South Black Water Coal Ltd v McCullough Robertson

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND
  Writ No. 353 of 1997
Before the Hon. Justice Muir

[South Black Water Coal Ltd  v.  McCullough Robertson]

BETWEEN:
  SOUTH BLACK WATER COAL LIMITED
  A.C.N. 011 026 154
  Plaintiff

AND:
  McCULLOUGH ROBERTSON (a firm)
  Defendant

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - MUIR J.

Judgment delivered 8 May 1997

CATCHWORDS:     SOLICITORS CONFLICT OF INTEREST - whether injunction should be acquiesence - discretionary considerations.

COUNSEL:                D. Jackson Q.C. with him  K.A. Barlow for the plaintiff.
  W. Sofronoff Q.C. with him D.D. Bates for the defendant.

SOLICITORS: Blake Dawson Waldron for the plaintiff.
  Corrs Chambers Westgarth for the defendant.

HEARING DATES:     29 April 1997 and 1 May 1997.

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND
  Writ No. 353 of 1997
Before the Hon. Justice Muir

[South Black Water Coal Ltd  v.  McCullough Robertson]

BETWEEN:
  SOUTH BLACK WATER COAL LIMITED
  A.C.N. 011 026 154
  Plaintiff

AND:
  McCULLOUGH ROBERTSON (a firm)
  Defendant

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - MUIR J.

Judgment delivered 8 May 1997

The plaintiff seeks an injunction restraining the defendant firm from acting as solicitors for Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd in action 9730 of 1996 or otherwise in respect of any dispute between Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd ("Thiess") and the plaintiff ("South Blackwater") arising out of a contract in writing between those companies dated 12 July 1994.  The circumstances which give rise to the claim are detailed below.  In brief, it is alleged that a solicitor, Mr McCosker, who participated in the giving of advice to South Blackwater whilst an employee of South Blackwater's solicitors cannot now, as a partner in the defendant firm, act against South Blackwater in the dispute the subject of action 9730 of 1996.  The plaintiff contends that he is in the possession of information confidential to South Blackwater which is relevant to such dispute.  It is contended further that, because Mr McCosker is a partner in the defendant firm, it is fixed with his knowledge and is also disqualified from acting for Thiess in the dispute.

The statement of claim in action 9730 of 1996

The statement of claim in action 9730 of 1996 alleges that by the agreement in writing dated 12 July 1994 between Thiess and South Blackwater ("the Contract"), Thiess agreed to upgrade the coal handling and processing plant for the Kenmare mine at South Blackwater.  An understanding of the scope of action 9730 of 1996 is of obvious relevance to the resolution of the issue between the parties in these proceedings.  The following is a general summary of its contents.

The contract

"(1)The Contract was contained in, or evidence by, or is to be inferred from the following documents:

(a)the form or instrument of agreement;

(b)section I of the contract:  the conformed contract correspondence;

(c)section II of the contract: 

(i)the special conditions of contract including appendices (a) and (b);

(ii)the general conditions of contract including annexure 1;

(d)section III of the contract:  the contract schedules and data;

(e)section IV of the contract:

(i)the scope of work and list of drawings;

(ii)the general…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read South Black Water Coal Ltd v McCullough Robertson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1997] QSC 77
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court of Queensland heard an application by South Black Water Coal Limited (South Blackwater) for an injunction to prevent McCullough Robertson (the defendant) from acting as solicitors for Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd in a legal dispute between South Blackwater and Thiess. The central issue was whether a former employee of South Blackwater's previous solicitors, now a partner at McCullough Robertson, could ethically and legally act against South Blackwater. The court examined the potential for conflict of interest and misuse of confidential information. The court held that South Blackwater had acquiesced in the defendant's conduct by allowing the former employee to continue acting in the dispute, despite being aware of the potential conflict. Despite this, the court, in its discretion, declined to grant the injunction due to the commercial considerations and the minimal risk of misuse of confidential information.

The court ordered that the action be dismissed and invited submissions on the question of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established