State of Queensland v Nolan

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: State of Qld v Alyssa Nolan & Anor [2001] QSC 174
PARTIES:

STATE OF QUEENSLAND
(applicant)

ALYSSA GRACE NOLAN (an infant, by her Litigation Guardian, SHAUN NOLAN)
(first respondent)
BETHANY ROSE NOLAN (an infant, by her Litigation Guardian, SHAUN NOLAN)

(second respondent)

FILE NO:   SC No 47602 of 2001
DIVISION: Trial Division
DELIVERED ON: 31 May 2001
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARING DATE: 25 May 2001
JUDGE: Chesterman J
ORDERS:

1.   I declare that an operation to separate the conjoined twins Alyssa Grace Nolan and Bethany Rose Nolan may be lawfully carried out in an attempt to save the life of Alyssa Grace Nolan.

2.   I order that Alyssa Grace Nolan and Bethany Rose Nolan be permitted to undergo, and the applicant’s servants and agents be permitted to perform surgery to effect the physical separation of the children.

3.   No orders to costs.

4.   Time for bringing the application be abridged.

CATCHWORDS:

CHILDREN – court’s inherent jurisdiction – medical treatment – conjoined twins – weaker twin surviving only through stronger twin’s blood supply – separation required to prevent the death of both but certain to cause death of weaker twin – parents giving consent – whether operation to separate lawful – whether in bests interests of each twin

Criminal Code 1901 (Qld) s 25, s 282, s 286

Fountain v Alexander (1982) 150 CLR 615, cited
Marion’s Case (1991–1992) 175 CLR 218, cited
R v Gyngall [1893] 2 QB 232, followed

Re A (Children) (Conjoined Twins: Surgical Seperation) [2001] 2 WLR 480, followed

COUNSEL: Mr D K Boddice for the applicant
No appearance for the respondents
SOLICITORS: Tress Cocks & Maddox for the applicant
No appearance for the respondents
  1. CHESTERMAN J:  Alyssa Grace Nolan and Bethany Rose Nolan were born on 3 May 2001 by caesarean section at the Royal Womens Hospital.  They are conjoined craniopagus twin girls.  The condition is extremely rare.  Of all conjoined twins those joined at the head account for only 2 – 6%.  Surgery to separate such twins is extremely complicated and the survival rate for even one of the twins is not high.  The first occasion on which the operation was successfully performed was 1953 when one of a set of twins was saved.

  1. Alyssa has only one kidney.  Bethany has no kidneys and no bladder.  As well she has a condition commonly referred to as club foot which is sometimes an indication of underlying brain damage.  Though joined at the head the girls have separate brains though they share the cranial draining veins (“venous draining sinuses”).  They thus share blood flow.  This has enabled Bethany to survive, Alyssa’s one kidney removing waste from the bloodstream of both girls.

  1. In the days prior to 25 May 2001  Bethany developed increasing hypertension from a cause which could not be ascertained.  Her high blood pressure proved resistant to drug therapy and she developed hypertrophy in the left ventricle of the heart.  A difficulty in treating Bethany’s hypertension is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read State of Queensland v Nolan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] QSC 174
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of the State of Queensland versus Nolan, the dispute centred on the medical treatment of conjoined twins, Alyssa Grace Nolan and Bethany Rose Nolan, and whether an operation to separate them was lawful and in their best interests. The matter was heard in the Queensland Supreme Court, which was tasked with determining the legality and ethical implications of the proposed surgery. The parents of the twins had given their consent to the operation, which was deemed necessary to prevent the death of both children but would certainly result in the death of the weaker twin, Alyssa Grace. The court was required to decide whether the operation could be lawfully carried out and if it aligned with the best interests of each twin.

The legal issues at the heart of this case revolved around the court's inherent jurisdiction over children, the ethical considerations surrounding the separation of conjoined twins, and the parents' rights to consent to medical procedures for their children. The court needed to balance the right to life of both children against the certainty of the death of one twin if the operation proceeded. The central question was whether the operation to separate the twins could be considered lawful and in their best interests, given the unique circumstances of their conjoined status and the life-threatening situation.

The court found that the operation to separate the twins could be lawfully carried out, as it was in the best interests of both children. The court recognised the inherent jurisdiction it held over children and the need to act in their best interests. It was determined that separating the twins was necessary to prevent the death of both, even though it would result in the death of Alyssa Grace. The court acknowledged the parents' consent and the ethical considerations surrounding the case, ultimately concluding that the operation was lawful and in the best interests of the twins as a whole. The court granted the orders sought by the State of Queensland, allowing the separation surgery to proceed and permitting the parents, medical professionals, and the applicant's servants and agents to carry out the necessary procedures.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. I declare that an operation to separate the conjoined twins Alyssa Grace Nolan and Bethany Rose Nolan may be lawfully carried out in an attempt to save the life of Alyssa Grace Nolan.

2. I order that Alyssa Grace Nolan and Bethany Rose Nolan be permitted to undergo, and the applicant’s servants and agents be permitted to perform surgery to effect the physical separation of the children.

3. No orders to costs.

4. Time for bringing the application be abridged.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established