SPI Spirits (Cyprus) Ltd v Diageo Australia Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

S.P.I. Spirits (Cyprus) Ltd v Diageo Australia Ltd (No. 2) [2006] FCA 931

PROCEDURE – Discovery and interrogatories – where discovery sought against non-party foreign State – where inter partes discovery yet to take place – whether discovery available pursuant to rules or otherwise – whether Sabre order appropriate

Federal Court of Australia Act (1976) (Cth) s 23
Federal Court Rules O 15A r 8

Sabre Corp Pty Ltd v Russ Calvin’s Hair Care Co (1993) 46 FCR 428 referred to
Willis & Co v Baddeley [1892] 2 QB 324 applied
Abu Dhabi National Tanker Co v Product Star Shipping Ltd [1992] 2 All E.R. 20 applied
James Nelson & Sons Ltd v Nelson Line (Liverpool) Ltd [1906] 2 KB 217 referred to
Commonwealth v Northern Land Council (1991) 30 FCR 1 cited
Gambro Pty Ltd v Fresenius Medical Care AustraliaPty Ltd [2002] FCA 581 cited
Hunter v Leahy (1999) 91 FCR 214 cited
CSR Ltd v CIGNA Insurance Australia Ltd (1997) 189 CLR 345 cited
Cardile v LED Builders Pty Ltd (1999) 198 CLR 380 cited
Stemcor (Australasia) Pty Ltd v Oceanwave Line SA [2004] FCA 391 referred to
Arhill Pty Ltd v General Percival Company (1991) 23 NSWLR 454 referred to
Aetna Pacific Securities v Hong Kong Bank of Australia Ltd (20 April 1993, Supreme Court of New South Wales, Giles J, unreported) referred to

S.P.I. SPIRITS (CYPRUS) LIMITED AND SPIRITS INTERNATIONAL N.V. v DIAGEO AUSTRALIA LIMITED, FEDERAL TREASURY ENTERPRISE (FKP) SOJUZPLODOIMPORT, FEDERAL TREASURY ENTERPRISE (FKP) SOJUZPLODOIMPORT, STATE FEDERAL UNITARY ENTERPRISE EXTERNAL ECONOMIC UNION SOJUZPLODOIMPORT (FGUP) (VO) v SPIRITS INTERNATIONAL N.V. AND DIAGEO AUSTRALIA LIMITED

NSD 1816 OF 2004

EDMONDS  J
25 JULY 2006
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1816 OF 2004

BETWEEN:

S.P.I. SPIRITS (CYPRUS) LIMITED
First Applicant

SPIRITS INTERNATIONAL N.V.
Second Applicant

AND:

AND BETWEEN:

AND:

DIAGEO AUSTRALIA LIMITED
First Respondent

FEDERAL TREASURY ENTERPRISE (FKP) SOJUZPLODOIMPORT
Second Respondent

FEDERAL TREASURY ENTERPRISE (FKP) SOJUZPLODOIMPORT
First Cross-Claimant

STATE FEDERAL UNITARY ENTERPRISE EXTERNAL ECONOMIC UNION SOJUZPLODOIMPORT (FGUP) (VO)
Second Cross-Claimant

SPIRITS INTERNATIONAL N.V.
First Cross-Respondent

DIAGEO AUSTRALIA LIMITED
Second Cross-Respondent

JUDGE:

EDMONDS  J

DATE OF ORDER:

25 JULY 2006

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The motion be stood over to a date to be fixed to hear the parties on the categories of discovery that might be given by the Russian Federation and how the orders to give effect to these reasons for judgment might be formulated.

2.The costs of the motion be reserved.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1816 OF 2004

BETWEEN:

S.P.I. SPIRITS (CYPRUS) LIMITED
First Applicant

SPIRITS INTERNATIONAL N.V.
Second Applicant

AND:

AND BETWEEN:

AND:

DIAGEO AUSTRALIA LIMITED
First Respondent

FEDERAL TREASURY ENTERPRISE (FKP) SOJUZPLODOIMPORT
Second Respondent

FEDERAL TREASURY ENTERPRISE (FKP) SOJUZPLODOIMPORT
First Cross-Claimant

STATE FEDERAL UNITARY ENTERPRISE EXTERNAL ECONOMIC UNION SOJUZPLODOIMPORT (FGUP) (VO)
Second Cross-Claimant

SPIRITS…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SPI Spirits (Cyprus) Ltd v Diageo Australia Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 931
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

SPI Spirits (Cyprus) Ltd v Diageo Australia Ltd (No 2) involved a dispute over the validity of trade mark registrations held by Spirits in Australia. The case was brought by FKP and FGUP, two Russian State-owned enterprises, who claimed that they were the true owners of the trade marks in question and sought either the cancellation of Spirits' Australian trade mark registrations or rectification of the Trade Marks Register. The dispute arose from events surrounding the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991, particularly concerning the transformation of a State-owned corporation, Sojuzplodoimport, into a private corporation, VAO-SPI, and the succession of assets, including trade marks, from Sojuzplodoimport to VAO-SPI.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether FKP and FGUP were the appropriate entities to bring the claim or if the Russian Federation was the true or real applicant. The court also had to consider the scope and appropriateness of the discovery orders sought by Spirits, which would require every ministry, agency, and instrumentality of the Russian Federation to undertake searches for documents related to the trade marks.

The court found that FKP and FGUP were not the true owners of the trade marks, as the Russian Federation held the rights to the trade marks. The court emphasised that the Russian Federation had registered ownership of the trade marks in Russia and had rights concerning the trade marks outside Russia. The court also ruled that the discovery orders sought by Spirits were overly broad, lacked evidentiary support, and were inappropriate given the current stage of the proceedings. The court stood over the motion to a later date to discuss the categories of discovery that might be given by the Russian Federation and how the orders could be formulated accordingly.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The motion be stood over to a date to be fixed to hear the parties on the categories of discovery that might be given by the Russian Federation and how the orders to give effect to these reasons for judgment might be formulated.

2.

Background

Background to the litigation

The ‘otherwise’ alternative basis to O 15A r 8 of the Federal Court Rules of the order sought in [2(a)] above, is that the Russian Federation is the ‘true’ or ‘real’ applicant/plaintiff on the cross-claim, not FKP and FGUP, which are but ‘nominal’ applicants/plaintiffs.FACTUAL BACKGROUND It is not in dispute that FKP and FGUP are Russian State-owned enterprises; that they are separate legal entities which are distinct from the Russian Federation. FKP is a ‘federal treasury enterprise’, being a commercial organisation which holds property settled on it by the Russian Federation ‘by right of operational management’. FGUP is a ‘federal State unitary enterprise’, being a commercial organisation which holds property settled on it by the Russian Federation ‘by right of economic management’. In her affidavit Ms Mozgonenko confirms the foregoing (at [11] and [12]) and explains what is meant by the terms ‘by right of operational management’ and ‘by right of economic management’ (at [13] – [19]) and Mr Tsyplakov, in his affidavit, confirms that he ‘substantially agrees’ with Ms Mozgonenko on all these matters (at [23]). It is also common ground that FKP did not exist at the time of the centrally disputed events in this case, which took place in 1990 – 1992. FKP was created by Order of the Government of the Russian Federation in 2001 and, according to Ms Mozgonenko, was first registered as a legal entity in the Russian Federation on 9 April 2002. It also seems to be common ground that FGUP was first registered as a legal entity in the Russian Federation on 18 April 2001 but that is where the common ground ends. FGUP contends, according to the further amended cross-claim, that it did exist at the relevant time, albeit in the form of Sojuzplodoimport, and that it (FGUP) is the legal successor to that entity. Spirits disputes this contention and contends that following the lawful transformation of Sojuzplodoimport into VAO-SPI around 1991 and 1992, VAO-SPI became the legal successor to Sojuzplodoimport, including its assets and liabilities which vested in VAO-SPI, and Sojuzplodoimport ceased to exist from approximately 20 January 2002. Common ground aside, Spirits contends that the factual background should also be understood in the context of what is set out in [7] to [12] below. The basis for the claims made in the cross-claim – for cancellation of certain Australian trade mark registrations (‘Australian Trade Marks’) or for rectification of the Trade Marks Register in relation to the Australian Trade Marks – lies in events which occurred around the time of the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991, a decade prior to the creation of FKP. FKP and FGUP’s claims concern, in particular, challenging the validity of Spirit’s reliance on the transformation of a State-owned corporation (Sojuzplodoimport) into a private corporation (‘VAO-SPI’) between 1990 and 1992 and the succession of assets (including trade marks) from Sojuzplodoimport to VAO-SPI.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

EDMONDS J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: EDMONDS J

Further, the Russian certificates of registration in respect of the trade marks indicate that the Russian Federation is recorded as the registered owner of the trade marks in Russia and that FKP has the right only to ‘use and dispose of (exclusive of the right to assign) [the trade marks] in the name and on behalf of the Russian Federation …’: Tzyplakov [13], Exhibit MT1.The phrase ‘use and dispose of (exclusive of the right to assign)’ is probably better rendered in English as ‘make use of, at discretion, but not surrender, relinquish or transfer’. Russian State bodies have also adopted the position that the Russian Federation is the owner of the trade marks in Russia and has rights in respect of the trade marks outside Russia: Tzyplakov [21], Exhibit MT3. In response, FKP and FGUP say that the relevant context needs to be understood by reference to the common ground referred to in [4] and [5] supra, but also by reference to the matters set out in [14] to [17] below. Although no precise analogy can be drawn, FKP and FGUP submit that they are not unlike State-owned corporations of the kind regularly established by governments in Australia, which hold particular assets for the benefit of the State or carry out particular functions or activities which might otherwise be carried out by the State, a practice which has been developed in part for reasons of commercial efficacy. Such State-owned corporations operate independently of the State, but, in a general sense, are subject to the overall direction and control of the State. Little weight should be given to the statements relied on by Spirits and referred to in [10] supra having regard to the particular context in which they are made. In substance, they are no higher than the matters pleaded by FKP and FGUP in the further amended cross-claim. Ms Mozgovenko’s evidence, which is unchallenged in this respect, also established that FKP and FGUP do not hold, and generally do not have, the capacity under Russian law to compel production of documents held by the various ministries, agencies and instrumentalities of the Russian Federation which were previously identified in Spirits’ proposed categories (save, of course, to the extent that copies of such documents are actually held in the files of FKP or FGUP). In effect, the orders now sought by Spirits would require every ministry, agency and instrumentality of the Russian Federation, not just FKP and FGUP, to undertake searches for documents in numerous, broadly defined categories, for the purposes of giving discovery in these proceedings. Even aside from questions of power, a lack of evidentiary support and the inappropriateness of granting such orders against an entity outside the jurisdiction, the orders are inappropriate because of their sheer scope. Further, the application is premature, in circumstances in which FKP and FGUP – the entities charged with dealing in and conducting proceedings in relation to the trade marks in question – have yet to give inter partes discovery.REASONING