St Vincent's Hospital Toowoomba Ltd v Hardy

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

[1997] QCA 364

URT OF APPEAL

NCUS JA
YNIHAN J

BROSE J

peal No 7477 of 1997

VINCENT'S HOSPITAL TOOWOOMBA LTD Appellant/Defendant

d

TTE HARDY Respondent/Plaintiff
ISBANE
DATE 22/09/97

DGMENT
NCUS JA: This is an application for leave to appeal
ainst a judgment of the District Court being one given by
s Honour Judge McGill. The Judge was confronted with an
tion based upon common law negligence and breach of
atutory duty for damages for injuries suffered when a lady
s climbing steps in a hospital and fell.
e judgment was in the vicinity of $20,000 and that amount
es not entitle the applicant to an appeal. Under the
e-existing law it would have been necessary to establish

rtain conditions before leave could be given but that has

en altered by the Courts Reform Amendment Act 1997. That

serts the new section 118 into the District Courts Act

67 and it is unnecessary, as it seems to me, to read it

t in full. The relevant part of it gives this Court power

give leave to appeal in a discretionary way, not being

und by the necessity of finding that there is any

portant question of law or justice involved.

question arose as to whether the new provision applies

re. That seems to be answered by section 138 of the

strict Courts Act, which was inserted by section 50 of the

97 Act. The new section 138 has the effect that in
lation to matters in which an application for leave to
peal was made before the commencement of the 1997 Act the
d law applies. The 1997 Act came into force on 1 August
97 and this application was made on 22 August 1997,
erefore the transitional provision does not catch this.
e implication is, as it seems to me, that the new
ovision applies, giving this Court a general discretion to
ant leave under section 118(3) and the Court is not
hibited by the test which would have been previously
plicable.

the reasons of the primary judge which, in my respectful

inion, are commendable for their care and
mprehensiveness, His Honour, as I understand the matter,
ve judgment for the plaintiff on the basis of common law
gligence and breach of statutory duty. The breach of

atutory duty relied on was a breach of section 9 of the

rkplace Health and Safety Act 1989 which provides that "an

ployer who fails to ensure the health and safety at work

all his employees, save where it is not practicable for

m to do so, commits an offence against this Act". That
ovision has been held by this Court (on a concession,
tually) to impose a duty in respect of which a civil

tion could be brought. The 1989 Act has, in fact, been

pealed by the Workplace Health and Safety Act 1995. No

ubt there may well be actions still to be heard or appeals

ill to be heard, relating to the old law.

e criticisms…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read St Vincent's Hospital Toowoomba Ltd v Hardy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1997] QCA 364
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the appeal St Vincent's Hospital Toowoomba Ltd v Hardy, the appellant, St Vincent's Hospital Toowoomba Ltd, sought leave to appeal a District Court judgment that awarded the respondent, Ms Hardy, approximately $20,000 in damages for injuries sustained from a fall on hospital stairs. The case involved allegations of common law negligence and breach of statutory duty under the Workplace Health and Safety Act 1989. The District Court had found in favour of the respondent on both grounds, leading to the hospital's appeal for leave to contest the judgment.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the new statutory provision allowing discretionary leave to appeal applied to the case, and if the District Court's judgment contained errors warranting an appeal. The new provision, introduced by the Courts Reform Amendment Act 1997, altered the criteria for granting leave to appeal by removing the requirement to establish specific conditions. Additionally, the court needed to assess the validity of the criticisms made by the hospital's representative concerning the primary judge's interpretation of negligence and statutory duty.

The Court of Appeal determined that the new statutory provision did indeed apply to this case, as the application for leave was made after the commencement of the 1997 Act. The court acknowledged that the District Court's judgment, while thorough, may have raised arguable points concerning the interpretation of negligence and statutory duty. However, given the relatively modest amount of damages awarded and the arguable nature of the criticisms, the court found that leave should be granted. The decision was influenced by the potential for broader implications regarding the interpretation of statutory duty under the Workplace Health and Safety Act 1989, and the unusual outcome of compensating for an injury sustained while performing an everyday activity.

The Court of Appeal granted leave to appeal, finding that the application met the criteria under the new statutory provision. The appeal was allowed, and the costs of the application were to be borne by the appellant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established