Specsavers Pty Ltd v The Optical Superstore Pty Ltd (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Specsavers Pty Ltd v The Optical Superstore Pty Ltd (No 4) [2012] FCA 652

Citation: Specsavers Pty Ltd v The Optical Superstore Pty Ltd
(No 4) [2012] FCA 652
Parties: SPECSAVERS PTY LTD (ACN 097 147 932) v THE OPTICAL SUPERSTORE PTY LTD (ACN 095 737 894), OPTOM ADMIN PTY LTD (ACN 101 150 449), WILLIAM CHIN, NORTHERN COAST OPTICAL PTY LTD (ACN 006 873 758), TOWNSVILLE OPTICAL PTY LTD (ACN 097 398 019), BUNDABERG OPTICAL PTY LTD (ACN 131 317 676), UNIQUE EYEWEAR PTY LTD (ACN 006 251 305) and IPSWICH OPTICAL PTY LTD (ACN 082 352 350)
File number: NSD 119 of 2010
Judge: KATZMANN J
Date of judgment: 21 June 2012
Catchwords: COSTS – claim for damages under an undertaking – amount initially claimed a fraction of amount awarded – whether parties claiming under undertaking were successful – whether costs should be reduced because of size of award – Federal Court Rules 2011 r 40.08 – multiple offers of compromise made by party providing undertaking without any response – party failed to act consistently with overarching purpose under Federal Court Act 1976 (Cth), s 37N(1) – claim for indemnity costs based on final offer of compromise – ambiguity of terms of offer – whether claimant acted unreasonably
Legislation: Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 37M(1), 37M(3), 37N(1), 43
Federal Court Rules 2011 rr 1.35, 25.14(1), 40.08
Cases cited:

Brother Industries, Limited v Dynamics Supplies Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 126

Futuretronics.com.au Pty Ltd v Graphix Labels Pty Ltd [2009] FCAFC 40
Kooee Communications Pty Ltd v Primus Telecommunications Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] FCAFC 141
Ruddock v Vadarlis (No 2) (2001) 115 FCR 229
Specsavers Pty Ltd v The Optical Superstore Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] FCA 566
Specsavers Pty Ltd v The Optical Superstore Pty Ltd(No 3) [2012] FCA 504

Date of hearing: 20 June 2012
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 39
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr DB Studdy SC with Mr HPT Bevan
Solicitor for the Applicant: Minter Ellison
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr MH O'Bryan SC
Solicitor for the Respondents: Maddocks

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 119 of 2010

BETWEEN:

SPECSAVERS PTY LTD (ACN 097 147 932)
Applicant

AND:

THE OPTICAL SUPERSTORE PTY LTD (ACN 095 737 894)
First Respondent

OPTOM ADMIN PTY LTD (ACN 101 150 449)
Second Respondent

WILLIAM CHIN
Third Respondent

NORTHERN COAST OPTICAL PTY LTD (ACN 006 873 758)
Fourth Respondent

TOWNSVILLE OPTICAL PTY LTD (ACN 097 398 019)
Fifth Respondent

BUNDABERG OPTICAL PTY LTD (ACN 131 317 676)
Sixth Respondent

UNIQUE EYEWEAR PTY LTD (ACN 006 251 305)
Seventh Respondent

IPSWICH OPTICAL PTY LTD (ACN 082 352 350)
Eighth Respondent

JUDGE:

KATZMANN J

DATE OF ORDER:

21 JUNE 2012

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant pay 65% of the respondents’ costs (including disbursements) of their claim for damages under the undertaking.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Specsavers Pty Ltd v The Optical Superstore Pty Ltd (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 652
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Specsavers Pty Ltd commenced proceedings against The Optical Superstore Pty Ltd and others, seeking damages for copyright infringement and misleading and deceptive conduct. The dispute involved claims under an undertaking given by Specsavers, where the amount initially claimed was a fraction of the amount awarded. The legal issues centred around whether the parties claiming under the undertaking were successful, if costs should be reduced because of the size of the award, and whether The Optical Superstore acted unreasonably.

The court considered whether the terms of the offer of compromise made by Specsavers were ambiguous and if The Optical Superstore was imprudent or unreasonable in failing to accept it. The court held that the offer was ambiguous as it did not explicitly include the costs of the claim under the undertaking. The court also noted that by the time the offer was made, most of The Optical Superstore’s costs had already been incurred. The court concluded that The Optical Superstore was not imprudent or unreasonable in failing to accept the offer.

The court ordered that Specsavers pay 65% of the respondents’ costs, including disbursements, for their claim for damages under the undertaking. This decision underscores the importance of clarity in offers of compromise and the court's discretion in assessing costs based on the circumstances of the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant pay 65% of the respondents’ costs (including disbursements) of their claim for damages under the undertaking.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Several issues arise. How should the costs up to the time of this offer be assessed? Should costs follow the event? Was The Optical Superstore in fact successful? Did it act unreasonably? Was the offer made on 7 September 2011 an offer of compromise under the Rules? If so, was the sum awarded less favourable than the terms of the offer? Even so, could the offer bind the licensees who had not then been added to the proceeding? If not, what should happen about their costs?THE EVIDENCE Lynne Peach, Specsavers’ solicitor, swore an affidavit setting out the relevant history and annexing the relevant correspondence. The respondents filed no evidence. They merely relied on a number of documents said to cast light on the meaning of the terms of the September 2011 offer of compromise. Importantly, the evidence indicates that Specsavers made several offers to settle the proceeding and on each occasion those offers were met with silence. The evidence does show that, before the second to eighth respondents were added (in October 2011), the parties participated in a mediation, but there is no evidence about whether The Optical Superstore’s position was any different there. The mediation was presumably conducted in confidence and there was evidently no agreement to waive confidentiality. The evidence Specsavers relied upon is summarised below. On 9 June 2010 Specsavers served an offer of compromise purportedly in accordance with O 23 of the former Rules in which it proposed that the Court make a declaration that the Tailor Made TVC contravened ss 52 and 53(e) of the TPA, that each party pay its own costs and that the proceeding be otherwise dismissed. The Optical Superstore did not respond to the offer. A mediation took place on 14 October 2010. Four days later Specsavers’ solicitors (Minter Ellison) wrote to the solicitors for The Optical Superstore (Maddocks) stating, amongst other things:… our client finds it difficult to see how your client will demonstrate that it (scil.) suffered any damage as a result of the injunction … In particular, we note that:(a)the [Standard] TVC was broadcast for 7 days during the period between 4 February 2007 to 10 February 2010;(b)it is not uncommon in this industry for advertisements to only run for 1 week;(c)there was no gap in your client’s advertising as it caused the Tailor Made TVC to be broadcast from 6 February 2010 to 11 February 2010; and (d)in paragraph 28 of your client’s Defence dated 26 February 2010, it is said that the [Standard] TVC may now be out of date and accordingly it had no further intention to cause the advertisement to be broadcast. Specsavers claimed that in the circumstances its “walk away” offer of 9 June 2010 was reasonable and it would continue to rely on it. Nonetheless, it made a further offer to settle on the basis that Specsavers pay damages of $100,000 (inclusive of GST, if any), the terms of any settlement be kept confidential, and the proceedings be otherwise dismissed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Optical Superstore did not contend that the offer of compromise was not an offer made under the Rules. Provided the judgment obtained was less favourable than terms of the offer, the presumption in favour of indemnity costs would therefore apply, although it could not bind the licensees who were not then parties to the proceeding. The next question, then, is whether the judgment by The Optical Superstore was less favourable than the terms of the offer. Was the judgment less favourable than the terms of the offer? As the sum mentioned in the first paragraph of the offer was greater than the amount of damages awarded to all eight respondents, there is no room for doubt that the judgment sum was less favourable than the amount proposed in the first paragraph of the offer. But the offer must be read as a whole. As Tamberlin J said in Brother Industries, Limited v Dynamics Supplies Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 126 at [6] of the predecessor of r 25.14:it is necessary to have regard to the terms of the orders in their totality. While an individual order may in its terms suggest a different conclusion to the one ultimately reached by the Court, no single particular order is determinative. It is necessary to weigh the overall effect of all the orders made. The word “favourable” in O 23 r 11(4) requires a balancing of the relative impacts of all the orders. Mr O’Bryan argued that the offer unambiguously made no allowance for the costs of the second part of the proceeding and, for this reason, the judgment was not less favourable than the terms of the offer, it being reasonable to assume that the successful party would recover costs in addition to its damages. Alternatively, he submitted, it was ambiguous in its terms and the ambiguity should be resolved in The Optical Superstore’s favour. While not disputing the assumption in Mr O’Bryan’s principal argument, Mr Studdy submitted that the offer provided (in effect) for the costs of all the proceeding relating to the Standard TVC and that necessarily included the claim for damages under the undertaking. Consequently, on any view of the matter, the offer was more favourable than the amount awarded to the respondents. I reject Mr O’Bryan’s primary argument but I accept his alternative submission. I think the offer was ambiguous. At the time it was made, the question of the costs of the first part of the proceeding remained to be determined. Although it is possible to read Specsavers’ offer in the way Mr Studdy urged, the references to the costs of the proceedings in respect of the two TVCs could be construed as references to the costs of the first part of the proceeding only and not to encompass the costs of the claim under the undertaking. A careful reading of the earlier offers gives rise to the inference that this was Specsavers’ intention. By the time the September 2011 offer of compromise was made, the bulk of The Optical Superstore’s costs had been incurred. Because I am persuaded that the did not make provision for the costs of the claim under the undertaking, I am not satisfied that the judgment was less favourable than the terms of the offer. Of course, that does not mean that the offer should necessarily be ignored. It may be taken into account in the exercise of the Court’s discretion. Still, in all the circumstances and having regard to the level of costs likely to have been incurred by this point in time, I do not think it could be said that The Optical Superstore was imprudent or unreasonable in failing to accept it.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.