Staikopolous v City of West Torrens

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Land and Valuation Division: Civil)

STAIKOPOLOUS v CITY OF WEST TORRENS

[2016] SASC 183

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Parker

8 December 2016

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - TREES, VEGETATION AND HABITAT PROTECTION

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING - DEVELOPMENT CONTROL - MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION OF CONSENT AUTHORITY - GENERALLY - CONSIDERATION OF DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS - PARTICULAR DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - COURTS AND TRIBUNALS WITH ENVIRONMENT JURISDICTION - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - SUPREME COURT - ERRORS OF RELEVANT AUTHORITY

Appeal against decision of a Commissioner of the Environment, Resources and Development Court (ERD Court) that dismissed an appeal against a decision of the Development Assessment Panel (DAP) of the City of West Torrens to refuse an application for development approval. The Commissioner held that the proposed land division did not have proper regard to the physical features and conditions on the land arising from the presence of a significant tree on adjacent land.

Appellant’s first ground of appeal is that the Commissioner failed to address the common law of nuisance and the remedies available in a court of competent jurisdiction where a tree on a neighbouring property poses undue risk to personal safety and property. The second ground of appeal is that the Commissioner failed to adopt the balanced approach required by the Act and Regulations and by the Development Plan when considering the effect of the significant tree on the development proposal. The third ground of appeal is that the finding by the Commissioner that the tree poses an unacceptable risk to personal safety should have led him to conclude that it should be removed or subjected to whole of tree pruning rather than his finding that the proposed development should be refused.

Held, per Parker J allowing the appeal:

1)  The Commissioner erred by failing to recognise that if “whole of tree” pruning was required in order to mitigate the danger caused by the tree, a remedy in private nuisance was potentially available in the Magistrates Court to ensure that this occurred.

2)  The Significant Tree provisions in the Development Plan for the City of West Torrens do not exhibit a bias to tree conservation or appropriate development. The balance between appropriate development and tree damaging activities is achieved by ensuring that approval is only given to tree damaging developments in the circumstances specifically permitted by the Principles of Development Control (PDC).

3)  The Commissioner erred by not having regard to the terms of PDC 3(a)(ii) and PDC 3(e)(ii) and giving paramountcy to PDC 5.

Development Act 1993 s4, s5, s33; Development Regulations 2008 reg 6A; Magistrates Court Act 1991 s 10A, referred to.
Lemmon v Webb [1895] AC 1; Bellucco v Netting and Netting [2010] SADC 12; Staikopolous v City of West Torrens [2016] SAERDC 18, considered.

STAIKOPOLOUS v CITY OF WEST TORRENS
[2016] SASC 183

Land and Valuation Division: Civil

  1. Parker J: This is an appeal from a decision of a Commissioner of the Environment, Resources…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Staikopolous v City of West Torrens and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] SASC 183
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Staikopolous v City of West Torrens, the appellant sought development approval to divide his property into two allotments and create a common lot for parking. The application was refused by the Council, which was appealed to the Commissioner who also dismissed the appeal. The Commissioner's decision was then appealed to the Supreme Court of South Australia. The primary issue before the court was whether the Commissioner erred in dismissing the appeal against the Council's refusal of the development application. The court identified several legal issues, including whether the Commissioner had failed to consider the common law of nuisance and the remedies available in a court of competent jurisdiction where a tree on a neighbouring property posed undue risk to personal safety and property, whether the Commissioner had failed to adopt a balanced approach when considering the effect of the significant tree on the development proposal, and whether the Commissioner had failed to decide whether pruning of the tree to the relevant Australian Standard would satisfactorily ameliorate the risk posed to occupants of lot 2.

The court found that the Commissioner had erred in dismissing the appeal against the Council's refusal of the development application. The Commissioner failed to consider the remedies available in an action for private nuisance to deal with problems caused by trees on neighbouring land. The court noted that the presence of a tree with branches overhanging a neighbour's property that causes substantial interference with the use or enjoyment of their land, has long been recognised as giving rise to an action in private nuisance. The Commissioner also failed to adopt a balanced approach when considering the effect of the significant tree on the development proposal. The court found that the Commissioner had given paramountcy to PDC 5, which prohibited division or development of land where that would be likely to result in substantial tree damaging activity, but failed to consider the provisions of PDC 3(a)(ii) and PDC 3(e)(ii) which permitted tree damaging activity where the work was required due to unacceptable risk to public or private safety.

The court held that because of these errors, the appeal against the Commissioner’s decision to dismiss the appeal against the Council’s refusal of the development application should be upheld. The court will hear from the parties as to whether conditions need to be imposed on the development approval and whether that question should be resolved by this Court or remitted. The court will also hear the parties as to costs.

The final orders of the court will be made after considering the submissions of the parties on the issues of conditions and costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Council was represented by counsel before the Commissioner and called three witnesses. However, the Council was not represented on the appeal and gave an undertaking to abide the decision of the Court. The appellant was represented by Mr Stuart Henry SC at the hearing of the appeal. The grounds of appeal are referred to in par 29 below. Background The appellant applied to the Council for development approval to create one additional allotment by way of a community plan of division in respect of land located at 1 Hinton Street, Underdale (the subject land). The subject land comprises a regularly shaped and largely level allotment of 989m2 with a frontage of 18.29m to Hinton Street and a depth of 54.1m. The subject land contains a single dwelling. The land immediately behind the dwelling comprises lawn and a utility area adjacent to a freestanding garage. A fence separates that area from the rear portion of the land. The Commissioner (who had the benefit of having conducted a view) described the rear portion of the land as being largely open and in unkempt condition. While the rear portion was accessible by a gate, it is clear that the present residents make little use of that part of the land. The development application proposes the division of the subject land into two community allotments and a common lot by way of a community plan of division. Community lot 1 would face Hinton Street and comprise the existing residence and the area immediately behind the house. It would have an area of 469m2. Community lot 2 would effectively comprise the portion of land at the rear of the current allotment. It would have an area of 312m2. There would also be a common lot 1 of 208m2 with a frontage to Hinton Street. The common lot would provide vehicle access and parking spaces for the two community lots. The factual foundation for the decision by the Commissioner arose from the presence upon adjacent land of a significant tree. The significant tree is located in the rear yard of 2 Garden Terrace immediately to the north of the subject land. This tree is a lemon scented gum (Corymbia citriodora) and is located 3.59m from the boundary of the subject land. One expert estimated the age of the tree at about 54 years while another expert suggested that it was aged between 45 and 90 years. It is about 18 to 20 metres tall and has a canopy radius of approximately 11 metres. The canopy extends for a distance of about 6 to 7 metres into the rear of the subject land, significantly overhanging lot 2. The arboricultural expert Dr Dean Nicolle called by the Council to give evidence before the Commissioner, stated that the trunk circumference of the tree 1m above the finished ground level is 3.19m.[1] He expects that at full maturity its canopy spread will be some 20m. [1] Thus, it is a “regulated tree” and a “significant tree” within the meaning given by regulation 6A of the Development Regulations 2008. The development regime The effect of s 33(1) of the Development Act 1993 (“the Act”) is to require that an application for development approval must be assessed against the provisions of the appropriate Development Plan. In this case the application must be considered against the Development Plan for the City of West Torrens as consolidated on 31 October 2013. The Development Plan included the following provisions in relation to significant trees:OBJECTIVES 1 The conservation of significant trees, in Metropolitan Adelaide, that provide important aesthetic and environmental benefit. 2 The conservation of significant trees in balance with achieving appropriate development. PRINCIPLES OF DEVELOPMENT CONTROL 1 Development should preserve the following attributes where a significant tree demonstrates at least one of the following attributes: (a) makes an important contribution to the character or amenity of the local area; or (b) is indigenous to the local area and its species is listed under the National Parks and Wildlife Act 1972 as a rare or endangered native species (c) represents an important habitat for native fauna (d) is part of a wildlife corridor of a remnant area of native vegetation (e) is important to the maintenance of biodiversity in the local environment (f) forms a notable visual element to the landscape of the local area. 2 Development should be undertaken so that it has a minimum adverse effect on the health of a significant tree. 3 Significant trees should be preserved, and tree-damaging activity should not be undertaken, unless: (a) in the case of tree removal, where at least one of the following apply: (i) the tree is diseased and its life expectancy is short (ii) the tree represents an unacceptable risk to public or private safety (iii) the tree is within 20 metres of a residential, tourist accommodation or habitable building and is a bushfire hazard within a Bushfire Prone Area (b) the tree is shown to be causing or threatening to cause substantial damage to a substantial building or structure of value (c) all other reasonable remedial treatments and measures have been determined to be ineffective (d) it is demonstrated that all reasonable alternative development options and design solutions have been considered to prevent substantial tree-damaging activity occurring (e) in any other case, any of the following circumstances apply: (i) the work is required for the removal of dead wood, treatment of disease, or is in the general interests of the health of the tree (ii) the work is required due to unacceptable risk to public or private safety(iii) the tree is shown to be causing or threatening to cause damage to a substantial building or structure of value (iv) the aesthetic appearance and structural integrity of the tree is maintained (v) it is demonstrated that all reasonable alternative development options and design solutions have been considered to prevent substantial tree-damaging activity occurring. 4 Development involving ground work activities such as excavation, filling, and sealing of surrounding surfaces (whether such work takes place on the site of a significant tree or otherwise) should only be undertaken where the aesthetic appearance, health and integrity of a significant tree, including its root system, will not be adversely affected. 5 Land should not be divided or developed where the division or development would be likely to result in a substantial tree-damaging activity occurring to a significant tree.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The definition of “tree damaging activity” in s 4(1) provides for the definition to be modified by regulation. Regulation 6A(8) of the Development Regulations 2008 provides as follows:(8) For the purposes of the definition of "tree damaging activity[2] in section 4(1) of the Act, pruning— [2] Note: Act uses “tree-damaging activity” while Regulations use “tree damaging activity”. (a) that does not remove more than 30% of the crown of the tree; and (b) that is required to remove— (i) dead or diseased wood; or (ii) branches that pose a material risk to a building; or (iii)branches to a tree that is located in an area frequently used by people and the branches pose a material risk to such people, is excluded from the ambit of that definition. Evidence As I have already noted, the Council called an arboricultural expert, Dr Dean Nicolle, to give evidence about the tree. The applicant called Mr David Mably, an expert arborist. While three other expert witnesses appeared before the Commissioner, only the evidence given by Mr D Batge and Mr D Hutchison, town planners called by the Council and the appellant respectively, is relevant to this appeal. Both Dr Nicolle and Mr Mably gave evidence about the structural root zone (SRZ) and the tree protection zone (TPZ) for the tree. The SRZ is the distance required to maintain the stability of the tree. The TPZ is the zone which must be managed during and following the development of the land so as to maintain the health of the tree. Dr Nicolle calculated the SRZ at 3.5m from the centre of the tree. Effectively, that is an exclusion zone for all activities. An SRZ of 3.5m is contained wholly within the land on which the tree stands, ie it does not intrude into the subject land. Mr Mably calculated the SRZ as 4.25m from the centre of the tree. Dr Nicolle calculated the TPZ as extending 8.9m from the centre of the tree while Mr Mably identified the TPZ as extending up to 11.755m from the centre of tree. As the centre of the tree is about 3.5m from the rear boundary of the subject land, on the calculations of Dr Nicolle the TPZ extends in an arc up to 5.4m into the subject land. On the calculations of Mr Mably the TPZ extends even further into the subject land. Dr Nicolle described the lemon scented gum species as having potential for individual trees to be subject to sudden failure of small to medium sized branches. However, he considered that a whole of tree structural failure in a mature and healthy specimen to be very rare. For this reason he considered the risk associated with the tree to be “… currently low to moderate and acceptable …”. In the opinion of Dr Nicolle, the risk can only be maintained at an acceptable level if regularly used outdoor active living spaces were excluded from the potential impact area by what Dr Nicolle described as a high use setback (HUS) area. He calculated the HUS as extending to 9m from the centre of the tree. In the opinion of Dr Nicolle, if the private open space and associated residential structures encroach significantly into the HUS this would “increase the risk to safety associated with the tree to an unacceptable level over the long term”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Commissioner erred by not having regard to the terms of PDC 3(a)(ii) and PDC 3(e)(ii) and giving paramountcy to PDC 5. While PDC 5 prohibited division or development of land where that would be likely to result in substantial tree damaging activity, that prohibition cannot be read in isolation from PDC 3(a)(ii) and PDC 3(e)(ii). The latter provisions of the Development Plan permit tree damaging activity where the work is required due to unacceptable risk to public or private safety. The Commissioner also erred by not taking into account that the common law provided a remedy to deal with the safety issue presented by the overhanging limbs. Conclusion Because of those errors I will uphold the appeal against the Commissioner’s decision to dismiss the appeal against the Council’s refusal of the development application. Mr Henry submitted that the Court should make the decision that should have been made by the Commissioner rather than remit the matter for further hearing. While I am concerned to avoid further costs and delay, I will hear from the parties as to whether conditions need to be imposed on the development approval and whether that question should be resolved by this Court or remitted. I will also hear the parties as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The grounds of appeal and also the submissions by Mr Henry SC contended that there were several fundamental errors in the Commissioner’s reasoning. They were, first, the Commissioner had failed to address the common law of nuisance and the remedies available in a court of competent jurisdiction where a tree on a neighbouring property poses undue risk to personal safety and property. Secondly, the Commissioner had failed to adopt the balanced approach required by the Act and Regulations and by the Development Plan when considering the effect of the significant tree on the development proposal. Thirdly, the finding by the Commissioner that the tree poses an unacceptable risk to personal safety should have led him to conclude that it should be removed or subjected to whole of tree pruning rather than his finding that the proposed development should be refused. Mr Henry also submitted that the Commissioner had also erred by failing to decide specifically whether pruning of the tree to the relevant Australian Standard would satisfactorily ameliorate the risk posed to occupants of lot 2. ConsiderationPrivate nuisance The Commissioner did not have any regard to the remedies available in an action for private nuisance to deal with problems caused by trees on neighbouring land. The presence of a tree with branches overhanging a neighbour’s property that causes substantial interference with the use or enjoyment of their land, has long been recognised as giving rise to an action in private nuisance. The neighbour may seek a mandatory injunction from a court of competent jurisdiction against the owner of the land on which the tree is located. Depending upon the facts and circumstances, an injunction might compel the removal of the tree or pruning so as to remove the risk that falling limbs may cause personal injury or damage to property. I accept the correctness of the submission by Mr Henry that there is no rule that a mandatory injunction may only compel pruning back to the boundary of the property. The latter principle applies only to the self-help remedy allowed by the common law whereby overhanging branches may be trimmed without entering the neighbour’s property.[4] Thus, if the evidence in a given case establishes that pruning will not suffice to abate the nuisance, removal of the tree may be ordered. [4] See generally Lemmon v Webb [1895] AC 1. A dispute about removal or pruning of a dangerous tree is a “neighbourhood dispute” and thus a “minor civil claim” for the purposes of the Magistrates Court Act 1991. Mr Henry referred to the decision of the District Court in Bellucco v Netting and Netting on appeal from the Magistrates Court as an example of the approach adopted with respect to neighbourhood disputes arising from the nuisance caused by a tree.[5][5] [2010] SADC 12. I accept the correctness of the submission by Mr Henry that the Commissioner erred by failing to recognise that if “whole of tree” pruning was required in order to mitigate the danger caused by the tree, a remedy in private nuisance was potentially available in the Magistrates Court to ensure that this occurred.