Stafford and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ entitlements)

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

Stafford and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ entitlements) [2016] AATA 935 (23 November 2016)

Division

VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION

File Number(s)

2015/0150 

Re

Terry Stafford

APPLICANT

And

Repatriation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Ms N Isenberg, Senior Member 

Date 23 November 2016
Place Sydney

The decision under review is affirmed

.................................[sgd].......................................

Ms N Isenberg, Senior Member

Catchwords

VETERANS’ ENTITLEMENTS – disability pension – special rate  – increase beyond general rate sought — whether war-caused conditions alone render veteran incapable of working more than 8 hours per week – professional skills, qualifications and experience –kinds of remunerative work suitable – impact of mental condition on ability to work –decision under review affirmed.

Legislation

Veterans’ Entitlement Act 1986 (Cth) ss 23, 24, 28, 119(1)(h)

Cases

Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles [2001] NSWCA 305

Chambers v Repatriation Commission [1995] FCA 1144; (1995) 36 ALD 207

Repatriation Commission v Buckingham [1996] FCA 1218

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms N Isenberg, Senior Member

23 November 2016

BACKGROUND

  1. The Applicant, Terry Stafford, served in the Royal Australian Navy from 1972 to 1991, including periods of operational service in Vietnam.  He has a number of medical conditions that have been accepted as related to this service:

    ·Erectile Dysfunction;

    ·Alcohol Dependence;

    ·Generalised Anxiety Disorder;

    ·Sensorineural Hearing Loss;

    ·Tinnitus;

    ·Asbestos-Related Pleural Disease;

    ·Chronic Emphysema; and

    ·Osteoarthritis affecting both knees.

  2. In addition, he has a number of non-accepted disabilities:

    ·Varicose Veins;

    ·Bilateral Sensorineural Hearing Loss;

    ·Varicose Veins of the Left Leg;

    ·Varicose Veins of the Right Leg;

    ·Sleep Apnoea;

    ·Diabetes Mellitus;

    ·Internal Derangement of the Right Knee;

    ·Internal Derangement of the Left Knee; and

    ·Osteoarthritis affecting both ankles.

  3. In applications to the Repatriation Commission dated 15 May 2013 and 14 June 2013, Mr Stafford sought an increase in his pension beyond the General Rate in respect of his accepted disabilities – specifically, he seeks the Special Rate of pension.  His applications were refused.  His application for review to the Veterans’ Review Board was also refused.  He now seeks review by this Tribunal. 

    Criteria for the Special Rate

  4. The special rate criteria are set out in s 24 of the Veterans’ Entitlement Act 1986 (Cth) (VEA).  That section provides, in part:

    Special rate of pension

    (1)  This section applies to a veteran if:

    … and

    (a)    either:

    (i)the degree of incapacity of the veteran from war-caused injury or war-caused disease, or both, is determined under section 21A to be at least 70% or has been so determined by a determination that is in force; or

    (ii)the veteran is, because he or she has suffered or is suffering from pulmonary tuberculosis, receiving or entitled to receive a pension at the general rate; and

    (b)the veteran is totally and permanently incapacitated, that is to say, the veteran's incapacity from war-caused injury or war-caused disease, or both, is of such a nature as, of itself alone, to render the veteran incapable of undertaking remunerative work for periods aggregating more than 8 hours per week; and

    (c)the veteran is, by reason of incapacity from that war-caused injury or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stafford and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ entitlements... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 935
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by a veteran seeking an increase in his disability pension beyond the general rate. The veteran contended that his war-caused conditions alone rendered him incapable of working more than eight hours per week. The Repatriation Commission opposed this claim. The decision was made by Ms N Isenberg, Senior Member.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the veteran's incapacity from his accepted war-caused conditions, viewed in isolation, was sufficient to prevent him from undertaking remunerative work for more than eight hours per week, as required by section 24(1)(b) of the *Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986* (Cth). This required an assessment of the veteran's professional skills, qualifications, and experience, and the kinds of remunerative work he might reasonably undertake, considering his physical and mental capacity.

The Tribunal considered medical evidence from the veteran's treating psychiatrist, Dr Koller, who opined that the veteran was "unemployable" due to a combination of psychological and physical problems, describing the veteran as "kaput." However, the Tribunal also noted evidence from the veteran's GP, Dr Shah, who stated that the veteran's varicose veins were resolved and did not contribute to his inability to work, identifying "deep anxiety and stress" as the main reason for his inability to work. The Tribunal applied the principle that the assessment of remunerative work capacity must consider the veteran's skills, qualifications, and experience broadly, not limited to past employment, and that the incapacity must arise from war-caused conditions alone.

Having determined that the veteran's war-caused conditions, viewed in isolation, did not meet the threshold for incapacity to work more than eight hours per week, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review. It was therefore unnecessary to consider further criteria for an increased pension.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In relation to his varicose veins, the veteran said they were a problem for many years and he received a number of treatments, the last of which was in 2011. In 2013, Dr Shah said that his veins had been treated and were not an ongoing problem. He said he no longer suffers any pain from them. The veteran, however, said that, currently, some aching has gradually returned. MEDICAL EVIDENCE Dr Karl Koller, the Applicant’s treating psychiatrist Dr Koller has been the veteran’s treating psychiatrist since 2006 and, the veteran said, he sees him every 3-4 months, although Dr Koller thought it was between every month to 3 months. On 27 March 2012 Dr Koller certified the veteran as unfit for work until 10 April 2012 due to his unspecified ‘service-related disabilities’. Similarly, on 9 May 2012 he certified the veteran as ‘unemployable’ due to his unspecified ‘service-related disabilities.’ Again, on 12 June 2013 Dr Koller described the veteran as ‘unemployable’ and noted that his varicose veins had been surgically removed in 2011 and he had used a sleep mask since 2010. Dr Koller wrote in his reports dated 22 and 23 July 2015 that he certified the veteran as unemployable in 2012. He first provided the veteran with medical leave after which he returned to work. When the veteran returned to work he could not manage, and Dr Koller concluded that he was unemployable. He repeated his view in relation to varicose veins and sleep apnoea. In a further report dated 25 May 2016 Dr Koller again repeated his view about sleep apnoea and varicose veins. He noted that the veteran’s osteoarthritis of his knees had been accepted and said that the previous reference to ‘internal derangement of knees’ was not to be regarded as fundamentally different to osteoarthritis because they both related to pathology inside the [knee] joints. In his evidence Dr Koller said he gave the veteran some time off as a test and then, when the veteran was unable to cope on his return to work, he ‘rendered the veteran unemployable’ because of a combination of his psychological and physical problems. When asked to elaborate, Dr Koller was adamant that it was the combination of his depression, anxiety, irritability, pain in the knees, poor hearing, pleural plaques, emphysema – the ‘totality of his symptoms’. As to the substantial reason for the veteran’s cessation of work, Dr Koller passionately re-iterated that it was both his psychological and his physical symptoms that made him unemployable, and described the veteran as ‘kaput’. He forthrightly referred many times during his evidence to the veteran’s ‘multitude’ of medical problems. He said that ‘after 10 years he came to the view that the veteran was unemployable’ (although, it is observed, that by 2012 he had been seeing the veteran for only 6 years), and became agitated, even with the veteran’s counsel, that his clinical assessment of the veteran may be questioned. Dr Koller was unperturbed by Dr Smith’s alternative diagnosis of adjustment disorder with anxious mood, and ‘entirely agreed’ with this as an alternative diagnosis.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having come to that view, it is unnecessary for me to consider the remaining criteria.DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In a report dated 14 February 2013, Dr Sanjiv Shah, the veteran’s GP stated that the Applicant’s varicose veins had been treated and were resolved and “do not contribute to his being unable to work”. Dr Shah considered that the main reason for veteran’s inability to work was ‘deep anxiety and stress’.CONSIDERATION The legislation requires that the material before the Tribunal must satisfy a number of tests. Firstly, the Applicant's degree of incapacity from war-caused conditions must be at least 70% of the General Rate: s 24(1)(a) of the VEA. There was no dispute that Mr Stafford met this test. Next, s 24(1)(b) of the VEA requires that an Applicant's incapacity from war-caused conditions, must be of such a nature as, of itself alone, to render him incapable of undertaking remunerative work for more than 8 hours a week. This does not require an examination of other causes that might render him unable to undertake remunerative work, but merely whether the war-caused disabilities, on their own, are sufficient to render him incapable of undertaking such work. Section 28 provides assistance in determining whether a veteran is incapable of undertaking remunerative work, by setting out the only matters that regard can be had to in deciding that question.What are Mr Stafford’s trade and professional skills, qualifications and experience? Section 24(1)(b) requires an examination of the veteran’s capacity to undertake any remunerative work which the veteran is physically and mentally able to carry out; the test is not limited to the type of work previously undertaken or for which the veteran is qualified by training or experience: Chambersv Repatriation Commission [1995] FCA 1144; (1995) 36 ALD 207 , where the Court said (at [47]):A person's skills are not confined to those acquired in formal training or by virtue of experience in particular employment. They include innate aptitude for tasks and abilities acquired or developed independently of employment or training. For example, a person may never have used computers at work and have no formal computer training. If that person has self-taught word processing skills, he or she nonetheless has skills that may well enhance opportunities for remunerative work. Similarly "qualifications" means (Oxford Shorter Dictionary and Macquarie Dictionary) "a quality or accomplishment which qualifies or fits a person for some office or function". The word is not confined to qualifications obtained as the result of formal training or work experience. Again, a person's experience is not necessarily restricted to that acquired in employment or formal training. From the Applicant’s evidence and from the history taken by Dr Chase, his Navy work involved engineering activities for 13 years, with another 7 years in the military police. In his subsequent civilian career since 1991, he worked in roles in hygiene services and as a truck driver. His last work was as a pest control technician. What kinds of remunerative work might a person with Mr Stafford’s skills, qualifications and experience reasonably undertake?