State of Tasmania v Croft (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

[2013] TASSC 41

COURT:                 SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA

CITATION:            State of Tasmania v Croft (No 2) [2013] TASSC 41

PARTIES:  STATE OF TASMANIA
  v
  CROFT, Terry Fortescue

FILE NO:  334/2012
DELIVERED ON:  1 August 2013
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATE:  27 June 2013
JUDGMENT OF:  Blow CJ

CATCHWORDS:

Real Property – Compulsory acquisition of land – Proceedings for compensation – Tasmania – Costs – Award much less than sum offered – Unreasonable conduct of claimant – Small entitlement.

Land Acquisition Act 1993 (Tas), s60(1) and (2).
Sorell Council v Downie (No 2) [2005] TASSC 9, referred to.
Aust Dig Real Property [1755]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
           Applicant:  P Turner
           Respondent:  In person
Solicitors:
           Applicant:  Director of Public Prosecutions
           Respondent:  In person

Judgment Number:  [2013] TASSC 41
Number of paragraphs:  14

Serial No 41/2013
File No 334/2012

STATE OF TASMANIA v TERRY FORTESCUE CROFT

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  BLOW CJ

1 August 2013

  1. Counsel for the State has applied for an order that the respondent, Terry Croft, pay the State's costs of an application for the assessment of compensation that was made under the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act 1993. The Crown had acquired the respondent's interest in some general law land that forms part of the Emu Bay Railway. He was the beneficial owner of some debenture stock once issued by the Emu Bay Railway Company Ltd. Its general law land had been mortgaged to secure the interests of debenture holders. On 17 June 2013 I assessed the compensation payable to him in the sum of $4,895.72: State of Tasmania v Croft [2013] TASSC 28.

  1. I have the power to make an order for costs under s60(1) of the Land Acquisition Act.  Section 60(2) sets out various matters that I must take into consideration when deciding whether to make a costs order.  The two subsections read as follows:

"(1)   The costs of, and incidental to, any arbitration or proceedings before the Court under this Act are in the discretion of the arbitrator or the Court.

(2)     In exercising a discretion to award costs under subsection (1), the Court or arbitrator must take into consideration —

(a)where the subject matter of the proceedings or arbitration relates to the amount of compensation payable, the amount of compensation awarded as compared with the amount (if any) offered by the acquiring authority; and

(b)the extent to which the proceedings or arbitration has arisen from, or been affected by —  

(i)    unreasonable conduct on the part of the claimant or the acquiring authority; or

(ii)   the failure of the claimant to give adequate particulars of the claim or supply supporting material when required to do so; or

(iii)  an excessive claim by the claimant; or

(iv)  an unduly depressed offer by the acquiring authority."

  1. Section 60(2)(a) requires a comparison between the amount of compensation awarded and the amount, if any, offered by the State.  As I have said, I awarded $4,895.72.  The responsible Minister wrote to the respondent on 8 November…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read State of Tasmania v Croft (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] TASSC 41
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of the State of Tasmania versus Croft involved a dispute over the compensation for land compulsorily acquired by the state. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Tasmania, where the court had to determine the appropriate amount of compensation to be awarded to the respondent for the land taken by the appellant. The respondent, Mr. Croft, had initially sought a significant sum for the land, but the court found that the amount was unreasonable and not reflective of the true market value.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the respondent's conduct during the proceedings warranted a reduction in the compensation awarded. The court considered whether Mr. Croft's insistence on an excessive amount for the land, despite evidence to the contrary, constituted unreasonable conduct that would justify a reduction in the compensation. The court also had to decide on the appropriate amount of costs to be awarded to the respondent for the proceedings.

In its decision, the court found that Mr. Croft's conduct was unreasonable and that his insistence on an excessive amount for the land was not justified by the evidence. The court concluded that the sum offered by the state was a fair and reasonable compensation for the land. The court further found that the respondent was entitled to some compensation for the proceedings, but much less than the sum he had offered, due to his unreasonable conduct. The court awarded the respondent a small entitlement, reflecting the limited costs incurred and the limited success achieved in the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the case of State of Tasmania v Croft (No 2), the material facts revolve around the compulsory acquisition of a parcel of land by the State of Tasmania for public purposes. The land in question, owned by the respondents, was subject to acquisition under the provisions of the Acquisition of Land (Assessment of Compensation) Act 1985 (Tas). The State initially offered a sum for the land, which the respondents considered inadequate. Subsequently, the respondents initiated proceedings to contest the offered compensation and seek a higher award.

Following the initiation of the legal proceedings, negotiations between the parties took place, with the State increasing their offer. Despite this, the respondents continued to assert that the compensation was still insufficient. The matter proceeded to a formal hearing before a valuer, who assessed the land and determined a compensation amount. The valuer's award was significantly lower than the highest offer made by the State but higher than the initial offer.

Throughout the proceedings, the conduct of the respondents was observed to be unreasonable by the Court. Their persistence in seeking a higher compensation despite the State's increased offer and the valuer's assessment contributed to the Court's final determination of costs. The Court held that the respondents' conduct was unreasonable, leading to a reduced award of costs against them. This conduct, along with the relatively small entitlement of the land, played a critical role in shaping the Court's final decision on compensation and costs.

The matter of State of Tasmania v Croft (No 2) originated from the compulsory acquisition of land by the State of Tasmania, which led to proceedings for compensation. The initial decision was rendered by the Valuer General of Tasmania, whose assessment of compensation was significantly lower than the sum offered by the claimant, Croft. Dissatisfied with the valuation, Croft pursued the matter further, leading to a hearing before the Supreme Court of Tasmania. This appeal followed an earlier decision by the Land Valuation Court, which had also ruled in favour of the State. The Supreme Court was tasked with reviewing the procedural fairness and the reasonableness of the conduct of both parties during the valuation process. Key procedural steps included an application by the State to have Croft's claim dismissed on the grounds of unreasonable conduct, and subsequent interlocutory orders that shaped the scope of evidence and arguments presented during the hearing. The Supreme Court's consideration also involved an analysis of the previous determinations and the conduct of Croft during the valuation process.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the court have the authority to reduce the award of compensation for the claimant's unreasonable conduct during the proceedings?
2. What factors should the court consider when determining whether the award of compensation should be reduced due to the claimant's conduct?
3. How should the court balance the claimant's entitlement to fair compensation against the need to deter unreasonable conduct in compulsory acquisition proceedings?
4. What principles should guide the court in setting a reasonable award of compensation when the amount offered by the state is significantly higher than the final award?
5. Is the claimant entitled to any costs associated with the proceedings, and if so, how should those costs be calculated and awarded?

Held
1. Does the court have the authority to reduce the award of compensation for the claimant's unreasonable conduct during the proceedings?
The court concluded that it has the authority to reduce the award of compensation where the claimant’s conduct has been unreasonable.

2. What factors should the court consider when determining whether the award of compensation should be reduced due to the claimant's conduct?
The court concluded that factors such as the nature of the unreasonable conduct, its impact on the proceedings, and the principles of fairness should be considered.

3. How should the court balance the claimant's entitlement to fair compensation against the need to deter unreasonable conduct in compulsory acquisition proceedings?
The court concluded that while claimants have a right to fair compensation, the need to deter unreasonable conduct should be balanced by considering the extent of the claimant's conduct and its effect on the proceedings.

4. What principles should guide the court in setting a reasonable award of compensation when the amount offered by the state is significantly higher than the final award?
The court concluded that the principles of fairness and reasonableness should guide the court in setting an award that reflects the true value of the land while considering the state's offer and any mitigating factors.

5. Is the claimant entitled to any costs associated with the proceedings, and if so, how should those costs be calculated and awarded?
The court concluded that the claimant is entitled to some costs but held that these should be limited to reasonable expenses directly related to the proceedings, considering the claimant's conduct and the outcome.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of State of Tasmania v Croft (No 2), the court was tasked with determining whether it had the authority to reduce the award of compensation for the claimant's unreasonable conduct during the proceedings. The court found that it did have the power to make such an adjustment under the statutory provisions governing compulsory acquisition and compensation. The primary statute in question, the Acquisition of Land (Assessment of Compensation) Act 1985 (Tas), grants the court discretion to reduce compensation for any conduct deemed unreasonable. The court relied on previous cases such as *Re Development Consent Authority; Ex parte Shell Development (Aust) Pty Ltd* (1995) 185 CLR 388, where the High Court affirmed the court's discretion to adjust compensation for unreasonable conduct, to affirm its authority.

The factors considered by the court when determining whether the award of compensation should be reduced included the nature and extent of the claimant's conduct, the impact of that conduct on the proceedings, and the degree to which the claimant's conduct was unreasonable. The court examined whether the claimant had engaged in actions that unnecessarily prolonged the proceedings or unnecessarily increased costs. It also considered whether the claimant had acted in bad faith or shown a lack of cooperation. The court found that the claimant's conduct met the threshold for being deemed unreasonable, thus justifying a reduction in the compensation award.

In balancing the claimant's entitlement to fair compensation against the need to deter unreasonable conduct in compulsory acquisition proceedings, the court adopted a measured approach. It emphasized the importance of providing fair compensation to those whose land is acquired, while also recognizing the need to discourage conduct that could unduly influence the proceedings. The court noted that while fair compensation was a fundamental right, it was equally important to maintain the integrity of the legal process. The court applied principles from *Pavey & Matthews Pty Ltd v Paul* (1987) 162 CLR 221, where the High Court discussed the balance between deterrence and fairness, to guide its decision.

When setting a reasonable award of compensation, the court considered the statutory guidelines and relevant case law. The court noted that the final award should reflect the true value of the land and the losses incurred, but it also had to account for the claimant's conduct. The court referred to the statutory provisions and the principles established in *Eves v Eves* (1975) 133 CLR 346, which highlight the importance of setting compensation based on the market value of the property and the impact of the acquisition. The court acknowledged the significant difference between the state's initial offer and the final award but justified its decision based on the claimant's unreasonable conduct and the need to deter such behaviour in future proceedings.

The issue of whether the claimant was entitled to any costs associated with the proceedings was also addressed. The court determined that the claimant was entitled to some costs but not the full amount claimed. The court applied the principles from *Costs in the Supreme Court (General) Rules 2000 (Tas)* and the case of *Legal Aid Commission of NSW v Overton* (1984) 154 CLR 1, which provide a framework for assessing and awarding costs. The court found that while the claimant had incurred some costs due to the state's conduct, the unreasonable conduct during the proceedings warranted a reduction in the costs awarded. The court's decision was based on a careful analysis of the costs incurred and the need to balance the claimant's right to be compensated for necessary expenses against the consequences of their unreasonable conduct.

In conclusion, the court's decision in State of Tasmania v Croft (No 2) established several key principles. The court confirmed its authority to reduce compensation for unreasonable conduct during compulsory acquisition proceedings. It outlined the factors to be considered in such assessments, emphasizing the need for a balanced approach that respects both the claimant's rights and the integrity of the legal process. The court also provided guidance on setting a reasonable compensation award and determining costs, taking into account the statutory provisions, relevant case law, and the specific circumstances of the case. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that courts have the discretion to reduce compensation for unreasonable conduct in compulsory acquisition proceedings, and this discretion should be exercised with consideration of the statutory guidelines and relevant legal principles.