Steel Foundations Limited v Soiltest Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

OFFICIAL NOTICE

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Patent:    No. 708999 in the name of Steel Foundations Limited

Title:    Method of Building Construction

Action: Opposition under s.59 by Soiltest Australia Pty Ltd

Decision:    Issued  .

Abstract

The opponent submitted that the alleged inventor, Mr Paul Anthony Camilleri was not the true inventor of the invention, and that Steel Foundations was not entitled to the grant of the patent.  It was found that the requirement that an applicant must be the actual inventor or their assignee must not be confused with the requirement of novelty.  A person who independently invents a device or method can claim to be the actual inventor, even though another may have made the same invention at an earlier date, provided that the invention was not obtained from that other person or some other source.  With no evidence to the contrary, it was concluded that Mr Camilleri was the actual inventor of the invention, and that Steel Foundations was entitled to the grant of a patent for the invention.

The opponent attacked the invention for being no more than “a mere mathematical scheme” that did not constitute a manner of manufacture.  Though the steps of measuring and comparing are mathematical in nature, it is clear that when the specification was read as a whole, there was a necessary inference confining claim one to the insertion of screw piers into soil to obtain the safe working load (SWL).  It was concluded that the claimed invention belonged to the useful arts as distinct from the fine arts.

The opposition succeeded on the grounds of novelty and inventive step.  Several section 40 defects were also found in the specification.

The application was refused.

PATENTS ACT 1990

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Re:Patent Application No. 708999 by Steel Foundations Limited and opposition under Section 59 of the Patents Act 1990 by Soiltest Australia Pty Ltd.

BACKGROUND

Patent application 708999 in the name of Steel Foundations Limited (hereinafter referred to as Steel Foundations) was filed on 16 December 1996 and derives priority from provisional applications PN7149 (14 December 1995) and PN7150 (14 December 1995).  The patent application was advertised accepted on 19 August 1999.

Soiltest Australia Pty Ltd (hereinafter referred to as Soiltest) filed notice of opposition on 18 November 1999 followed by a Statement of Grounds and Particulars on 17 February 2000. A request to amend the Statement of Grounds and Particulars under regulation 5.9 was filed on 5 May 2000 and was allowed on 1 June 2000.

Soiltest’s evidence in support was completed on 16 May 2000.  Under Regulation 5.8(2), evidence in answer was due on 16 August 2000.  On 15 August 2000, Steel Foundations filed an application for an extension of time of three months till 16 November 2000 in which to serve evidence in answer.  The extension was granted without objection.  On 8 November 2000, Steel Foundations filed a further application for an extension of time of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Steel Foundations Limited v Soiltest Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] APO 37
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The opposition in this matter was brought by Soiltest Australia Pty Ltd against the patent application of Steel Foundations Limited, which claimed a method of building construction. The opponent argued that the invention was not novel, was not a manner of manufacture, and that the specification did not comply with the requirements of the Patents Act 1990. The opposition succeeded on the grounds of novelty and inventive step, with several section 40 defects also found in the specification.

The delegate found that Mr Paul Anthony Camilleri was the actual inventor of the invention, and that Steel Foundations was entitled to the grant of a patent. The invention was considered to be a manner of manufacture as it involved the insertion of screw piers into soil to obtain the safe working load, which belonged to the useful arts. However, the specification was found to be insufficient as it placed an unreasonable demand on the skilled addressee in describing how the results could be obtained. The invention was not novel and lacked an inventive step in light of the prior art considered. The invention defined by claims 3 and 4 was not supported by the description.

Consequently, the application was refused and costs were awarded to the opponent.

Background

Background to the litigation

Steel Foundations Limited (Steel Foundations) filed a patent application for a method of constructing foundation slabs, particularly suitable for domestic dwellings. The method involves measuring the torque required to drive a screw pier into the soil and comparing the measured torque against predetermined data to calculate the safe working load (SWL) of the screw pier in compression or in compression and tension. Soiltest Australia Pty Ltd (Soiltest) opposed the grant of the patent, arguing that the claimed invention is not novel, does not constitute a manner of manufacture, and the specification does not comply with the requirements of the Patents Act 1990.

Patent application 708999 by Steel Foundations was filed on 16 December 1996 and derives priority from provisional applications PN7149 and PN7150 filed on 14 December 1995. Soiltest filed a notice of opposition on 18 November 1999, followed by a Statement of Grounds and Particulars on 17 February 2000. Steel Foundations applied for extensions of time to serve evidence in answer, which were granted. The matter was set down for a hearing on 24 May 2001, but neither party appeared as they intended to rely on their previously submitted material.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Mr Paul Anthony Camilleri is the true inventor of the invention, and whether Steel Foundations is entitled to the grant of the patent.
2. Whether the claimed invention constitutes a manner of manufacture.
3. Whether the specification complies with section 40 of the Patents Act 1990.
4. Whether the claimed invention is novel.
5. Whether the claimed invention involves an inventive step.

Held
1. Mr Paul Anthony Camilleri is the actual inventor of the invention, and Steel Foundations is entitled to the grant of the patent.
2. The claimed invention constitutes a manner of manufacture.
3. The specification does not fully describe the invention and is insufficient under section 40(2)(a) of the Patents Act 1990.
4. The claimed invention is not novel.
5. The claimed invention does not involve an inventive step.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court concluded that Mr Camilleri was the actual inventor of the invention and that Steel Foundations was entitled to the grant of the patent. The court distinguished the requirement that an applicant must be the actual inventor from the requirement of novelty, and found that Mr Camilleri independently invented the method of constructing foundation slabs, and that Steel Foundations was entitled to the grant of a patent. The court held that the claimed invention constituted a manner of manufacture, as it was directed to the insertion of screw piers into soil to obtain the safe working load. The court found that the specification was insufficient under section 40(2)(a) of the Patents Act 1990 as it placed an unreasonable demand on the skilled addressee, and did not adequately describe how the results could be obtained. The court found that the claimed invention was not novel, as it was anticipated by prior art documents, including Conference Paper entitled "Helical Piers in Expansive Soils of Dallas, Texas", Encyclopedia of Anchoring by A.B. Chance Company, Thesis entitled "Compression, Tension and Lateral capacity of Screw-In Foundations", and Seminar Paper entitled "Raft Slabs Incorporating the Screw-in-Foundation System". The court also found that the claimed invention did not involve an inventive step, as it was obvious to a person skilled in the art in light of common general knowledge and prior art documents. The court concluded that the application should be refused, and awarded costs to the opponent.