STATE CENTRAL AUTHORITY & YOUNG

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

STATE CENTRAL AUTHORITY & YOUNG [2012] FamCA 563

FAMILY LAW – CHILD ABDUCTION – HAGUE CONVENTION – return proceeding following alleged wrongful removal of child from Republic of South Africa –  Early identification of justiciable issues – rights of custody – objections to return by child who is 9 year old – exposure to grave risk of harm from family violence – exposure to grave risk of harm because adequate arrangements and safeguards against family violence are unable to be implemented in South Africa upon the return of the child – exposure to grave risk of harm arising from child being separated from siblings – access between child and left behind father pending determination of return application.

FAMILY LAW – PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – HAGUE CONVENTION – bifurcation of proceedings so that issue of “rights of custody” is determined as a preliminary issue – international expectations of time in which return proceedings can be determined - expeditious determination will not be achievable within 6 weeks – possible criminal prosecution and sanctions to be faced by abducting parent on return to South Africa.

FAMILY LAW – PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – HAGUE CONVENTION – role of independent children’s lawyer in, and incidental to, return proceedings – Regulation 26 report – scope of report – specification of matters to be assessed by family consultant.

Children’s Act 2005 (South Africa)
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)

Family Law (Child Abduction Convention) Regulations 1986 (Cth)
Emerging Guidance Regarding the Development of the International Hague Network of Judges and General Principles for Judicial Communications, Including Commonly Accepted Safeguards for Direct Judicial Communications in Specific Cases, within the Context of the International Hague Network of Judges (2011)

Browne v Dunn (1894) 6 R 67 (HL)
DP & Commonwealth Central Authority; JLM v Director-General NSW Department of Community Services (2001) FLC 93-081
Laing v The Central Authority (1999) FLC 92-849
Murray & Director Family Services (ACT) (1993) FLC 92-416
MW v Director-General, Department of Community Services [2008] HCA 12
Re C (A Minor)(Abduction) [1989] 1 FLR 403
TB & JB  (Abduction: Grave risk of harm) [2001] 2 FLR 515
APPLICANT: State Central Authority
RESPONDENT: Ms Young
INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER: Ms C Smith
FILE NUMBER: MLC 5904 of 2012
DATE DELIVERED: 20 July 2012
PLACE DELIVERED: Melbourne
PLACE HEARD: Melbourne
JUDGMENT OF: Bennett J
HEARING DATE: 20 July 2012

REPRESENTATION

SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT:

State Central Authority

Department of Human Services
Legal Services Branch

COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT: Mr Stanley
SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: Burrell Family Law
SOLICITOR FOR THE INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER: Victoria Legal Aid

Orders

IT IS ORDERED THAT:

1.The hearing of this matter insofar as it pertains to the requesting parent’s right of custody in relation to the child D YOUNG born … March 2003 be set down for hearing before me on 8 August 2012 to commence at 4.00 pm and estimated to take 3 days (“the first hearing”).

2.The hearing insofar as it pertains to exceptions to mandatory return any…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read STATE CENTRAL AUTHORITY & YOUNG and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FamCA 563
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a return proceeding under the Hague Convention, initiated by the State Central Authority on behalf of a requesting parent, against the respondent mother concerning the child D Young. The core dispute revolved around the alleged wrongful removal of D Young from the Republic of South Africa. The court was required to consider various objections to D Young's return, including his age and objections, potential exposure to grave risk of harm from family violence, the adequacy of safeguards in South Africa, and the risk of separation from siblings.

The legal issues before the court included whether D Young had rights of custody in relation to the child, and if so, whether any objections to his return, particularly those of a nine-year-old child, warranted refusal. The court also had to determine if D Young faced a grave risk of harm due to family violence or the inability to implement adequate safeguards in South Africa. Furthermore, the court considered the impact of potential separation from siblings and the father, and the role and scope of the independent children's lawyer and the Regulation 26 report. The court also addressed the practicalities of expeditiously determining the proceedings, acknowledging that a determination within six weeks might not be achievable.

Bennett J ordered that the proceedings be bifurcated. The first hearing, scheduled for 8 August 2012, would focus solely on the issue of the requesting parent's right of custody. A second hearing, commencing on 10 September 2012, would address exceptions to mandatory return, any discretion to refuse return, and conditions of return. The court also made detailed directions regarding the preparation of the Regulation 26 report, specifying the issues to be addressed, including D Young's objections, the impact of separation from siblings and parents, and appropriate access arrangements between D Young and his father. The father was to be provided with an opportunity to participate in the report's assessment, at least in part, by audio-visual link.

Orders

Orders of the court

IT IS ORDERED THAT:

1. The hearing of this matter insofar as it pertains to the requesting parent’s right of custody in relation to the child D YOUNG born … March 2003 be set down for hearing before me on 8 August 2012 to commence at 4.00 pm and estimated to take 3 days (“the first hearing”).

2. The hearing insofar as it pertains to exceptions to mandatory return any discretion to refuse return that arises therefrom and any other matter such as conditions to return be set down for hearing before me to commence on 10 September 2012 estimated to take 4 days (“the second hearing”).

3. The evidence in the first hearing is evidence in the second hearing to the extent that such evidence is relevant.

4.

Paragraph 8 of the Order made on 13 July 2012 (as to the date of the interviews for the Regulation 26 report) be discharged and in lieu thereof for the purpose of the preparation of the report a family consultant or like appropriately qualified person nominated by the Director of Child Dispute Services in the Melbourne Registry of this Court be available to see the child D YOUNG born … March 2003 at a date, time and place nominated by the Director of Court Counselling of this Registry of the Court. The mother deliver the child to the family consultant as directed, on the nominated date and time, and thereafter, abide any reasonable requests of the family consultant.

5.

The father be provided with an opportunity to participate in the assessment for the Regulation 26 Report which is comparable to the participation of the mother in preparation of the report and such participation by him be, at least in part, by audio-visual link.

6.

The independent children’s lawyer be at liberty to introduce herself to the child D during the assessment process in such manner and at such time as the report writer, in her discretion, considers appropriate.

7.

The Regulation 26 Report in relation to D YOUNG born … March 2003, pursuant to paragraph 7 of the Order made on 13 July 2012, address the following issues:-

a. Whether he objects to being returned to South Africa;

b. Whether his objection (if any) shows a strength of feeling beyond the mere expression of a mere preference or of ordinary wishes;

c. Whether the child has attained an age and degree of maturity at which it is appropriate to take account of any objection he may have.

8.

The report also address the following further issues:-

a. The impact on the child, in terms of his medium to long term psychological health and otherwise, of being separated from his siblings in the event that the child is returned to South Africa but his siblings remain in Australia;

b. The impact on the child, in terms of his psychological health and otherwise, of being separated from the mother in the event that the child is returned to South Africa but the mother remains in Australia for whatever reason;

c. The impact on the child, in terms of his psychological health or otherwise, of being separated from the father in the event that a return is not ordered and the child is permitted to remain in Australia

d. What (if any) face to face access or electronic communication between the child and his father, Mr A, would be appropriate between now and the final hearing of this matter having regard, where appropriate, to the considerations applicable to parenting cases set out in ss60CC(2) and (3) of the Act;

e. Any other matter which relates to the care, welfare and development of the child and which the family consultant considers ought to be brought to the attention of the Court.

9.

The Regulation 26 report be completed within three weeks of this date and be released to the parties promptly AND IT IS NOTED that the report writer will be required to be accessible to the independent children’s lawyer on the day/night of any mediation and for cross-examination at the hearing.

10.

The applicant State Central Authority advise Ms H of Child Dispute Services, my Associate and each other party to the proceeding as soon as practicable of the following:-

a. whether the father is prepared to participate in the assessment for the Regulation 26 Report;

b. whether the father has access to and is able to operate Skype;

c. whether the father will meet the expense of an audio-visual link (not Skype) to enable him to give evidence at the first hearing and the second hearing.

11.

IT IS DIRECTED that my reasons for decision this day be published and made available to the parties and the Director of Child Dispute Services.

12.

IT IS FURTHER DIRECTED that my Associate commence making arrangements for the audio visual link for the purpose of the father’s evidence on 8 August 2012 at 4.00 pm estimated to take not longer than 150 minutes.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established