ST CLAIR v POLICE
[2000] SASC 290
Magistrate’s Appeal
1................ MARTIN J......... (Ex tempore) The appellant pleaded guilty to a charge that on 24 November 1999 she assaulted her daughter, Rebecca St Clair, a person under the age of 12 years, thereby occasioning her actual bodily harm contrary to s 40 of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935. She pleaded guilty before a Magistrate on 14 December 1999. A sentence of two years imprisonment was imposed and a non-parole period of five months was fixed. The appellant appeals against the sentence on the basis that it is manifestly excessive and should have been suspended.
On the morning of the offence, the appellant was in the kitchen of her home with her two daughters aged five and four years. Her de facto was asleep in the house. The appellant was preparing the girls for school. They were asking for their breakfast. The appellant began to run a bath. Subsequently she placed the younger child Rebecca in the top loading area of a washing machine in the laundry and turned the hot water on the child. As a result, Rebecca sustained severe burns to her torso, both legs and her right arm. A neighbour heard screams and a conversation which included abuse being yelled at the child. The neighbour called the police.
When the police attended the appellant declined to admit them into the premises. In an unsophisticated fashion, she attempted to evade responsibility for her actions. She referred to the child having fallen in the bath and being burnt. Police later re-visited the premises with a social worker. The child was observed to be in distress with large pieces of skin peeling off her body. The appellant subsequently acknowledged having been responsible. The injuries will require skin grafting.
Prior to sentencing, the children had been removed from the custody of the appellant. She has had supervised access for a short period each week with both children and the Department of Family and Youth Services has been undertaking work with a psychologist in that regard.
The Magistrate had the assistance of a pre-sentence report from the Department of Correctional Services, as well as reports from Dr Craig Raeside and Mr Richard Balfour. Both reports gave extensive detail of the appellant’s history. The appellant is a single woman now aged 42 years. She was receiving a disability pension. She has had a most unfortunate background which included domestic violence when she was a child. She has been a slow developer who experienced difficulties with literacy and learning. She has been diagnosed as suffering an intellectual disability with an intelligent quotient of 55, which places her in the moderately disabled range. She would appear to be well below the lowest five per cent of the population so far as intelligence is concerned. She is vulnerable to crisis and at risk of impulsive and immature behaviour when under stress. The appellant has been prone to binge alcohol abuse as well as depression. She has been…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read St Clair v Police No. Scgrg-00-562 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] SASC 290
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide whether the sentence was manifestly excessive and should have been suspended. The Magistrate had regarded the issue of general deterrence as a “paramount” factor and he referred to it as a “dominant consideration” in imposing sentence. However, the court found that the Magistrate overlooked the principle discussed in a number of authorities, including R v Wiskich [2000] SASC 640, which recognises that in some circumstances the element of general deterrence, while remaining relevant, should be given less weight by reason of an offender’s mental impairment or disability. In the words of some authorities, the impact of the element of general deterrence is to be “sensibly moderated” as part of the exercise of balancing the gravity of the crime and the matters personal to the offender. The court found that the failure of the Magistrate to refer to the relevant principle when considered in conjunction with his Honour’s emphasis on the importance of general deterrence demonstrated a sentencing error of such significance as to justify a review of the sentence by the Court. However, the court found that the sentence of two years imprisonment was well within the range of the Magistrate’s sentencing discretion and that, notwithstanding all the matters of mitigation personal to the appellant, a sentence of two years imprisonment was the appropriate sentence. The court found that the sentence should be suspended upon the condition that the appellant enter into a bond to be of good behaviour for a period of 18 months. The bond will be in the amount of $500. It will be a condition of the bond that the appellant be under the supervision of an officer of the Department of Correctional Services for the period of the bond. It will be a further condition of the bond that the appellant obey the lawful directions given to her by the supervising community corrections officer. The appeal was allowed and the sentence of two years imprisonment and the non-parole period of five months were set aside.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi