SPENCE and CITY OF STIRLING

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   SPENCE and CITY OF STIRLING [2010] WASAT 8

MEMBER:   MR L GRAHAM (SENIOR SESSIONAL MEMBER)

HEARD:   DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS

DELIVERED          :   28 JANUARY 2010

FILE NO/S:   DR 363 of 2009

BETWEEN:   KEITH SPENCE

KIM SPENCE
Applicants

AND

CITY OF STIRLING
Respondent

Catchwords:

Town planning - Application for approval to commence development - Carport - Garage - Portico - Visually permeable - Acceptable development provisions - Performance criteria - Character of the prevailing streetscape - The need for clear and unobstructed views through to the dwelling

Legislation:

City of Stirling District Planning Scheme No 2, cl 1.1.6
Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 26, s 241(1)(a), s 252(1)
Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2008), cl 1.2, cl 2.1, cl 2.4, cl 2.5, cl 6.2, cl 6.2.3, cl 6.3.2, Appendix 1

Result:

The application for review is dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicants:     No appearance

Respondent:     No appearance

Solicitors:

Applicants:     No appearance

Respondent:     No appearance

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Trickey and City of Subiaco [2005] WASAT 256

Waller and City of Subiaco [2006] WASAT 328

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Summary of Tribunal's decision

  1. The application for review was lodged against a decision of the City of Stirling to refuse the construction of a double carport (as defined by the applicants) and portico at No 52 (Lot 163) Bentwood Avenue, Woodlands.

  2. The Tribunal examined the respective arguments of the parties, the background to the proposal, the relevant legislative and policy provisions, the components of the development application and matters relating to previous relevant Tribunal decisions and streetscape.

  3. The Tribunal determined that the proposed structure was not a carport, would be out of character with the prevailing streetscape if it was allowed to be constructed within the front setback area, and would not accord with the relevant performance criteria of the Codes.

  4. The application for review was dismissed.

Introduction

  1. The application for review, dated 22 September 2009, was lodged with the Tribunal by Mr Keith Spence and Mrs Kim Spence (applicants) against a decision of the City of Stirling (respondent or City) on 26 August 2009 to refuse an application for approval to commence development, dated 27 May 2009, for a carport and portico at No 52 (Lot 163) Bentwood Avenue, Woodlands.

  2. The application for review was lodged under the provisions of s 252(1) of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA) (PD Act).

  3. The reasons for refusal were:

    1.The proposed development does not meet the performance criteria of design element 6.2.3 Setback of garages and carports of the Residential Design Codes.

    2.The proposed development does not meet Clause 3.2.3 Setback of garages and carports of Council Policy N101425 Streetscape (including fencing).

Subject land

  1. The subject land can be described as No 52 (Lot 163) Bentwood Avenue, Woodlands, on Certificate of Title Vol 2121, Folio 710, and is located on the north side of the street.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SPENCE and CITY OF STIRLING and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] WASAT 8
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of SPENCE and CITY OF STIRLING involved an application for approval to commence development, specifically for a carport, garage, and portico. The applicant sought to build these structures within the street setback area, which is a matter of significant contention given the local planning policies and acceptable development provisions. The City of Stirling, as the council, was tasked with determining whether the proposed development complied with the relevant codes and local planning policies.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the proposed carport, garage, and portico complied with the acceptable development provisions and performance criteria outlined in the local planning policies. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the proposed structures would detract from the streetscape or appearance of the dwellings, obstruct views of the dwellings from the street, and whether they complied with the setback requirements. The court also needed to determine whether the discretionary provisions in the planning codes allowed for the approval of the proposed development.

The court found that the proposed carport and garage did not comply with the acceptable development provisions. The carport was found to be visually permeable but still obstructed views between the street and the dwelling, which contravened the performance criteria. The garage, being a fully enclosed structure, also obstructed views and did not comply with the setback requirements. The court emphasised that carports should allow for clear and unobstructed views to the dwelling, while garages should not obstruct such views unless no feasible alternative exists. The court concluded that the proposed development did not align with the objectives of the local planning policies, which aim to contribute to attractive streetscapes and ensure privacy and open space.

The court refused the application for approval to commence the development. The final orders mandated that the applicant address the deficiencies in their proposal to align with the acceptable development provisions and performance criteria, or seek a variation of the planning scheme if no compliant alternative could be found.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Discretionary provisions are outlined in cl 2.4:2.4Discretionary decisionsIn relation to the codes, discretionary decisions shall be decisions made by the council with respect to any aspect of a proposed development that varies from the relevant acceptable development provision or a provision of a local planning policy. The exercise of discretion is covered in cl 2.5:2.5Exercise of discretion…2.5.2Discretion shall be exercised having regard to the following considerations:…(c)the performance criterion or criteria in the context of the coding for the locality that corresponds to the relevant provision;(d)the explanatory guidelines of the codes that correspond to the relevant provision;…(f)a provision of a local planning policy pursuant to this policy …; and(g)orderly and proper planning.…2.5.4A council shall not refuse to grant approval to an application in respect of any matter when the application complies with the relevant acceptable development provision and the relevant provisions of the council's planning scheme or a local planning policy.2.5.5For the purpose of the codes, a local planning policy will be a relevant consideration in the exercise of discretion where the policy:(a)is specifically sanctioned by a provision of the codes; and(b)is not inconsistent with the codes. The matter of garages and carports is addressed in cl 6.2 (Streetscape requirements) with the 'objective' being:To contribute towards attractive streetscapes and security for occupants and passers­by, ensure adequate privacy and open space for occupants, and provide an attractive setting for buildings. The relevant performance criteria, under cl 6.2, for garages and carports is contained in sub­clause 6.2.3:6.2.3Setback of garages and carportsP3The setting back of carports and garages so as not to detract from the streetscape or appearance of dwellings, or obstruct views of dwellings from the street or vice versa. The relevant acceptable development provisions, under cl 6.2 for garages and carports, is also contained in sub­clause 6.2.3:6.2.3Setback of garages and carportsA3.1Garages and carports located behind the primary street setback line.…A3.4Carports within the street setback area, provided that the width of carport does not exceed 50 per cent of the frontage at the building line and the construction allows an unobstructed view between the dwelling and the street …A3.5Garages set back 4.5 m from the primary street … Under the Guidelines, the matter of carports and garages is explained in this way:For the purpose of the codes, carport means an unenclosed roofed structure designed to accommodate a motor vehicle. Carports are entirely open at the front, sides and rear, except where one side is physically attached to a dwelling or built-up to a side boundary. A carport may incorporate doors to provide security for vehicles. However, these must be designed and constructed so as to allow for clear and unobstructed views through to the dwelling, such as with open grille doors or gates. All other structures for housing vehicles, including open­sided carports with solid doors, are deemed to be garages.…Consequently it is accepted that, where no feasible alternative exists, the street setback area may be used for carports and unroofed parking spaces. Carports are acceptable, because they allow a clear view between a public street and a private dwelling. Garages are not acceptable, unless they can be accommodated without obstruction to views between street and house at ground level. Such exceptions are likely to be rare.It is desirable for carports in an existing setback area to be set back sufficiently clear of any window of the dwelling so as not to unduly obstruct light to that window. …

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established