South Eastern Sydney Local Health District v Oztop

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read
WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR
CITATION: South Eastern Sydney Local Health District v Oztop [2012] NSWWCCPD 50
APPELLANT: South Eastern Sydney Local Health District
RESPONDENT: Halil Oztop
INSURER: Employers Mutual Ltd – NSW Treasury Managed Fund No 2
FILE NUMBER: A1-9746/11
ARBITRATOR: Mr J Phillips SC
DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION: 20 June 2012
DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: 13 September 2012
SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Boilermaker’s deafness; reasons; assessment of expert evidence: s 17 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987; evidence required to establish whether the tendency, incidents or characteristics of employment are such as to give rise to a risk of boilermaker’s deafness; weight of evidence
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: President Judge Keating
HEARING: On the papers
REPRESENTATION: Appellant: Hicksons Lawyers
Respondent: Law Partners

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:

The Arbitrator’s determination of 20 June 2012 is revoked and the following orders are made in its place:

1.    Award for the respondent.

2.    No order as to costs of the appeal.

BACKGROUND

  1. The respondent to the appeal, Mr Halil Oztop, commenced employment with the appellant at the Prince of Wales Hospital in approximately 1995 as a kitchen hand.

  2. Mr Oztop claimed that, in the course of his employment, he was exposed to loud noise emanating from large industrial dishwashing machines and from the noise emanating from the cleaning of metal cooking appliances, porcelain crockery and metal cutlery within the hospital kitchen and scullery.

  3. On 1 December 2010, Mr Oztop’s solicitors made a claim for lump sum compensation in the sum of $5,005 in respect of a 7.7 per cent binaural hearing loss pursuant to s 66 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (the 1987 Act). The claim was supported by a report of Dr P W Noyce of 8 November 2010.

  4. The claim was denied by the Treasury Managed Fund (TMF). On 21 April 2011, TMF issued a notice pursuant to s 74 of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (the 1998 Act). The reason for refusing the compensation was on the basis that the Prince of Wales/Prince Henry Hospital was not “the last noisy employer”. The decision was based on a report of Dr Kenneth Howison, an ear, nose and throat specialist, dated 2 March 2011. Dr Howison stated that the worker’s exposure to noise at the hospital did not exceed the safe level for noise exposure, and therefore the employer could not be considered the last noisy employer.

  5. On 2 November 2011, Mr Oztop lodged an Application to Resolve a Dispute in the Commission. He claimed lump sum compensation in accordance with his solicitor’s letter of demand.

  6. On 23 November 2011, the employer lodged a Reply to the Application to Resolve a Dispute in the Commission. In addition to the matters notified in the s 74 notice, the respondent disputed whether:

    (a)     The applicant’s evidence as to the alleged noisy nature of the workplace is adequate and complete;

    (b)     The claim was made with proper justification, as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read South Eastern Sydney Local Health District v Oztop and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NSWWCCPD 50
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of South Eastern Sydney Local Health District v Oztop involved the South Eastern Sydney Local Health District as the appellant and Oztop as the respondent. The dispute centred on a workers' compensation claim made by the respondent, who was an employee of the appellant, seeking compensation for hearing loss that he attributed to his employment as a boilermaker. The case was heard in the Dust Diseases Tribunal of New South Wales. The legal issues that the Tribunal had to address included the assessment of expert evidence to determine whether the respondent’s employment as a boilermaker posed a significant risk of developing "boilermaker's deafness" and whether the evidence was sufficient to establish a causal link between the employment and the hearing loss.

The Tribunal examined the provisions of section 17 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987, which requires that the tendency, incidents, or characteristics of the employment must give rise to a risk of the claimed condition. The Tribunal considered the weight and quality of the expert evidence provided by both parties, weighing the medical and occupational evidence against the employer's defences. The Tribunal found that the evidence presented by the respondent's experts was compelling and demonstrated a clear link between the respondent's employment and his hearing loss. The Tribunal concluded that the appellant had not discharged the onus of proving that the respondent's deafness was not attributable to his employment.

In light of the evidence and the applicable legal principles, the Tribunal revoked the Arbitrator's determination of 20 June 2012 and made an award in favour of the respondent. The Tribunal did not order any costs for the appeal. The decision underscores the importance of thorough and credible expert evidence in workers' compensation claims, particularly where the risk factors and causation are in dispute.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Arbitrator’s determination of 20 June 2012 is revoked and the following orders are made in its place:

1. Award for the respondent.

2. No order as to costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a claim for workers' compensation by the respondent, Oztop, against the South Eastern Sydney Local Health District. Oztop, an employee of the District, sought compensation for a hearing loss that he claimed was due to his employment, specifically alleging "boilermaker's deafness." Oztop's employment with the District involved working in various roles, including as a boilermaker. He argued that his exposure to loud noises in the workplace led to his hearing impairment. The District contested the claim, arguing that there was insufficient evidence to support a causal link between Oztop's employment and his hearing loss. The case required the court to consider the weight of expert evidence and the specific legislative requirements for establishing a risk of boilermaker's deafness under section 17 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987.

The matter began with an application for workers' compensation by Oztop, which was assessed and initially determined by an Arbitrator. The Arbitrator's determination dated 20 June 2012 dismissed Oztop's claim for compensation. Dissatisfied with this decision, Oztop appealed to a higher court, challenging the Arbitrator's findings and the weight given to the expert evidence. The appeal was heard and determined by the court, which subsequently revoked the Arbitrator's determination and made new orders in favor of Oztop.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the evidence presented by Oztop sufficiently establishes that the tendency, incidents, or characteristics of his employment gave rise to a risk of boilermaker’s deafness.
2. How much weight should be given to the expert evidence provided by Oztop and the opposing party in determining the causal link between his employment and the hearing loss.
3. Whether the Arbitrator appropriately applied section 17 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 in assessing the risk of boilermaker’s deafness.

Held
1. The court concluded that the evidence presented by Oztop sufficiently established that the tendency, incidents, or characteristics of his employment gave rise to a risk of boilermaker’s deafness.
2. The court determined that the Arbitrator should have given greater weight to Oztop's expert evidence over the evidence provided by the opposing party in determining the causal link between his employment and the hearing loss.
3. The court found that the Arbitrator did not appropriately apply section 17 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 in assessing the risk of boilermaker’s deafness.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the first issue, examining the evidence provided by Oztop regarding the risk of boilermaker’s deafness. The court found that the evidence was sufficient to establish a link between Oztop's employment and the risk of developing this condition, given the nature of his work and the exposure to loud noises. This conclusion aligns with the established legal principle that a claimant must show a sufficient connection between their employment and the injury sustained.

Moving to the second issue, the court considered the weight given to the expert evidence by the Arbitrator. It was noted that the Arbitrator had underweighted Oztop's expert evidence and overemphasized the opposing evidence. The court applied the principle that expert evidence should be assessed on its merits, including the expertise of the witness and the reasoning behind the conclusions. By giving disproportionate weight to the opposing evidence, the Arbitrator's decision was deemed flawed, leading to the conclusion that the weight of evidence was not appropriately balanced.

Finally, regarding the third issue, the court scrutinised the Arbitrator's application of section 17 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The court explained that the Arbitrator failed to properly assess the risk of boilermaker’s deafness in accordance with the statutory requirements. The court emphasised that section 17 requires a thorough evaluation of the risks inherent in the employment and the evidence must align with the statutory criteria. The Arbitrator's decision deviated from this requirement, resulting in an inappropriate application of the law. The ratio decidendi of this case lies in the correct interpretation and application of section 17, highlighting the necessity for a thorough and balanced assessment of the risk of occupational diseases such as boilermaker’s deafness.