St Mary's Hog's Pty Ltd v HBCA Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

St Mary’s Hog’s Pty Ltd v HBCA Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 52

File number: NSD 351 of 2021
Judgment of: MARKOVIC J
Date of judgment: 4 February 2022
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – applications for security for costs – whether applicants impecunious – where respondents’ likely costs exceed applicants’ net assets – where insufficient evidence of the ability and willingness of group members to contribute to security if ordered – where lack of evidence about availability of current franchisees’ assets to meet any security for costs order – whether applicants’ proceeding is defensive in nature – where respondents commenced proceedings in local and state courts regarding debt claim for unpaid royalties – where applicants’ pleading raises matters beyond scope of debt claim – application granted
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 1335

Federal Court of Australia Act1976 (Cth) ss 33ZG, 43(1A), 56

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 19.01

Cases cited:

Abbott v Zoetis Australia Pty Limited (No 2) [2019] FCA 462; (2019) 369 ALR 512

Australian Battery Distributors Pty Ltd v Robert Bosch (Australia) Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 1164

Clarence City Council v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2020] FCAFC 147

Knight v Beyond Properties Pty Ltd [2005] FCA 764

KP Cable Investments Pty Ltd v Meltglow Pty Ltd (1995) 56 FCR 189

Madgwick v Kelly (2013) 212 FCR 1

Monarch Advisory Group Pty Ltd v Puxty [2021] FCA 341

Prynew Pty Ltd v Nemeth [2010] NSWCA 94; (2010) 28 ACLC 10-026

Visco v Minter [1969] 2 All ER 714

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 155
Date of hearing: 10 September 2021
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr T D Castle SC and Mr E L Olivier
Solicitor for the Applicants: Keypoint Law
Counsel for the First and Third Respondents: Mr S Ivantsoff
Solicitor for the First and Third Respondents: Finn Roache Lawyers
Counsel for the Second, Fourth and Fifth Respondents Mr J K S Entwisle
Solicitor for the Second, Fourth and Fifth Respondents Thomson Geer Lawyers
Counsel for the Sixth Respondent Mr J Hogan-Doran SC and Ms R Thrift
Solicitor for the Sixth Respondent Tucker & Cowen Solicitors

ORDERS

NSD 351 of 2021
BETWEEN:

ST MARY'S HOG’S PTY LTD

First Applicant

MR LUKE BERNARD GOODWIN

Second Applicant

MR TODD ADAM BLACKSTOCK

Third Applicant

AND:

HBCA PTY LTD ABN 75 07 132 655

First Respondent

MR ALFRED BRETT DRYLAND

Second Respondent

MR ROSS MURRAY WORTH (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

MARKOVIC J

DATE OF ORDER:

4 FEBRUARY 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicants are to provide security for the costs of the first and third respondents in the form of a bank guarantee or payment into Court as follows:

(a)$102,668 within 30 days of the date of these Orders;

(b)$542,638 within 30 days from the date of filing and service of the first and third respondents’ defences;

(c)$134,671…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read St Mary's Hog's Pty Ltd v HBCA Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 52
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

St Mary's Hog's Pty Ltd was the applicant in a proceeding brought against it by six respondents. The proceeding involved a dispute over unpaid royalties and advertising fund contributions in relation to the Hog's Breath Café franchise system. The respondents applied for an order that the applicants provide security for the respondents' costs of the proceeding. The applicants opposed the applications for security for costs. The court was required to decide whether the applicants were impecunious, whether the applicants' proceeding was defensive in nature, and whether the applicants' net assets were sufficient to cover the likely costs of the proceeding.

The court found that the applicants' proceeding was defensive in nature as it raised matters beyond the scope of the debt claim. The court also found that the applicants' net assets were insufficient to cover the likely costs of the proceeding. The court noted that the applicants had not provided sufficient evidence of the ability and willingness of group members to contribute to security if ordered, or of the availability of current franchisees' assets to meet any security for costs order. The court held that the applicants were impecunious and granted the applications for security for costs. The court ordered that the applicants provide security in the form of a bank guarantee or payment into Court in tranches at various stages of the proceeding. The court also ordered that the proceeding be stayed until such time as the security was paid and that the applicants pay the respondents' costs of the applications for security for costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicants are to provide security for the costs of the first and third respondents in the form of a bank guarantee or payment into Court as follows:

(a) $102,668 within 30 days of the date of these Orders;

(b) $542,638 within 30 days from the date of filing and service of the first and third respondents’ defences;

(c) $134,671 at least 30 days before the date the proceeding is fixed for mediation; and

(d) $455,589 at least 30 days before the first day fixed for the final hearing of the proceeding.

2. The proceeding against the first and third respondents be stayed until such time as the security in Order 1(a) above is paid.

3. The first and third respondents have liberty to apply on five days’ notice for any stay should the applicants fail to pay security in accordance with Order 1(b), (c) and/or (d) above.

4. The applicants are to provide security for the costs of the second, fourth and fifth respondents in the form of a bank guarantee or payment into Court as follows:

(a) $17,850 within 30 days of the date of these Orders;

(b) $41,930 within 30 days from the date of filing and service of any reply by the applicants; and

(c) $118,650 within 30 days of the service of the parties’ evidence.

5. The proceeding against the second, fourth and fifth respondents be stayed until such time as the security in Order 4(a) above is paid.

6. The second, fourth and fifth respondents have liberty to apply on five days’ notice for any stay should the applicants fail to pay security in accordance with Orders 4(b) and/or (c) above.

7. The applicants are to provide security for the costs of the sixth respondent in the form of a bank guarantee, payment into Court or other form of security as agreed between the applicants and the sixth respondent as follows:

(a) $107,848 within 30 days of the date of these Orders;

(b) $228,047 within 30 days of the date on which the sixth respondent files its defence; and

(c) $184,366 within 30 days of the close of evidence or the conclusion of any mediation, whichever is the later.

8. The proceeding against the sixth respondent be stayed until such time as the security in Order 7(a) above is paid.

9. The sixth respondent have liberty to apply on five days’ notice for any stay should the applicants fail to pay security in accordance with Order 7(b) and/or (c) above.

10. The applicants pay:

(a) the first and third respondents’ costs of the interlocutory application filed by them on 24 August 2021 seeking security for their costs;

(b) the second, fourth and fifth respondents’ costs of the interlocutory application filed by them on 24 August 2021 seeking security for their costs; and

(c) the sixth respondent’s costs of the interlocutory application filed by it on 23 August 2021 seeking security for its costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

No orders have yet been made for the filing of defences. THE EVIDENCE Each of the respondents and the applicants relied on a number of affidavits. I set out below a summary of their evidence.The Franchise System Ginger White and Donald Algie are the directors of HBCM and the founders of the Franchise System. They opened the first Hog’s Breath Café in Airlie Beach, Queensland in 1989 and franchised the business at various locations throughout Australia and New Zealand. HBCA was the franchisor of the Franchise System from about 2000 to October 2020. HBCA has different directors and shareholders to HBCM. The current director of HBCA is Mr Worth. In September 2005 a franchise system and development management agreement (FSDMA) was entered into by HBC, a company of which Ms White and Mr Algie are directors, and HBCA pursuant to which HBC granted HBCA a licence to use the intellectual property of the Franchise System and to grant franchises in Australia and New Zealand for the duration of that agreement. In 2020 a dispute arose between HBC and HBCA. HBC alleged that HBCA had committed various breaches of the FSDMA and that it was entitled to terminate the FSDMA. HBCA disputed those allegations. In October 2020 that dispute was resolved and HBCA sold certain assets of the Hog’s Breath Café franchisor business to HBCM. On 30 October 2020 HBCA and HBCM entered into a deed of assignment of franchise agreement pursuant to which HBCA assigned its right, title and interest in the Franchise Agreements of the Franchise System to HBCM. The applicants dispute the validity of the assignment (see [6(12)] above). However, HBCA says that as a result the assignment from 30 October 2020:(1)it has no ongoing interest or right to operate the Franchise System; (2)HBCM is the franchisor of the Franchising System and, from November 2020, is entitled to receive royalties and advertising fund contributions from franchisees;(3)it retains the right to recover any royalties owing for the month of October 2020 from franchisees; and(4)advertising fund contributions owing by franchisees prior to 30 October 2020 were assigned to HBCM. As at 31 July 2021 there were 45 stores in the Franchise System. The total gross sales of all stores in the Franchise System for the six months prior to 31 July 2021 was approximately:(1)February 2021 - $6,222,575;(2)March 2021 - $6,559,204;(3)April 2021 - $7,230,494;(4)May 2021 - $7,214,589; (5)June 2021 - $6,031,132; and(6)July 2021 - $5,883,405. The plant and equipment for a Hog’s Breath Café would typically include equipment such as a kitchen, bar and refrigerator, office supplies, POS system, audio visual media, lighting and security, fit-out, furniture and flooring, memorabilia, painting and signage. According to Ms White:(1)under each Franchise Agreement, the franchisee is required to make monthly contributions to the national advertising fund for each month by the 15th of the following month; and(2)as at 30 June 2021, a total of approximately $725,170 is owing by 28 franchisees for advertising fund contributions that became due prior to 30 October 2020. This includes approximately $39,413.38 owing by St Mary’s Hog.The applicantsSt Mary’s Hog’s

Decision

Reasons for decision

I have some difficulty applying the principles enunciated in Clarence City Council to the application before me. There the Full Court was considering the question of costs at the conclusion of the appeals when all issues had been identified and fully ventilated. It did so based on the history of the proceeding and the issues that arose for determination on the appeals. Here, for the reasons I have already given, I am satisfied that the respondents are entitled to their separate representation as presently constituted, having regard to the nature of the claims made and the relationships between them. CONCLUSION For those reasons I will make the orders sought by the respondents for payment of security for their costs of the proceeding in the amounts and in the tranches sought by the respondents in each case, albeit with some variation to align the timing of payment and the event which triggers payment of each tranche, orders staying the proceeding until such time as the first tranche of security is paid and for liberty to apply for appropriate orders in the event that subsequent tranches of security are not paid. As the respondents have been successful in their respective applications, the applicants should pay their costs of the applications for security for costs. I will make orders accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.