FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
State of Western Australia v Ward [2003] FCAFC 124
THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA v BEN WARD & ORS
WAG 6293 OF 1998
CROSSWALK PTY LTD & ANOR v BEN WARD & ORS
WAG 6292 OF 1998
ALLIGATOR AIRWAYS PTY LTD v BEN WARD & ORS
WAG 6294 OF 1998
ARGYLE DIAMOND MINES PTY LTD & ORS v BEN WARD & ORS
WAG 6295 OF 1998
ATTORNEY-GENERAL FOR THE NORTHERN TERRITORY v BEN WARD & ORS
WAG 6296 OF 1998
CECIL NINGAMARRA & ORS v NORTHERN TERRITORY
W 6020 OF 1999
NORTH J
MELBOURNE
3 JUNE 2003
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIAN DISTRICT REGISTRY
On Remitter from the High Court in P59 of 2000; P62 of 2000; P63 of 2000 and P67 of 2000.
No. WG 6293 of 1998
BETWEEN:
THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA & ORS
Appellants
and
BEN WARD, JOHN TOBY, JIMMY WARD, RONNY CARLTON, JEFF JANAMA, BUTTON JONES, BEN BARNEY, DODGER CARLTON, KIM ALDUS, MURPHY SIMON, SHEBA DIGNARI, JOE LISSADELL, CHOCOLATE THOMAS, and PETER NEWRY
ON BEHALF OF THE MIRIUWUNG AND GAJERRONG PEOPLE
First Respondents
and
CECIL NINGARMARA, DOUGLAS BOOMBI, STEPHANIE BOOMBI, ALICE BOOMBI, SANDRA BOOMBI, RITA BOOMBI, HELEN BOOMBI, ROSIE GALLAGHER, DAVID LUAMI, PETER NEWRY, TOM BARNEY, PATRICK BITTANG, BINGLE GUNDARI, CARLTON GEORGE, RODNEY WALMAJA, GREGORY CALWAT, HERBERT ANTHONY, CHARLIE BARNEY, STAN LONG, ASHLEY WILLIAMS, JOCK McDONALD, and DIANNE DINGAL
Second Respondents
and
DELORES CHEINMORA, MATTENMORO (MARTIN CLARK), VERNON GERARD, DUDLEY BAMBRA, ELAINE JOHNSTONE, ERIC JOHNSTONE, CLARA (LEARAY) MITCHELL, MARY TERESA (TAYLOR), MAY SMITH, MONA WILLIAMS, RAYMOND WILLIAMS, JAMES TAYLOR, VICTOR MARTIN, HECTOR UNHANGO, MANUELLA PURWAN, MARY PANDILOW, KENNY MORGAN, JOYCE EVANS, and ROY MARTIN
ON BEHALF OF THE BALANGARRA PEOPLES
Third Respondents
and
COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Intervener
No. WG 6292 of 1998
BETWEEN:
CROSSWALK PTY LTD AND BAINES RIVER CATTLE CO PTY LTD
Appellants
and
BEN WARD, JOHN TOBY, JIMMY WARD, RONNY CARLTON, JEFF JANAMA, BUTTON JONES, BEN BARNEY, DODGER CARLTON, KIM ALDUS, MURPHY SIMON, SHEBA DIGNARI, JOE LISSADELL, CHOCOLATE THOMAS, and PETER NEWRY
ON BEHALF OF THE MIRIUWUNG AND GAJERRONG PEOPLE
First Respondents
and
CECIL NINGARMARA, DOUGLAS BOOMBI, STEPHANIE BOOMBI, ALICE BOOMBI, SANDRA BOOMBI, RITA BOOMBI, HELEN BOOMBI, ROSIE GALLAGHER, DAVID LUAMI, PETER NEWRY, TOM BARNEY, PATRICK BITTANG, BINGLE GUNDARI, CARLTON GEORGE, RODNEY WALMAJA, GREGORY CALWAT, HERBERT ANTHONY, CHARLIE BARNEY, STAN LONG, ASHLEY WILLIAMS, JOCK McDONALD, and DIANNE DINGAL
Second Respondents
No. WG 6294 of 1998
BETWEEN:
ALLIGATOR AIRWAYS PTY LTD, PETER LAURENCE ALVIN, OASIS FARMS, C A & T BRADLEY, W R & A J BROGMUS, J A CARATI, L & M CONLEY, T & E CROOT, C W CURTIS, MAURICE DAVIDSON, DALENE N DAVIES, UTE & HANS DIEDRICKSON, C C & P M DONE, IAN & COLLEEN DUPE, KIMBERLEY NATIVE SEEDS, J ELLETT, B M & J FAIRCLOUGH, STEVE FARQUHAR, JOHN FILE, H G GARDINER T/AS UPSTREAM ORD BANANAS, JEFF GOODING & G HARDING T/AS GOLDEN FRUITS, DOUG G & E M GRANDISON, GUERINONI NOMINEES PTY LTD, NOEL A & AILEEN M HACKETT, ROY & ROSALIE…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read State of Western Australia v Ward and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] FCAFC 124
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The High Court was required to determine whether the claimants' claims were valid under the Native Title Act, and if so, what rights and interests they conferred. The Court had to consider the nature of the claimants' connection to the land, the continuity of their traditional laws and practices, and the extent to which those laws and practices were still in existence. The Court also had to consider whether the claimants' claims were inconsistent with other rights and interests in the land, such as pastoral leases or mining rights.
The Court held that the claimants' claims were valid under the Native Title Act, and that they conferred a range of rights and interests over the land in question. The Court found that the claimants had a strong connection to the land, and that their traditional laws and practices were still in existence. However, the Court also found that some of the claimants' rights and interests were inconsistent with other rights and interests in the land, such as pastoral leases. The Court referred the matter back to the Federal Court for further consideration of the scope and extent of the claimants' rights and interests, and for determination of any inconsistencies with other rights and interests.
The Court made several orders in relation to the proceedings. The appellants were required to file notices identifying the grounds of their appeals, and the respondents were required to file notices identifying any cross-appeals or contentions they wished to pursue. The Court also referred the matter to mediation, with separate mediations to be held in Perth and Darwin. The Registrar was required to report to the Court on the outcome of the mediations by a specified date.
Orders
Orders of the court
DEFINE THE ISSUES
1. Each appellant file and serve by 13 June 2003 a notice identifying the grounds, or amended grounds, of appeal it seeks to pursue on the remitter.
2. Each respondent file and serve by 27 June 2003 a notice identifying any cross-appeal or contention it seeks to pursue on the remitter.
3. Applications for leave to amend a notice of appeal, cross appeal or contention or to file a notice of appeal, cross appeal or contention out of time pursuant to Order 15 Rule (2), Order 21 Rule (3) or Order 22 Rule (1) of the Federal Court Rules, will be heard on 31 July 2003.
REFERRAL TO MEDIATION
4. In so far as it relates to land and waters in Western Australia the matter is referred to mediation by Deputy District Registrar Efthim. The mediation is listed for 5 days commencing on 23 June 2003 and is to take place in Perth.
5. The Registrar is to report to the Court on the outcome of the mediation referred to in Order 4 by 28 July 2003.
NORTHERN TERRITORY
6. In so far as it relates to land and waters in Northern Territory the matter is referred to mediation by Deputy District Registrar Efthim. The mediation is listed for 2 days on 18 and 19 June 2003 and is to take place in Darwin.
7. The Registrar is to report to the Court on the outcome of the mediation referred to in Order 6 by 28 July 2003.