact Centre, but that he was also required to visit the various spas operated by the Group. She said that he was responsible for all aspects of client satisfaction. The Tribunal questioned whether time spent by the nominee in addressing the satisfaction of clients of the various spas was relevant to his employment by the applicant, a business primarily provided a payroll employment service. The Tribunal sought confirmation from Ms Dunstan of the individual entities which operated the six spas within the Group’s operations. She stated that each spa was operated by a separate company or trust, but that all were related to the applicant. Prior to the hearing the applicant had provided evidence that Ms Stephanie Shepherd was the sole Ordinary shareholder in the corporate trustee of the applicant trust (Mr Desmond Plaisted holding one Class C share in that company). After the hearing, the applicant provided evidence that Ms Shepherd was the sole Ordinary shareholder in each of the companies which operated the various spas. The Tribunal is satisfied that the spa operators are related bodies corporate to the applicant and are entities associated with the applicant pursuant to s 50AAA of the Corporations Act 2001.