WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR
CITATION:Spicer Axle Australia Pty Limited v Merza [2007] NSWWCCPD 148
APPELLANT: Spicer Axle Australia Pty Limited
RESPONDENT: Maykel Merza
INSURER:CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited
FILE NUMBER: WCC14967-04
DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION: 8 December 2006
DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: 27 June 2007
SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Section 329 Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998; estoppel; res judicata, and effect of Medical Assessment Certificates.
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: Deputy President Bill Roche
HEARING:On the papers
REPRESENTATION: Appellant: Lee and Lyons
Respondent: Ron Kramer Associates
ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL: The decision of the Arbitrator dated 8 December 2006 is confirmed.
The Appellant Employer is to pay the Respondent Worker’s costs of the appeal.
BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL
On 15 September 2001 Maykel Merza (‘the Respondent Worker/Mr Merza’) sustained injury to his back in the course of his employment with Spicer Axle Australia Pty Limited (‘the Appellant Employer/Spicer’) when he lifted a 60-kilogram tray containing axles.
After his injury Mr Merza was placed on light duties until he ceased work on 24 May 2002 because of continuing severe pain as a result of his injury. He underwent surgery to his low back on 29 October 2002 when an L4/5 discectomy was performed.
On 22 September 2004 Mr Merza’s Application to Resolve a Dispute (‘the Application’) was registered in the Commission seeking lump sum compensation in respect of a 30% permanent loss of sexual function, 36% permanent impairment of his back, 10% permanent loss of efficient use of his left leg at or above the knee and 5% permanent loss of efficient use of his right leg at or above the knee.
By its Reply filed on 8 October 2004 the Appellant Employer disputed injury, whether Mr Merza’s employment was a substantial contributing factor to any injury and whether he suffered from any pre-existing or unrelated condition or abnormality.
The matter was listed for a teleconference before a Commission Arbitrator on 21 December 2004 when it was referred to an Approved Medical Specialist (‘AMS’) (Dr Hitchen) for assessment of Mr Merza’s losses and impairments under the Table of Disabilities and the whole person impairment threshold dispute. Two assessments were conducted, one for Mr Merza’s orthopaedic injuries by Dr Kitchens and one for his loss of sexual organs by Dr Breslin. The referral did not identify Mr Merza’s injury other than by reference to the Application, which stated “injury to lower back” (see Application Part 3).
A Medical Assessment Certificate (‘MAC’) was issued in respect of the orthopaedic injuries on 5 April 2005. Dr Hitchen found that whilst Mr Merza had disc pathology at L4/5 and L5/S1 his work injury on 15 September 2001 was only to his L5/S1 disc and that the herniation of the L4/5 disc “would not have occurred at the workplace and the herniation at L4/5, for which he had surgery, is degenerative in nature” (MAC, page seven). The MAC certified Mr Merza…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Spicer Axle Australia Pty Limited v Merza and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] NSWWCCPD 148
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the Arbitrator had not erred in her determination that the issue of injury had not been previously determined. The court highlighted the distinction between the Commission's role in determining liability and the Approved Medical Specialist's role in assessing impairment, and confirmed that the Arbitrator's decision was consistent with the legislative framework. Furthermore, the court rejected the employer's argument that the principles of res judicata applied, noting that no final determination on the issue of injury had been made prior to the Arbitrator's decision.
In relation to the medical evidence, the court found that the Arbitrator's conclusion that Mr. Merza sustained injury to both L4/5 and L5/S1 levels on 15 September 2001 was supported by the preponderance of the evidence. The court held that the Arbitrator's decision to prefer the medical evidence provided by the worker's treating specialists over that of the employer's medical expert was reasonable and legally sound.
Ultimately, the court upheld the Arbitrator's decision and ordered that the employer pay the worker's costs of the appeal. The court found that the Arbitrator had not abused her discretion in referring the matter for further medical assessment, and that the referral was in line with the objectives of the legislation.
Background
Background to the litigation
The procedural history of this case begins with Mr Merza lodging an Application to Resolve a Dispute with the Workers Compensation Commission on 22 September 2004. The Appellant Employer filed a Reply disputing various aspects of Mr Merza's claim. The matter was referred to an Approved Medical Specialist for assessment, resulting in a Medical Assessment Certificate issued on 5 April 2005. Mr Merza appealed this certificate under section 327(3) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998, but the Registrar's Delegate dismissed the appeal on 4 August 2005. Mr Merza sought judicial review of this decision in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which was dismissed on 14 September 2006. The matter returned to the Workers Compensation Commission, where it was heard by an Arbitrator on 17 November 2006. The Arbitrator issued a Certificate of Determination on 8 December 2006, which the Appellant Employer appealed. The appeal was heard on the papers by Deputy President Bill Roche on 27 June 2007.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Arbitrator erred in finding that the issue of injury had not been determined.
2. Whether the Arbitrator erred in determining that the principles of res judicata did not apply.
3. Whether the Arbitrator erred in determining the issue of injury.
4. Whether the Arbitrator erred in determining that there was no issue estoppel.
5. Whether the Arbitrator erred in accepting Mr Merza's medical evidence over that of Dr Hitchen, the AMS.
6. Whether the Arbitrator erred in failing to find that the re-determination of the issue of injury amounted to an abuse of process.
7. Whether the Arbitrator erred in rejecting the submission that if Mr Merza wanted to re-agitate the issue of injury the proper process was by appeal of Justice Hoeben's decision.
8. Whether the Arbitrator erred in exercising her discretion to refer the matter for a further medical assessment under section 329 of the 1998 Act.
Held
1. The court held that the Arbitrator did not err in finding that the issue of injury had not been determined.
2. The court held that the Arbitrator did not err in determining that the principles of res judicata did not apply.
3. The court held that the Arbitrator did not err in determining the issue of injury.
4. The court held that the Arbitrator did not err in determining that there was no issue estoppel.
5. The court held that the Arbitrator did not err in accepting Mr Merza's medical evidence over that of Dr Hitchen, the AMS.
6. The court held that the Arbitrator did not err in failing to find that the re-determination of the issue of injury amounted to an abuse of process.
7. The court held that the Arbitrator did not err in rejecting the submission that if Mr Merza wanted to re-agitate the issue of injury the proper process was by appeal of Justice Hoeben's decision.
8. The court held that the Arbitrator did not err in exercising her discretion to refer the matter for a further medical assessment under section 329 of the 1998 Act.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court found that the issue of injury had not been determined as there was no clear admission by the Appellant Employer or finding by the first Arbitrator. The court considered the definition of injury under the 1987 and 1998 Acts, which includes both the injurious event and the pathology arising from that event. The court held that the determination of these issues requires a consideration of all the factual and legal issues in the case and is not simply a medical question. The court also found that there was no determination or decision by the Commission on any issue at the time of the referral to the first AMS. Therefore, the principles of res judicata and estoppel by record or issue estoppel did not apply. The court further found that the Arbitrator was entitled to rely on the medical evidence that Mr Merza sustained injury to both the L4/5 and L5/S1 discs when he lifted axles at work on 15 September 2001. The court held that the Arbitrator's conclusion was well supported by the evidence and the authorities on causation. The court also found that the proceedings before the Arbitrator were not an abuse of process as a worker is entitled to make such application for compensation as he or she thinks is appropriate. The court further held that the referral under section 329 of the 1998 Act was appropriate as issues of liability and causation are matters to be determined by the Commission and not by an AMS. The court held that the Arbitrator did not misuse her discretion by referring the matter to a further AMS under section 329.