SQNR and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

[2014] AATA 16

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2013/5462

Re

SQNR

APPLICANT

And

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Mr John Handley, Senior Member

Date 15 January 2014
Place Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the reviewable decision dated 18 October 2013.

(sgd) John Handley

Senior Member

IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP  ‑ Applicant convicted of multiple sex offences – substantial criminal record – victim an infant and related – offending occurred over 18 months – offending contemplated by paragraph 6.3(2) of the Principles in Direction 55 – applicant has not had treatment as recommended to him – risk of reoffending assessed as moderate – risk of future harm unacceptable – decision affirmed.

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958 s 501

CASES

Williams v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and Anor [2013] FCA 702

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr John Handley, Senior Member

15 January 2014

  1. The applicant, has applied for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister of Immigration and Border Protection (the Minister) on 18 October 2013 to cancel his visa pursuant to s 501(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. The applicant is a citizen of Fiji where he was born on 8 May 1971.  He is presently 42 years of age.  He first arrived in Australia on 4 January 1989 on a visitor’s visa which expired on 4 April 1989.  On 25 May 1989, solicitors he then engaged applied to the Department of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (as it then was), by letter, seeking a permanent resident visa and a work permit.  That application was made on the basis of strong compassionate or humanitarian circumstances (G-documents, p. 60-62) and was treated as a protection application.  It was contended that by reason of the applicant being of mixed race, he would be relegated to second class citizen status following a coup in Fiji in 1987.

  3. The application for permanent residence was refused.  A bridging visa was issued pending the determination of a review application to the Refugee Review Tribunal.

  4. In 1989 the applicant commenced a relationship with his cousin, AN.  In the following year they commenced living together.  Two children were born from that relationship, C, a daughter in 1990 and a son, D, in 1992.  In March 1995 the applicant withdrew his application for permanent residency (and an appeal against refusal) and elected to voluntarily leave Australia.  He returned to Fiji with AN and the children on 6 May 1995.

  5. The applicant and AN married in Fiji in 1996 and they had 3 more children, W and H, both boys in 1996 and 1997 respectively and a daughter, L, in 2000.  Their son, H, was later adopted by another cousin and has subsequently lived in the United States.

  6. The applicant and AN separated in 2004 and were divorced, in Fiji, in 2006.  The applicant subsequently had custody of the children C, D, W and L.

  7. Later in 2006, the applicant remarried an Australian woman, HB, in Fiji.  The applicant, HB and the 4…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SQNR and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 16
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of SQNR and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, the applicant, an adult male, appealed against the decision to cancel his visa due to his commission of multiple sexual offences against a vulnerable infant. The court was tasked with determining whether the applicant's removal from Australia was necessary for the protection of the community, considering the nature and seriousness of his conduct and the risk of reoffending. Additionally, the court needed to assess the strength, duration, and nature of the applicant's ties to Australia, as well as the best interests of his minor children affected by the decision.

The court found that the applicant's conduct, involving repeated sexual abuse of a vulnerable infant, was very serious and required consideration under the Migration Act. The psychological assessments indicated a moderate risk of reoffending if the applicant were not adequately treated. The court was concerned that the applicant had not received sufficient treatment, particularly regarding his alcohol consumption and temper. Given the nature of the offences and the risk to the community, the court concluded that the applicant's removal was necessary for the protection of the Australian community.

The court also examined the applicant's ties to Australia, noting his previous residence and employment history, as well as his family connections. However, the court found that these ties were not sufficiently strong to outweigh the need to protect the community from the risk of reoffending. Furthermore, the court considered the best interests of the applicant's minor children, who had no ongoing relationship with him and were aware of his offending. The court concluded that the children's interests would not be adversely affected by the visa cancellation.

The court upheld the decision to cancel the applicant's visa, determining that his removal was necessary for the protection of the Australian community and the best interests of his minor children. The court found that the risk of reoffending without adequate treatment and the seriousness of the offences justified the cancellation of his visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In concluding this part, I note that Dr Newton did review dynamic risk factors and was satisfied that the applicant presented as a somewhat higher level of risk without treatment (SG, p.11). He noted that the applicant’s history of alcohol abuse and its role in his offending was of concern. He also was satisfied that the applicant did suffer cognitive distortions regarding the precocious sexual development of young people, his rationalisations about the victim’s role in the offending and his chronic social-skills deficits [which] elevate the risk. CONCLUSION AND REASONS FOR DECISION Between April or May 2010 and November 2011 the applicant, an adult male, sexually abused an infant boy on approximately 18 occasions. The offending occurred after the infant had consumed alcohol, which on many occasions had been provided to him by the applicant. The behaviour of the applicant in relation to AW, was calculated, intentional, exploitative and predatory. The Australian community would find the offences to be disgusting. For reasons which will follow, I am satisfied the applicant has abused the privilege given to him of residing in Australia because he has not been law abiding and he has caused harm to a member of the Australian community. He has committed crimes of a sexual nature against a vulnerable member of the community, being an infant. I am also satisfied that there is a risk of reoffending if he were permitted to remain in Australia which of course would be unacceptable and strengthens the case for his removal (Direction 55 paragraph 6.3).9.1 Protection of the Australian community The first of the Primary considerations I must consider in applying Direction 55 is the protection of the Australian community which requires consideration of the nature and seriousness of the applicant’s conduct and the risk to the community should he reoffend. The applicant’s conduct by his commission of sexual crimes, repeatedly, over an extended period, upon a vulnerable infant is to be regarded very seriously (9.1.1). Having regard to the psychological assessments, I am satisfied that there is a moderate risk of him reoffending. The Principals at 6.3(2) contemplate the circumstances of this application, namely whether a noncitizen should generally be expected to forfeit the privilege of staying in Australia, having committed a serious crime of a sexual nature against a vulnerable member of the Australian community, a minor. That question will in part be answered by an assessment of whether the applicant is an unacceptable risk of future harm to the Australian community (Direction 55 paragraph 7(1) a)). In order to make an assessment under paragraph 9.1.2 of the risk to the Australian community I am obliged to consider the nature of the harm, the likelihood of further offending having regard to any information or evidence about that risk and any evidence of rehabilitation. I will later discuss the basis for my conclusions concerning the risk to the Australian community if the applicant was permitted to remain here. At this stage I would indicate that I am very concerned, in the absence of adequate treatment, that there is a risk of the applicant reoffending as he did previously. I am also concerned that he has not had adequate counselling nor has attention been properly given to his alcohol consumption and his temper. His sentence has concluded and he is currently a resident of immigration detention. Although he is eligible for parole, if released into the Australian community, which will be upon terms, I am directed by paragraph 9.1.2 b) ii, that a decision on the determination of risk is not to be delayed in order for rehabilitative courses to be undertaken.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I will note at this stage that the applicant’s brother, SL, a physiotherapist, spoke in strong and supportive terms at the hearing. He said he was prepared to stand by the applicant and would advise him to morally make amends. It was his opinion that the applicant’s environment, including his consumption of alcohol, together with the illness of his mother-in-law was responsible for his offending. He said he had also visited the applicant whilst in gaol and was satisfied that his brother was determined to make amends and repent. 9.2 Strength, duration and nature of the applicant’s ties to Australia The applicant resided in Australia for about 6 years between 1989 and 1995 and for about 6 years subsequent to 2007. He was 17 years of age when he first arrived. He eventually obtained a work permit, he earned income, was engaged in a relationship but eventually returned to Fiji. The applicant was 36 years of age when he arrived in Australia in 2007. He has subsequently been employed. He first offended in 2010, 3 years after he returned, when he was 39 years of age. He did not have any prior convictions. There are 5 children of the applicant’s marriages who reside in Australia. Two of the children, C and D are adults and live independently from him. His daughter, C is the mother of 2 children. Accordingly the applicant has grandchildren also present in Australia. He has an extended family of cousins, aunts, uncles and a brother, some of whom live interstate. C, D and his brother gave evidence in this review. All of his immediate and extended family members, living in Australia are entitled to remain here. The marital relationship between the applicant and HB has ended. She made it very clear from her evidence that she has no wish to have any association with him. There is an enduring intervention order against the applicant in favour of the 3 infant children and herself. The applicant was employed on a full-time basis until shortly prior to his arrest. There is no evidence of any contribution by him, other than employment, to the Australian community.9.3 Best interests of minor children in Australia affected by the decision The applicant’s 3 infant children, W, L and J are presently 17, 13 and 3 years. None of them have had any contact with the applicant after he was arrested except for 2 supervised access visits. They did not visit him in gaol nor is there any evidence that they communicated with him either by letter or by telephone. It would be a very rare situation where a finding could be made that a child’s interests would not be adversely affected by a visa cancellation of a parent. J was 15 months old when the applicant was arrested. He would not have the same relationship with the applicant as held previously by W and L, who are both significantly older and have lived with their father from birth until he was arrested. It would appear that the relationship between W and L and the applicant is now very remote. They are aware of his offending and of the identity of his victim. It is unlikely that the applicant, if permitted to remain in Australia, could undertake any positive parental role until he successfully completes rehabilitation and treatment and the children are prepared to trust him. Certainly there will not be any parental role, positive or otherwise during the currency of the intervention orders.