SS Family Pty Ltd v WorkCover Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

SS Family Pty Ltd v WorkCover Queensland [2018] QCA 296

PARTIES:

SS FAMILY PTY LTD
ACN 117 147 449
(applicant)
v
WORKCOVER QUEENSLAND
ABN 40 577 162756
(first respondent)
MILJAN STANKOVIC
(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 5285 of 2018
DC No 3948 of 2016

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Application for Leave s 118 DCA (Civil)

ORIGINATING COURT:


District Court at Brisbane – [2018] QDC 54 (Porter QC DCJ)

DELIVERED ON:

30 October 2018

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

12 October 2018

JUDGES:

Sofronoff P and Fraser JA and Davis J

ORDERS:

1.   Application for leave to appeal is granted.

2.   The appeal is dismissed with costs.

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – INSURANCE AND LEVIES – LIABILITY OF INSURERS AND STATUTORY AUTHORITIES – GENERALLY – where the second respondent applied for compensation but did not tick the box which would have identified him as a trustee at the time of the injury – where the first respondent, WorkCover, allowed his application for lump sum compensation under chapter 3 of the Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld) – where the second respondent elected to seek damages under chapter 5 of the Act – where WorkCover now denies that it is obliged to indemnify the applicant employer on the ground that the second respondent was not a “worker” at the material time as he performed his work under a contract of service with a trust of which he was a trustee – where the applicant applied for orders striking out the allegations in WorkCover’s amended defence denying its obligation to indemnify the applicant – where the primary judge rejected this application – whether an insurer’s decision to allow an application for compensation by a person claiming to have been a worker who sustained an injury in the course of working for an employer precludes the insurer from subsequently contending that the person was not a worker as a ground for denying that the alleged employer is entitled to an indemnity against legal liability for damages for the injury

Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld), s 8, s 134, s 233, s 237

COUNSEL:

R Douglas QC, with K Holyoak, for the applicant
G Diehm QC, with C Harding, for the first respondent

SOLICITORS:

Barry Nilsson for the applicant
DWF (Australia) for the first respondent
Slater & Gordon for the second respondent

  1. SOFRONOFF P:  I agree with the reasons of Fraser JA and the orders his Honour proposes.

  2. FRASER JA:  The appeal from a decision in the District Court which the applicant seeks leave to bring would turn upon the proper construction of provisions of the Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld).[1]

    [1]All references to the Act are to the version that was current as at 14 August 2012.

  3. The applicant expressed the question in the proposed appeal as follows:

    If the First Respondent determines that a person is a worker to whom compensation is payable under chapters 3 and 4 of the Workers’ Compensation…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SS Family Pty Ltd v WorkCover Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QCA 296
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of SS Family Pty Ltd v WorkCover Queensland, the applicant employer sought to compel the insurer, WorkCover Queensland, to indemnify it against the legal liability for damages claimed by a former employee who had been a trustee of a trust at the time of his injury. The insurer had previously allowed the former employee’s application for compensation under chapter 3 of the Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld). However, WorkCover now contended that the former employee was not a “worker” within the meaning of the Act, as he performed his work under a contract of service with a trust of which he was a trustee, and therefore, WorkCover was not obliged to indemnify the applicant employer against the former employee’s damages claim. The primary judge rejected the applicant’s application to strike out the insurer’s defence, which denied its obligation to indemnify the applicant employer against the former employee’s damages claim. The applicant sought to appeal the primary judge’s decision, arguing that the insurer’s decision to allow the former employee’s compensation application precluded the insurer from later contending that the former employee was not a worker as a ground for denying the applicant employer’s entitlement to an indemnity against legal liability for damages for the injury.

The court was required to decide whether an insurer’s decision to allow an application for compensation by a person claiming to have been a worker who sustained an injury in the course of working for an employer precluded the insurer from subsequently contending that the person was not a worker as a ground for denying that the alleged employer is entitled to an indemnity against legal liability for damages for the injury. The court considered the relevant provisions of the Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld), particularly the definition of “worker” and the distinction between the insurer’s obligation to pay compensation to a worker and its obligation to indemnify an employer against legal liability for damages claimed by a worker. The court held that the differences between the insurer’s obligations in relation to compensation and damages claims meant that the definition of “worker” should not be extended beyond the subject matter of compensation claims to affect the insurer’s obligation to indemnify an employer against legal liability for damages.

The court found that the applicant’s argument was not supported by the relevant provisions of the Act. The court held that the insurer’s decision to allow the former employee’s compensation application did not preclude the insurer from later contending that the former employee was not a worker as a ground for denying the applicant employer’s entitlement to an indemnity against legal liability for damages for the injury. The court dismissed the applicant’s appeal and granted leave to appeal, but dismissed the appeal with costs. The court’s decision emphasised the importance of distinguishing between the insurer’s obligations in relation to compensation and damages claims and the need to interpret the Act in a way that does not extend the effect of determinations implicit in an insurer’s decision to allow compensation beyond the subject matter of compensation claims.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Application for leave to appeal is granted.

2. The appeal is dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

I would grant leave to appeal because the issue raised in the proposed appeal is of some importance to workers, employers, insurers and others and the proposed appeal is arguable. Before discussing the issue it is useful to refer to the facts and some important provisions of the Act.Background Section 108(1) in chapter 3 of the Act provides that compensation is payable under the Act for an injury sustained by a worker. Section 46(1) in chapter 2 imposes legal liability upon an employer for compensation for injury sustained by a worker employed by the employer. The word “compensation” is defined in s 9 to mean (so far as is directly relevant) “compensation under this Act, that is, amounts for a worker’s injury payable under chapters 3 and 4 by an insurer to a worker”. Section 48 obliges employers to maintain accident insurance against injury sustained by workers employed by the employer, both for the employer’s legal liability for compensation and for the employer’s legal liability for damages. “Accident insurance” is defined in s 8 as meaning “insurance by which an employer is indemnified against all amounts for which the employer may become legally liable, for injury sustained by a worker employed by the employer for – (a) compensation; and (b) damages”. The applicant held accident insurance with the first respondent (“WorkCover”). The word worker is used in each of those sections and in many other places in the Act. Section 11(1) defines “worker” as “a person who works under a contract of service”. That definition is qualified in various ways, including by the provision in s 11(3) that schedule 2, part 2, sets out who is “not a worker in particular circumstances.” Relevantly to this matter, under item 1(b) of schedule 2, part 2, a person is not a worker if the person performs work under a contract of service with a trust of which the person is a trustee. The second respondent applied for compensation. In the claim form the second respondent stated that he sustained an injury when he was a worker employed by the applicant. He did not tick the box which would have identified him as a trustee at the time of the injury. Section 134 of the Act obliges the employer’s insurer to make a decision allowing or rejecting a claimant’s application for compensation. That section provides:“134 Decision about application for compensation(1)A claimant’s application for compensation must be allowed or rejected in the first instance by the insurer.(2)The insurer must make a decision on the application within 20 business days after the application is made.(3)The insurer must notify the claimant of its decision on the application.(4)If the insurer rejects the application, the insurer must also, when giving the claimant notice of its decision, give the claimant written reasons for the decision and the information prescribed under a regulation.(5)Subsection (6) applies if the insurer does not make a decision on the application within the time stated in subsection (2).(6)The insurer must, within 5 business days after the end of the time stated in subsection (2), notify the claimant of its reasons for not making the decision and that the claimant may have the claimant’s application reviewed under chapter 13.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The second respondent applied for compensation. In the claim form the second respondent stated that he sustained an injury when he was a worker employed by the applicant. He did not tick the box which would have identified him as a trustee at the time of the injury. Section 134 of the Act obliges the employer’s insurer to make a decision allowing or rejecting a claimant’s application for compensation. That section provides:“134 Decision about application for compensation(1)A claimant’s application for compensation must be allowed or rejected in the first instance by the insurer.(2)The insurer must make a decision on the application within 20 business days after the application is made.(3)The insurer must notify the claimant of its decision on the application.(4)If the insurer rejects the application, the insurer must also, when giving the claimant notice of its decision, give the claimant written reasons for the decision and the information prescribed under a regulation.(5)Subsection (6) applies if the insurer does not make a decision on the application within the time stated in subsection (2).(6)The insurer must, within 5 business days after the end of the time stated in subsection (2), notify the claimant of its reasons for not making the decision and that the claimant may have the claimant’s application reviewed under chapter 13.” WorkCover notified the second respondent that it had allowed his application for compensation. That decision implies that for the purpose of the second respondent’s entitlement to compensation WorkCover accepted that the second respondent sustained an injury when he was a worker employed by the applicant. Under part 10 of chapter 3 of the Act, a worker may become entitled to compensation for permanent impairment. Pursuant to sections 179 and 183, WorkCover assessed the second respondent as having a permanent impairment, with a work related impairment (“WRI”) of less than 20 per cent. He was offered lump sum compensation to which he was entitled under s 180. WorkCover gave the second respondent the notice of assessment required by s 185 of the Act. Consistently with the Act, WorkCover stated that the second respondent needed to decide whether he agreed or disagreed with the assessment of the degree of permanent impairment in the notice of assessment, if he agreed with the assessment of permanent impairment he needed to make a decision about the offer of lump sum compensation within 20 business days, and under the Act WorkCover must stop paying his weekly compensation benefits and medical expenses upon the earlier of him notifying WorkCover of his decision about the offer of lump sum compensation or 20 business days after he received the notice of assessment containing the offer. The second respondent subsequently elected to sue the applicant. He issued proceedings against the applicant in the District Court claiming damages for personal injury for breach of duty in tort and contract. Chapter 5 of the Act extensively regulates aspects of claims by a “worker” for damages for “injury”. That regulation includes provision in part 5 of chapter 5 for certain pre-proceeding procedures, which commence with the claimant giving a notice of claim under s 275(1). The effect of subsections 189(6) and (7) was that, if the second respondent had not previously given WorkCover a notice electing to reject WorkCover’s offer of lump sum compensation, he was taken to have rejected lump sum compensation when he gave his notice of claim. An effect of s 239 in chapter 5 of the Act is that the second respondent was not entitled to both payment of the lump sum compensation and damages for the injury.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The applicant applied for orders including an order striking out the allegations in WorkCover’s further amended defence which deny and allege it is entitled to deny indemnity on the ground that the second respondent was not a “worker” when he sustained injury. The primary judge rejected the applicant’s construction of the Act and dismissed its application accordingly. It is that order against which the applicant seeks to appeal.Consideration The applicant claims that WorkCover is liable under the statutory accident insurance to indemnify the applicant against legal liability for damages sought to be established by the second respondent. Section 8 of the Act relevantly confines the indemnity under that insurance to a case in which an employer may become legally liable for compensation or damages in respect of injury sustained by a “worker” employed by the employer. The effect of s 32A of the Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld) is that the definition of “worker” must be applied except so far as the context or subject matter otherwise indicates or requires. Accordingly the task for the applicant is to identify an indication or requirement in some relevant context or subject matter that the definition of “worker” does not apply to that word in s 8. In deciding whether or not there is some such indication or requirement in the Act, it is necessary to bear in mind the differences between the insurer’s obligation to pay compensation to a worker and its obligation to indemnify an employer against legal liability for damages claimed by a worker. Section 8 describes the statutory accident insurance both in relation to compensation and in relation to legal liability for damages claims, but they are quite different heads of liability. A worker’s rights in relation to compensation derive from the Act and are regulated in chapters 3 and 4. Those chapters give effect to the objects summarised in s 5(1)(a) of “providing benefits for workers who sustain injury in their employment, for dependants if a worker’s injury results in the worker’s death, for persons other than workers, and for other benefits”. Damages claims are regulated by a different part of the Act, chapter 5, which has very different objects. Chapter 5 does not create any entitlement for workers or their dependants. Instead it extensively limits the common law rights of persons to seek damages for injuries sustained by a worker. This chapter gives effect to the object expressed in s 5(4)(c) of providing “for the protection of employers’ interests in relation to claims for damages for workers’ injuries” and the object expressed in s 5(5) that “compulsory insurance against injury in employment should not impose too heavy a burden on employers and the community”. Those expressions discourage a construction of the Act which would extend the effect of determinations implicit in an insurer’s decision to allow compensation beyond that subject matter and in a way that would enlarge the scope of the statutory accident insurance described in s 8 with reference to defined terms, including “worker”.