Southern Forest Export Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

Southern Forest Export Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs [2020] AATA 1892 (22 June 2020)

Division:Taxation and Commercial Division

File Number(s):      2019/2045

Re:Southern Forest Export Pty Ltd

APPLICANT

AndComptroller-General of Customs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Boyle

Date:22 June 2020

Place:Perth

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

...................................[SGD]..................................

Deputy President Boyle

CATCHWORDS

CUSTOMS – Tariff Concession Order – equipment – TCO criteria – performance based criterion – statutory interpretation – hypothetical performance – “wharfside test” – implied term – gloss – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Acts Interpretation Act1901 (Cth) – s15AA

Customs Act 1901 (Cth) – ss 163, 269F(3)(a), Part XVA, VIII

Customs Tariff Act 1995 (Cth) – s18, Sch 4

CASES

Becker Vale Pty Ltd v Chief Executive Officer of Customs [2015] FCA 525

Brand Developments Aust Pty Ltd and Chief Executive Officer of Customs [2015] AATA 215

Newbridge Civil Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs [2016] AATA 81

Times Consultants Pty Ltd v Collector of Customs(Qld) (1987) 16 FCR 449

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Customs Regulations 2015 Bill (Cth) – sub-reg 107(3)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Boyle

22 June 2020

THE APPLICATION

  1. The Applicant seeks the review of the Respondent’s decision not to apply a tariff concession under the Customs Tariff Act 1995 (CT Act) to a freeze dryer used in the preparation of pet food which was manufactured in and imported from Taiwan (the freeze dryer).

    BACKGROUND

  2. In or about late 2018 the Applicant imported the freeze dryer from Taiwan. In January 2019 the Applicant applied for an exemption to the import duties applying to the freeze dryer on the ground that no such machine is produced in Australia.

  3. The Applicant’s application for exemption, and a refund of the import duty paid,[1]
    was made pursuant to s 163 of the Customs Act 1901 (Cth) (the Customs Act) and

    [1] T5.1.

    [2] T5.2.

    sub-reg 107(3) of the Customs Regulations 2015 (Cth), on the basis that the subject goods were eligible for a concessional rate of duty. The Applicant claims that it is entitled to an exemption under Tariff Concession Order (TCO) 9102659.[2]
  4. An assessment was undertaken of the refund application by the Respondent. During that assessment process the Applicant provided further information about the freeze dryer.[3]

    [3] T5, T5.1-5.4, T7, T 7.1-7.2, T9, T9.1.

  5. On 18 March 2019 the Respondent rejected the refund application on the basis that TCO 9102659 did not apply to the freeze dryer.[4] It is of that decision that the Applicant seeks review.[5]

    [4] T13, T14.

    [5] T1

    THE LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK

  6. The import of goods into Australia is regulated by the Customs Act. Part VIII provides for the payment and computation of any duty payable on those goods. The rate of duty payable in respect of goods is dealt with in the CT Act.

  7. The CT Act provides for duty to be paid on goods. In broad terms, s 18 of the CT Act provides for the duty on goods to which an…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Southern Forest Export Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Cu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 1892
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Southern Forest Export Pty Ltd (the Applicant) sought to have a freeze dryer classified under Tariff Concession Order (TCO) 9102695. The Comptroller-General of Customs (the Respondent) opposed this, arguing the freeze dryer did not meet the performance criteria stipulated in the TCO. The matter came before Deputy Boyle P.

The central legal issue was the interpretation of TCO 9102695, specifically a performance-based criterion relating to condenser temperature. The Applicant contended that the freeze dryer met the criterion if it was capable of achieving a condenser temperature of -60°C or lower, even if this was only a theoretical or possible performance. The Respondent argued that the criterion should be assessed based on the goods' condition as imported and their normal operating conditions, applying the "wharfside test" which requires goods to precisely meet the description of a TCO in their imported state.

Deputy Boyle P reasoned that TCOs are intended to protect Australian manufacturing and must be interpreted with a realistic application. The TCO in question was deficient in not specifying the operating conditions under which the performance criterion should be measured. In the absence of such explicit conditions, a gloss or implied condition must be inferred. The Tribunal considered that interpreting the criterion as referring to theoretical or possible performance, outside the manufacturer's specified operating range, would render the criterion meaningless and undermine the purpose of the TCO. Instead, the Tribunal implied a condition that the performance criterion should apply to the freeze dryer operating under normal or reasonably foreseeable conditions, as indicated by the manufacturer's specifications and the actual operating environment.

Consequently, the Tribunal found that the freeze dryer did not come within the description of TCO 9102695, as it did not meet the performance criterion under normal operating conditions. The decision under review was affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the present case a TCO, the purpose of which is to protect Australian manufacturing, which is expressed in terms of a performance characteristic cannot, in the Tribunal’s view, be interpreted to mean a possible or theoretical performance, one not even anticipated by the manufacturer as being within the normal range of operating conditions. Because TCO 9102695 is deficient, or perhaps more kindly, incomplete, in that it does not identify the operating conditions in which the performance criterion is to be measured or met, a gloss or condition must be implied. The Applicant, in effect, proposes that the performance criteria in TCO 9102695 are to be read as theoretical or possible performance and the Respondent, in effect, proposes that the criteria are to be read to mean a level of performance in normal operational conditions. Given that the manufacturer itself stipulates a condenser temperature based on a specified operating temperature range, which is a range that reflects the conditions that the freeze dryer has operated in since its importation and is likely to continue to operate in, the obviously more sensible interpretation of TCO 9102695 is that it is to be read as to apply to a freeze dryer operating in normal or reasonably foreseeable operating conditions. To apply the Applicant’s interpretation of theoretical or possible satisfaction of a performance criterion in conditions unlikely to be encountered, and outside the manufacturers assumed range of operation, would largely render any unqualified performance criteria meaningless and significantly undermine, if not defeat, the purpose of the TCO. TCOs, to be effective, have to be given a realistic application.DECISION The Tribunal finds that the freeze dryer does not come within the description TCO 9102659. Accordingly, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As noted above, the Respondent had made submissions in its SFIC about TCOs being interpreted applying principles of statutory interpretation, in particular that words should be given their “ordinary meaning”[11] and that the goods in question must “‘precisely’ meet the description of a TCO in their condition as imported”.[12] The Respondent cited Becker Vale Pty Ltd v Chief Executive Officer of Customs[13] at [57], referring to Brand Developers Aust Pty Ltd v Chief Executive Officer of Customs[14] at [29]-[44] and cases cited at [31]. [11] SFIC para. 20.[12] SFIC para. 20.[13] [2015] FCA 525.[14] [2015] AATA 215.CONSIDERATION The issue in the present case goes more to what TCO 9102695 requires and in what circumstances, rather than whether the freeze dryer “precisely meets the description”. Obviously, in one sense, it does not meet the relevant criterion because the machine in the vast majority of operating conditions, including those identified in the manufacturer’s standard specifications, does not operate with a condenser temperature of -60°C or lower and since it has been operating it has not met the criterion. In another sense, however, the freeze dryer does meet the criterion because it is capable, if one accepts the Applicant’s extrapolation and the manufacturer’s additional information, of operating with a condenser temperature of -60°C. The difficulty arises because of the somewhat incomplete or cryptic drafting of TCO 9102659. As the Tribunal noted at the hearing, it is usual for specifications of a piece of machinery to specify operating assumptions, conditions and parameters if any sort of performance warranty is included. In that sense the manufacturer’s “Specification Confirmation Letter”[15] did that in specifying a work environment temperature range (see [19] above). Unfortunately, TCO 9102659 does not do that. [15] T5.3. The Respondent’s submissions provided after the hearing referred to various cases that applied the “wharfside test”:14. In Woolworths Limited and the CEO of Customs [2013] AATA 730, the Tribunal applied the same “wharfside test” to whether goods come within the word description a TCO as is applied in the classification of goods, stating at [23]-[25]23. To determine whether goods come within the terms of a TCO a decision-maker must first ascertain the identity of the goods as at the time and port of entry: “The characteristics of the goods, their get-up, colour, decoration, labelling and packaging are all relevant considerations” (per Lockhart J, with whom Woodward and Ryan JJ agreed, in Chinese Food and Wine Supplies Pty Ltd v Collector of Customs (Vic)(1987) 72 ALR 591, at 599). The determination must be made objectively without reference to the intentions of the manufacturer, the exporter or the importer. In Times Consultants Pty Ltd v Collector of Customs(Qld) (1987) 16 FCR 449, at 462, the majority of the Federal Court, Morling and Wilcox JJ said:The authorities make it clear that in determining what is the essential character of goods it is the state or condition of the goods at the time of importation that is the determining factor and that it is wrong to classify goods or to determine their essential character by reference to the purpose of the importer or of the purchaser. Regard must be had to the characteristics of the goods themselves, as they would present themselves to an informed observer (emphasis added).