Stanley Jones and Svitzer Offshore Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

[2014] AATA 902

Division General Administrative Division

File Number

2013/6259

Re

Stanley Jones

APPLICANT

And

Svitzer Offshore Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President S D Hotop

Date 5 December 2014
Place Perth

The decision under review is set aside and the matter is remitted to the respondent for reconsideration in accordance with the direction that the respondent treat the applicant’s request, given on 23 September 2013, for a reconsideration of the respondent’s determination of 26 November 2008 as a request made in accordance with s 78(3) of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth) (“SRC Act”).

Pursuant to s 92(2) of the SRC Act, the Tribunal orders that the costs of these proceedings incurred by the applicant be paid by the respondent in accordance with Section 6.8 of the Tribunal’s Guide to the Workers’ Compensation Jurisdiction (September 2013).

..............................[sgd]..........................................

S D Hotop

Deputy President

  1. Stanley Jones (“the applicant”) has applied to the Tribunal for review of a deemed reviewable decision made on behalf of the respondent under s 78 of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth) (“SRC Act”) whereby a request by the applicant, dated 4 September 2013, for a reconsideration of a determination made on behalf of the respondent under the SRC Act on 26 November 2008, was taken to be refused.

    The Evidence

  2. The evidence before the Tribunal comprised:

    ·the “T Documents” (T1–T69, pp 1-193) lodged by the respondent in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth);

    ·witness statement of the applicant, dated 10 February 2014 (including Attachments SWJ1–SWJ20) (Exhibit A1);

    ·affidavit of John Gaetano Mario Fiocco sworn on 24 October 2014 (including Attachments JF1–JF9) (Exhibit A2);

    ·Labour Market Assessment Report of Michelle Woolerson, Advance Personnel Management, dated 11 July 2014 (Exhibit R1);

    ·supplementary report of Candice Sparre, Advanced Personnel Management, dated 25 August 2014, together with letter from respondent’s solicitors, dated 14 August 2014, requesting supplementary report (Exhibit R2); and

    ·the oral evidence of the applicant.

    The Relevant Factual Background

  3. The following background facts are found by the Tribunal on the basis of the T Documents and Exhibit A2.

  4. The applicant, who was born in June 1948, was at all material times employed by Adsteam Offshore Services Pty Ltd/Svitzer Offshore Pty Ltd (“the respondent”).

  5. On 5 September 2003 the applicant, who was then employed as an Able Seaman acting as Bosun on board the vessel MV BBC Portugal, suffered a severe crush injury to three fingers of his left hand in the performance of his normal employment duties.  (T4)

  6. On 11 September 2003 the applicant lodged a claim for compensation in respect of an injury described by him as “mangled left hand, fractured fingers, amputation little finger” (T7).  Liability to pay compensation to the applicant in respect of that injury was subsequently accepted on behalf of the respondent.

  7. On 13 September 2003 the applicant underwent surgery to his left hand by Mr Jeff Ecker and Mr Tim Cooper which included amputation of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stanley Jones and Svitzer Offshore Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 902
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Stanley Jones, a former employee of Adsteam Offshore Services Pty Ltd/Svitzer Offshore Pty Ltd, applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) for a review of a decision made by the employer. The employer had accepted liability for a claim Jones lodged in 2003 for an injury he suffered while working as an Able Seaman on the MV BBC Portugal. The employer had issued a determination in 2008, which Jones did not accept. In 2013, Jones requested a reconsideration of the 2008 determination, which the employer deemed refused. Jones argued that the employer should have granted an extension of time for his request for reconsideration, which was submitted beyond the 30-day period stipulated by the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (SRC Act).

The primary legal issue the AAT had to decide was whether it was fair and equitable to grant Jones an extension of time to request a reconsideration of the 2008 determination. The AAT had to consider the reasons for the delay in Jones' request, the merits of his request for reconsideration, and whether the employer would suffer significant prejudice if the extension was granted.

The AAT found that Jones provided an acceptable explanation for the delay in submitting his request for reconsideration. It was also determined that Jones' request for reconsideration had significant merit. The Tribunal was not convinced that the employer would suffer significant prejudice if the extension was granted. Consequently, the AAT concluded that it would be fair and equitable to grant Jones the required extension of time for requesting a reconsideration of the 2008 determination.

In light of the above findings, the AAT set aside the decision under review and directed the employer to treat Jones' request for reconsideration as having been made within the prescribed time limit. The employer was required to reconsider the 2008 determination in accordance with the SRC Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The evidence before the Tribunal comprised:·the “T Documents” (T1–T69, pp 1-193) lodged by the respondent in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth);·witness statement of the applicant, dated 10 February 2014 (including Attachments SWJ1–SWJ20) (Exhibit A1);·affidavit of John Gaetano Mario Fiocco sworn on 24 October 2014 (including Attachments JF1–JF9) (Exhibit A2);·Labour Market Assessment Report of Michelle Woolerson, Advance Personnel Management, dated 11 July 2014 (Exhibit R1);·supplementary report of Candice Sparre, Advanced Personnel Management, dated 25 August 2014, together with letter from respondent’s solicitors, dated 14 August 2014, requesting supplementary report (Exhibit R2); and·the oral evidence of the applicant.The Relevant Factual Background The following background facts are found by the Tribunal on the basis of the T Documents and Exhibit A2. The applicant, who was born in June 1948, was at all material times employed by Adsteam Offshore Services Pty Ltd/Svitzer Offshore Pty Ltd (“the respondent”). On 5 September 2003 the applicant, who was then employed as an Able Seaman acting as Bosun on board the vessel MV BBC Portugal, suffered a severe crush injury to three fingers of his left hand in the performance of his normal employment duties. (T4) On 11 September 2003 the applicant lodged a claim for compensation in respect of an injury described by him as “mangled left hand, fractured fingers, amputation little finger” (T7). Liability to pay compensation to the applicant in respect of that injury was subsequently accepted on behalf of the respondent. On 13 September 2003 the applicant underwent surgery to his left hand by Mr Jeff Ecker and Mr Tim Cooper which included amputation of the little finger through the proximal shaft metaphysis of the fifth metacarpal, and amputation of the ring finger proximal to the proximal interphalangeal joint. (T8) By letter dated 7 March 2008 the respondent’s insurer, Allianz Australia Insurance Limited (“Allianz”), wrote to the applicant’s (then) solicitors as follows:“ Further to our letter dated 14 September 2007, we kindly write to you in relation to the workers compensation claim for Mr Staley [sic] Jones and the Notice of Determination issued to Mr Jones, c/- your office, on the 3rd April 2007. Please find attached a copy of this Determination for your reference.To date, nothing has been received from Mr Jones with regards to whether this determination of permanent impairment has been accepted, although it is noted a request for reconsideration has not been received.Could you please advise as to whether Mr Jones has accepted this Determination with regards to his claim for permanent impairment. Once confirmation of this acceptance has been received, Allianz is able to pay this lump sum to Mr Jones.Please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned should you have any questions.” (T51) By letter dated 22 September 2008 Allianz wrote to the applicant’s (then) solicitors as follows:“ Further to our letters dated 14th September 2007, 7th March 2008, and 16th June 2008, we write in relation to the workers compensation claim for Mr Staley [sic] Jones and the Notice of Determination issued to Mr Jones, c/- your office, on the 3rd April 2007.As we have not received a response to any of this correspondence, could you please advise if you continue to represent Mr Stanley Jones in this matter? Allianz Australia Insurance will contact Mr Stanley Jones direct with relation to the resolution of his permanent impairment entitlements should this not be the case.Please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned should you have any questions.” (T52)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Stanley Jones (“the applicant”) has applied to the Tribunal for review of a deemed reviewable decision made on behalf of the respondent under s 78 of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth) (“SRC Act”) whereby a request by the applicant, dated 4 September 2013, for a reconsideration of a determination made on behalf of the respondent under the SRC Act on 26 November 2008, was taken to be refused.The Evidence The evidence before the Tribunal comprised:·the “T Documents” (T1–T69, pp 1-193) lodged by the respondent in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth);·witness statement of the applicant, dated 10 February 2014 (including Attachments SWJ1–SWJ20) (Exhibit A1);·affidavit of John Gaetano Mario Fiocco sworn on 24 October 2014 (including Attachments JF1–JF9) (Exhibit A2);·Labour Market Assessment Report of Michelle Woolerson, Advance Personnel Management, dated 11 July 2014 (Exhibit R1);·supplementary report of Candice Sparre, Advanced Personnel Management, dated 25 August 2014, together with letter from respondent’s solicitors, dated 14 August 2014, requesting supplementary report (Exhibit R2); and·the oral evidence of the applicant.The Relevant Factual Background The following background facts are found by the Tribunal on the basis of the T Documents and Exhibit A2. The applicant, who was born in June 1948, was at all material times employed by Adsteam Offshore Services Pty Ltd/Svitzer Offshore Pty Ltd (“the respondent”). On 5 September 2003 the applicant, who was then employed as an Able Seaman acting as Bosun on board the vessel MV BBC Portugal, suffered a severe crush injury to three fingers of his left hand in the performance of his normal employment duties. (T4) On 11 September 2003 the applicant lodged a claim for compensation in respect of an injury described by him as “mangled left hand, fractured fingers, amputation little finger” (T7). Liability to pay compensation to the applicant in respect of that injury was subsequently accepted on behalf of the respondent. On 13 September 2003 the applicant underwent surgery to his left hand by Mr Jeff Ecker and Mr Tim Cooper which included amputation of the little finger through the proximal shaft metaphysis of the fifth metacarpal, and amputation of the ring finger proximal to the proximal interphalangeal joint. (T8) By letter dated 7 March 2008 the respondent’s insurer, Allianz Australia Insurance Limited (“Allianz”), wrote to the applicant’s (then) solicitors as follows:“ Further to our letter dated 14 September 2007, we kindly write to you in relation to the workers compensation claim for Mr Staley [sic] Jones and the Notice of Determination issued to Mr Jones, c/- your office, on the 3rd April 2007. Please find attached a copy of this Determination for your reference.To date, nothing has been received from Mr Jones with regards to whether this determination of permanent impairment has been accepted, although it is noted a request for reconsideration has not been received.Could you please advise as to whether Mr Jones has accepted this Determination with regards to his claim for permanent impairment. Once confirmation of this acceptance has been received, Allianz is able to pay this lump sum to Mr Jones.Please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned should you have any questions.” (T51)

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having regard to the considerations discussed in paragraphs 40–64 above, the Tribunal concludes that, on balance, it would be fair and equitable in the circumstances of the present case for the required extension of time for requesting a reconsideration of the determination of 26 November 2008 to be granted to the applicant. The Tribunal has come to that conclusion primarily on the bases that:·although the applicant’s request for a reconsideration of that determination was given to the respondent approximately 4 years and 9 months beyond the expiration of the 30-day period prescribed by s 78(3)(b) of the SRC Act, the applicant has given a reasonable and acceptable explanation for that very substantial delay;·the applicant’s substantive request for a reconsideration of that determination has great merit; and·the Tribunal is not satisfied that significant prejudice would be caused to the respondent by the grant to the applicant of the required extension of time for requesting a reconsideration of that determination.Decision For the above reasons, the decision under review is set aside and the matter is remitted to the respondent for reconsideration in accordance with the direction that the respondent treat the applicant’s request, given on 23 September 2013, for a reconsideration of the respondent’s determination of 26 November 2008 as a request made in accordance with s 78(3) of the SRC Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The SRC Act relevantly provides as follows:“Part 6 - Reconsideration of determinations and review of decisions by the Administrative Appeals TribunalDivision 1 - Definitions76Interpretation (1)In this Part: AAT Act means the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. AAT extension application means an application under subsection 29(7) of the AAT Act that relates to a review of a reviewable decision or an extension of time decision.claimant means a person in respect of whom a determination is made. decision has the same meaning as in the AAT Act. determination means a determination, decision or requirement made by the employer under section 13, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 39, 40, 41, 43, 44, 45, 49, 50, 51, 66 or 126. extension of time decision means a decision of the Authority under paragraph 72(1)(b), 73(2)(c) or 73A(1)(b). reviewable decision means a decision made under section 78. (2)For the purposes of this Part, the parties to proceedings instituted under this Part are: (a)the applicant; and (b)where the applicant is not the claimant—the claimant; and(c)the employer. Division 2—Reconsideration of determinations by employers 77 Determinations to be notified in writing (1)As soon as practicable after an employer makes a determination, the employer must cause to be served on the claimant a notice in writing setting out: (a)the terms of the determination; and (b)the reasons for the determination; and (c)a statement to the effect that the claimant may, if dissatisfied with the determination, request a reconsideration of the determination under subsection 78(2). (2)… 78Reconsiderations of determinations (1)An employer may, on the employer's own initiative, reconsider a determination made by the employer, whether or not a proceeding has been instituted or completed under this Part in respect of a reviewable decision made in relation to that determination. (2)A claimant may, by notice in writing given to an employer, request the employer to reconsider a determination made by the employer. (3)A request for reconsideration of a determination must: (a)set out the reasons for the request; and (b)be given to the employer within 30 days after the day on which the determination first came to the notice of the claimant, or within such further period (if any) as the employer, either before or after the end of that 30 day period, allows. (4)On receipt of a request, the employer must for the purposes of this section: (a)if the employer is a party to a collective agreement or a pre-reform certified agreement that relates to industry panels—arrange for an industry panel; or (b)in any other case - arrange with Comcare for a Comcare officer; to assist the employer in reconsidering the determination under subsection (5). (5)After making arrangements under paragraph (4)(a) or (b), the employer must, with the assistance of the industry panel or the Comcare officer, reconsider the determination.(6)After an employer reconsiders a determination, the employer must make a decision affirming or revoking the determination or varying the determination in such manner as the employer thinks fit. (7)In this section: industry panel means an industry panel established under an industrial agreement for the purposes of assisting the employer in reconsidering a determination under this section. 79 Time limit for reconsideration of determinations (1)If a claimant requests an employer to reconsider a determination made by the employer, the employer must reconsider the determination before the later of the following times: (a)the end of the period of 60 days after the employer receives the request; (b)if, at the written request of the employer, the Authority, by written notice served on the employer, allows a further period or further periods for the determination of the liability—the end of that period or those periods, as the case may be. …(6)If the employer has not determined the claim by the end of the period allowed by this section, the employer is taken to have made a decision, at the end of that period, disallowing the claim. …88Applications to the AAT (1)Application may be made to the AAT by a claimant for review of a reviewable decision. (2)Despite section 27 of the AAT Act, no person other than the claimant may make an application under subsection (1).”