State of Queensland v Fraser

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

CITATION: State of Queensland & Ors v Fraser [2025] QCATA 39
PARTIES:

STATE OF QUEENSLAND (QUEENSLAND POLICE SERVICE)

(first applicant/appellant)

JORGIA GRAY

(second applicant/appellant)

SCOTT MITCHELL

(third applicant/appellant)

v

JENNIFER FRASER

(respondent)

APPLICATIONNO/S: APL039-24, APL055-24
ORIGINATING APPLICATIONNO/S: ADL021-23, ADL059-23
MATTERTYPE: Appeals
DELIVEREDON: 9 May 2025
HEARINGDATE: 11 February 2025
HEARDAT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Judicial Member Rinaudo AM
ORDERS:

IT IS THE DECISION OF THE APPEAL TRIBUNAL THAT:

    The application for leave to appeal granted.     The appeal is dismissed.

    The original decision of the Tribunal made on 22 January 2024 is affirmed but for the reasons set out.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – RIGHT OF APPEAL – WHEN APPEAL LIES – ERROR OF LAW – WHAT IS – GENERALLY –

whether leave to appeal should be granted – where the self- represented respondent makes submissions introducing fresh evidence at the hearing in circumstances where no application for its admission is made – where the Appeal Tribunal finds the authorities relied on at first instance did not support the original decision – whether more weight ought to be given to the events transpiring after the notice

was initially emailed – where the Appeal Tribunal reaches the same decision as that at first instance but for different reasons – whether the appeal should be dismissed

Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld)

Human Rights Act 2019 (Qld)
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009

(Qld)

Fraser v State of Queensland & Ors [2024] QCAT 57 Garcia v Queensland Newspapers Pty Ltd and Prain [2003] QADT 4

Goodwin v Gillespie [1998] QSC 138; [2000] 1 Qd R 517 Kelly v Harris, Madigan, Head and Qantas Airways Pty Ltd [2002] QADT 9

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:
Firstandsecond appellants: Blair Hall instructed by the QPS Legal Services and Ms Gray
Thirdappellant: Matt Black instructed by Gnech and Associates
Respondent: Self-represented

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. This is an appeal against a decision made by a Senior Member of this Tribunal on 22 January 2024 (‘review decision’).

  2. The appellants lodged appeals APL039-24 and APL055-24. The appeals were consolidated and were heard together. For the purposes of this appeal, it is not necessary to refer to the appellants individually. Therefore, in this decision, the appellants collectively will be referred to as the ‘appellants’.

  3. Dr Jennifer Fraser who is the complainant, will be referred to as the ‘respondent’.

Short history

  1. The respondent made a Queensland Human Rights Commission (‘QHRC’) complaint about direct discrimination alleged to have occurred on 14 January 2021, on the grounds of race and alleged breaches of section 59 of the Human Rights Act 2019 (Qld) (‘HR Act’).

  2. For the purposes of this appeal, it is not necessary to consider the merits of the complaint. On 24 August 2023, the complaint was referred to the Tribunal.

  3. The appellants do not take issue with the facts as found by the decision-maker.1 The complaint was not able to be conciliated with the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read State of Queensland v Fraser and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QCATA 39
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal was brought by the appellants against a decision made by a Senior Member of the Tribunal on 22 January 2024. The respondent, Dr Jennifer Fraser, had made a complaint to the Queensland Human Rights Commission (QHRC) about alleged direct discrimination on the grounds of race and breaches of the Human Rights Act 2019 (Qld). The appellants challenged the Tribunal's decision, arguing that the complaint was not filed within the required time frame, and thus, the Tribunal lacked jurisdiction. The key issue for the court was whether the appeal should be allowed, particularly in light of the respondent's introduction of new evidence at the hearing without making an application for its admission, and whether the Appeal Tribunal should have given more weight to events occurring after the notice was initially emailed.

The Appeal Tribunal examined whether the original decision-maker's authorities were correctly applied and found they did not support the original decision. However, the Tribunal concluded that the decision was correctly reached for different reasons. Despite the appeal being heard on the basis of a different rationale, the Tribunal affirmed the original decision. The court found that the appeal should not be dismissed outright as the introduction of new evidence, although not formally admitted, did not alter the outcome. The events occurring after the notice was emailed were also considered, but they did not warrant a different conclusion. Ultimately, the Appeal Tribunal determined that the appeal should be dismissed, and the original decision was affirmed.

The Appeal Tribunal granted the application for leave to appeal but dismissed the appeal itself. The original decision of the Tribunal, made on 22 January 2024, was affirmed. This means that the Tribunal's initial findings and conclusions, despite being reached for different reasons, were upheld. The court's decision ensures that the original determination stands, and the appeal process did not result in a change to the outcome. This ruling reinforces the Tribunal's jurisdiction and the importance of adhering to the statutory time frames for filing complaints.

Orders

Orders of the court

IT IS THE DECISION OF THE APPEAL TRIBUNAL THAT:

The application for leave to appeal granted. The appeal is dismissed.

The original decision of the Tribunal made on 22 January 2024 is affirmed but for the reasons set out.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

This is an appeal against a decision made by a Senior Member of this Tribunal on 22 January 2024 (‘review decision’). The appellants lodged appeals APL039-24 and APL055-24. The appeals were consolidated and were heard together. For the purposes of this appeal, it is not necessary to refer to the appellants individually. Therefore, in this decision, the appellants collectively will be referred to as the ‘appellants’. Dr Jennifer Fraser who is the complainant, will be referred to as the ‘respondent’. The respondent made a Queensland Human Rights Commission (‘QHRC’) complaint about direct discrimination alleged to have occurred on 14 January 2021, on the grounds of race and alleged breaches of section 59 of the Human Rights Act 2019 (Qld) (‘HR Act’). For the purposes of this appeal, it is not necessary to consider the merits of the complaint. On 24 August 2023, the complaint was referred to the Tribunal. The appellants do not take issue with the facts as found by the decision-maker.1 The complaint was not able to be conciliated with the result that the Commissioner was required to issue a notice to the respondent pursuant to s 165 of the Anti- Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld) (‘AD Act’) (‘s 165 letter’). Review decision paragraph 11. The facts as found by the review decision-maker are as follows:2(a)On 15 May 2023, a letter declaring the complaint inconciliable was forwarded to the respondent by email at 3:42pm. The letter was copied to the respondent’s legal representatives on that day.(b)On 29 May 2023, the respondent verbally advised the QHRC that she had received correspondence “last week” but was unable to specify a day. The QHRC formed the view the s 165 letter was delivered no earlier than 22 May 2023, being Monday of last week.(c)On 29 May 2023, the QHRC sent a further email to the respondent, reattaching the s 165 letter and advising the respondent had 21 days to refer the complaint. (That is 28 days from 22 May 2023 – expiring on 19 June 2023).(d)On 19 June 2023, the QHRC contacted the respondent and advised it was her last day to refer her complaint.(e)On 19 June 2023, the respondent emailed the QHRC and asked for an extension of time within which to refer her complaint.(f)On 20 June 2023, the QHRC emailed the respondent and requested advice as to whether the s 165 letter had been read by the respondent on 22 May 2023.(g)On 20 June 2023, the respondent emailed the QHRC advising she had received and read the email dated 29 May 2023 but had not read correspondence prior to this.(h)On 22 June 2023, QHRC emailed the respondent advising of the s 166 process. It is accepted by the parties that, if the complaint was not filed within time, namely, within 28 days of the Commissioner telling the respondent that the complaint cannot be resolved by conciliation, then the Tribunal had no jurisdiction to deal with the complaint.3 This is said to be, within 28 days of the respondent being notified of the notice required under s 165.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.