Reported Decision:
59 NSWLR 259
Supreme Court
CITATION: South Eastern Sydney Area Health Service v Wallace [2003] NSWSC 1061 HEARING DATE(S): 5/11/03 JUDGMENT DATE:
24 November 2003JUDGMENT OF: Burchett AJ at 1 DECISION: Orders to be made for an application of the charitable gift in the Will cy-près in accordance with short minutes to be brought in. CATCHWORDS: CHARITIES - anomalous non-charitable "tomb trusts" - invalidity where the tomb is not part of a church and the trust is perpetual - rule against perpetuities - consequences for gift of surplus income to charity - exceptional rule where tomb trust is invalid - gift over to charity upon tomb falling into disrepair or where repair is in the opinion of the trustee "impracticable" - trustee bound to have that opinion if "tomb trust" invalid - whether trust to establish grave could be held valid though trust for its upkeep was void for perpetuity - whether gift to a charity (a hospital) took effect too remotely - whether gift to charity was a limitation on the failure or expectant on the determination of a limitation (the "tomb trust") that was void as a perpetuity- association with a prior invalid limitation distinguished from dependency or expectancy upon it - position where a gift is contingent upon alternative conditions some of which offend the rule against perpetuities but one does not - plaintiff's entitlement to charitable gift upon a cy-près order. LEGISLATION CITED: Perpetuities Act 1984 (NSW) CASES CITED: Allan, Re [1958] 1 WLR 220
Cambridge v Rous (1858) 25 Beav. 409; 53 ER 693
Canning's Will Trusts, Re [1936] Ch 309
Chamberlayne v Brockett (1872) LR 8 Ch 206
Chardon, Re [1928] 1 Ch 464
Coleman, Re [1936] Ch. 528
Coxen, Re; McCallum v Coxen [1948] 1 Ch 747
Curryer's Will Trusts, Re [1938] Ch. 952
Dalziel, Re (1943) 1 Ch 277
Davey, Re [1915] 1 Ch. 837
Dawson v Small (1874) LR 18 Eq 114
Durour v Motteux (1749) 1 Ves. Sen. 320; 27 ER 1057
Endacott, Re [1960] Ch. 232
Filshie, Re [1939] NZLR 91
Fisk v Attorney-General (1867) LR 4 Eq 521
Harvey, Re (1888) 39 Ch D 289
Jones, Re (1898) 79 LT 154
Kelly v Attorney-General [1917] 1 IR 183
Leahy v Attorney-General for New South Wales [1959] AC 457
Martin, Re [1952] WN (English) 339
Muir v Archdall (1918) 19 SR(NSW) 10
Norton, Re (1948) 64 TLR 582; Sub nom Re Norton's Will Trusts [1948] 2 All ER 842
Oldfield (No.2), Re [1949] 2 DLR 175
Pedulla v Nasti (1990) 20 NSWLR 720
Pettit, Re [1988] 2 NZLR 513
Pooley v The Royal Alexandra Hospital for Children (1932) 32 SR(NSW) 459
Porter, Re [1925] Ch. 746
Rogerson, Re [1901] 1 Ch. 715
Spehr, Re [1965] VR 770
Taylor, Re (1888) 58 LT 538
The Public Trustee v Nolan (1943) 43 SR(NSW) 169
Thomson v Shakespear (1860) 1 De G F & J 399
Tyler, Re [1891] 3 Ch 252PARTIES :
South Eastern Sydney Area…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read South Eastern Sydney Area Health Service v Wallace and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [2003] NSWSC 1061
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The case of South Eastern Sydney Area Health Service v Wallace involved a dispute concerning a tomb trust that was deemed invalid due to its perpetual nature and the absence of a connection to a church. The High Court of Australia was called upon to decide whether the gift of surplus income to a charitable institution was valid and whether the gift to the charity was contingent upon the failure or determination of the prior invalid limitation. The crux of the legal issue was to determine the validity of the gift to charity when the tomb trust was invalid and whether the gift was a limitation on the failure or expectant on the determination of a limitation that was void as a perpetuity.
The court examined the nature of the tomb trust and its invalidity due to the rule against perpetuities, which prohibits interests in property that might not vest within a certain time period. The court considered whether the gift to the charity was an immediate limitation on the failure of the tomb trust or if it was dependent upon the determination of the prior invalid limitation. The court distinguished between association with a prior invalid limitation and dependency or expectancy upon it. In doing so, the court found that the gift to the charity was not contingent upon the failure of the tomb trust but rather was a limitation on the failure of the trust, which made it valid. The court also noted that where a gift is contingent upon alternative conditions, some of which offend the rule against perpetuities but one does not, the gift would still be valid.
In conclusion, the court found in favour of the South Eastern Sydney Area Health Service, allowing them to claim the charitable gift upon a cy-près order. The court determined that the gift to the charity was valid and not dependent upon the failure of the tomb trust, as it was a limitation on the failure of the trust. This decision provides clarity on the validity of gifts to charities in situations where the associated trust is invalid due to the rule against perpetuities.
The court examined the nature of the tomb trust and its invalidity due to the rule against perpetuities, which prohibits interests in property that might not vest within a certain time period. The court considered whether the gift to the charity was an immediate limitation on the failure of the tomb trust or if it was dependent upon the determination of the prior invalid limitation. The court distinguished between association with a prior invalid limitation and dependency or expectancy upon it. In doing so, the court found that the gift to the charity was not contingent upon the failure of the tomb trust but rather was a limitation on the failure of the trust, which made it valid. The court also noted that where a gift is contingent upon alternative conditions, some of which offend the rule against perpetuities but one does not, the gift would still be valid.
In conclusion, the court found in favour of the South Eastern Sydney Area Health Service, allowing them to claim the charitable gift upon a cy-près order. The court determined that the gift to the charity was valid and not dependent upon the failure of the tomb trust, as it was a limitation on the failure of the trust. This decision provides clarity on the validity of gifts to charities in situations where the associated trust is invalid due to the rule against perpetuities.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi