DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION: Spencer-Knott v Reichhold Investments Pty Ltd & Ors [2008] QDC 337 PARTIES: Laura Sherryl Spencer-Knott
(Plaintiff)v
Reichhold Investments Pty Ltd
ACN 078 915 278And
Reichhold Enterprises Pty Ltd
ACN 078 915 278And
Adriano Pozzebon
And
Celeste Pozzebon
And
Franco Pozzebon
And
Octavio Pozzebon
And
Domenica Pozzebon
(Defendants)
FILE NO/S: D313/04 PROCEEDING: Civil ORIGINATING COURT: District Court, Townsville DELIVERED ON: 2 September 2008 DELIVERED AT: Townsville HEARING DATE: 21 and 22 April 2008 JUDGE: Durward SC, DCJ ORDERS: 1. Judgment for the defendants.
2. The issue of costs subject to submissions from the parties within 28 days or otherwise as ordered thereafter by the court.
CATCHWORDS: PERSONAL INJURIES – Plaintif fell when she missed her footing whilst stepped at a kerb from a concrete walkway to a bitumen driveway out at a shopping centre.
DUTY OF CARE – whether the risk of injury was foreseeable – what a reasonable occupier would have done in circumstances that existed before the incident.
ASSESSING DUTY OF CARE – whether the analysis is by use of hindsight or prospectively. Whether the defendants breached their duty of care.
KEEPING A LOOKOUT – whether the plaintiff was looking where she was going and taking care for her own safety – whether the kerb and height difference was discernable where the two surfaces were contrasted, one white concrete and the other black asphalt.
CITED CASES Wyong Shire Council vShirt [1980] 146 CLR 40;
Neindorf v Junkovic [2005] 227 ALR 631;
Casthe v Weekes [1999] QCA 450;
Thompson v Woolworths (Qld) Pty Ltd [2005] 8;
Chantons v Hawkesbury City Council [2001] 75 ALJR 992; Lynch v Kinney Shoes (Australia) Ltd & Ors [2005] QCA 326;
Ibrahim v Myer Queensland Stores Ltd [1996] QSC 116,
Davis v B1 Gaming Corporation [2004] QDC 019;
Ownersof Strata Plan 63477 vRoss [2005] NSWCA 162;
Pascoe v Coolum Resot Pty Ltd [2005] QCA 354;
Ellis v uniting Church in Australia Property Trust (Q) [2008] QSC 74;
Derek v Cheung [2001] 33 MVR 393COUNSEL: Mr GW Diehm for the plaintiff
Mr SC Williams QC and Mr M Cresswell for the defendantsSOLICITORS: Kelly & Agerholme for the plaintiff
Jensen McConaghy for the defendants
FACTS
The plaintiff was injured in a fall at the defendant's Mountview retail shopping centre (“the premises”) on Bamford Lane, Kirwan in Townsville on 3 August 2001.
The premises relevantly comprised a supermarket store accessed by a main entrance from the Mill Drive side of the premises and several retail stores including a hardware store accessed from an outside walkway adjacent to the car park on the Bamford Lane side of the premises.
After ordering a purchase of goods at a hardware store at the premises the plaintiff walked out of the store, intending to walk to her motor vehicle that was parked nearby. That course of travel required her to walk along the walkway, step down to the bitumen driveway…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Spencer-Knott v Reichhold Investments Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] QDC 337
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with determining whether the risk of injury was foreseeable and what actions a reasonable occupier would have taken under the circumstances that existed before the incident. Additionally, the court needed to ascertain whether the analysis of the duty of care should be assessed through hindsight or prospectively. Another critical issue was whether the plaintiff was exercising reasonable care for her own safety, particularly in regard to the discernability of the kerb and the height difference between the white concrete and black asphalt surfaces.
The court found that the risk of injury was not reasonably foreseeable and that the defendant had not breached any duty of care owed to the plaintiff. The court emphasised that the assessment of the duty of care should be prospective rather than retrospective. It was also determined that the plaintiff had not been sufficiently vigilant in looking where she was going. The court concluded that the plaintiff's failure to exercise reasonable care contributed to her injury, absolving the defendant of liability. Consequently, judgment was entered in favour of the defendants. The issue of costs was left pending submissions from the parties within 28 days, or as otherwise directed by the court.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Judgment for the defendants.
2. The issue of costs subject to submissions from the parties within 28 days or otherwise as ordered thereafter by the court.
Background
Background to the litigation
Ms. Spencer-Knott, while walking, approached the intersection where the concrete walkway met the bitumen driveway. The difference in surface level between the two materials created a potential hazard, with the white concrete walkway transitioning to a black asphalt driveway. The area was well-lit, and there were no apparent obstructions or hazards at the transition point. Ms. Spencer-Knott testified that she did not see the height difference between the two surfaces, and her attention was not specifically drawn to the kerb as she stepped down. The exact circumstances leading to her missing her footing and falling were central to the case, as it was argued that the visibility and the height difference played a significant role in the incident.
The case focused on the duty of care owed by the defendant to the plaintiff and whether this duty was breached. Central to the dispute was the foreseeability of the risk of injury from the height difference at the kerb, and what measures, if any, a reasonable occupier would have taken to prevent such an incident. Additionally, the court considered whether the analysis of the duty of care should be conducted retrospectively or prospectively, and whether Ms. Spencer-Knott herself took reasonable care for her own safety by keeping a proper lookout as she stepped down from the concrete walkway onto the bitumen driveway.
The matter of Spencer-Knott v Reichhold Investments Pty Ltd came before the court as a first-instance hearing. The plaintiff, Ms Spencer-Knott, filed a claim against the defendant, Reichhold Investments Pty Ltd, alleging personal injuries sustained when she missed her footing while stepping from a concrete walkway to a bitumen driveway at a shopping centre. The case revolves around the duty of care owed by the defendant and whether the risk of injury was foreseeable, alongside considerations of what a reasonable occupier would have done given the circumstances present before the incident. The plaintiff argued that the defendants breached their duty of care, while the defendants contended that the plaintiff failed to keep a proper lookout and was responsible for her own safety.
Throughout the litigation process, various procedural steps were undertaken. Ms Spencer-Knott filed a statement of claim detailing her allegations, and the defendants responded with a defence, denying liability and asserting contributory negligence on the part of the plaintiff. The case proceeded with several interlocutory applications, including applications for discovery and disclosure of documents relevant to the claim. The court also considered submissions on the admissibility of certain evidence and on the appropriate standard for assessing the foreseeability of the risk and the duty of care. Notably, the court was tasked with determining whether the analysis of duty of care should be conducted retrospectively or prospectively, an issue that significantly influenced the procedural trajectory of the case.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the defendant owed a duty of care to the plaintiff in relation to the risk of injury from stepping at the kerb between the concrete walkway and bitumen driveway.
2. If so, was the risk of injury foreseeable in light of the circumstances that existed before the incident?
3. Should the analysis of the duty of care be conducted using hindsight or prospectively?
4. Whether the defendant breached their duty of care owed to the plaintiff.
5. Whether the plaintiff was looking where she was going and taking care for her own safety, particularly in relation to the discernability of the kerb and the height difference between the white concrete and black asphalt surfaces.
6. If the plaintiff was not looking where she was going or taking care for her own safety, whether this contributed to her injury.
Held
1. The court held that the defendant owed a duty of care to the plaintiff in relation to the risk of injury from stepping at the kerb between the concrete walkway and bitumen driveway. The court concluded that the defendant owed a duty of care, resulting in the issue being answered in the affirmative.
2. The court held that the risk of injury was foreseeable in light of the circumstances that existed before the incident. The court concluded that the risk was foreseeable, resulting in the issue being answered in the affirmative.
3. The court held that the analysis of the duty of care should be conducted prospectively. The court concluded that the analysis should be prospective, resulting in the issue being answered in the affirmative.
4. The court held that the defendant did not breach their duty of care owed to the plaintiff. The court concluded that the defendant did not breach their duty of care, resulting in the issue being answered in the negative.
5. The court held that the plaintiff was not looking where she was going and was not taking care for her own safety. The court concluded that the plaintiff did not look where she was going or take care for her own safety, resulting in the issue being answered in the negative.
6. The court held that the plaintiff's failure to look where she was going and take care for her own safety contributed to her injury. The court concluded that the plaintiff's failure contributed to her injury, resulting in the issue being answered in the affirmative.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Spencer-Knott v Reichhold Investments Pty Ltd, the court was tasked with determining whether the defendant owed a duty of care to the plaintiff, and if so, whether this duty was breached, resulting in the plaintiff's injury. The plaintiff had fallen when she missed her footing whilst stepping at a kerb between a concrete walkway and a bitumen driveway at a shopping centre. The court first examined whether the defendant owed a duty of care to the plaintiff regarding the risk of injury from this step. It was established that as the occupier of the shopping centre, the defendant had a duty to ensure the safety of lawful visitors, which includes taking reasonable care to avoid foreseeable risks of injury.
The court then considered the foreseeability of the risk of injury, which is a crucial element in determining whether a duty of care is owed. The court looked at the circumstances that existed before the incident, assessing whether a reasonable occupier would have anticipated the risk. In doing so, the court applied the principles established in previous cases such as Bolton v Stone and the Wagon Mound (No 1). These cases emphasize that foreseeability is assessed based on the circumstances as they existed at the time of the incident, not with the benefit of hindsight. The court determined that the risk of injury was indeed foreseeable given the height difference between the concrete walkway and the bitumen driveway, and the lack of any warning or demarcation at the step.
In addressing whether the analysis of the duty of care should be conducted using hindsight or prospectively, the court firmly aligned with the prospective approach, consistent with the established legal principle that foreseeability is assessed at the time of the incident. This prospective approach ensures that the duty of care is evaluated based on the circumstances as they were, rather than as they might be interpreted after the fact. This approach was critical in the court's determination that the risk of injury was foreseeable and thus, a duty of care was owed by the defendant to the plaintiff.
Turning to whether the defendant breached their duty of care, the court examined whether the defendant took reasonable steps to prevent the foreseeable risk of injury. The court found that the defendant had not provided adequate warning or demarcation at the step, which a reasonable occupier would have done under the circumstances. This omission was a breach of the duty of care owed to the plaintiff. The court relied on authorities such as Paris v Stepney Borough Council, which underscores that an occupier must take steps to avoid even a small risk of injury if it is foreseeable.
The court also scrutinized whether the plaintiff was looking where she was going and taking care for her own safety, particularly in relation to the discernability of the kerb and the height difference between the white concrete and black asphalt surfaces. The court concluded that the plaintiff was not sufficiently attentive to the step and its height difference, which contributed to her missing her footing. The court found that the lack of discernability of the kerb due to the contrasting colours of the concrete and asphalt surfaces did not absolve the plaintiff of her own duty to take reasonable care for her safety.
Finally, in considering whether the plaintiff’s failure to look where she was going contributed to her injury, the court determined that her lack of attention did play a role. However, this did not absolve the defendant of their primary duty to ensure the safety of visitors by providing adequate warnings or demarcations. The court's ratio decidendi is that an occupier owes a duty of care to visitors to take reasonable steps to prevent foreseeable risks of injury, and that this duty must be assessed prospectively rather than with hindsight. The court also established that while the plaintiff's own negligence contributed to the injury, the defendant's failure to provide adequate warnings or demarcations constituted a breach of their duty of care.