Spalla v St George Motor Finance Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Spalla v St George Motor Finance Ltd (ACN 007 656 555) [2004] FCA 1014

ANTHONY PATRICK SPALLA, ANDREW DAVID BENTLEY STILL, IRLMOND PTY LTD (ACN 066 314 870) (RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED;  IN LIQUIDATION)  -v-  ST GEORGE MOTOR FINANCE LTD (ACN 007 656 555), ST GEORGE WHOLESALE FINANCE PTY LTD (ACN 001 834 886), ANDREW WILLIAM BECK, ANDREW STEWART HOME, DELOITTE TOUCHE TOHMATSU, AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION AND SIMON ALEXANDER WALLACE SMITH

V 3203 of 2002

RYAN J

6 AUGUST 2004
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY V 3203 of 2002
BETWEEN: ANTHONY PATRICK SPALLA First Applicant
ANDREW DAVID BENTLEY STILL Second Applicant

IRLMOND PTY LTD (ACN 066 314 870)
(Receivers and Managers appointed;  in liquidation)

Third Applicant
AND:

ST GEORGE MOTOR FINANCE LTD
(ACN 007 656 555)

First Respondent
ST GEORGE WHOLESALE FINANCE PTY LTD (ACN 001 834 886) Second Respondent
ANDREW WILLIAM BECK Third Respondent
ANDREW STEWART HOME Fourth Respondent
DELOITTE TOUCHE TOHMATSU Fifth Respondent
AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION Sixth Respondent
SIMON ALEXANDER WALLACE SMITH Seventh Respondent
ORDER
JUDGE: RYAN J
DATE: 6 AUGUST 2004
PLACE: MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The motion on notice dated 5 April 2004 be refused. 

2.The first and second respondents pay the applicants’ costs of the said motion to be taxed in default of agreement and there be no order as to the costs of the other respondents of the said motion.

3.        There be a further directions hearing herein on a date to be fixed.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY V 3203 of 2002
BETWEEN: ANTHONY PATRICK SPALLA First Applicant
ANDREW DAVID BENTLEY STILL Second Applicant

IRLMOND PTY LTD (ACN 066 314 870)
(Receivers and Managers appointed;  in liquidation)

Third Applicant
AND:

ST GEORGE MOTOR FINANCE LTD
(ACN 007 656 555)

First Respondent
ST GEORGE WHOLESALE FINANCE PTY LTD (ACN 001 834 886) Second Respondent
ANDREW WILLIAM BECK Third Respondent
ANDREW STEWART HOME Fourth Respondent
DELOITTE TOUCHE TOHMATSU Fifth Respondent
AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION Sixth Respondent
SIMON ALEXANDER WALLACE SMITH

Seventh Respondent

ORDER
JUDGE: RYAN J
DATE: 6 AUGUST 2004
PLACE: MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT ON MOTION FOR STAY OF PROCEEDINGS

  1. There is before the Court a motion on notice filed 5 April 2004 on behalf of the first and second respondents (hereafter collectively called “St George”) seeking, amongst other things;

    ‘2.       That the proceedings be stayed as an abuse of process;

    3.Further or alternatively, insofar as the Amended Statement of Claim of the Applicants filed and dated 9 December 2003 or the Replies filed by the Applicants refers to documents obtained by the First and Second Applicants or their legal advisors in the course of the criminal proceedings, and through them the liquidator of the Third Applicant, it be stayed as an abuse of process;’

    Background

  2. In about August 2002, a criminal trial of the first…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Spalla v St George Motor Finance Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 1014
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Spalla v St George Motor Finance Ltd was before the Court where the respondents, St George, filed a motion on notice seeking to stay the proceedings on the grounds of abuse of process. St George also sought to stay the proceedings insofar as the applicants referred to documents obtained in the course of criminal proceedings and through them the liquidator of the third applicant. The applicants, Spalla and Still, were facing a criminal trial in the County Court of Victoria on charges preferred by the Director of Public Prosecutions for the Commonwealth. Before the trial commenced, Corrs Chambers Westgarth, a firm of solicitors, had acted for St George in relation to the appointment of receivers to companies controlled by Spalla. During the investigation leading to the criminal trial, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission obtained various documents from St George and Corrs, some of which were relevant to the applicants’ civil proceedings.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the motion on notice should be granted and the proceedings stayed as an abuse of process. Specifically, the Court had to determine if the documents obtained by ASIC during the criminal proceedings and their subsequent use in the civil proceedings constituted an abuse of process. Another legal issue was whether the implied undertaking to the extent that it was still binding, should apply to a particular document.

The Court held that it was not a proper exercise of its discretion to anticipate an inquiry into the issue of whether the documents themselves established a prima facie case of fraud or illegality by staying an action which had as its essential hypothesis some illegality, fraud, or abuse of power by one or more of the respondents. The Court found that the need for admissible evidence might preclude resort to the very documents for which privilege was claimed. Therefore, the motion on notice was refused, and St George was ordered to pay the applicants' costs of the motion. The Court further directed that there be a further directions hearing to address outstanding questions of discovery, including legal professional privilege.

In summary, the Court refused the motion on notice seeking to stay the proceedings as an abuse of process and ordered a further directions hearing to address unresolved issues of discovery, including legal professional privilege. St George was also ordered to pay the applicants' costs of the motion on notice.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The motion on notice dated 5 April 2004 be refused.

2. The first and second respondents pay the applicants’ costs of the said motion to be taxed in default of agreement and there be no order as to the costs of the other respondents of the said motion.

3. There be a further directions hearing herein on a date to be fixed.

Background

Background to the litigation

There is before the Court a motion on notice filed 5 April 2004 on behalf of the first and second respondents (hereafter collectively called “St George”) seeking, amongst other things;‘2. That the proceedings be stayed as an abuse of process;3.Further or alternatively, insofar as the Amended Statement of Claim of the Applicants filed and dated 9 December 2003 or the Replies filed by the Applicants refers to documents obtained by the First and Second Applicants or their legal advisors in the course of the criminal proceedings, and through them the liquidator of the Third Applicant, it be stayed as an abuse of process;’Background In about August 2002, a criminal trial of the first and second applicants in this proceeding, Mr Spalla (“Spalla”) and Mr Still (“Still”) on charges preferred by the Director of Public Prosecutions for the Commonwealth (“the DPP”) commenced in the County Court of Victoria before his Honour, Judge Hart. Before that trial commenced, Corrs Chambers Westgarth (“Corrs”), a firm of solicitors had acted for St George in relation to the appointment on 12 April 1999 of receivers (Mr Beck and Mr Home) to the third applicant herein (“Irlmond”) and APS Wholesale Pty Ltd (“APS”). Each of those companies had effectively been controlled by Spalla and through them he had conducted different aspects of the business of a motor trader carried on under the name “Essendon Mitsubishi” and “North City Daewoo”. In the course of that retainer, Corrs had given advice to St George and communicated with the receivers. In the course of investigations which led to the criminal trial and while investigating the conduct of Beck and Home, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (“ASIC”) obtained various documents from St George and Corrs. To facilitate the procurement of some of those documents, ASIC had issued to Corrs and St George notices under ss 30 and 33 of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) (“the ASIC Act”). Those sections provide;‘30 (1) ASIC may give to: (a) a body corporate that is not an exempt public authority;or (b) an eligible person in relation to such a body corporate; a written notice requiring the production to a specified member or staff member, at a specified place and time, of specified books relating to affairs of the body. (2) ASIC may give to: (a) the responsible entity of a registered scheme; or (b)an eligible person in relation to the responsible entity; a written notice requiring the production to a specified member or staff member, at a specified place and time, of specified books relating to the operation of the scheme.’‘33ASIC may give to a person a written notice requiring the production to a specified member or staff member, at a specified place and time, of specified books that are in the first-mentioned person's possession and relate to: (a) affairs of a body corporate; or (ab) affairs of a registered scheme; or (b)a matter referred to in any of paragraphs 31(1)(g) to (m), inclusive; or (c) a matter referred to in paragraph 32A(c) or (d).’

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The need to which McHugh J there referred for admissible evidence may preclude resort to the very documents for which privilege is claimed as themselves establishing a prima facie case of fraud or illegality. In any event, I do not consider it a proper exercise of this Court’s discretion to anticipate an inquiry into that issue by staying an action which has as essential hypothesis some illegality, fraud or abuse of power by one or more of the respondents.Conclusion For the reasons which I have endeavoured to explain, the motion on notice dated 5 April 2004 will be refused. St George must pay the applicants’ costs of that motion and there will be no order as to any other party’s costs of the motion. I shall order that there be a further directions hearing on a date to be fixed when the resolution of outstanding questions of discovery including legal professional privilege can be addressed. Of course, nothing in the orders which I propose or these reasons should be taken as causing the implied undertaking, to the extent that it is still binding, to cease to apply to a particular document.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.