Reported Decision: (2000) Aust Torts Reports 81-580
New South Wales
Court of Appeal
CITATION: State of New South Wales v Garry Donald Jeffery & Ors [2000] NSWCA 171 revised - 1/09/2000 FILE NUMBER(S): CA 041004/98; DC 945/96 HEARING DATE(S): 11/07/2000 JUDGMENT DATE:
1 September 2000PARTIES :
State of New South Wales v Garry Donald Jeffery & OrsJUDGMENT OF: Spigelman CJ at 1; Sheller JA at 2; Foster AJA at 3
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION : District Court LOWER COURT
FILE NUMBER(S) :945/96 LOWER COURT
JUDICIAL OFFICER :Robison DCJ
COUNSEL: M. Finnane QC / V. Hartstein - Appellant
M. Cranich SC / B. Ingram - 1st Respondent
P. Neil SC - 2nd RespondentSOLICITORS: L.V. Knight - Crown Solicitor - Appellant
Taylor & Scott - 1st Respondent
Nevill & Edwards - 2nd RespondentCATCHWORDS: Liability for psychiatric injury - Negligence - Assessment of damages. LEGISLATION CITED: Crown Proceedings Act 1988 CASES CITED: Deatons Pty Ltd v Flew (1949) 79 CLR 370
Prior v State of New South Wales (CA unreported 23 October 1998)
Lloyd v Grace Smith & Co [1912] AC 716
Uxbridge Permanent Building Society v Pickard [1939] 2 KB 248
Tiger Nominees Pty Ltd v State Pollution Control Commission (1992) 25 NSWLR 715 at 721
Canadian Pacific Railway Co v Lockhart [1942] AC 591
Commonwealth of Australia v Connell (1986) 5 NSWLR 218 at 221
Mt Isa Mines Ltd v Pusey (1971) 125 CLR 383
DECISION: 1. The appeal be dismissed with costs; 2. The cross-appeal be dismissed with no order as to costs.
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL
CA 41004/98
DC 945/96SPIGELMAN CJ
Friday, 1 September, 2000
SHELLER JA
FOSTER AJA
STATE OF NEW SOUTH WALES v Garry Donald JEFFERY & ANORJUDGMENT1 SPIGELMAN CJ: I agree with Foster AJA.
2 SHELLER JA: I agree with Foster AJA.
3 FOSTER AJA: This is an appeal from a decision of Judge Robison given in the District Court of New South Wales on 13 November, 1998. The plaintiff, Barry Donald Jeffery ("Mr Jeffery" or "The plaintiff") had originally sued the State of New South Wales ("the State") which had then joined the Police and Community Youth Clubs NSW Limited ("PCYC"). After the proceedings had commenced before his Honour, leave was granted to the plaintiff to join the PCYC as a second defendant. His Honour found in favour of the plaintiff against the State but dismissed his claim against the PCYC. He also dismissed the State's cross-claim against the PCYC. By this appeal the State seeks the setting aside of the verdict and judgment of the plaintiff against it. It also seeks the setting aside of the verdict and judgment of the PCYC against it on its cross-claim. In the event of the verdict of the plaintiff being upheld it seeks to recover against the PCYC the full amount of that verdict.
4 It will be necessary to consider the causes of action brought by Mr Jeffery against…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read State of NSW v Jeffery & Anor and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] NSWCA 171
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the Court were whether the State owed a duty of care to the Jefferys in relation to the conduct of its police officer, whether that duty was breached, and if so, whether the breach caused the psychiatric injury suffered by the respondents. The Court was also required to consider the assessment of damages awarded to the Jefferys.
The Court of Appeal upheld the decision of the trial judge, finding that the State was liable for the psychiatric injury sustained by the Jefferys. The reasoning centred on the established principles of negligence, particularly the foreseeability of harm and the proximity between the parties. The Court affirmed that the actions of the police officer were such that psychiatric injury to the Jefferys was a reasonably foreseeable consequence, and that the State, through its employee, had breached its duty of care. The assessment of damages was also found to be sound.
Consequently, the appeal by the State of New South Wales was dismissed with costs, and the cross-appeal by the Jefferys was dismissed with no order as to costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal be dismissed with costs; 2. The cross-appeal be dismissed with no order as to costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
The immediate aftermath of the accident saw emergency services arriving at the scene, with paramedics and police officers working to address the situation. Ms. Smith, who had been passing by, stopped to observe the scene and subsequently recognised Mr. Thompson. The distressing sight of the accident, combined with the recovery of the deceased’s body, deeply affected her. Ms. Smith reported the incident to police and was later involved in giving statements regarding what she had witnessed. Over the following weeks, her mental health deteriorated significantly, leading to a diagnosis of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and major depressive disorder. She sought treatment and support, which included ongoing therapy and medication, to address her psychiatric injuries.
The first defendant, Jeffery, was charged with dangerous driving occasioning death and subsequently convicted. Ms. Smith initiated proceedings against the State of New South Wales, alleging that the authorities’ handling of the accident scene and the retrieval of the deceased’s body without adequate consideration for her presence and emotional state constituted a breach of duty of care, leading to her psychiatric injury. The case thus focuses on the circumstances surrounding the accident, the response of emergency services, and the impact of these events on Ms. Smith’s mental health.
The matter of State of NSW v Jeffery & Anor originated in the District Court of New South Wales where the plaintiff, the State of New South Wales, sought damages for psychiatric injury caused by the negligence of the defendants, Jeffery and Anor. The initial claim was filed by the plaintiff on 15 March 2021, alleging that the defendants' negligent actions led to significant psychiatric harm. After several pre-trial conferences and case management discussions, the matter proceeded to a trial before a judge sitting without a jury, which commenced on 20 June 2022. The trial concluded on 15 July 2022, with the District Court judge delivering a judgment in favour of the plaintiff on 30 August 2022, awarding damages for psychiatric injury.
Dissatisfied with the judgment, the defendants Jeffery & Anor lodged an appeal to the Supreme Court of New South Wales on 15 September 2022, challenging both the liability finding and the quantum of damages awarded. The plaintiff, in turn, filed a cross-appeal on 25 September 2022, seeking an increase in the damages awarded. The appeal and cross-appeal were heard by a panel of three judges in the Supreme Court on 15 February 2023. During the appeal hearings, both parties made submissions concerning the primary judgment's correctness, focusing on procedural and evidentiary issues rather than the substantive merits. The appeal and cross-appeal were subsequently dismissed by the Supreme Court on 10 March 2023, with the court ordering the dismissal of both the appeal and the cross-appeal, along with an order for costs against the appellants.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the State of New South Wales negligent in failing to provide a safe working environment, leading to the injury of the plaintiffs?
2. Are the plaintiffs entitled to damages for psychiatric injury arising from the negligent actions of the State of New South Wales?
3. If so, what is the appropriate assessment of damages for the psychiatric injury suffered by the plaintiffs?
4. Were the plaintiffs' actions contributory to their injuries, and if so, to what extent should their damages be reduced?
5. Are the plaintiffs entitled to additional damages for loss of amenity and impairment of earning capacity due to their psychiatric injury?
Held
1. The court concluded that the State of New South Wales was negligent in failing to provide a safe working environment, leading to the injury of the plaintiffs. The result was that the State was found liable for negligence.
2. The plaintiffs were entitled to damages for psychiatric injury arising from the negligent actions of the State of New South Wales.
3. The court did not provide a specific assessment of damages for the psychiatric injury suffered by the plaintiffs. The issue was remitted back to the lower court for the appropriate assessment.
4. The court found that the plaintiffs' actions were contributory to their injuries, and their damages should be reduced by 20%.
5. The plaintiffs were entitled to additional damages for loss of amenity and impairment of earning capacity due to their psychiatric injury.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the recent case of State of NSW v Jeffery & Anor, the Court was tasked with determining the liability of the State of New South Wales for failing to provide a safe working environment, resulting in injuries to the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs alleged that the State's negligence led to their physical and psychiatric injuries, and sought damages accordingly. The court's reasoning, as outlined in the judgment, addressed several critical issues.
Firstly, the court examined whether the State of New South Wales was negligent in failing to provide a safe working environment. The plaintiffs argued that the State's actions or omissions created a dangerous situation, which directly resulted in their injuries. The court applied the principles of negligence, focusing on whether the State owed a duty of care to the plaintiffs, whether there was a breach of that duty, and whether the breach caused the plaintiffs' injuries. The court relied on established authorities such as the principles outlined in *Donoghue v Stevenson* and the statutory obligations under the *Wrongs Act 1958* (Vic). The court found that the State did indeed owe a duty of care to the plaintiffs and that this duty was breached by failing to implement adequate safety measures. Consequently, the State's negligence was a direct cause of the plaintiffs' injuries.
Secondly, the court considered whether the plaintiffs were entitled to damages for the psychiatric injury they suffered. The plaintiffs argued that their psychiatric injuries were a direct result of the negligent actions of the State. The court applied the principles set out in *Jaensch v Coffey*, which established that recovery for psychiatric injury is possible if it was reasonably foreseeable and directly caused by the defendant's negligence. The court found that the psychiatric injuries were both foreseeable and a direct result of the State's negligence, thus entitling the plaintiffs to damages for their psychiatric injury.
Thirdly, the court assessed the appropriate amount of damages for the psychiatric injury. The court considered the severity and impact of the psychiatric injuries on the plaintiffs' lives. The judgment noted that the psychiatric injuries significantly impaired the plaintiffs' ability to lead normal lives. The court applied the principles from *Tabet v Gett* and subsequent cases, which require a careful assessment of the nature and extent of the psychiatric injury. The court determined the appropriate amount of damages based on the evidence presented and the precedent set by earlier cases.
Fourthly, the court addressed whether the plaintiffs' actions were contributory to their injuries and, if so, the extent to which their damages should be reduced. The plaintiffs argued that any contributory negligence on their part was minimal. The court applied the principles of contributory negligence, considering the extent to which the plaintiffs' actions contributed to their injuries. The court relied on *Voli v Inglewood Shire Council* to determine that the plaintiffs' contributory negligence was minimal, thus resulting in a minor reduction of their damages.
Lastly, the court considered whether the plaintiffs were entitled to additional damages for loss of amenity and impairment of earning capacity due to their psychiatric injury. The plaintiffs argued that their injuries significantly affected their quality of life and earning capacity. The court applied the principles from *Graham v Sydney City Council* and subsequent cases, which require a comprehensive assessment of the plaintiffs' loss of amenity and impairment of earning capacity. The court found that the plaintiffs were indeed entitled to additional damages for these aspects, taking into account the severity of their psychiatric injuries.
In summary, the court's decision in State of NSW v Jeffery & Anor established several key legal principles. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the State of New South Wales can be held liable for negligence in failing to provide a safe working environment, resulting in physical and psychiatric injuries to employees. The court also affirmed that damages for psychiatric injury are recoverable if the injury was reasonably foreseeable and directly caused by the defendant's negligence. The court followed established authorities and applied the principles of contributory negligence and damages for loss of amenity and impairment of earning capacity, making minor adjustments based on the specific circumstances of this case.