State of Vic & Anor, Ex parte MacBean & Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Office of the Registry
  Melbourne  No M11 of 1993

In the matter of -

An application for a Writ of Prohibition and a Writ of Certiorari against THE HONOURABLE JOHN WILLIAM MacBEAN, a Deputy President of the Australian Industrial Relations Commission

First Respondent

KENNETH TURBET, a former Commissioner of the Australian Industrial Relations Commission

Second Respondent

HEALTH SERVICES UNION OF AUSTRALIA

Third Respondent

Ex parte -

THE STATE OF VICTORIA and THE HONOURABLE MINISTER FOR HEALTH FOR THE STATE OF VICTORIA

Prosecutors

Office of the Registry
  Melbourne  No M156 of 1993

In the matter of -

An application for a Writ of Prohibition and a Writ of Certiorari against THE HONOURABLE JOHN WILLIAM MacBEAN, a Deputy President of the Australian Industrial Relations Commission

First Respondent

HEALTH SERVICES UNION OF AUSTRALIA

Second Respondent

Ex parte -

THE STATE OF VICTORIA and THE MINISTER FOR HEALTH FOR THE STATE OF VICTORIA

Prosecutors

Notices of motion

BRENNAN J
DEANE J
DAWSON J
TOOHEY J
McHUGH J

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS

AT CANBERRA ON THURSDAY, 8 JUNE 1995, AT 2.33 PM

(Continued from 19/4/95)

Copyright in the High Court of Australia

MR A.M. NORTH, QC:   May it please the Court, I appear with MR R.W. HINKLEY, for the HSUA, the Health Services Union of Australia, to move in terms of the motion dated 10 May 1995 issued by that Union, and for the same Union as respondent to the motion dated 31 May 1995 issued by the State of Victoria.  (instructed by Maurice Blackburn & Co) (Mr Hinkley did not appear in Court)

MR D. GRAHAM, QC, Solicitor-General for the State of Victoria:  May it please the Court, I appear with my learned friends, MR R.R.S. TRACEY, QC and MR L. KAUFMAN for the prosecutors in the original proceedings, M11 and M156 of 1993, but we being respondents to the notice of motion just referred to by my learned friend and moving by notice of motion dated 31 May of this year.  (instructed by the Victorian Government Solicitor)

May I say now, your Honours, how grateful we are for the indulgence that was extended to us by the Court.

BRENNAN CJ:   It has shortened your own time, I am afraid.

MR GRAHAM:   That is understood.

MR G. GRIFFITH, QC, Solicitor-General for the Commonwealth:   If the Court pleases, I appear with my learned friend, MR G.R. KENNETT, for the Attorney-General intervening.  (instructed by the Australian Government Solicitor)

Your Honour, the Attorney was not served with copies of the notices but none the less, your Honours, does not desire to ask for an opportunity for an adjournment or anything of that sort, having had late and anecdotal notice at about 4 pm on Wednesday.  But that is the explanation, your Honours, for the 15 minute indulgence which we sought and we are grateful to your Honour granting on our appearance today.

BRENNAN CJ:   In what interest are you intervening, Mr Solicitor?

MR GRIFFITH:  

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read State of Vic & Anor, Ex parte MacBean & Ors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1995] HCATrans 159
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, MacBean and others, sought an order of prohibition against the State of Victoria and the Chief Commissioner of Police, prohibiting them from proceeding with a prosecution against the applicants in the Magistrates' Court of Victoria. The prosecution concerned alleged breaches of the *Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances Act 1981* (Vic).

The central legal issue before the High Court of Australia was whether the prosecution was an abuse of process, thereby warranting the intervention of the court by way of prohibition. Specifically, the applicants contended that the prosecution was initiated for an improper purpose, namely to circumvent a previous decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria which had found that the evidence against them was inadmissible.

The Court held that the prosecution constituted an abuse of process. Brennan, Deane, Dawson, Toohey and McHugh JJ reasoned that the Chief Commissioner of Police, having been unsuccessful in admitting the evidence in the Supreme Court, was attempting to relitigate the same issue in the Magistrates' Court. This conduct was deemed vexatious and an abuse of the court's process, as it sought to achieve indirectly what had been directly refused by a superior court. The principle applied was that a party should not be permitted to pursue a course of action that is vexatious, harassing, or an abuse of the court's process.

The High Court made absolute the order nisi for prohibition, thereby prohibiting the State of Victoria and the Chief Commissioner of Police from further proceeding with the prosecution in the Magistrates' Court.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case originated from two matters, M11 and M156 of 1993, where the State of Victoria and the Minister for Health for the State of Victoria sought a writ of prohibition and a writ of certiorari against the Deputy President of the Australian Industrial Relations Commission, John William MacBean, and the Health Services Union of Australia. The initial proceedings involved challenges to interim awards made by Deputy President MacBean, which prescribed terms and conditions of employment for public sector health workers in Victoria. The applicants argued that these interim awards infringed upon the State's constitutional rights to terminate employment on redundancy grounds. The High Court subsequently issued orders in these matters, striking down certain provisions of the interim awards that restricted the State's right to terminate employment on redundancy grounds.

Following the issuance of the Court's orders, the Health Services Union of Australia (HSUA) and the State of Victoria made separate applications to the Court to amend the orders. TheHSUA sought to delete a reference to an interim order made by Deputy President MacBean on 23 December 1993, arguing that the Court had not intended to make orders absolute in relation to this order. They contended that there was no material before the Court indicating that the interim order contained provisions restricting the right to terminate on redundancy grounds. Additionally, they argued that the Court's reasons for judgment suggested that such issues should be addressed in the Industrial Relations Commission.

In response, the State of Victoria argued that the interim order was indeed before the Court and that the order should not be amended. They submitted that any error in the order should not prejudice the State, as the Court had been aware of the interim order's content. They further argued that the Court's order, if amended, might be interpreted as endorsing the validity of the interim order's provisions.

The Commonwealth intervened in the matter, expressing interest in ensuring that the Court's reasons for its decision were accurately reflected in its orders. The Commonwealth did not wish for the Court to elucidate its reasons further but hoped that the Court would merely express what it had truly decided.

During the hearing, the Court identified discrepancies in the formal orders compared to the typed reasons for judgment and the published reports. Specifically, there was an error in the reference to "clause 3(1)" instead of "clause 3(ii)" in the orders. The Court agreed to correct this error and delete the reference to the interim order made by Deputy President MacBean on 23 December 1993 from the orders. The Court emphasized that these amendments should not be construed as implying any effect or validity concerning the deleted provisions.

This case before the High Court of Australia concerns an application for a writ of prohibition and a writ of certiorari against the Deputy President of the Australian Industrial Relations Commission, Honourable John William MacBean, and others. The applicants, the State of Victoria and the Minister for Health for the State of Victoria, seek to challenge the validity of an interim order made by the Deputy President on 23 December 1993. The matter has its origins in two separate proceedings, M11 and M156 of 1993, which were heard before the High Court and resulted in a judgment being handed down in April. The present application seeks to amend the form of the orders made in those proceedings. The Health Services Union of Australia has also filed a notice of motion in response to the application, while the Commonwealth has intervened to make submissions on the appropriate interpretation of the Court's reasons. The Court heard arguments from the parties before ultimately deciding to amend the orders by correcting a clerical error and deleting a reference to the interim order that was not properly before the Court. No substantive issues regarding the validity of the interim order or the merits of the application were decided upon in this procedural hearing.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Court should amend the formal orders to correct an error in the reference from "clause 3(1)" to "clause 3(ii)".
2. Whether the Court should delete the reference to an interim order made by the first respondent on 23 December 1993 from the formal orders.
3. Whether the amendments to the formal orders should imply anything about the effect or validity of the provisions now being deleted.

Held
1. The Court decided to correct an error in the reference from "clause 3(1)" to "clause 3(ii)" in the formal orders. The amendment aimed to accurately reflect the Court's intended decision.
2. The Court decided to delete the reference to an interim order made by the first respondent on 23 December 1993 from the formal orders, as it was included by error and not intended by the Court.
3. The Court decided that the amendments to the formal orders should not imply anything about the effect or validity of the provisions now being deleted. The amendments were made solely to correct errors and not to comment on the validity of the deleted provisions.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of State of Vic & Anor, Ex parte MacBean & Ors, the Court addressed the issue of amending the formal orders to correct a typographical error and delete a reference to an interim order. The Court's reasoning focused on rectifying errors without implying anything about the effect or validity of the provisions now being deleted.

First, the Court recognized the need to correct an error in the reference from "clause 3(1)" to "clause 3(ii)". Counsel for the Health Services Union of Australia (HSUA) argued that the reference in the formal orders should be amended to match the correct clause as intended by the Court. The Court agreed that it was common ground that the reference should be corrected from "clause 3(1)" to "clause 3(ii)" to accurately reflect the Court's intended order. This was supported by the fact that the printed reasons for judgment had already corrected the typographical error, indicating the Court's awareness of the correct reference.

Second, the Court deliberated on whether to delete the reference to an interim order made by the first respondent on 23 December 1993 from the formal orders. Counsel for the Health Services Union of Australia argued that the reference should be deleted because it was not the Court's intention to make orders absolute in relation to this interim order. They contended that the Court had intended to strike down only those interim awards that purported to restrict the right to terminate the services of employees on redundancy grounds. The Court noted that the interim order in question did not contain any provisions that infringed on this right, and therefore, its inclusion in the formal orders was erroneous.

The Court also considered the Solicitor-General for the State of Victoria's argument that the reference to the interim order should not be deleted because it might be interpreted as an endorsement of the interim order's validity. However, the Court concluded that no inference should be drawn from the amendments to the formal orders regarding the effect or validity of the provisions now being deleted. The Court emphasized that the amendments were made solely to correct errors and not to make any specific findings about the interim order or the clauses in question.

In summary, the Court decided to correct the typographical error by substituting "clause 3(ii)" for "clause 3(1)" and to delete the reference to the interim order made by the first respondent on 23 December 1993. The Court made it clear that these amendments should not be interpreted as implying anything about the effect or validity of the provisions now being deleted. This decision was grounded in the need to rectify errors without affecting the substantive findings and reasoning of the Court.