SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Land and Valuation Division: Civil)
STAIKOPOLOUS v CITY OF WEST TORRENS
[2016] SASC 183
Judgment of The Honourable Justice Parker
8 December 2016
ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - TREES, VEGETATION AND HABITAT PROTECTION
ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING - DEVELOPMENT CONTROL - MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION OF CONSENT AUTHORITY - GENERALLY - CONSIDERATION OF DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS - PARTICULAR DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS
ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - COURTS AND TRIBUNALS WITH ENVIRONMENT JURISDICTION - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - SUPREME COURT - ERRORS OF RELEVANT AUTHORITY
Appeal against decision of a Commissioner of the Environment, Resources and Development Court (ERD Court) that dismissed an appeal against a decision of the Development Assessment Panel (DAP) of the City of West Torrens to refuse an application for development approval. The Commissioner held that the proposed land division did not have proper regard to the physical features and conditions on the land arising from the presence of a significant tree on adjacent land.
Appellant’s first ground of appeal is that the Commissioner failed to address the common law of nuisance and the remedies available in a court of competent jurisdiction where a tree on a neighbouring property poses undue risk to personal safety and property. The second ground of appeal is that the Commissioner failed to adopt the balanced approach required by the Act and Regulations and by the Development Plan when considering the effect of the significant tree on the development proposal. The third ground of appeal is that the finding by the Commissioner that the tree poses an unacceptable risk to personal safety should have led him to conclude that it should be removed or subjected to whole of tree pruning rather than his finding that the proposed development should be refused.
Held, per Parker J allowing the appeal:
1) The Commissioner erred by failing to recognise that if “whole of tree” pruning was required in order to mitigate the danger caused by the tree, a remedy in private nuisance was potentially available in the Magistrates Court to ensure that this occurred.
2) The Significant Tree provisions in the Development Plan for the City of West Torrens do not exhibit a bias to tree conservation or appropriate development. The balance between appropriate development and tree damaging activities is achieved by ensuring that approval is only given to tree damaging developments in the circumstances specifically permitted by the Principles of Development Control (PDC).
3) The Commissioner erred by not having regard to the terms of PDC 3(a)(ii) and PDC 3(e)(ii) and giving paramountcy to PDC 5.
Development Act 1993 s4, s5, s33; Development Regulations 2008 reg 6A; Magistrates Court Act 1991 s 10A, referred to.
Lemmon v Webb [1895] AC 1; Bellucco v Netting and Netting [2010] SADC 12; Staikopolous v City of West Torrens [2016] SAERDC 18, considered.
STAIKOPOLOUS v CITY OF WEST TORRENS
[2016] SASC 183Land and Valuation Division: Civil
Parker J: This is an appeal from a decision of a Commissioner of the Environment, Resources…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Staikopolous v City of West Torrens and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] SASC 183
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the Commissioner had erred in dismissing the appeal against the Council's refusal of the development application. The Commissioner failed to consider the remedies available in an action for private nuisance to deal with problems caused by trees on neighbouring land. The court noted that the presence of a tree with branches overhanging a neighbour's property that causes substantial interference with the use or enjoyment of their land, has long been recognised as giving rise to an action in private nuisance. The Commissioner also failed to adopt a balanced approach when considering the effect of the significant tree on the development proposal. The court found that the Commissioner had given paramountcy to PDC 5, which prohibited division or development of land where that would be likely to result in substantial tree damaging activity, but failed to consider the provisions of PDC 3(a)(ii) and PDC 3(e)(ii) which permitted tree damaging activity where the work was required due to unacceptable risk to public or private safety.
The court held that because of these errors, the appeal against the Commissioner’s decision to dismiss the appeal against the Council’s refusal of the development application should be upheld. The court will hear from the parties as to whether conditions need to be imposed on the development approval and whether that question should be resolved by this Court or remitted. The court will also hear the parties as to costs.
The final orders of the court will be made after considering the submissions of the parties on the issues of conditions and costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The grounds of appeal and also the submissions by Mr Henry SC contended that there were several fundamental errors in the Commissioner’s reasoning. They were, first, the Commissioner had failed to address the common law of nuisance and the remedies available in a court of competent jurisdiction where a tree on a neighbouring property poses undue risk to personal safety and property. Secondly, the Commissioner had failed to adopt the balanced approach required by the Act and Regulations and by the Development Plan when considering the effect of the significant tree on the development proposal. Thirdly, the finding by the Commissioner that the tree poses an unacceptable risk to personal safety should have led him to conclude that it should be removed or subjected to whole of tree pruning rather than his finding that the proposed development should be refused. Mr Henry also submitted that the Commissioner had also erred by failing to decide specifically whether pruning of the tree to the relevant Australian Standard would satisfactorily ameliorate the risk posed to occupants of lot 2. ConsiderationPrivate nuisance The Commissioner did not have any regard to the remedies available in an action for private nuisance to deal with problems caused by trees on neighbouring land. The presence of a tree with branches overhanging a neighbour’s property that causes substantial interference with the use or enjoyment of their land, has long been recognised as giving rise to an action in private nuisance. The neighbour may seek a mandatory injunction from a court of competent jurisdiction against the owner of the land on which the tree is located. Depending upon the facts and circumstances, an injunction might compel the removal of the tree or pruning so as to remove the risk that falling limbs may cause personal injury or damage to property. I accept the correctness of the submission by Mr Henry that there is no rule that a mandatory injunction may only compel pruning back to the boundary of the property. The latter principle applies only to the self-help remedy allowed by the common law whereby overhanging branches may be trimmed without entering the neighbour’s property.[4] Thus, if the evidence in a given case establishes that pruning will not suffice to abate the nuisance, removal of the tree may be ordered. [4] See generally Lemmon v Webb [1895] AC 1. A dispute about removal or pruning of a dangerous tree is a “neighbourhood dispute” and thus a “minor civil claim” for the purposes of the Magistrates Court Act 1991. Mr Henry referred to the decision of the District Court in Bellucco v Netting and Netting on appeal from the Magistrates Court as an example of the approach adopted with respect to neighbourhood disputes arising from the nuisance caused by a tree.[5][5] [2010] SADC 12. I accept the correctness of the submission by Mr Henry that the Commissioner erred by failing to recognise that if “whole of tree” pruning was required in order to mitigate the danger caused by the tree, a remedy in private nuisance was potentially available in the Magistrates Court to ensure that this occurred.