State Pollution Control Commission v Sydney Harbour Tunnel Company Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION: State Pollution Control Commission v Sydney Harbour Tunnel Company Limited [1989] NSWLEC 197
PARTIES:

APPLICANT
State Pollution Control Commission

RESPONDENT
Sydney Harbour Tunnel Company Limited
FILE NUMBER(S): 50063; 50064; 50065 of 1989
CORAM: Stein J
KEY ISSUES: :-
LEGISLATION CITED: Clean Air Act
Land and Environment Court Act
Noise Control Act
State Pollution Control Commission Act
CASES CITED: R. v. Bellman (1988);
Australian Oil Refining Pty. Ltd. v.Copper (1987 64 LGRA 322);
J. & A. Brown and Abermain Collieries v. Robertson, ((1980) 1 NSWLR 622),
DATES OF HEARING:
DATE OF JUDGMENT:
05/26/1989
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:
APPLICANT
Mr. Street
RESPONDENT
Mr. Bennett


JUDGMENT:

HIS HONOUR: There are two Notices of Motion before the Court in matters Nos. 50063 and 50065 of 1989 being prosecutions under the State Pollution Control Commission Act (section 17D(9)). The first Notice of Motion seeks that the summons be struck out on the basis that each of the summonses are mutually inconsistent, or indeed mutually destructive, (a phrase referred to in some of the authorities), unless there is an election by the Prosecutor upon which summons to proceed.

At the request of the parties I have also agreed to hear two other matters that are relevant to the set of prosecutions brought by the State Pollution Control Commission against the Sydney Harbour Tunnel Company Limited. There is a third summons, issued pursuant to an Order of the Court, (No. 50064 of 1989), under the Noise Control Act alleging a breach of section 26(2) of that Act. It is common ground that each of the three summonses allege an offence arising out of the same set of facts and circumstances on 27 October 1988 at Bradfield Park, Sydney.

The submissions that I am asked to deal with to-day in relation to the Noise Control Act prosecution are firstly, whether or not the Noise Control Act prosecution places the defendant company in double jeopardy because it is also charged with offences arising out of the same incident under the State Pollution Control Commission Act. And secondly, whether or not the summons under the Noise Control Act is bad for duplicity because of the words in the charge "cause or" - and I underline the word, 'or' - "increase" the emission of noise.

It is the submission of Mr. Street of Counsel on behalf of the Prosecutor that while he concedes that charges are mutually inconsistent in relation to the SPCC Act summonses, and there is a need for the Prosecutor to elect upon which to proceed, that election does not need to be made until the close of the prosecution case. In support of this submission he cites an English Court of Appeal decision of R. v. Bellman (1988) 86 Cr App R 40 at 46.

This submission is contested by Mr. Bennett, Counsel for the defendant, who submits that an election needs to be made at an earlier point of time before the hearing commences, otherwise, in his…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read State Pollution Control Commission v Sydney Harbour Tunnel C... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1989] NSWLEC 197
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The State Pollution Control Commission, as the applicant, filed a case against the Sydney Harbour Tunnel Company Limited, as the respondent, in the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales. The case was about the alleged breach of the Clean Air Act, Land and Environment Court Act, Noise Control Act, and State Pollution Control Commission Act by the respondent company. The case was presided over by Stein J and the file numbers were 50063, 50064, and 50065 of 1989. The main legal issues that the court had to decide were whether the summonses were mutually inconsistent, whether the Noise Control Act prosecution placed the defendant in double jeopardy, and whether the summons under the Noise Control Act was bad for duplicity due to the words "cause or increase" the emission of noise.

The court ruled that the summonses could proceed separately to avoid any unfairness or prejudice to the defendant. It held that the summons under the Noise Control Act did not place the defendant in double jeopardy, as the offences charged under the Noise Control Act and the State Pollution Control Commission Act were separate and distinct. The court also ruled that the words "cause or increase" in the Noise Control Act summons did not amount to a duplex situation, and therefore the summons was not bad for duplicity. The court dismissed the notices of motion.

In conclusion, the court ruled that the summonses could proceed separately to avoid any unfairness or prejudice to the defendant. It held that the Noise Control Act prosecution did not place the defendant in double jeopardy, and the summons under the Noise Control Act was not bad for duplicity. The court dismissed the notices of motion, and the case was concluded.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established