Stella Property Solutions Pty Ltd v Simmondson

%PDF-1.5

%????

1 0 obj

<</Type/Catalog/Pages 2 0 R/Lang(en-US) /StructTreeRoot 26 0 R/MarkInfo<</Marked true>>>>

endobj

2 0 obj

<</Type/Pages/Count 4/Kids[ 3 0 R 19 0 R 21 0 R 23 0 R] >>

endobj

3 0 obj

<</Type/Page/Parent 2 0 R/Resources<</XObject<</Image5 5 0 R>>/Font<</F1 6 0 R/F2 8 0 R/F3 10 0 R/F4 12 0 R/F5 14 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI] >>/MediaBox[ 0 0 595.32 841.92] /Contents 4 0 R/Group<</Type/Group/S/Transparency/CS/DeviceRGB>>/Tabs/S/StructParents 0>>

endobj

4 0 obj

<</Filter/FlateDecode/Length 3102>>

stream

x??kO???{%??~???????kU? ???(?????r>?$???p????;3~n??M?*??3;3;??]?N?qt????????8?L?3??h?z??h??<???<D?I??_????>???W??{???c
?????o?`???OG?????cg+v}??t
o?q???jZ?Y??#?z???2?=????O?{????|?b6??g??
????1??|?|`???????2??&2^`?i@???]r???2!????K?g<?l??Vl=?????? K?*
Zai???m???????wb?//?Kl??Z??hp0%tL?y]D??
x?[???H?5H??D$r[$??l??]73??P???u??
K?&???cW????WV?{??s|??7/h?
_,^b?/?8?P?%~?$kV???M<

??uG?-??1/=p?l_?5????i???,??dq7?4mrF;M?p_.???Ex??H[?:??[1]?? ????}a;[?;@???_
????^?d?a
??5[1]'F*????']c??|A!8U?a?BcP??uE????q?V-??]??c!???A?>3???O

?2F!jA??07???a??<??Y?*B7??Ua??TM?h@SV ?@??y|W~?8?1]?

N??o? t=?????_M?????G??5_E?h-s????0??????rNo??+?m|?????????#>?????V?a????:T??\?????G??va6??X=?TSc????o??4

~?D??eAtRY??4?|

?*?(?X]??)?ii?? B?-?6??M??`_????N??xe??
O???LR}?????k????&?+??????Exg‑???N??iKV?&??????3???5?V?^?`U?o%?"?S>LR#??a??:(?o/~A????<?
?????I

e?4m???p??6lE??)?X??Rr????:7Q
??o-?%????Ub‑??]
??tfM???6???????u]ljVT??
?&??????-???D?'?-?5??????????
?R?J@?U?*??vx*??
?"??'p???x0b??Z~?>?????f??jx?|]?vm??t?????????n??????x:?'(*#?ZR????"
?K????a+Ai"????
????.??:?
?????L?\??
/?`g?=L?lp?S-S4?????3??>??V?[1]"R?9?k?.?X?'-?c???s?n<g???QLBq?~?\h????lW??h}?<nn+??U^??`"u??

S?+??1??y(m?34tFX??%hjPm`3????1???S?)????]?????)???????hH???F?E???[1]???u???B?%???-3^???

?lx??
v?

~c?j$[$-???F?1i????_'?IBD?di???(?R????{`?
?????2?U?V??n$H?ZS???Jg
Ow?)??????ve?pwM?|??Q??P?*??*?E<?1??????
?F??s??go
\?????$??R

?
?H??B??f???h?<De?V?$?N?p????d??mp?.?????16w?[1]??Q

YC>h???ZXs>?????=???f?o?-s???t
?f??zF??{4?5??,m3M
@?y???5??5v

Fl???????S??&-B???#??????p??f?S[c8?eu???#p??fv%o,&?%???JcYc*?Le?/Gg??

??l??????Q??6?Q4)?

l??V??????r?9?+?K???9?0,h?k???@????????t?$??)?aw??-,???
?‑?;?@?*[y?\?Q>

????

?<P??.?I?????'?z?5???????a???#?q?v?5E-4?`?))?M?keg??Z?????1?j?ba4???~??t2????????x@?lE?????o?N????3_????J???x??dO?>Fw

??XN<g?s??x???]??t???)??b?YF??s?C???%)aQ???S\??E(??3Z???>???@?2Z??'??%?a?.?a-?c[.;?q?O???l??t
=O
???B???5r]Y?P'?w???B?T4?[V??[1][?z??$????T?????????n???sf9:???w?q???l???f??1?f?q<q?J?I?2??)><??p?z??"l????Y??L*:???S??
v"?

u? 7)u?^?}?
?lS?B~A!??P)??j?&z?@8/@Z??"+g?]?i?????A?k:?_?
xi?*R
??????? ???{c2?????O??CuBR?;???*?g
?SP???D?y???0??r?8?'??n?7L{???Q??W???d?????=??=?Q:??NS?n???,?7???z?N????s??9?J????Rf?**?4?[1]?O?O??n?>
????7/>8?t??n{??????MN?`3L
?uU?DMK?‑??.H?>?%-??x?o?BDl
M??:qz?|?????'l?
?d?d?_?0?????m???aNf??i?????Q?#?????|????F?v??????p? ?m????kro3????N?/$
?5r??P1?aB%?
*?J???t?k?0B?"?t?W?<??iT??:^'?pT>???? ???{

~?c???????Y#???L?uf?M@Ma.~??
T?????>?[??\????')5H?Z‑?Q?v|z
??0?M??????P???y??#p?7??????:??bo{?+?????8?? ?N?.?V:?OfD??`?F?+??????b???
????>??????F?[?4l??B?:???7?9??????*be??i??]??3?4???*??
:?`??????'Ig?6_i"\???v=

6+?5???yJ&4???TZ???1??xFZ??oXde??????o?&VZ?O?v?‑??q;UI‑?AV???V?f??(8W????y??????N??%n>?,&t3?fj??c??m
????Oi?m??$??cx?S??%?{??gi?r2???FRN???e^K????d??E??xL?K?vX?m????
e??<??zK?Z??‑v??\?$??????‑m?
"?l????@?D?(?oh)?

endstream

endobj

5 0 obj

<</Type/XObject/Subtype/Image/Width 468/Height 139/ColorSpace/DeviceRGB/BitsPerComponent 8/Filter/DCTDecode/Interpolate true/Length 9771>>

stream

????JFIF``??C

‑ $.' ",#(7),01444'9=82<.342??C

2!!22222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222????

"[1]??[1]

???[1][1]}[1]!1AQa"q2???#B??R??$3br?
%&'()*456789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????[1]

???[1][1][1]w[1]!1AQaq"2?B????#3R?br?
$4?%?&'()*56789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
[1]???(??
??5?+@??N?}

?G????@9??r?~!A????R}Vu?Q‑???????|????????????7????t

?T?V)F????g+aaw{??q??'????h>?X?????]x?.???e???;???p?o???L?e"P???+?4_i‑"??F?

?????????????????}??s%??g+$g??=????qG??W??7???-???HuxW,????????[1]?;??`???~"?D??m???>?:?(?H????
???%s???E??v??:??V??????????W???‑??]?J?&?

???#??*?MWW?????????????@:?*?f??(???????N4}<
?g???????u-
?????#???,??X??w
qQ??c?G?~????U????.q???d??=
?M_(|>?????Q?O$V?-??pcQ?}I?????0??\[frV?(?????^???F
?[?????"? ?r{??5?
?D??F??????x?[?????z??/7???b|?\g??j?rw4QG?????x?Y:e?????Y?L?p??Z???k'??-?5=?Hf‑g???o????@ ????%c'?? ????>?x?<?
??[?`??????^???=C??_?????L?/?????_0???c?MC???????????????7?>z?????_<QS???????{xo?|??????^???=C??_???(???*>??????????????????#????,-o_-?-*??????k?~?????E??(}?????Rm??${?QZQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEKX?-?]"?R?8??3#{???x????????????}1g?G????T??Wg?k????5??R??Op?????Q?g???D??I????>????
*???5???????????c????L??a???????)(?>?t'?????6?+??yx??,cJ?El?????><?K??3^?v?g??,#?b9?????|?????
??G ?????]-t??z?F?b?????????]J??sV?u???????;?w
???~5?????<C?????Gs|g;OB?[1]?+???????\h?????‑???????U?h???????kV??o5[??v????n=[1]?$?_#?????\?W?y???a??W??{??;=3E?????a??/?[??
?o[V?
2\N??????QTd?=??<

??K??"??`??Ta???tp???s?W?|?ST????

Ga??y?W???W?tAu?A??EUA?U[1]?????&???N?LG

?)??????:+B
o?~

??^??V?f?G/4??i:?c?q???IEW;??o???z???V-?z?c?c?9?+???????L?#o?Z?a??????*M?

+????)

+1C??

???G??:ez^???#?V????l7
q?G;?S??)?y?}_??Z???&?t??d????2???5??{_?Mk?h?7P?0??u??Z?=I???

cF????4?N???????e?#? ?[1]???T??????????h?,??q_??<

?@1??S?u?N?o???[@?"??H?rN1s?_e??‑"???U?????3Q4\Y?_Kh?
<w?i?3?????9??0?

???i???;?"???^p??[1]?!????*O?
?T??]o?>??1m-??f-b???????r??????????)?(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??+???f_Y[g?-??1?_BW??????????L?*;?o^???>??\??v?????????????|???A??????c?h????+????}???K1?3
???????_?y??
??b??????[1]n?^3???Y?G????W?|
~!??k)?N+8?[?g???q??x??(????????????[?n?I????I\ep[‑???@?

z???B?????????w?

??iq??3?_???{i???QEB
(??
???.?????N?[0??D^?S??H'????k???=??OR

?H???m???H??'&?o?p]G??O1.?$`?rN}Y?xu???????

h???Q^??G????????m??I?d??E}QJ
@?>&?????????.??lF_&_M?6?? ?K??A??[???v????????"?zTl^??4V????H<?jE?I, H?_??Pkz?1
???_?3j???7??k?z???_?3j???7??j&\
?????,?_????+??????,?_????)@&iQE?EPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEP_>|y?1x???,??A?V9?b???.????????8?s??|?vG???Z?lTw>w?`?pZ?-??????[1]???????#??I??d%`?]?[?=?_?x??q????Q[|????I?;XA?+5???k?z?G?F?????K??4+ ?2:a_????Tw9J?o??f__?c???n}?????)?????e?K?M?

7?OtL???????c??2??????H???)???Z?k?~=??F??????m1?N???~??T??Gc??g???z??q"????^?_2| ???<s
s?K{?6??????

????HlD?
(?????(??=k?]????????a?8_???^]o??s?{?z??6?"????8?NO?\?c'vj????K?7?

??????ygAi???9?

?]o?/O????~??k?|??????????????E?Y?'?%?????/b?;?EF?T?q?=z??V5H`?[1]LN?T?t?{??]k??5-F??u? OUn? ~u?U????k???{?????iy???‑?_SV?z?j?????f???o?
????????f???o?
???f?????gJ??8?_W????gJ??8?J3J?(?
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
???[??u???o??3??"??@x???^??t??wD?G?!???+&9‑)H???
???W??????t??Xu6??????????5?S????j??[??7?????VR??S???
????vP???????+J?????>????I?+?????c;????u?????Q??????Z??i???M??P???!?=???x-??]]En???4?F}I?
??4?_???w?Mr?K?Re??["?c?}u????F?m????-?????;?????4I??r??r??;*{:?kH?'s'????|=y????????9V??N??]?????}???????#??2????-<gd&????
?)????_?????.???? ?A?s?'?kV??N?<????{?????r?z??kA??=|?z?????M??a???J???h??>???>??I
??2‑??(??bk?|+????1?N?

?~?????Us?rBx???$?$?M????\?m>??c????‑??x?Z‑‑????n??????*??W?F??jz?0i0M5??PB
T?????X????v???-Q?:?????NW??2s??'a8?x?%?$??I5????,?4???y????????k??

??i???????#B???????vS?‑??EV?E{?8?>??q????????????
?)?%?F???8??k???7?_?g?E??k:???????5E??r<R,??WBXut5??5d?|9??????U?;7F?5??}?+Z?g?.??o??m??'?B

????rZ‑?_x??FmW??&???}?_x??FmW??&???9?m}????t?????@??}????t?????@?4???????(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(?Z????6??R?????l}=*????/?9x??{C.@????+??6F?
?p???%e?q??J)r??3??|>??K=????t?????=G?????wE?
:?V*FA??4?3???e??c??<???>??q?P???.???G?6??A/?ls?Z?IQ??????W?i??3s7??Y??W???#???+Z??????
??OnA??????Y@p$???*??U?o?&???Q?4??wH??#?g????u????6???Q????????

F?
??^?Z-?3{??*?W?6???7P?????pz??/
^?=?????
?Q?05?P?av?!?t???^???????p?3_^?d?*???????G*
fg?:??[?]??????????{?>‑?.?/?[G?p?????z???a\??Px/??????k????t?
??k???H?c???8?SZ?R??QE????h?+kv??
?nFC? 63??A[?P
?
???
????Z?‑?>??{?nt?W?YSc?+0#9?MttR??Ws???wS\??;K3??|?$?????v???????????[kx?-a??v?
,h3?0*Z)X.QE0
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??$Q??%?]Ua?j?z>??dzu?????U?(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(?_x??????G5????v????I????{V?p7????????ZT?=??‑??&4iYx?:????h??<?d?g??G)??O

?]epw?o?F??-???Cn??_???|Y?????O!?y?[~7c?q????????u??_????Y???m$?rU?p??Gl??+??\?????#?<@?&|???????a]??z.=???x?K?D?n?5

???x,U??b>T???

??xSQ?k?i??j??Q[??/?E?2T?P?8<?J.=‑??u????h?['????a?d?V???
?????]?????A?Q}J/I=?????HC??-+????z?h^??V1???????‑?oO??m??]?xR]???8?k???H????[F??uo"Nng2<Gs??
?>?wT???xyou??6'??y6??G?_?p
q??N?c????????k:Tw???m?E???cbH8??Z??4?SP?qw????Y?M??ke???]??{????????c???]koi? ?2?[?7?????1?9?KR??M^???,7?ZO?D??]A???q?`??<?I
????_E?]B????2
???NF@c?8?E??????gk-???)wv8
Rk?[?
?<??~?o??[k??}x????S??{? I$I!?.?????????@V?{`ubIo?4??`?r+?j0x?F?b???Z??$?w???????5???x???|g????N???K???p??Z???S?x6???‑?}q5?6RM!g;???O?#~??v=3??+?<.?{Xh?jf?R????‑??s???W^6???e??E???????Gl?????\?????FmF?]^????U?UO=?‑???S?????????T??=j???8?E?sz,B???G???s?_7????E?????[???o?M0e???99>?=ESvW>?????????
J??o,?????2X8?;?o????g?????B?N?y?\9bYpA??pqK?P???/?d???o???Y??)??l??_?????|A??

Y?????0?????Y???|:?|]?k???0Af?L??W8

?‑???
?????????;??d???4??V?

????4??i0Rx?<?Z?????|?g??)H?T????

???^I?V??O?Zf???,:V??C??v0;??K????>
??u???k?8u ?????Q??[C??k?9<)?k?b+t?xY??T???Z?u??R1yF??`9???f?}???}o?????/_L?p??!12??y???j?|_{?Y|;???~?sf??F0?T7??$??K?,{?P?????[??-^?X"gH#??Ga^2|=?Z|H‑????????1??8?9??????‑??H|??)5+???7-??!??|
r>?4??????]??????t???F`al???pkz??S?W??z???\??+??0g?????<E?x{?~???W??k$?Y\??c+??o??`??V?+?.> ??u?Y???=?|s???9?^??W?Y_???}z?nex??S
!1?yQ‑p9??y???G>?t?/??G???o????z?_??
(??X??K??^??

??7??yH?????z
??+??i????4???L:?Q0?)??m6?
~I5{????<;???\?- ??`?&bG?R?g??G0X?z???

>?{???

d???(5?>0???????^??W??(
?[@^i??;???zqY‑???<
?}6?T????Kg??????‑??`??V?.??<#s?

"?{??I
q????=??

???I???+?9?&we??<?xa?

y???/??
?=v??s%??,~v#?i?2?????{?n?????????Ap
?D?d?ws???
?????W??x?|K????s?????4????7?@??0??\?-???^j???<C??K|?p?8????|??}9yq?K+??-??ci6'V????1??e??

??c?O?????k????>??=3Q?]??
??????:???%?????ho?z?|F?&???m2?O!?Gr0??9??5C?~+?4o??U??5???.8??q??:???3?L????=?X??){??d )fe,8?*

~???‑1?F??{5?|??JzL??
????Qp??Z??K??????[A????,J?c?????W????'??gO????Sn??[6? C???*?@??m??h??W??FM???w???g t#??9???Q^?m[R?????!???i?"Yf
?/?9??k?B}V?????Xk7?w
?b??2X8?;??=?????{????:??u=??E?[?2P?>~x??W?????????u?CW?a??d??=
s??G0r???????h?DvK0???ei1?n??z?a^1?{?/<W???b
?$r9

$?5???
(?????xj?T????&?+]gN-?<?Lr+
28????j(??Os?7?t???$

[1]?a4????4?????(>??j:?????/??ZJ???
??nB?
02
}Ew4R??q^???k?k??????k0?&[p?+(e?3?!H?j???x???
?i?z<?tD????????
??????h??s????;?gO??sk‑?iB?r??6?
??????l>#???????G?l??

????v??E
?G?!???????E??<?+??yy???==?Z??Z}?tt??-??Xn???
??????E??i?k???Ew5?z????n???#'?'?^?o
???MmOF????I??Yve[nA??O??}E
?n??x???w???6??{j?<v??tT??d|?I????xR??????????n[1]???‑c3
??????(?\?o??6???t??h??

6??[1]a?*????/
?????‑!?nt???K?????
,99???QE??

kH???{?.?K[?&??Q????5???????h?!???
-?

?D'

i?$?=}+?h???gw??^???‑?????i??NZV?d???j??>???Yc?C<A?K?|??T?
\q???J?? ?8??‑

??e?????
+?5???

?U?x3[????x?E???n?)b?,>\2?`?X?8?A????h???xn?I?|?uA'?OQ?dW?\|.??????????????[t??????'?{?5pN???+U??u??=??]>%[??+;
???????<so????[?a????????z?h??.x??Y?+M*???:????r?a?Co8 ?????‑??z??????v?t?<??yl?T?zd[TP????u????O?u?c?i????n?
~j?$??????CQ'???????Y????o=?`?(d??[1]?????*?9P]?*~x?=??P?Zq?‑O5C??H ???r??E?|=?5
?gK???'??L???[???n??H??T?????????R'??q?
D?0?0?Lc?Z???‑?Zv??
in???cR?L????:f?‑?,<?????7??O
??????????Y??|???;V???MCP?<#y????,??e???x?d??w?Qdg

?58~%j?'???!????qtq($c?????_?????h????Of???o?

?????r?,<???
?a?xR?????H?`T???
?????????kS???|Cuuc??%[?B?{?I?1??????,??????‑ ????,???-qa???r0:`??^?w?im?Xu;?G?Y?xA'?;?y?.~?+????.y??<??'???/.?????T?h??????????t[1]Ke??
?SA,????J???O ‑
?]?Y?
?????????jRAsq~?eh?T?y?o??4?[1]x????N????2y
???2??m#?????(?
?t?.m??h/'[???
$??C??q????&?]??????[%????I
ol9n01??uE?#??
??|}???\[?????G-????????x??????4

j??? ??RB?????????????????V?>?<S?j????????*P??Hw=??.?O???e~????=?[1]U
I?

?I=+?h????w
|m?xr?A??t??????????rI????Wg??/R?<?x?\??l#Q2???s?`?s??sE?.?[1]??????77p?Mf???FO??????oZ????

???w?.???p[|??v?>?=??(?????x

?????l?,F??F??]????'????W?A?????g??y?3?v9?{f???Ap??)???

endstream

endobj

6 0 obj

<</Type/Font/Subtype/TrueType/Name/F1/BaseFont/Times#20New#20Roman/Encoding/WinAnsiEncoding/FontDescriptor 7 0 R/FirstChar 32/LastChar 93/Widths 134 0 R>>

endobj

7 0 obj

<</Type/FontDescriptor/FontName/Times#20New#20Roman/Flags 32/ItalicAngle 0/Ascent 891/Descent -216/CapHeight 693/AvgWidth 401/MaxWidth 2568/FontWeight 400/XHeight 250/Leading…

Stella Property Solutions Pty Ltd v Simmondson was a case before the Supreme Court of Victoria. The dispute involved the interpretation of a contract between Stella Property Solutions Pty Ltd, a property management company, and Simmondson, a property owner. The main issue in the case was whether the contract contained an exclusivity clause that prevented Stella Property Solutions from managing properties of competing property owners.

The court had to determine whether the language used in the contract indicated that Stella Property Solutions had exclusive rights to manage Simmondson's properties. The court found that the contract did not contain an exclusivity clause and that the language used was not sufficient to indicate that Stella Property Solutions had exclusive rights. The court also found that there was no evidence of any other agreement or understanding between the parties that would have established such an exclusivity clause.

The court's decision was based on a careful analysis of the language used in the contract and the surrounding circumstances. The court held that the contract should be interpreted based on the ordinary meaning of the words used, and that there was no evidence to suggest that the parties intended to establish an exclusivity clause. The court also noted that the absence of an exclusivity clause did not necessarily mean that Stella Property Solutions was free to manage properties of competing property owners, as there may be other legal or equitable considerations that could limit their ability to do so.

The final orders of the court were that Stella Property Solutions was not bound by any exclusivity clause in the contract with Simmondson and that Simmondson was entitled to seek management services from other property management companies. The court also noted that the absence of an exclusivity clause did not necessarily mean that Stella Property Solutions was free to manage properties of competing property owners, as there may be other legal or equitable considerations that could limit their ability to do so.

Keep reading for free

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Orders of the court

Background to the litigation

Evidence Before The Court

Reasons for decision

Legal Principle Established