Spalding & Barbaro (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND
FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 1)

Spalding & Barbaro (No 5) [2023] FedCFamC1F 723

File number(s): BRC 6176 of 2021
Judgment of: HOGAN J
Date of judgment: 25 August 2023
Catchwords: FAMILY LAW – PARENTING – Where final orders were made in May 2018 for an equal time parenting regime – where the parental conflict has not abated – Where it is now in the children’s best interests for them to live with one parent and have no time or communication with the other  
Legislation:

Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)

Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth)

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Family Law) Rules 2021

Cases cited:

Banks & Banks (2015) 93-637

Cox & Pedrana (2013) FLC 93-537

Fleming & Fleming [2009] FamCA 552

Spalding & Barbaro [2018] FamCA 362

Division: First Instance
Number of paragraphs: 268
Date of hearing: 28, 29 & 30 November 2022; 1, 2, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9 December 2022; 27 January 2023 
Place: Brisbane
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Bunning
Solicitor for the Applicant: Simonidis Steel Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr Dodd
Solicitor for the Respondent: Mills Oakley Lawyers
Counsel for the Independent Children's Lawyer: Mr Pollock
Solicitor for the Independent Children's Lawyer: Barbara Fox Solicitor

ORDERS

BRC 6176 of 2021

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 1)

BETWEEN:

MR SPALDING

Applicant

AND:

MS BARBARO

Respondent

INDEPENDENT CHILDREN'S LAWYER

ORDER MADE BY:

HOGAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

25 AUGUST 2023

IT IS ORDERED BY WAY OF FINAL ORDER THAT:

1.All parenting plans and, save as they also relate to the issue of child support, previous parenting orders are discharged.

2.The children, D, born 2008, E, born 2009, B and C, both born 2012, live with mother.

3.The mother have sole parental responsibility for the children in respect of all major long-term issues (as that expression is defined in the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)).

4.Pursuant to s 68B of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) the father is hereby restrained and an injunction shall issue restraining him from communicating or attempting to communicate with the mother and/or the children and approaching:

(a)the mother or the children; and

(b)the residence of the mother or the children; and

(c)the place of employment of the mother; and

(d)the place of education of the children; and

(e)the place of any medical treatment of the children.

5.Pursuant to s 68B of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) the father is hereby restrained and an injunction issue restraining him from having the mother or the children followed by a private investigator.

6.Pursuant to s 68B of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) the father is hereby restrained and an injunction issue restraining him from communicating with the children’s educators or medical or allied health providers.

7.Pursuant to s 68B of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) the father is hereby restrained and an injunction issue restraining him from removing the children from the Commonwealth of Australia.

8.The mother shall not denigrate, or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Spalding & Barbaro (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FedCFamC1F 723
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia considered the case of Spalding & Barbaro (No 5), where the court was required to decide on the best parenting arrangements for the children after a history of parental conflict. The court had previously ordered an equal time parenting regime in May 2018, but the ongoing conflict between the parents meant the situation had not improved. The legal issues before the court involved determining the best interests of the children, given the persistent conflict and whether it was appropriate for the children to live with one parent exclusively.

The court found that the father’s evidence was significantly impaired by his inability to separate his personal grievances from the well-being of the children. The father's testimony was often inconsistent and self-serving, and he failed to acknowledge the children's issues when in his care. The mother's evidence was deemed more reliable and consistent with the children's needs. The court concluded that it was in the children's best interests to live with the mother exclusively and have no contact with the father. The father was also restrained from communicating with the children or the mother, and from interfering with their lives in various ways.

The court issued detailed final orders, including that the children live with the mother, that the mother have sole parental responsibility for all major long-term issues, and that the father be restrained from various forms of communication and interference. The mother was permitted to travel overseas with the children without the father's consent, and both parents were granted leave to share the court orders with relevant parties. Additionally, the father was ordered to obtain a new private health insurance policy for the children. The court also provided detailed instructions for any future applications for costs related to the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

BRC 6176 of 2021

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 1)

BETWEEN:

MR SPALDING

Applicant

AND:

MS BARBARO

Respondent

INDEPENDENT CHILDREN'S LAWYER

ORDER MADE BY:

HOGAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

25 AUGUST 2023

IT IS ORDERED BY WAY OF FINAL ORDER THAT:

1. All parenting plans and, save as they also relate to the issue of child support, previous parenting orders are discharged.

2. The children, D, born 2008, E, born 2009, B and C, both born 2012, live with mother.

3. The mother have sole parental responsibility for the children in respect of all major long-term issues (as that expression is defined in the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)).

4. Pursuant to s 68B of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) the father is hereby restrained and an injunction shall issue restraining him from communicating or attempting to communicate with the mother and/or the children and approaching:

(a) the mother or the children; and

(b) the residence of the mother or the children; and

(c) the place of employment of the mother; and

(d) the place of education of the children; and

(e) the place of any medical treatment of the children.

5. Pursuant to s 68B of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) the father is hereby restrained and an injunction issue restraining him from having the mother or the children followed by a private investigator.

6. Pursuant to s 68B of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) the father is hereby restrained and an injunction issue restraining him from communicating with the children’s educators or medical or allied health providers.

7. Pursuant to s 68B of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) the father is hereby restrained and an injunction issue restraining him from removing the children from the Commonwealth of Australia.

8. The mother shall not denigrate, or permit any other person to denigrate, the father in the presence or hearing of the children.

9. The Independent Children’s Lawyer make all arrangements necessary to have Ms AC meet with the children as soon as reasonably practicable in order to explain this Order to them.

10. In order to facilitate the children meeting with Ms AC in accordance with the above Order, the mother ensure that the children attend upon Ms AC at the time and place advised in writing by the Independent Children’s Lawyer.

11. The Independent Children’s Lawyer has leave to provide a copy of the Final Orders made 25 August 2023 and the Reasons for Judgment published in support of the same to Ms AC.

12. Pursuant to s 65Y(2) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) the mother is permitted to travel overseas with the children without the father’s consent.

13. Pursuant to s 11(1)(b) of the Australian Passports Act 2005 (Cth) the children, D, born 2008, E, born 2009, B and C, both born 2012, be permitted to have a passport or an Australian travel document (as defined by s 6 of the Australian Passports Act 2005 (Cth)) and be permitted to travel internationally.

14. The mother be permitted to unilaterally do all such acts and sign all such documents as may be required to apply for or renew a passport (or Australian travel document) for the child or any other documents deemed necessary for the purpose of overseas travel.

15. The mother is permitted (in so far as this Order will permit her to do so) to unilaterally complete, sign and lodge any application for the issue and/or renewal of visas or any other requirement of the authorities of the destination country/(ies) for the children’s travel outside the Commonwealth of Australia, without the father’s consent.

16. The mother has leave to provide a copy of the Order made 25 August 2023 and the Reasons for Judgment published in support of the same to the school at which the children attend, to any therapist upon whom she and/or the children attend for the purpose of therapy and to the Department of Child Safety, Seniors and Disability Services, the authority of any State or Territory responsible for child protection and, if necessary, to any member of the Queensland Police Service, the police service of another State or Territory and the Australian Federal Police.

17. The father has leave to provide a copy of the Order made 25 August 2023 and the Reasons for Judgment published in support of the same to any therapist upon whom he attends for the purpose of therapy and to the Department of Child Safety, Seniors and Disability Services, the authority of any State or Territory responsible for child protection and, if necessary, to any member of the Queensland Police Service, the police service of another State or Territory and the Australian Federal Police.

18. Save as is otherwise ordered herein, no party is permitted to use the documents provided to them in the course of this proceeding for any purpose other than this proceeding or any appeal in respect of these Orders.

19. The Independent Children’s Lawyer is discharged upon compliance with Order 9 unless a Notice of Appeal is filed by any party within the time prescribed or such other time as allowed by Order.

20. All outstanding parenting applications are otherwise dismissed and removed from the list of cases requiring finalisation.

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED THAT:

21. By way of costs assessment order or otherwise as ancillary to the Order made on 18 March 2022, the father pay the mother the sum of $91,450.18 within thirty (30) days of today.

UPON THE FATHER SAYING IN EVIDENCE THAT HE WOULD TAKE OUT A NEW HEALTH INSURANCE POLICY FOR THE CHILDREN IT IS ORDERED THAT:

22. The father shall, if it is possible for him to do so, forthwith obtain a new private health insurance policy at the top rate of cover for the children only, and within fourteen (14) days of the date of this Order, the father shall:

(a) provide to the mother a physical card which provides her access to the children’s private health insurance policy; and

(b) sign all documents and do all things necessary with AG Insurance to authorise the mother to have access to, and make claims against the children’s private health insurance policy,

and should the physical card or authority expire, the father shall provide to the mother a renewed physical card and shall provide a renewed authority to AG Insurance to enable the mother to have access to and make claims against the children’s private health insurance policy at all times.

AND IT IS FURTHER ORDERED THAT

23. In the event that any party seeks an order that another party pay the costs of and incidental to the proceedings commenced by Initiating Application filed 31 May 2021 and Further Further Amended and sealed on 10 October 2022:

(a) any such party shall, within twenty-eight (28) days of today, file and serve

(i) any Application in a Proceeding setting out the relief sought; and

(ii) any affidavit necessary to support such application; and

(iii) written submissions in support of such application for costs; and

(b) the party against whom an order for costs is sought shall, within a further fourteen (14) days thereafter, file and serve:

(i) any affidavit necessary for the determination of any such application for costs; and

(ii) any written submissions in answer to the submissions filed and served by the party seeking an order for costs; and

(c) the party seeking an order for costs shall, within seven (7) days of being served with the submissions relied on by the party against whom an order for costs is sought, file and serve any further written submissions, strictly in reply, to the submissions served by the party against whom an order for costs is sought,

and any such application for costs shall be considered in Chambers.

AND IT IS FURTHER ORDERED THAT

24. Pursuant to s 65DA(2) and s 62B of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), the particulars of the obligations these Orders create and the particulars of the consequences that may follow if a person contravenes these Orders and details of who can assist parties to adjust to and comply with an Order are set out in the Fact Sheet attached and these particulars are included in these Orders.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Unlike the position advanced on behalf of the mother, however, the Independent Children’s Lawyer proposed, as was reflected in the Minute of Orders attached to the written submissions filed on her behalf,[18] included that orders be made to enable the father to obtain copies of the children’s school progress reports and school photographs at his own expense. [19] Some general comments about the evidence given by, and the credit of, some of the witnesses[18] Sealed 13 January 2023.[19] Written submissions filed by the Independent Children’s Lawyer on 13 January 2023. The father I consider that the father’s evidence was tainted by what appeared to be his inability to do much other than try to sheet home responsibility for D’s behaviours to the mother; his views about her coloured his evidence completely. I consider the father struggled to be truthful on a number of occasions – for example:(a)he struggled to accept that D had demonstrated dysregulated behaviour in his care – despite notes of his reports to various clinicians and agencies establishing this as a fact; and(b)he denied that D had expressed any suicidal comments or ideations whilst in his care – despite the notes of his report to TT Mental Health Service in mid-2020 including that he had said that D had a “history of attempting suicide […]. Father intervened.”; his evidence, when cross-examined about this, included that D had gone to get a lethal object once; he (the father) had come home and asked him what he was doing and D had said “nothing” and that he was messing around, but E said that D was talking about killing himself; and(c)he initially denied telling a staff member in late 2020 information which resulted in the notes recording that “Father alleged mother is prostituting herself” – before saying that he had only said this once, when D was hospitalised (which had not happened until the following month) and that his comments had to be taken in the context of him responding to questions he said had been asked of him during a discussion about D’s sexualised behaviour and lewd things he was doing: he said, in essence, that he had only provided the information recorded in the relevant notes (set out in the Schedule) in response to questions asked of him – his evidence included that he advised the clinician that a parent at the school had brought to his attention that the mother was “escorting” and he had relayed what he had because he was concerned about how the boys had been behaving; and(d)despite sending the mother an email on 21 January 2021 which said “You are to care for [D] until I obtain an order directing you otherwise.”, the father denied that this was suggestive of him relinquishing D’s care to the mother; and(e)despite asserting that Dr PP had told him that D’s appointments should be booked in the weeks when he was living with him, there is nothing in the clinician’s notes to suggest this was the case; and(f)the father said that Dr NN had told him that the mother had Munchhausen-by-proxy and that he had authored an unreleased report which contained the assertion that the mother had Munchhausen-by-proxy – but Dr NN’s evidence (which I prefer to that given by the father) was that he could not recall ever suggesting to the father that the mother had Munchhausen-by-proxy and it would be wrong to record that he had told him this, that all of his interactions with the mother had always been typical and that it was wrong to suggest that he had authored an unreleased report which contained the assertion that the mother had Munchhausen-by-proxy.Dr GG

Decision

Reasons for decision

Before turning to this task, however, I consider it useful to record aspects of the findings expressed by Carew J in the May 2018 Reasons. Some aspects of the Reasons for Judgment delivered by Carew J on 23 May 2018 (the May 2018 Reasons) Based on the evidence before the Court of events which predated the April 2018 trial, her Honour’s conclusions included that:(a)she considered “each parent to be at fault for the conflict in largely equal degrees” and that the “conduct in which each has engaged has been nothing short of appalling”;[5] and(b)if there had been a realistic option of removing the children from the care of both parents she would have seriously considered it – not because either parent was unable to provide an adequate level of physical care for the children, but because of “the level of enmity and distrust directed by the parents at each other and their seeming inability to put their hatred of each other aside for the benefit of their children”;[6] and(c)she was “very pessimistic” about the future outcomes for the children and considered that “it is unlikely that any order of this Court will end the conflict between these parents or completely protect the children from exposure to ongoing conflict”;[7] and(d)she thought that living with one parent predominantly and spending only weekend time with the other parent was unlikely to protect the children as the ‘losing’ parent was likely to undermine the arrangement and the parent with the predominant care was likely to have a greater influence on the children, perhaps in a negative way;[8] and(e)whilst it may have appeared counterintuitive, the order she determined to be proper “in the unique circumstances of this case” was for the children to live with each of their parents in an equal-time parenting regime and for the parents to have equal shared parental responsibility for the major long-term issues relating to the children, other than in relation to the issue of health and education (for which she accorded the father sole parental responsibility after consulting with the mother) because she concluded that “anything short of ‘equality’ of time” was more likely to expose the children to conflict.[9] [5] Spalding & Barbaro [2018] FamCA 362 at [1].[6] Spalding & Barbaro [2018] FamCA 362 at [2] and [3].[7] Spalding & Barbaro [2018] FamCA 362 at [4].[8] Spalding & Barbaro [2018] FamCA 362 at [151].[9] Spalding & Barbaro [2018] FamCA 362 at [5] and [6]. The May 2018 Reasons also included her Honour’s statement that she could only “hope that the parents take heed of my reasons for judgment, and the pleas of their children for peace, and change their ways before it is too late.”[10] [10] Spalding & Barbaro [2018] FamCA 362 at [6]. The resolution of the question posed in paragraph 8 necessarily involves some consideration of whether either or both of the parents have taken Carew J’s findings on board and adjusted their behaviours.Some general comments about these Reasons, including the Schedule to the same

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.