South Australian Farmers Fuels Pty Ltd v Whittingham

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Civil)

SOUTH AUSTRALIAN FARMERS FUELS PTY LTD & ANOR v WHITTINGHAM & ANOR

[2008] SASC 211

Judgment of The Honourable Justice David

4 August 2008

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - DISCHARGE, BREACH AND DEFENCES TO ACTION FOR BREACH - DISCHARGE BY AGREEMENT - NOVATION

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS - OTHER MATTERS

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS - PENALTIES AND LIQUIDATED DAMAGES - GENERAL PRINCIPLES

PROCEDURE - COSTS - APPEALS AS TO COSTS - MISTAKE OF LAW OR FACT

Appeal against a decision of magistrate dismissing a claim for debt and breach of contract and dismissing a counterclaim refusing to award costs in the appellants' favour - respondents conceded the error on the part of the magistrate in dismissing the claim on the basis of unconscionability - respondents raised alternative arguments on appeal in answer to the claim - whether there was novation of the contract - held, neither findings of fact by magistrate nor evidence supports a finding of novation - whether the appellants waived their right to recovery of the debt - held, neither findings of fact by magistrate nor evidence supports a finding of waiver - whether clause pursuant to which debt is claimed by appellants is unenforceable as a penalty - held, law as to penalties is not invoked as the respondents repudiated the contract, thereby giving rise to their liability to pay the sum stipulated - whether magistrate erred in fact in refusing to award costs on the basis that it would be too difficult to differentiate between the costs the appellants incurred in prosecuting their claim and the costs the appellants incurred in defending the counterclaim - whether magistrate erred in not awarding costs on the basis of the contract - held, magistrate did not err in the exercise of this discretion.

Held: Appeal as to claim allowed, appeal as to costs of counterclaim dismissed.

AMEV-UDC Finance Ltd v Austin and Another (1986) 162 CLR 170; Associated Distributors v Hall [1938] 2 KB 83; Dunlop Pneumatic Tyre Co Ltd v New Garage and Motor Co Ltd [1915] AC 79; O'Dea v Allstates Leasing System (WA) Pty Ltd (1983) 152 CLR 359; Ringrow Pty Ltd v BP Australia Pty Ltd (2005) 224 CLR 656, applied.
Fightvision Pty Ltd v Onisforou & Ors; Tszyu v Fightvision Pty Ltd & Anor (1999) 47 NSWLR 473, discussed.
Commonwealth v Verwayen (1990) 170 CLR 394; Medway Oil and Storage Co Ltd v Continental Contractors Ltd [1929] AC 88; Smith v Madden (1946) 73 CLR 129, considered.

SOUTH AUSTRALIAN FARMERS FUELS PTY LTD & ANOR v WHITTINGHAM & ANOR
[2008] SASC 211

Magistrates Appeal

DAVID J.

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal against the decision of a magistrate dismissing a claim in contract against the respondents. At first instance, the appellants in this matter, South Australian Farmers Fuel Pty Ltd (“SAFF”) and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read South Australian Farmers Fuels Pty Ltd v Whittingham and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] SASC 211
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal by South Australian Farmers Fuels Pty Ltd against the decision of the magistrate in the Magistrates Court of South Australia involved a claim for debt and breach of contract, as well as a counterclaim for costs. The respondents conceded that the magistrate erred in finding the contract unenforceable based on unconscionability. The appeal raised several issues, including whether there was a novation of the contract, whether the appellants waived their right to recover the debt, and whether the clause for the stipulated debt was enforceable as a penalty. The appeal also contested the magistrate's refusal to award costs on the basis of difficulty in differentiating between costs incurred for the claim and the counterclaim, and whether the magistrate erred in not awarding costs based on the contract.

The court examined the evidence and found that neither the findings of fact by the magistrate nor the evidence supported a finding of novation or waiver. Regarding the penalty clause, the court held that the law on penalties was not invoked as the respondents repudiated the contract, leading to the appellants' liability to pay the stipulated sum. The court also found that the magistrate did not err in the exercise of discretion when refusing to award costs on the basis of difficulty in differentiating between the costs, nor in not awarding costs based on the contract.

The court dismissed the appeal regarding the costs of the counterclaim but allowed the appeal as to the claim. Judgment was awarded to the appellants in the sum of $13,000. The court will hear the parties regarding the costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Both at the trial and on appeal, it has not been disputed that if the appellants were successful in their claim, they would be entitled to the amount of $13,000.Background Facts The parties entered into a written contract on 11 October 2004 (“the contract”). Pursuant to the contract, the respondents operated a service station near Loxton as commissioned agents for the appellants. The contract provided that the appellants would supply fuel and oil products to the respondents. The respondents would sell these products and would earn a commission, the percentages of which were stipulated in the contract. The plaintiff called one witness at trial, namely the general manager of the appellant companies, Mr Fischer. The defendants, Mr and Mrs Whittingham, gave evidence at trial and called no other persons to give evidence. There was a dispute at trial as to the length of the contract. Mr Whittingham gave evidence of discussions between himself and Mr Smith, as representative for the appellants, as to whether the contract was to last for three years or five years. According to Mr Whittingham, Mr Smith had said that although the appellants usually required the contract run for a term of five years, he thought the appellants would agree to the lesser term. When Mr and Mrs Whittingham signed the contract, the end date written into the contract was 11 October 2007. As to other references throughout the contract suggesting it was for a term of five years, Mr Whittingham said that Mr Smith had told him to ignore those references. The contract was subsequently counter‑executed and returned to the respondents and Mr Whittingham said there was no further discussion as to its term. He said the end date, 11 October 2007, which appeared at the time he and Mrs Whittingham executed the contract, was subsequently amended without their knowledge or consent. The magistrate accepted the evidence of Mr Whittingham regarding this alteration. The discrepancy as to the term of the contract was significant at trial. The magistrate ultimately found that because Mr Smith had secured the respondents’ signatures on the pretence that they were signing up for a period of three years when, in fact, it was for five years, it would be unconscionable to permit the appellants to rely upon the alleged breach of contract by the respondents. On appeal, counsel for the respondents conceded that the magistrate erred in finding the contract unenforceable on the basis of unconscionability. Matters now raised on appeal by the respondents in answer to the claim were not specifically put, nor addressed, at trial. Although the magistrate touched upon them in his reasons, his primary finding was that of unconscionability. The contract provided that in the event of an early termination for whatever reason by the respondents, an amount (defined as “signage” in the contract) would be payable by the respondents to the appellants, to be calculated according to the duration of the contract left at the time of the termination. In short, it laid down that $10,000 would be payable for signage on termination, but that it would be reduced by $2,000 for each year commenced after the first full year, so that if the fifth year were commenced nothing would be payable. As it was, the respondents left after only 20 full months and, pursuant to that part of the contract, the appellants claimed the amount of $8,000. The additional amount of $5,000 claimed is for steps taken to secure that debt. There is no dispute as to quantum.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

DAVID J
In my view, the magistrate has not erred in the exercise of his discretion. I would dismiss the appeal against the order as to costs on the counterclaim.Conclusion I allow the appeal as to the claim. Judgment is awarded to the appellants in the sum of $13,000. I dismiss the appeal as to the costs of the counterclaim. I will hear the parties as to the costs of the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DAVID J