State of Victoria v Horvath

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
COURT OF APPEAL

No. 5310-5313 of 2001

STATE OF VICTORIA

v.

CORINNA HORVATH & ORS

---

JUDGES:

WINNEKE, P., CHERNOV and VINCENT, JJ.A.

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING:

19-22 August 2002

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

7 November 2002

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2002] VSCA 177

---

DAMAGES – Police raid resulting in assault and other torts by police – Joint and several tortfeasors – Whether negligence in planning and execution of raid was causative of damages resulting from intentional torts committed by police during raid – Inconsistent findings that police acted in contumelious disregard of victims’ rights and that police acted necessarily or reasonably in the course of duty – Whether the circumstances admit the award of exemplary damages – Whether police members relieved of liability for intentional torts under s.123(1) of the Police Regulation Act 1958 – Whether such liability attached to the State under s.123(2) of the said Act – Whether exemplary damages awards against police can attach to the State under s.123 of the said Act - Purpose and scope of operation of s.123 of the Police Regulation Act 1958.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Appellant Mr. S.W. Kaye Q.C.
with Mr. P.G. Golombek
Victorian Government Solicitor
For the 1st Respondent Mr. M.A. Dreyfus Q.C.
with Mr. M.G.R. Gronow
Nowicki Carbone & Co.
For the 2nd Respondent  Mr. M.F. Wheelahan Kenna Croxford & Co.
For the 3rd, 4th and 5th Respondents Mr. O.P. Holdenson Q.C.
with Mr. A.N. Murdoch
Kenna Croxford & Co.

WINNEKE, P.
CHERNOV, J.A.
VINCENT, J.A.:

  1. The appeals and cross-appeals in these proceedings arise out of the decision of a judge of the County Court made on 23 February 2001 whereby he awarded in favour of the plaintiffs damages, including aggravated and exemplary damages, against four policemen who were the first four defendants below, variously for negligence, intentional torts and malicious prosecutions. The learned judge ordered that some of these damages should be transferred to the State of Victoria ("the State"), which was the fifth defendant below, pursuant to s.123 of the Police Regulation Act 1958 (“the Act”). The circumstances which gave rise to the proceedings are helpfully summarised in his Honour’s reasons for judgment and it is only necessary to re-state such of them as are relevant for present purposes.

Background

  1. On Friday, 8 March 1996, between approximately 9 and 10 p.m., Corinna Horvath ("Horvath")[1], who was then aged 21, drove her Torana motor car, in which her 25 year-old partner, Craig Love ("Love")[2], was a passenger, into a service station at Hastings.  A police car, which was occupied by Constables David Laurence Jenkin (“Jenkin”) and Stephen Davison (“Davison”)[3], came up behind them.  It is convenient to mention briefly at this stage some of the relevant background concerning Horvath and Love.  The learned trial judge found that, at the time in question, both had extensive prior involvement with the local police and that both had a number of prior convictions for various offences, including, in the case of Horvath,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read State of Victoria v Horvath and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] VSCA 177
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of State of Victoria versus Horvath was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The dispute involved a police raid that resulted in the plaintiff suffering from assault and other torts committed by the police. The case focused on whether the State of Victoria, through its police officers, could be held liable for the torts committed during the raid, and whether exemplary damages could be awarded.

The court had to determine several legal issues, including whether the negligence in planning and executing the raid caused the damages resulting from the intentional torts committed by the police. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the circumstances justified the award of exemplary damages. The court also had to determine whether the police members were relieved of liability for the intentional torts under section 123(1) of the Police Regulation Act 1958 and whether such liability attached to the State under section 123(2) of the said Act. Finally, the court had to decide whether exemplary damages awards against the police could attach to the State under section 123 of the Police Regulation Act 1958.

The court found that the police acted in contumelious disregard of the victims' rights, and that their actions were not necessary or reasonable in the course of duty. The court held that the circumstances admitted the award of exemplary damages. However, the court held that the police members were relieved of liability for the intentional torts under section 123(1) of the Police Regulation Act 1958. The court also held that such liability did not attach to the State under section 123(2) of the said Act. Finally, the court held that exemplary damages awards against the police could not attach to the State under section 123 of the Police Regulation Act 1958.

The court ordered that the State of Victoria pay damages to the plaintiff for the torts committed during the raid. However, the court held that the State could not be held liable for exemplary damages. The court also held that the police members could not be held liable for the intentional torts committed during the raid.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established