SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
COURT OF APPEAL
No. 3740 of 2005
| STATE OF VICTORIA (DEPARTMENT OF SUSTAINABILITY AND ENVIRONMENT formerly DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES AND ENVIRONMENT) | Appellant |
| v. | |
| DAVID ANDREW RATTRAY | Respondent |
---
JUDGES: | MAXWELL, A.C.J., NETTLE, J.A. and BONGIORNO, A.J.A. | |
WHERE HELD: | MELBOURNE | |
DATE OF HEARING: | 22 June 2006 | |
DATE OF JUDGMENT: | 7 July 2006 | |
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: | [2006] VSCA 145 | |
---
ACCIDENT COMPENSATION - Work-related injury - Worker's application for leave to sue employer at common law - Misconstruction of "capable of earning in suitable employment" - Relevant question is whether suitable jobs exist, not whether jobs are available - Remitted to trial judge - Barwon Spinners Pty Ltd v Podolak & Ors [2005] VSCA 33 applied - Accident Compensation Act 1985 s. 134AB(38)(f).
--
| APPEARANCES: | Counsel | Solicitors |
| For the Appellant | Mr J. Ruskin, Q.C. with Mr P.H. Solomon | Dibbs Abbott Stillman |
| For the Respondent | Mr R.K.J. Meldrum Q.C. with Mr M.J. Waugh | Constable Connor & Co. |
MAXWELL, P.:
I have had the advantage of reading in draft the reasons for judgment of Bongiorno, A.J.A. I agree with his Honour’s conclusions and proposed orders, for the reasons which he gives.
NETTLE, J.A.:
I have had the advantage of reading in draft the reasons for judgment of Bongiorno, A.J.A.
I agree with his Honour for the reasons that he gives that the appeal should be allowed and with the disposition of the appeal that he proposes.
BONGIORNO, A.J.A.:
On 12 December 2000 David Andrew Rattray suffered a partial thickness tear of his right supraspinatus tendon in the course of his employment by the Department of Sustainability and Environment. Mr Rattray was a seasonal firefighter. When he suffered this injury he was assisting another firefighter to remove a fallen tree from a fire access track near Bright in north eastern Victoria. As it was being moved the tree sprang backwards and struck Mr Rattray in the right shoulder.
Mr Rattray claims that the injury to his right shoulder is a serious injury within the meaning of s.134AB of the Accident Compensation Act 1985, such that he is entitled to claim common law damages for the losses he has suffered as a result of it. To this end, by an originating motion filed on 5 July 2004, he sought leave of the County Court pursuant to s.134AB(16)(b) of the Act to institute such a proceeding. The defendant to this originating motion, Mr Rattray's employer, denied both that he had a permanent serious impairment of body function and that he had a 60% loss of earning capacity as required by s.134AB(38) to enable his damages claim to include a component for pecuniary loss.
The County Court proceeding
Mr Rattray's application was tried before a judge of the County Court in May 2005. Her Honour gave judgment on 1 June 2005 upholding the application. She published reasons making it clear that that grant of leave entitled Mr Rattray to bring proceedings for damages generally, including damages for pecuniary loss.
Mr Rattray's injury and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read State of Victoria v Rattray and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] VSCA 145
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal found that the County Court had misconstrued the statutory phrase "capable of earning in suitable employment." The relevant question, according to the Court of Appeal, was whether suitable jobs existed for Mr. Rattray, not whether jobs were available. This misconstruction led the County Court to incorrectly determine Mr. Rattray's loss of earning capacity. The Court of Appeal concluded that the matter should be remitted to the County Court for rehearing, as the necessary facts had not been properly considered.
The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, set aside the orders made by the County Court, and remitted the case for rehearing. The costs in the County Court to date were to be part of the costs of the retrial, while the costs of the appeal were to be paid by Mr. Rattray. The decision was grounded on the statutory interpretation provided in Barwon Spinners Pty Ltd v Podolak & Ors, which emphasized the physical capacity of the claimant over the availability of job vacancies.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter originated in the County Court where Rattray filed an originating motion seeking leave to sue his employer at common law for his work-related injury. The County Court judge found in favour of Rattray and granted his application for leave. The employer appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria. The appeal was heard on 22 June 2006 and the judgment was delivered on 7 July 2006.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the County Court judge erred in her approach to determining Rattray's loss of earning capacity.
2. Whether Rattray met the statutory criteria to claim common law damages for the losses he suffered as a result of his work-related injury.
3. Whether the appeal should be allowed and the matter remitted to the County Court for rehearing.
Held
1. The County Court judge erred in her approach to determining Rattray's loss of earning capacity by considering whether jobs were available rather than whether suitable jobs existed.
2. Rattray did not meet the statutory criteria to claim common law damages for the losses he suffered as a result of his work-related injury because the County Court judge misconstrued the relevant statutory provisions.
3. The appeal was allowed, and the matter was remitted to the County Court for rehearing.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal held that the County Court judge's approach to determining Rattray's loss of earning capacity was incorrect. The Court noted that the relevant question was whether suitable jobs existed, not whether jobs were available. This was based on the Court's interpretation of the definition of "suitable employment" in the Accident Compensation Act 1985, which required the existence of a job within the worker's capacity regardless of its availability. The Court applied the reasoning from Barwon Spinners Pty Ltd v Podolak & Ors [2005] VSCA 33, which held that the Act was concerned with the physical consequence of injury and not its economic effect. The Court held that the County Court judge's consideration of job availability was irrelevant to the determination of Rattray's loss of earning capacity. Consequently, Rattray did not meet the statutory criteria to claim common law damages because the County Court judge's misconstruction of the statutory provisions led to an incorrect determination of his loss of earning capacity. The Court allowed the appeal and remitted the matter to the County Court for rehearing to ensure that the correct approach was taken in determining Rattray's loss of earning capacity.