Spiral Tube Makers Pty Ltd v PIHA Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

PIHA Pty Ltd v Spiral Tube Makers Pty Ltd [2010] APO 16

Patent Applications                  785507

Title:Encased Piping System

Patent Applicant:  Spiral Tube Makers Pty Ltd

Opponent:  PIHA Pty Ltd

Delegate:  Karen Ayers

Decision Date:  27 August 2010

Hearing Date:  Heard by written submissions

Catchwords:  PATENTS – objection to an extension of time under section 223 to serve a Statement of Grounds and Particulars – service of a document is completed when the document comes to the attention of the applicant –section 14(4) of the Electronic Transactions Act – causative error in not realising that service after business hours was not effected until the following day - extension of time under section 223(2)(a) granted.

Representation:  Patent applicant:  self-represented

Opponent:Wrays, Perth, Western Australia

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:                   785507

Title:Encased Piping System

Patent Applicant:  Spiral Tube Makers Pty Ltd

Date of Decision:  27 August 2010

DECISION

Request for an extension of time under section 223(2)(a) granted up to 22 April 2010 to serve a SGP.

Mr Rushton’s had erroneously believed that service of the SGP could be effected anytime up until midnight (EST) on the last day of the prescribed period. Because of this, he instructed his attorneys to serve the SGP by facsimile after close of business at the applicant’s address for service on 21 April 2010. Because of section 14(3) of the Electronic Transactions Act 1999, service was actually not effected until the following day and was therefore 1 day late. 


The opponent showed the existence of an error or omission that caused the failure to serve the SGP in time. The evidence established that Mr Rushton genuinely believed that settlement was imminent and had delayed serving the SGP while waiting for the applicant to return the executed deed of settlement.

The balance of interests of the parties strongly favoured granting the extension. 

REASONS FOR DECISION

BACKGROUND

1.   Patent Application 785507 was filed by Spiral Tube Makers Pty Ltd (STM) on 5 November 1998 under the provisions of the PCT claiming priority from an Australian provisional application (PP 0236) filed on 7 November 1997.

2.   The complete application was advertised accepted on 22 October 2009 meaning the prescribed period for filing a notice of opposition to the grant of a patent under regulation 5.3(1) was 22 January 2010.  On 21 January 2010, the opponent (PIHA Pty Ltd) filed a notice of opposition setting 21 April 2010 as the deadline for serving the Statement of Grounds in Particulars (SGP) under regulation 5.4.

3.   The opponent served their SGP by facsimile at 17:24 (5:24 pm) Perth time (WST) on 21 April 2010.  This means that the earliest time the applicant (in Melbourne) could have received the transmission was 19:24 (7:24 pm) Melbourne time (EST).  In a letter dated 6 May 2010, the applicant advised the Commissioner that they did not receive the SGP until 22 April 2010.  They argued that as this was 1 day after the statutory deadline, the opponent had failed to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Spiral Tube Makers Pty Ltd v PIHA Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] APO 16
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of PIHA Pty Ltd v Spiral Tube Makers Pty Ltd, the parties were engaged in a dispute concerning the service of a Statement of Grounds in Particulars (SGP) in opposition to a patent application filed by Spiral Tube Makers Pty Ltd. The application was for a patent titled "Encased Piping System". The key legal issues before the court were whether there was a causative error or omission that led to the late service of the SGP and whether the balance of interests favoured granting an extension of time for service under section 223 of the relevant legislation. The court needed to determine if the error was significant enough to warrant an extension and if granting the extension would better serve the interests of the parties and the public.

The court found that the opponent, PIHA Pty Ltd, had made a genuine error in judgement in not realising that service after business hours was not effective until the following day. The opponent had believed that service could be completed anytime up until midnight on the last day, which was not the case under the Electronic Transactions Act. The court accepted that this was a causative error that contributed to the failure to serve the SGP on time. The court also found that the opponent had genuinely believed that a settlement was imminent and had delayed serving the SGP while waiting for the applicant to return the executed deed of settlement. The balance of interests strongly favoured granting the extension, as refusing to grant the extension would result in the dismissal of the substantive opposition, while granting the extension would allow the opposition to proceed, protecting the public interest in ensuring that invalid patents are not granted. The court therefore granted the opponent an extension of time under section 223(2)(a) to serve their SGP. Costs were awarded against the applicant.

In conclusion, the court granted the request for an extension of time for the service of the SGP, recognising the opponent's genuine error and the balance of interests favouring the grant of an extension. The decision allowed the opposition to proceed, upholding the public interest in preventing the grant of invalid patents.

Background

Background to the litigation

Patent Application 785507 was filed by Spiral Tube Makers Pty Ltd (STM) on 5 November 1998, claiming priority from an Australian provisional application filed on 7 November 1997. The complete application was advertised accepted on 22 October 2009, and the prescribed period for filing a notice of opposition to the grant of a patent expired on 22 January 2010. On 21 January 2010, PIHA Pty Ltd filed a notice of opposition, setting 21 April 2010 as the deadline for serving the Statement of Grounds in Particulars (SGP). The opponent served their SGP by facsimile at 17:24 (5:24 pm) Perth time (WST) on 21 April 2010. The applicant claimed they did not receive the SGP until 22 April 2010, arguing that this was 1 day after the statutory deadline and requested the Commissioner to dismiss the opposition. The opponent filed a section 223 request on 10 June 2010 to extend the time to serve their SGP by one day. The applicant objected to the section 223 extension of time, and a hearing on the written record was arranged.

The matter came before the Australian Patent Office for a hearing on the written record. The opponent filed a section 223 request to extend the time to serve their SGP by one day. The opponent provided statutory declarations in support of the request. The patent applicant objected to the section 223 extension of time. The Commissioner's Delegate decided to deal with the matter by a hearing on the written record, considering the written submissions from both parties and the material already on file in relation to the section 223 request and SGP.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the date of service of the SGP 21 April 2010 when the document entered the applicant's electronic systems or 22 April 2010 when the document came to the attention of the applicant?
2. Does the opponent's understanding that service could be effected anytime up until midnight (EST) of the final deadline constitute a causative error to enliven the provisions of section 223?
3. Should the discretion to extend time under section 223 be exercised in this case?

Held
1. The date of service of the Statement of Grounds and Particulars (SGP) is 22 April 2010 when the document came to the attention of the applicant, as per section 14(4) of the Electronic Transactions Act.
2. The opponent's understanding that service could be effected anytime up until midnight (EST) of the final deadline constitutes a causative error to enliven the provisions of section 223.
3. The discretion to extend time under section 223 should be exercised in this case, and the extension is granted until 22 April 2010.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The decision addresses whether the date of service of the SGP was on 21 April 2010 when the document entered the applicant’s electronic systems or on 22 April 2010 when the document came to the attention of the applicant. Under section 14(4) of the Electronic Transactions Act, service of an electronic document occurs when it comes to the attention of the addressee, not when it reaches their electronic information system. Given that the document entered the applicant’s electronic systems on 21 April 2010, but the applicant did not come to attention of the document until 22 April 2010, the date of service is 22 April 2010.

The court also examined whether the opponent's understanding that service could be effected anytime up until midnight (EST) of the final deadline constituted a causative error under section 223. The opponent’s error was not realising that service after business hours was not effective until the following day, which aligns with the decision in Aristocrat Technologies, Inc v IGT [2009] APO 11. This understanding contributed to the failure to serve the SGP on time, thus constituting a causative error.

Finally, the court considered whether the discretion to extend time under section 223 should be exercised in this case. The balance of interests strongly favoured granting the extension. The consequence of refusing the extension would be the dismissal of the substantive opposition, while granting the extension would protect the public interest in ensuring that invalid patents are not granted. The delay in requesting the extension was not undue, and the extension was for a relatively short period. Therefore, the court exercised its discretion to grant the extension until 22 April 2010 to serve the SGP.